CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  

Search Article Archives

Find:   

Author:    Article: 
Search Date (From):    Search Date (To):   
Sort Results by:  Relevance
 Date
Show me  Results

   Show Article Summaries

New! Search comments:      
(NOTE: Relevance, Author, and Article are not applicable for comment searches)

alskor
310 comments | 73 total rating | 0.24 average rating
Facebook Twitter email a friend
Share comments by 'alskor' posted at
Baseball Prospectus http://bbp.cx/i/39403
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Have you seen Lee play OF?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Pretty sure it was Sean McAdam who reported the Sox approached the A's about a restructured deal with just Anderson (No PTBNL) but were rebuffed. So I'd agree... good chance the PTBNL was a half decent prospect.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

They desperately needed *backup* catching...?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Drew Stubbs and George Springer are two recent CFers in this mold, too. It does seem like its been more common historically for up the middle guys to be premium defenders who put the ball in play and make use of their speed... but I'm not sure if that's just a stereotype we've got stuck in our heads. It could very well be that in the metal bat amateur era TTO up the middle guys aren't really that uncommon.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

To be fair, 24 total bases is almost as silly.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

You know what else is "all the rage?" Fans of a team thinking they've struck gold with their fringy, 25 year old, unathletic Rule 5 pick. Emaus was not some well regarded, stud prospect before he became a Met, I assure you.

Mar 29, 2011 10:01 PM on Monday Morning Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

...and you call yourself a "velo-whore?" /smh

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Also, KG's Cubs list came out in December while Szczur didn't actually commit to the Cubs until the end of January. He had signed a two sport deal previously, which certainly was a concern for me with regards to his prospect status. http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=12522 http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20110118&content_id=16458346&vkey=news_chc&c_id=chc Also, from that second article, Cubs fans should become aware that Szczur is actually pronounced "Caesar" - as in Julius or Augustus. Or Salad.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Its on the front page. Scroll down.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I saw Beckham as well a couple weeks back and he definitely looks bigger, especially the lower half. Completely agree with your assessment.

Mar 19, 2011 10:13 AM on Visions of Spring
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I'm having a very hard time buying Mantle over Williams, Larry. I know it would make for a much less interesting article, but I'd be tempted to go Ruth until his death, then Williams until his death, then Mays since (also with strong consideration to Bonds).

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Maybe I'm forgetting how to do the math here (quite possible), but how can this be correct... Pedroia, a plus fielding 2B is projected to hit .295/.362/.438 over 675 PAs. His projected WARP is 2.4 Nick Swisher, an averageish (and that's slightly charitable) defensive RF is projected to hit .252/.353/.462 over 632 PAs. His projected WARP is 3.0 A player hitting for ~9 points less of OBP and 24 points more of SLG at a much less valuable defensive position... and he plays that position just so-so while the other player is an elite defender... how can that add up that way? Is the replacement level set correctly?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Weclome to BP! Another great addition.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I think perhaps one motivation here for Melvin was that this group of young player and prospects was mildly disappointing so far (Escobar hasn't hit, Jeffress off field stuff & a reliever, Odorrizi doesn't have FOR stuff really, Lawrie is an OF or perhaps even a 1B, etc...). Doing these trades lets you get two years of control of two front line starters AND the ability to replenish your farm system and start over with a new group of kids - either by trading these guys & Fielder next year or collecting comp picks when they walk (assuming the comp. system still exists).

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I still don't understand how both berkman and oswalt were so seriously overpaid by the astros.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Those timelines don't match up at all. I'm not sure the Sox even had interest in the team until well into the 2010 baseball season.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

While the commenters you talk to on Pirates blogs may have nothing to go on besides his looks, the people Kevin talks to may just have a little more insight.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Sounds like your tripling the amount of work you have to do and giving yourself half the time. Impressive. If PECOTA is what I think it will be then BP is really leading the way again. Love the new additions like Mike Fast, too.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

"I was there for the first week of games and you could obviously see the kid's timing is off." So YOUR SSS observations are valid, but not the pro scouts? Interesting take.

Oct 26, 2010 8:12 PM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Not sure what you're trying to say here... Jeter never really turned into a good defender.

Oct 26, 2010 8:08 PM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

Matt Wieters: A) Will be 25 years old in 2011. B) Was an uber prospect based largely on scouting and college performance - not his 2009 PECOTAs. Still a pretty good chance he emerges as one of the best catchers in baseball. Let's not write his obit. just yet. Though, obviously if you watch him recently he doesn't look like an impact bat... the tools are still there and no one should be shocked in the slightest if he turns it around.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Crow and Melville certainly didn't hold their spots and were surpassed by Lamb and Dwyer, IMO. Both from a performance and scouting standpoint.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

FYI, I prefer my poetic baseball information in the form of dirty limericks. Something to think about.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

I think the real issue is how much credit to give Ackley because his teammates got on base before he came to the plate... conversely, how much do we "blame" a guy who hits a solo shot for his teammates not being on base?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Speaking of which... good luck with that Royals top 11!

