BP360 now on sale! A yearly subscription, '23 Annual & Futures Guide and t-shirt for one low price
Value Picks 2010 PECOTA Games '10
Starting Pitchers Throws W IP H HR ERA WHIP K/9 BB/9 HR/9 K/9 BB/9 HR/9 Starts SIERA
Randy Wells RH 5 129.0 146 10 4.40 1.43 7.3 2.7 0.7 6.9 2.3 0.8 22 3.87
Brian Duensing LH 4 60.0 49 4 2.10 1.10 5.3 2.6 0.6 5.1 3.3 0.9 3 4.30
Tom Gorzelanny LH 6 93.0 89 5 3.48 1.45 8.6 4.5 0.5 8.1 4.0 0.8 15 4.07
Jhoulys Chacin RH 5 82.1 70 8 4.04 1.31 9.7 4.2 0.9 9.0 3.9 0.8 12 3.54
Thomas Diamond RH 0 6.0 7 0 4.50 1.67 15.0 4.5 0.0 8.5 5.0 1.3 1 2.11
Bud Norris RH 4 86.0 94 10 5.65 1.56 9.5 4.2 1.0 8.9 4.5 1.1 16 3.72
Barry Enright RH 3 41.2 38 5 2.81 1.27 6.1 3.2 1.1 6.0 3.0 1.5 7 4.50
Subscribe to Heater 2007-09 in Rotation 1.39 6.6 3.1 1.1  
Heater Magazine 2007-09 in Relief 1.36 7.7 3.8 0.9  

Added to the list

Jhoulys Chacin: Aaron Cook has struggled all season but his last three starts have forced the Colorado Rockies to place him on the 15-day disabled list. Although he has not been recalled yet, Jhoulys Chacin, currently at Triple-A Colorado Springs, will take Cook's spot in the rotation. In 82 and one-third innings before his demotion to the Minors, Chacin put up a 3.54 SIERA and averaged more than a strikeout per inning.

Chacin will be in the rotation until the end of the season as the Rockies want to put themselves in the best position possible for a run at the National League Wild Card.  That means that Chacin, available in 98 percent of ESPN leagues, would get 10 starts. He is certainly worth the add in almost all formats. He even has value in shallower leagues as his strikeout rate is hard to ignore. The one issue with Chacin, though, is his propensity for issuing free passes. He averaged more than four per nine innings in his previous stint with the Rockies. Every rose has its thorn, and such.

Thomas Diamond: Diamond is similar to Chacin in that he can miss a lot of bats but also struggles with control often enough to become worrisome. To Diamond's credit, he has harnessed his control a bit as he has accrued more playing time following Tommy John surgery in 2007.

Diamond struck out ten Milwaukee Brewers in his Major League debut, taking Ted Lilly's spot in the Chicago Cubs' starting rotation. The Cubs will certainly give him some more Major League experience so they can evaluate him. He is worth an add in all NL-only leagues and most deep leagues. If choosing between Chacin and Diamond, opt for Chacin simply because he plays for a better offensive team and thus will be in line for more wins. You really cannot go wrong with either so long as you accept the control issues.

Removed from the list

Brian Duensing: Duensing's spot in the Minnesota Twins' starting rotation is secure barring a run of poor starts. However, given his lack of strikeouts and the recent emergence of strikeout-heavy starters like Chacin and Diamond, you should make a switch unless you are desperate for WHIP help. Barry Enright, mentioned below, is also a superior (and WHIP-friendly) option.

Bud Norris: Sometimes Norris can be brilliant, as he was on May 13 against the St. Louis Cardinals, July 3 against the Padres, and July 28 against the Cubs. Most of the time, he will be an average pitcher. He has allowed exactly four earned runs in four out of his last eight starts, including three out of his last four. Since the end of June, Norris has shown better control but he also has not put up the lofty strikeout totals we saw in May and June.

Norris has some value in NL-only leagues and deep mixed leagues, but otherwise you should opt for someone else on this list.

Staying on the list

Randy Wells: Wells is perplexing. From June 28 to July 23, he compiled a 1.30 ERA and 7.8 K/9 in 34 and two-thirds innings of work. In his next start on July 28, he walked five en route to allowing three runs in five and two-thirds innings. In his most recent start on August 2, he lasted only four innings, allowing seven runs (six earned) on ten hits.

It is not time to lose faith in Wells, though. Control is usually his forte, so you can chalk up his five walks on July 28 as a fluke. And you can attribute his ten hits allowed in his last start to some unfortunate BABIP luck, especially since his batted ball splits were not egregiously different that game (50 percent fly balls, 35 percent ground balls, 15 percent line drives). Wells should be owned in all but the shallowest formats. (Even AL-only! I kid, I kid.) However, he is available in 94 percent of ESPN leagues.

