Below is the second update of my fantasy bid limits for AL-only, NL-only, and mixed leagues for auction formats. Listed below are the players whose prices have been shifted by two dollars or more in either direction. In most cases, I moved my prices up or down based on the results from the CBS and LABR NL and AL-only auctions in late February and early March. I might be in love with Lorenzo Cain this year, but if his average salary is $25, there is no reason to put a bid limit on him over $30. On the other hand, the purpose of this exercise isn’t solely to adjust bid limits based on what players went for in LABR. I want to express a preference, not merely follow the herd.

Adjustments below are for AL and NL only in the case of significant players whose value moved up or down by two dollars or more in either direction. Corresponding mixed bid adjustments will be reflected in the table at the bottom of this article.

A quick note: any late-breaking news will not make this piece (after 5 p.m. ET on Thursday, March 17).


Non-CBS/LABR Related Adjustments
A.J. Ramos $17 (previous $11)
Carter Capps NO BID (previous $5)

The Capps injury cleared up the Marlins’ somewhat murky closer status.

Jose Reyes $14 (previous $18)
Trevor Story $6 (previous $2)

Uncertainty about a potential suspension pushes his price down significantly. If you don’t want to pay even this price, I don’t blame you. I will move Trevor Story up even more in the next update if it becomes clearer he is the Opening Day starter.

Kenta Maeda $12 (previous $8)
He looks great this spring, and I may need to find more money for him in the update. For all of the hand wringing about the Dodgers starting rotation, it looks like they Maeda good decision here.

Miguel Montero $10 (previous $12)
Jorge Soler $5 (previous $8)

The Dexter Fowler signing will mostly take time away from Soler, but Montero will likely lose a little more time behind the plate with Kyle Schwarber catching 10-15 more games than I had anticipated in early March.

Hector Olivera $10 (previous $13)
I have faith in the bat, but some reports indicate Olivera is struggling in the field. The Braves could send him to Triple-A, and since they are not on competitive footing, there isn’t an imperative to bring him back quickly.

Jhonny Peralta $10 (previous $16)
Jedd Gyorko $6 (previous $4)
Aledmys Diaz $5 (previous NO BID)

This bid assumes Peralta is back in June. I project Gyorko will still be more of a utility player and a platoon partner to Kolten Wong than a regular shortstop and can see Diaz getting a fair amount of playing time at short.

Jason Grill $7 (previous $4)
Arodys Vizcaino $7 (previous $9)

My educated guess is Grilli starts out as the closer and Vizcaino takes over after Grilli is traded. But I don’t have a good feeling about this bullpen in either direction.

David Freese $7 (previous NO BID)

Scott Kazmir $6 (previous $11)
Michael Bolsinger $3 (previous NO BID)
Hyun-Jin Ryu $3 (previous $5)

Yes, I’m nervous about the diminished velocity. I will bump him back up if this is a blip, but the ceiling for Kazmir was not particularly high in the first place. Bolsinger is a decent back-end arm in NL-only if he gets the innings, while I have no faith that Ryu will ever pitch again.

Andrew Bailey $6 (previous NO BID)
David Hernandez $2 (previous $6)

Larry Bowa scooped the Phillies beat writers on Bailey taking the lead in camp for the closer’s job on a Philadelphia talk radio station on Tuesday morning. This has been my favorite part of the spring so far. As you can see by my bid, I have as little faith in Bailey as I did in Hernandez, but saves are saves.

Chris Owings $6 (previous $3)
Nick Ahmed $1 (previous $7)

Owings looks more and more likely to play regularly for the Diamondbacks.

Rymer Liriano $4 (previous $7)
Kirk Niewenhuis $1 (previous $3)
Keon Broxton $7 (previous NO BID)

It appears to be a wide open competition in Milwaukee for center field, and Broxton may have gained the upper hand. He is a high risk/high reward player, but the steals alone make him worth more than a nominal bid in NL-only.

Aaron Altherr NO BID (previous $13)
Tyler Goeddel $7 (previous 1)

CBS/LABR Adjustments
Nolan Arenado $34 (previous $32)
Madison Bumgarner $27 (previous $24)
Randall Grichuk $18 (previous $16)
Chris Carter $14 (previous $11)
Justin Bour $14 (previous $12)


Non-LABR Adjustments

Michael Brantley $22 (previous $18)
Will Venable $2 (previous $9)

Brantley is ahead of his earlier timetable and could be back in April. There will still be an adjustment period for him, but an extra month of games is still a significant positive.

Aroldis Chapman $19 (previous $16)
It may seem weird that I am zagging when everyone else is zigging, but I was anticipating a 40-game suspension. Chapman will still be an elite closer when he returns.