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

I would think the poor but not atrocious CS% is in large part due to guys not being scared of running on him... being more aggressive and less selective deciding when to run. He's had 126 SB attempts in his 101 games at Catcher. No other IL catcher is really all that close in attempts allowed or SB allowed... and there are some BAD defensive catchers in that league right now. Tyler Flowers has been awful and drawn awful reviews from what I've heard and his defensive numbers, while eye-bleedingly bad, actually look significantly better than Montero. Take Flowers & Adam Donachie out and no one is even near the guy. His SB allowed are like 2 standard deviations off the average IL starting catcher's.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Rondon is out for the year. He missed nearly the entire year with a forearm injury.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Melville is a RHP.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Its no doubt slowly driving Dayton Moore insane. I imagine him alone in his office late at night, staring at his team's batting averages and asking himself "how can this be happening????."

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Yeah... I mean, its been a little over a week. Let's close the book on this one already!

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

He's playing in Las Vegas. You really shouldn't be this impressed by what he's doing this year.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I've seen this argument before... obviously what Jeffress has done isn't a capital crime. OTOH, its extremely troubling to me that the kid continues to put his career in baseball at risk by using a recreational drug. He knows the chance he's taking smoking pot and he keeps doing it - that's a big red flag for me in terms of character and dedication. How much does he want to be a baseball player?

Jun 16, 2010 12:37 AM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Soriano's 2010 salary: 1 yr/$7.25mm Wagner's 2010 salary: 1 yr/$7mm w/ $0.25mm buyout for 2011 + $6.5mm option vests with 50 games finished. I understand Soriano hasn't exactly been the picture of health... but Wagner is 38 and made a grand total of 17 appearances the last TWO seasons.

Jun 12, 2010 9:36 PM on Draft Wrap: NL East
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Seriously? Chris Carter is just a notch above organizational filler regardless of how he performed last night. The Mets gave up a free first round pick and supplemental pick for him. Bad any way you cut it. Wagner has been great, sure... but Soriano has been great, too. They've been equally valuable by WAR so far. Once again, my argument isn't that Wagner is bad - its that the difference between him and Soriano isn't close to worth giving up (basically) two first rounders for. It doesn't matter who Boston took with the picks, either. The fact Ranaudo was projected as a top 5 talent before the injury only makes them giving up the picks potentially look much worse in a couple years. If you don't like Ranaudo fill in another guy you would have liked there. They still gave up a lot of value for no good reason.

Jun 12, 2010 8:01 AM on Draft Wrap: NL East
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

They could have just kept Rafael Soriano and not given up picks, though.

Jun 12, 2010 7:54 AM on Draft Wrap: NL East
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Negative me all you want. That's still an obscene waste of value. They gave up the picks that became Vitek and Ranuado for a 39 year old injury prone reliever. Not smart. To be fair, the Mets are even more foolish for trading those picks for Chris Carter (the 26 year old OF/1B, not the stud A's prospect).

Jun 12, 2010 12:02 AM on Draft Wrap: NL East
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Atlanta Braves Day One Selections -Billy Wagner, LHP, Boston Red Sox (MA)

Jun 10, 2010 6:52 PM on Draft Wrap: NL East
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Not to mention that by pretty much every evaluation tool we have, Jeff Mathis doesn't show up as all that good of a defensive catcher... albeit better than Napoli.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Coaches and teammates have said he's "relaxed" and using the whole field again, fwiw.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

If the Rockies don't appreciate him, the Red Sox would be happy to have him...

Apr 27, 2010 11:07 AM on Iannetta Demoted
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

"Andrew Brackman, rhp, Yankees (High-A Tampa): Four innings, 10 hits, seven runs and zero strikeouts last night. Sure, he's throwing strikes, but at what cost?" A $$4,550,000 bonus and a wasted first round pick - that many people didn't like at the time (since he needed TJ and all). Also, the cost of every non-Yankee fan having to hear for three years how good he is since BA decided to put him on a top 100 list for some insane reason.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

You're also confusing talent with results. Even the injured Tribe of last year had a pyth 7 games better than they finished with. Their expected W-L was 73-89. Add in the guys who are back healthy...

Apr 03, 2010 11:03 PM on AL Pre-season Edition
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Very true. Sometimes player exceed their true talent level. If Cesar Izturis hits .290 this year we'd all just shrug and chalk it up to luck. Yet, if a team scores 30 more runs than PECOTA projected apparently the system must be broken.

Apr 02, 2010 8:31 PM on AL Pre-season Edition
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

"The A's have been 'overrated' in my estimation two years in a row! There must be something wrong with this system that I admittedly don't understand! Also, don't bother trying to explain it to me, just *fix* your system!" "What? No - I'm 100% positive it couldn't be injuries, luck and random variance. Why do you ask?"