Tom Gorzelanny: If you need strikeouts and missed out on Chacin and Diamond (or if you prefer a lefty), Gorzelanny should be on your radar. He is currently averaging nearly a strikeout per inning and had been on a roll of four straight wins before earning a no-decision against the Colorado Rockies on July 31.

He will start today against the Cincinnati Reds but his next starts will come against the Giants in San Francisco, the San Diego Padres at home, and the Atlanta Braves at home. The Giants and Padres are average offenses and the Braves have struggled against lefties. This is a pretty good time to pick up Gorzelanny, statistically speaking.

(Note: Despite the preponderance of Cub pitchers in this week's Value Picks, I am not in any way financially backed by Jim Hendry.)

Barry Enright: Enright may soon become known as Mr. Consistency. Last night against the Washington Nationals, Enright continued a streak of pitching at least five innings and allowing no more than three earned runs. He held the Washington Nationals to two runs over six innings of work.

Enright is a control pitcher who does not strikeout as many batters. Additionally, he is an extreme fly ball pitcher — not far off the pace of Kevin Slowey. Enright is a good fallback option if the Jekyll and Hyde qualities of some the aforementioned turn you off. Although the Arizona Diamondbacks have a decent offense, their bullpen has had a penchant for blowing leads late in games so Enright is not a great candidate if you are chasing wins. However, he is still a great play in NL-only leagues. Use your best judgment if you are considering adding him in a mixed league. Obviously, the deeper, the better.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
So the list is now NL-only? Any good value to be had in the Junior circuit?
I didn't notice that it was NL-only, though I was worried that I might be accused of being to Cub-friendly!

Josh Tomlin may we worth checking out. He's among the same mold as Barry Enright: average strikeout stuff, good control, but he gets a lot of fly balls. While he's had a great first three starts, I wouldn't expect him to have anywhere near as much success going forward. If you're fine with a 4.25-ish ERA pitcher, Tomlin may be worth a look.

Is Brett Cecil taken in your league? He should be universally owned but I saw him floating around in one of my leagues. He is taken in 22 percent of ESPN leagues but you could be a member of one of the lucky 78 percent.

Other than that, I can't think of any other players whose actual value is greater than their perceived value. If you have any questions about a specific player, I'd be happy to let you know what I think.
Would you start Gorz today against the Reds? Pitching at home helps, but I don't know if he can pick up a win.
The Reds hit lefties nearly as well as right-handers and they're the National League's top offense, so tonight may be a good time to sit Gorzelanny. The Reds strike out a bit more than the average team but that's about the only real benefit I see from starting him tonight, unless you badly need the counting stats like strikeouts.
I'd like to add that as someone who blew all of his future-predicting mana on a 1-2-3 inning by Brad Lidge a few days ago, my writing the above is an absolute guarantee that Gorz will go 8 shutout innings tonight against the Reds. :)
Oh jeez, I did not know they were playing this afternoon.

He went 7 IP, gave up 3 earnies.
Trade Help!

I'm in a daily league with 11 teams where you start 13 hitters and 8 pitchers with daily lineup changes mixing in your 4 bench slots. I'm ten points out in 4th place. I'm second or third in every hitting category, so a push there isn't going to change things. I'm first in saves, last in wins and ERA, 10th in WHIP, and 4th in Ks. Clearly, if there's enough time, pitching is the place to make up ground.

I've got two trade offers:

I get Latos and H Kendrick for trading Uggla

I get Price and Hughes for Wagner and Werth.

My replacement for Werth would be moving a 1B/OF and inserting Morneau when he comes of the DL, or Napoli in the meantime.

Which should I pick? Or should I do both?
I like the Price/Hughes haul from your perspective. Werth's value is limited since he usually hits behind Chase Utley and Ryan Howard, giving him RBI opportunities aplenty. Now, he's hitting behind Raul Ibanez and Mike Sweeney. Then add in that he has been bipolar at the plate, sometimes extremely hot but mostly extremely cold. I think this trade maximizes on Werth's quickly declining value.

As for the first trade offer, while you get a legitimately great starter in Latos, the decline from Uggla to Kendrick is pretty steep. The Price/Hughes trade should give you enough of a boost, assuming the back of your rotation includes fringe starters like Barry Enright and Bud Norris. Also note that Price has been pitching over his head and is more likely to be a 3.50-4.00 ERA pitcher the rest of the season.

If you are looking for saves sans Wagner, I'm sure Mike Petriello could definitely show you some good targets. Keep your eyes on Ryan Madson if Brad Lidge starts to stumble again for the Phillies.
Good solid advice there. But just a quick comment, when did Brad Lidge stop stumbling? :)
He's actually been better than his ERA indicates. His high walk rate combined with an unsustainably high HR/FB in a very small sample of innings have made him look much worse than he really is.

Madson is still better than him by a New York mile, though. (However long a New York mile is... I assume it's quite long?)