Cody Allen $18 (previous $16)

Pedro Alvarez $14 (previous NO BID)
Austin Jackson $13 (previous NO BID)

Alvarez and Jackson both signed and should have every day jobs for their respective major league teams.

Jarrod Dyson $11 (previous $13)
Travis Snider $4 (previous $1)

I was high on Dyson this year, but an oblique injury for someone whose game relies so much on speed is bad.

Glen Perkins $11 (previous $13)
Trevor May $3 (previous $1)

May is one of my favorite stealth candidates for saves in the American League.

Lance McCullers $10 (previous $12)
I was lower on McCullers than the rest of the pack to begin with; his shoulder woes make me even warier than I had been earlier this spring.

Cameron Maybin $10 (previous $13)

Sean Doolittle $10 (previous $12)
Liam Hendriks $3 (previous $1)

Hendriks is my other stealth candidate for AL-only saves.

Jimmy Rollins $8 (previous $6)
It looks more and more like Rollins will win the shortstop job for the White Sox.

Michael Saunders $8 (previous $4)
Dalton Pompey $6 (previous $4)

It seems illogical that both players would get a boost, but at these prices this is positive speculation on both, not an endorsement of either.

Juan Uribe $7 (previous NO BID)

Avisail Garcia $7 (previous $10)
Adam LaRoche NO BID (previous $3)

LaRoche’s abrupt retirement puts Garcia back into a starting role for now.

Steve Cishek $7 (previous bid $9)

Eduardo Escobar $6 (previous $4)

LABR Adjustments
Miguel Cabrera $34 (previous $32)
Mookie Betts $33 (previous $31)
Justin Upton $27 (previous $25)
Dallas Keuchel $24 (previous $22)
Felix Hernandez $23 (previous $21)
Carlos Carrasco $22 (previous $19)
Chris Archer $21 (previous $19)
Cole Hamels $20 (previous $17)
Danny Salazar $20 (previous $17)
Mark Teixeira $17 (previous $20)
Evan Gattis $14 (previous $16)
Adam Lind $13 (previous $15)
Taijuan Walker $13 (previous $11)
Collin McHugh $12 (previous $14)
Yordano Ventura $12 (previous $14)
C.J. Cron $12 (previous $9)
A.J. Reed $6 (previous $9)
Logan Morrison $6 (previous $9)

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
My auction is tomorrow. Mike you are the man!
So Avasail Garcia gets a bump in PT, but his value drops $3? I know his splits arre bad, but.....
Keep in mind that the first edition was in late February, when Garcia was a projected starter and before the White Sox signed Austin Jackson. I moved Garcia down in part because I suspect the White Sox still may acquire someone at some point to replace/platoon with him.
I heard Stassi's injury may mean Gattis catches some April games. My league gives positional eligibility after one game in season. Do you think Gattis catches in April and how much should catcher eligibility impact his value?
I don't foresee that, but if he does catch I'd bump him up $2-3.
Not buying Tanaka's spring all that much? Or just think risk too large regardless to pay for upside?
I don't put much stock into spring stats, but I also am skeptical of the injury risk.
Just to get a jump on the 3rd Ed., who is saving games for the Rays in April and May?
My guess is Alex Colome. But it could be Danny Farquhar.
"it looks like they Maeda good decision here." duuuuuude
You're in mid-season form with the Maeda line Mike!
Yeah love the Maeda play on words, also. Original? Thanks for this Mike, always very very helpful.
I think I tweeted you this question already Mike -

in a 12tm NL only; we play with 1 Catcher and 2 Utility. SP usually go for a lot.

thoughts on how value may shift around?

last year Top 10-12 catchers still went normal prices, and just a couple of teams grabbed a 2nd catcher for utility or place at other position.
You probably would need to move some money off of catcher and push it around elsewhere on offense.
If it's a keeper league and you like someone for next year or more then would you bump him a $1 or 2 for this?
Yes, maybe even more because of inflation (depending on what yours is).
Mike, would you characterize your pricing as reflective of a "spread the risk" vs. "stars and scrubs" strategy? Also, are you enough of a believer in JD Martinez that you would extend him if he's $10 in AL leagues?
It worked out that way this year in both my expert auctions.

Yes, I'd extend Martinez
It would be rad if the aav's for the major websites were also incorporated in the list. List is still rad without it though, thanks mike!
Thanks Mike for updating these. I have an auction tomorrow!

Has anybody turned these into EXL docs?
Hey Mike, Clint Robinson is listed under pitchers at $2. thanks.
Besides adjusting your bids to the market with the expert leagues, how much weight do you give to the bids in CBS, LABR and Tout, Mike?