Apr 02, 2010 8:26 PM on AL Pre-season Edition
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

"80 Speed" isn't some random number scouts dream up and pull out of the air. Its based off clocked times to 1B, around the bases, etc... So maybe something like 25% pulled out of the air.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

He's throwing mid 80's right now, for one thing.

Mar 30, 2010 12:52 PM on AL Central Battle Royale
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Reports out of Cleveland seem to give Aaron Laffey the edge over Talbot, actually.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Gardenhire has all but ruled Neshek out: Twins manager Ron Gardenhire shot down talk Friday of Pat Neshek possibly being considered for the club's ninth-inning vacancy. Neshek is about 15 months removed from Tommy John surgery http://www.fantasysp.com/player/mlb/Pat_Neshek/828635

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Swing and a miss.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Its a shame PECOTA was so messed up initially. Its going to cast doubts on the projections when the real story should be how good the Sox are projected. There's plenty of reason to think they will be the best team in baseball in 2010 and PECOTA picking them there should have been the story.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Its difficult to become a team's top prospect (especially for a team as loaded as the Rangers) when you're suspended the first 50 games of the season for a violation of MLB's minor league drug prevention and treatment program. http://www.baseballamerica.com/blog/prospects/?p=7524

Mar 15, 2010 7:51 PM on Future Top Dogs, AL
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Follow up: Will this be done? Should this be done? Why?

Mar 12, 2010 10:36 PM on PECOTA Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I think that's probably important point #3: Prospects and farm systems are but a means to an end (winning at the MLB level). Still, the major problem that teams face is how to balance the present and the future. Its pretty clear the Cardinals haven't done a very good job of preparing for their future.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

I hate to say it, but I think a number of these problems may actually have been with LAST YEAR'S PECOTA.

Feb 27, 2010 9:56 AM on The Owners' Rep Speaks
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

"Just when I think you couldn't possibly be any dumber, you go and do something like this… and totally redeem yourself!" If the previous PECOTA confusion was necessary to get these awesome looking player cards up - it was completely worth it. Love how all the mentions of a player are tied in, too, even chats.

Feb 26, 2010 10:22 PM on The Owners' Rep Speaks
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Well the fact he was going to be moved to the OF because of Kouzmanoff is probably an indication they already had a plan for this problem...

Feb 25, 2010 7:21 PM on Padres Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I was thinking the same thing when I saw Betancourt atop the the "TAv lower than you might think" category! I bet he would win a poll for who BP readers think is the worst regular in baseball. I realize it wasn't meant as a shocking placement... still make me laugh at how bad he is.

Feb 25, 2010 2:40 PM on Call it True Average
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

In my experience, most people either can't or simply refuse to wrap their mind around win probability.

Feb 18, 2010 7:39 PM on June 3-9
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

Perhaps its just me, but I don't mind seeing how the sausage is made if its explained to me in a enjoyable, easy to read manner. That seems like its really the core mission of BP, actually.

Feb 18, 2010 8:32 AM on June 3-9
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I think its more like they changed some of the underlying principles - some of the basic inputs, and theyre finding out step by step how those interact with each advanced step of the process. It certainly hasnt been smooth so far.

Feb 14, 2010 6:01 PM on June 4-5, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

"Was Nate too distracted by politics?" Hope you were joking... can't tell. PECOTA is the most complex system out there. Its entirely natural and appropriate that it takes a long time to work out the kinks.

Feb 14, 2010 4:44 PM on June 4-5, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 8

I was kidding... I do agree *in part* with some of your criticisms, but Im torn. I like getting my PECOTA as early as possible, so I dont mind the beta - but I agree the wild swings we've seen so far don't exactly inspire me with confidence in the system/process. Still, I think we would find every projection system except perhaps the simplistic MARCEL has these same sort of bumps in the process. The difference is we're just privy to them. People here seem turned off by seeing so much of the guts of the process - it is sort of like viewing an operation. For Clay and company, I would imagine the individual results that many BP readers are clinging to (like the processed standings) are far less interesting than playing with the process. I dont mind seeing the guts, personally... I think its more the first release of PECOTA this year was just extraordinarily raw. Im not sure this really any different (systematically) than it has been in previous years. The projections constantly get tweaked throughout February-April. Not sure why so much attention is being paid and with so much dissatisfaction this year.

Feb 14, 2010 4:38 PM on June 4-5, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

So... looks like someone's favorite team took a hit in the latest PECOTA standings.

Feb 13, 2010 11:35 AM on June 4-5, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Max Scherzer as a Green? Kind of surprised by that. Beyond all the mechanics arguments, etc... he was a young pitcher (24) who jumped from 109 IP to 175 IP. That seems like the sort of thing the THR's hate.... no?

Feb 05, 2010 11:43 AM on Team Health Reports 2010
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

R+RBI...? That's a pretty curious way to approach the issue.

Feb 02, 2010 5:55 PM on Draft Day
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Beta

Feb 01, 2010 8:16 PM on May 30-June 1, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Its difficult enough to predict the true talent levels... now you're asking PECOTA to predict who will get lucky...

Feb 01, 2010 10:51 AM on Wet Horsehide
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yeah... pretty sure that's not what PECOTA is thinking. It just sees a year lost to injury and doesn't tie the diminished stuff, velocity and results in the following year to that.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Logan Morrison was one of those guys where I read your description of him and it sounded more 3 star than 5 star. Inside-out swing, questionable power, big platoon problems, 1B only, bad baserunner. That sounds... awful. What happened to your "1B have to absolutely mash to rank really high" rule?

Jan 31, 2010 11:21 AM on Marlins Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

-and then he didn't allow a single run in 2009!

Jan 28, 2010 10:14 PM on May 28-29, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

ZiPS also loved Colby Lewis, fwiw... http://www.baseballthinkfactory.org/files/oracle/discussion/rangers_signed_lewis/

Jan 28, 2010 7:43 PM on May 28-29, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Its like... 50/50 anyway, isnt it?

Jan 28, 2010 7:41 PM on May 28-29, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Ah, that makes sense. Maybe BP should come up with a new defensive metric based on play by play data... Oh, wait...

Jan 28, 2010 3:38 PM on May 28-29, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -3

You mean rival Boston for best defense.

Jan 28, 2010 3:29 PM on May 28-29, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

There's a few like this. I think I would prefer CHIPS - Carroll's ""...

Jan 28, 2010 1:22 PM on Padre Problems
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

It was the first thing that came to mind for me, too... downside is the word has a different meaning, as in previously. Kind of bothers me. What's nice about acronyms like PECOTA are that they can't be confused with anything else. If we're having a conversation and I mention Derek Jeter's PRIORs you might think he had been arrested.

Jan 28, 2010 10:20 AM on Padre Problems
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

THOMEs Team Health Opinions and Medical Evaluations

Jan 28, 2010 10:09 AM on Padre Problems
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

BIP data based...? Or just a different version of FRAA/FRAR? I take it PECOTA will still be using FRAA/FRAR this year, then...?

Jan 27, 2010 8:11 PM on The Master Plan
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Ok. Now include defense. PMLV is a pretty peculiar place to start, never mind declare a "winner."

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Here are the Yankees left side CHONE projections by WAR: Teixeira: 5.1 Cano: 4.2 Total: 9.3

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Well, the man did say "arguably." Here are their WAR by CHONE projections for 2010: Utley: 6.1 Howard: 4.4 Total: 10.5 Pedroia: 4.7 Youkilis: 5.5 Total: 10.2

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

Will, this was an excellent article. This is exactly the sort of stuff I was hoping to see more of from BP. Keep up the great work.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Somebody actually signed Brandon Lyon?? I sure hope they didn't pay him much. WHAT?!?

Jan 20, 2010 2:10 PM on Midweek Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Wasn't that the case 2 years ago, too (except for Terry Ryan and Bill Smith, of course!)...? They must have been fooled by that awesome 6.5 K/9 in 2007.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Ah. It must have worked then. When I next logged in my initial comment had a positive rating. My apologies.

Jan 09, 2010 11:27 AM on Ken Cloude
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

"Try to win" = spending gobs of money? Damn all those small market teams that never "try to win!" I hate them so much!

Jan 09, 2010 11:24 AM on Rays Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Oh wow, really?? Boy, is my face red! Really? That was a joke?? I honestly thought they were seriously claiming they were the "coolest people on the web." All a joke. Wow. Now my eyes are open. Thank you, citizen!

Jan 09, 2010 12:05 AM on Ken Cloude
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 9

"You’ll get to work on cutting edge baseball analysis with some of coolest people on the web" So the project involves a collaboration with people other than BP writers...?

Jan 07, 2010 10:07 PM on Ken Cloude
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

American League at least?? Now Im stumped.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Crap. Its a pitcher?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

My money is on Profar.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I don't have a problem nor do I want to shift the divisions. I just get sick of seeing people knocking the Red Sox for their resources without taking note of EXACTLY how much larger the Yankees resources are. Its a huge, dramatic difference, and the sheer scale of it is unmatched in any other division.

Jan 05, 2010 12:27 PM on New Year Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

Frankly, I care way less about writing than I do about seeing some original and interesting ideas. If BP's readers do indeed favor writing over ideas these days, then perhaps that is why this place is stagnating. For instance, Perotto is a good addition, but I dont want more of just random opinion articles. I can get some guy's opinion on trades lots of places these days! Give me some interesting statistical analysis! That's what this place was really about when it was breaking new ground and creating buzz.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

"I could care less if BP gets things out a little slower than other sites, who seem to base their whole identity on the timeliness of a 140-character outburst - what I care about is that they leave the loudest reverb once the noise has stopped being made." Right now theyre doing neither. If it was quality or original writing, sure. When I see something that's the same thing everyone else said a week after everyone else had it - no thanks. That's what Transaction Analysis and Hit List, etc... have become. Neither quality nor quick. You want jokes about wine and subtle wit? That's great. I want quick, enlightening analysis of what's going on in the world of baseball. Frankly, I much prefer RJ Anderson, Tom Tango or Dave Cameron to what I get at BP these days. Fact is, there is nothing special about much of the product BP is giving us these days. If they want me to pay for it they could at least get that part out faster and make it easier to digest. As for in depth articles - I would love them, but the ones we've been getting arent original or interesting. New ground IS being broken in Sabrmetric fields... just not here. I pay my subsription for Future Shock and PECOTA, essentially. Everything else here is tired, uninteresting and definitely lacking in quality. I much, much prefer the fangraphs types of articles that ask questions and then explore answers. BP used to be more like that and it was far better for it.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

Frankly, I like the more blogs idea. I would love to see BP become more like fangraphs - well written, intelligent blurbs on what is going on. Ive never cared for Transaction Analysis or Hit List. The format is the issue - not Christina's writing style. They give me nothing I cant get elsewhere. Break it up into little pieces easier to digest and get them out quicker. Ive usually ready three or four analyses by the time TA is out. BP needs to stop being reactive and start being proactive again.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

They sure do, but it doesnt diminish the problems of the Red Sox.

Jan 04, 2010 11:08 AM on New Year Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I would love to see the European football style system happen.

Jan 03, 2010 10:20 PM on New Year Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Ok, now find another division where the team with the highest payroll is 165% of the second team's payroll. Or anything close to that. The Sox may have extra resources, but theyre at least equaled out by the extra problem of having to go through the Yankees. No one else has anything close to that big a problem.

Jan 03, 2010 10:18 PM on New Year Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

I hope you're not considering Burnett an Ace. LOLz!11!!1

Jan 03, 2010 8:04 PM on New Year Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

B.S. Boston has great resources, but they pale in comparison to NY's. No other divison has as big a disparity BY PERCENTAGE between the top two teams as exists in the AL East.

Jan 03, 2010 8:03 PM on New Year Update
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Ugh. All this discussion has demonstrated is EXACTLY why the thumbs down/hidden comments section is a good thing. Just ask anyone who was able to skip over this pointless tangent and got to read only comments about A's prospects. I can only wish I was among them.

Dec 30, 2009 8:08 PM on A's Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

How about Bill Mueller?

Dec 30, 2009 11:09 AM on A's Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

He got enough thumbs down that it hid what was by his own admission a pretty silly comment. Its not like we chopped off a hand.

Dec 30, 2009 11:07 AM on A's Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -6

Right. Why would people thumbs down two completely unnecessary comments cluttering the page.

Dec 29, 2009 11:39 PM on A's Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Felix Hernandez = Historic

Dec 29, 2009 12:24 PM on A's Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

He does take much longer to get warmed up these days. He is also terrible at holding runners and slow to the plate. This combined with his propensity for wild pitches/passed balls makes him a particularly bad choice for high lev relief innings.

Dec 18, 2009 3:06 PM on No Lack of Lackey
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

What the hell are you talking about? Can you show me one instance of this? Find me a quote where someone at BP overrated Mike Cameron. + Regardless of that, he's a very good player.

Dec 17, 2009 2:15 PM on Through Six Weeks
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

Yes, Bay and Cameron have some of the same flaws (Ks, age). Fortunately, they didnt have ANYWHERE NEAR THE SAME PRICE. No idea why you're comparing their AVGs. Bay clearly is a better contact hitter. If Bay was willing to sign for what Cameron did or somewhere near it he would be a Red Sox today, I guarantee you. Cameron, even at age 37, is actually a very good defender, while Bay stinks. As for the defense in front of the Monster - sadly, MLB has yet again denied the Red Sox' petition to play all their games at Fenway in the 2010 season. If you had read all the comments here you might have noticed the Sox might slide Ellsbury over, too. Signing Lackey had absolutely nothing to do with Matsuzaka. He was a target of opportunity that they couldnt pass up and he also gives them flexibility to move Buchholz if they so desire. Theo was very surprised Lackey was interested in Boston. He wasnt someone they had planned on making a big run at.

Dec 17, 2009 9:55 AM on Through Six Weeks
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

Its certainly under consideration and the comments from team personnel have seemed to have left that door open. Adding to that argument is that Ellsbury actually posted an excellent UZR/150 rate in his time there (SSS, though). The downside is: we all agree that Ellsbury has the tools to be an excellent/plus CFer, so what do we gain by not giving him the experience to get better? Its not like Cameron is a long term solution there... Im also of the opinion that UZR is unnecessarily harsh on Ellsbury. I think this is a result of UZR's known issues with Fenway and the strange wall dimensions. Further, Bay was such an atrocious defender that I can't help but wonder if Ellsbury was hurt by having to shade to Bay's side too often. Neither Reddick nor Hermida are full time options if Ellsbury is dealth. They would likely look for a platoon mate for Hermida. Xavier Nady has been mentioned. Reddick probably needs some more seasoning and is also hurt by both him and Hermida (and Ellsbury and Drew) being LHH.

Dec 16, 2009 9:13 PM on Through Six Weeks
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Why would he steal less? Johnny Damon, older and less speedy, hitting out of the #2 spot stole 25, 27, 29 and 12(injuries) with the Yankees. The Yankees run plenty. In fact, in 09 the Yanks stole 111 bases while the Tigers stole only 72. I would predict a bump in Runs, HR, RBI and SB. In fact, given how bad Comerica was for him and how friendly Yankee Stadium will be, I could see 30-40 HRs (he did just hit 30 in Detroit). He could be a real fantasy monster. Im less confident in the AVG rebounding, as I think he's legitimately changed his approach some, giving up some contact for power.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Read the comments following this: http://www.baseballthinkfactory.org/files/oracle/discussion/red_sox_signed_scutaro/ Scutaro has played most of his career in two parks (Oakland and Toronto) badly suited for his swing - as well as two of the parks that most suppress batting AVG (ask Matt Holliday). All indication are Fenway will be particularly helpful to him, as well. In either case, he can never be Lugo, since a) He's making much less money over a much shorter term; and b) even if he craps out he can be moved to another team or made into a super sub, since he can play multiple positions fairly well. The contract makes this a real low risk, medium reward kind of deal.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

There is zero reason to believe Scutaro will be "below average in the field." No idea where youre getting that from. The worst projections are "average," while there is some reason to believe he can be a plus defender. The scouting reports certainly read that way. Also, from Theo's comments today it appears their internal defensive metrics had very favorable readings on Scutaro. As for the bat - where the hell are you getting 10-20 runs below average??? The last five years he has been +14.5, -7.2, -5.7, +1.0, -5.1. That's a far, far cry from "10-20 runs below average at the plate." Take off your Yankees cap and stop pulling numbers out of your ass. No one is claiming Scutaro is some sort of impact player, but he could probably best your projections for him on one leg.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

No one is "obsessed" with cost. The issue is that a fair and accurate evaluation of front office performance can't be made without taking into account the resources available.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

Uh... the pitcher, not the actor/entertainer... Oh hell, both of them if you want.

Dec 04, 2009 10:34 AM on Angels Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Thoughts on Will Smith?

Dec 04, 2009 10:33 AM on Angels Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -5

Wow! A big fatbody who can play below average to poor defense at multiple positions!

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

So your point would be something like: "Red Sox: 75-90% of the Yankee success at half the cost!"...?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I would have a hard time voting for a team that spent 200 million a year for a decade and only has one ring to show for it, and - oh yeah, they had let the core of their team fall apart so much they had to give out almost 500 million in contracts on free agents the year before that title to make it happen. The only amazing thing about the Yankees of the last decade is that they only won a single title spending that incredible amount of money.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Curious where Hochevar would rank on the 25 and under list if he qualified, as well as any other comments you have on him.

Dec 01, 2009 12:22 PM on Royals Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Search function for chats would be great, please. I hate when I half remember a KG comment on a prospect and I have to go to 8 different chat pages to try to find it.

Nov 23, 2009 9:32 AM on April 15-28, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Get ready to miss some really great players. Everyone is aware there is an inherent risk here. The issue is you need to lean much more heavily on scouting (vs. stats) with low minors guys, IMHO.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

So if there was Fantasy Baseball in the early 1900's and you saw Babe Ruth go 0-8 with 4 Ks over two days you wouldn't have drafted him, either? If you can only go by what you saw: 1) You're going to miss a hell of a lot; and 2) you're on the wrong website.

Nov 12, 2009 12:18 PM on November 11
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

This system has two 5 star players and 2 4 star players, with lots of 3s. At the end of the day, it might be down a little from years past, but its still going to compare favorably.

Nov 12, 2009 11:46 AM on Red Sox Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Anybody in the org. you talked to regretting the aggressive promotion at this point...?

Nov 12, 2009 11:30 AM on Red Sox Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

No way. Pujols is heads, tails and a mile better. Gonzalez Career vs RHP: .298/.383/.543 vs LHP: .244/.316/.428 Pujols Career vs RHP: .330/.419/.622 vs LHP: .346/.452/.646 Pujols is the better contact hitter by a wide margin. Pujols doesnt have a platoon split. Pujols has a 11.1% K rate. Gonzalez K's 19.7% of the time. Gonzalez is a very good fielder, but Id give Pujols the edge there as well. Even though theyre both big sluggers, the difference in baserunning ability is pretty big. Pujols is a far superior player to Gonzalez any way you cut it. Gonzalez is a lot closer to Ryan Howard.

Nov 11, 2009 1:05 PM on April 16-17, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Pujols doesnt have a huge platoon split.

Nov 11, 2009 12:57 PM on April 16-17, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I have to agree with you - its just too early to tell. There are many possible outcomes for Desme and even the wild extremes wouldn't shock me. I feel like I just don't have enough information to even make an educated guess at this point. Should be very interesting to see what he does in 2010.

Nov 11, 2009 10:31 AM on November 11
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yes, other GMs won't do that... at least no more than usual. AA has been involved in the trade discussions the entire time. Nothing has really changed. Every GM knows AA. He's not some noob they think they can/should try to scam out of Halladay.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Its been reported that the Sox offered Michael Bowden.

Nov 09, 2009 12:26 AM on Fire Up the Hot Stove
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Woo hoo!

Oct 14, 2009 10:26 AM on Light Breaks Through
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Ive heard some positive things about Jackson's swing... but having seen it a few times now (months apart) it seems like an awfully long/slow stroke.

Oct 07, 2009 11:55 PM on Playoff Stars Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 4

There's one more guy better than Sabathia.

Aug 24, 2009 11:34 AM on AL Awards Quandary
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Span's never shown power at all except briefly in the majors. Its not coming back.

Aug 07, 2009 11:41 AM on Fish or Cut Bait?
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

"I think it's dangerous to look at the overall numbers and take comfort in the idea that he's been the victim of bad luck. Smoltz's problem has been the big inning, especially late in the game." Swing and a miss. Might want to take another whack at reading this article.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

"Yankees: They figure to be quiet because they feel their team is good enough to get to the postseason and win it all as-is." That might be the party line. I see a team a) without many obvious places where they can upgrade; and b) without the bullets to pull off a significant upgrade. Montero and Jackson are both far off limits. As are Cano, Hughes and Joba. What's left that can land an impact player?

Jul 29, 2009 1:18 PM on Who's Still Shopping?
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yeah... about that. You said he "just missed the cut." On behalf of your readers, if you ever have trouble cutting down from six guys to five, well please feel free to throw in that sixth guy! I dont think anyone is gonna complain that you broke the format or anything...

Jul 23, 2009 11:16 AM on July 23
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

How bout this for a fit: Ty Wigginton? 3B and LF... can fill in all over and adds more power to the lineup.

Jul 16, 2009 12:26 PM on AL
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Those guys are elite basestealers who steal against everyone. The Red Sox have openly coached their pitchers not to speed up their delivery or worry too much about baserunners. Their extent of holding runners is basically to hold for different times before delivering each pitch. There are a number of organizations that take this approach. Theyre more interested in pitchers focusing on delivering their pitches. Varitek doesnt have a good arm, but its not awful. Kottaras does have a decent arm, but no shot while catching Wake.

Jul 16, 2009 11:22 AM on AL
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

"Fine-tuning might include acquiring a catch-and-throw reserve backstop; both Jason Varitek and George Kottaras have thrown out fewer than 20% of attempting basestealers, a bad weakness to have when you’re in the same division as Carl Crawford, B.J. Upton, and Brett Gardner." I dont think there are many who would best those kind of numbers. As an organization, the Sox de-emphasize this with their pitchers.

Jul 15, 2009 3:39 PM on AL
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

Id prefer BP continuing doing what theyre doing - an integrated approach that tries to paint the whole picture instead of just half. Besides, BA's half full of crap anyway. What they "do well" is apparently invite beat writers who have no clue to write up top 10 lists.

Jul 09, 2009 11:45 AM on Big Steps Backwards
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Its all SSS. He's only had 244 ABs as a pro. Of those, only 64 were against LHPs. At that point just 3 more hits would have him batting .250. As you say, its never been a problem before - and him being a switch hitting further adds to the skepticism. Who would they platoon him with? LHH (and terrible) Chris Davis...? LHH Hank Blalock?

Jul 08, 2009 12:55 PM on Great Leaps Forward
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Kevin - any thoughts on Rzepczynski?

Jul 08, 2009 12:19 PM on Great Leaps Forward
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

#87 going into 2009: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=8506 So decent shot at top 50 I would guess...?

Jul 07, 2009 9:55 AM on July 7
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Where are you getting this impression that Manny is beloved? He's not regarded as one of the game's greatest villains or anything(though perhaps he should be), but he's certainly not beloved everywhere. Hated in Boston. Hated in New York (regards of having been in Boston). Hated in San Fran (He's a Dodger). Hated in Cleveland (took the cash and ran). The guy has burned lots of bridges and is reviled in a number of the biggest baseball markets. Manny is neither likable nor hugely popular outside of LA. He's a lot closer to hated. His antics are sometimes amusing, but in the way you laugh at what Terrell Owens does... but you wouldnt describe him as likable or hugely popular.

Jul 04, 2009 5:41 PM on January 14-27, 2002
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

They do have another solid catching prospect - Austin Romine. Pretty solid all around. Kevin has previously called him their catcher of the future.

Jul 03, 2009 10:47 AM on Represent!
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Seriously?? He has a .400 OBP and a ~.500 SLG. Kid is a stud all the way. You know who's else is batting around .267(actually .268)? Adrian Gonzalez. What a huge disappointment that guy has been this year, eh?

Jul 03, 2009 12:48 AM on Represent!
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

No! Still a terrible trade. Santana isnt doing "just okay." .268/.405/.496 is more than "just okay" for a good defensive catcher. That's a 901 OPS. 55 BB to 38 Ks, too. Regardless, if Santana and Meloan were both struck dead by lightning tomorrow, the trade would still have been a big mistake. He gave away a lot of value for a pretty mediocre asset. It was a bad trade at the time and it remains a bad trade. Good GMs dont give away value like that.

Jul 03, 2009 12:45 AM on Represent!
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Will his power carry at 3B? Id imagine Jemile Weeks will be the better shortstop of the two... Heard any back up plans for Weeks? CF?

Jul 03, 2009 12:41 AM on Represent!
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -7

Right. Hey, Kevin, If Montero was even an average defensive SHORTSTOP, how high in the rankings would he be? top 15? if he was a great defensive SHORTSTOP? What if he could throw 100 mph and fart lightning bolts??

Jul 03, 2009 12:39 AM on Represent!
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yes, and he's been promoted since then and hasnt exactly raked... until the last couple days

Jul 01, 2009 11:32 AM on Dream Crushing
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Unfortunately I think we will be trending towards more of this as the draft keeps rising in visability, not less...

Jun 17, 2009 8:04 PM on AL Draft Wrap
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I dont know how much stock you want to put into it, but on Brandon Jacobs, reports are he is no longer leaning football: "Auburn football signee chooses pro baseball Posted by Charles Goldberg -- Birmingham News June 10, 2009 4:30 PM Auburn running back/linebacker signee Brandon Jacobs will sign a professional baseball contract with Boston after the Red Sox selected him in the 10th round of the Major League draft on Wednesday, according to our friends at AuburnSports.com. Jacobs told Inside the Auburn Tigers that the Red Sox have agreed to pay for his college education. Jacobs told AuburnSports.com he'll sign for second-round money, which may mean upwards to $800,000. The website also said Jacobs would have been a grayshirt this season at Auburn, meaning he would not have played." http://blog.al.com/goldmine/2009/06/auburn_football_signee_chooses.html

Jun 17, 2009 11:00 AM on AL Draft Wrap
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Will tomorrow's roundtable have more than three questions...? /kidding

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Could definitely see Purke dropping to Boston.

Jun 08, 2009 9:55 AM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

FYI, KG proudly built and launched the Feliz bandwagon...

May 28, 2009 11:42 AM on 2008 Draft Review: AL
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Just wanted him to weigh in. The guy is kind of a train wreck (Kevin previously described him as having "more red flags than a Chinese army parade") and has shown pretty uninspiring results against younger competition so far this year... but he still gets a ton of hype and has laughably been on the BA top 100 two years running. He still has a lot of fanboys for some reason and I was hoping KG would weigh in with the industry consensus on this guy.

May 27, 2009 11:51 AM on May 27th
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Are you aware Grady Sizemore is half African-American?

May 27, 2009 10:28 AM on AL All-Stars
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

So, in your opinion, Andrew Brackman should not be considered a top 100 prospect, right?

May 27, 2009 9:23 AM on May 27th
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

How can he pick Pedroia? This is the "Real Life" All Star team. Fantasy stats like HR and SB dont have added significance here. Take a look at their slash stats and defense.

May 22, 2009 8:55 AM on AL All-Stars
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

That rationale for Tex over Youk doesnt make a whole lot of sense. You admit he was "comparable" (I would say better) last year and "outperformed" him this year... but youre giving it to Tex on... a career achievement basis...? Not sure I follow this line of thought. Dont get me wrong - if youre asking me to wager who will be better in the future Im taking Teixeira. What's the point of this entire thing, though, if we're not rewarding performance to some extent? There's nothing Youk could do to get your vote over Teixeira...? Why even look at the numbers then. Just fill out a ballot with your favorite players before the season.

May 22, 2009 8:53 AM on AL All-Stars
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Well, again, you could make the same arguments about Peavy's value. Regardless of that, if youve made the decision to trade Peavy - for whatever reasons - you should trade Gonzalez too in order to try to obtain a young championship caliber core. You have twenty other needs... why hold on to the mashing 1B? Youre going to try to build a team around him and nothing else? I dont buy it. They have too many other problems. By the time you fill those other needs Gonzalez will be approaching free agency. It doesnt make a lot of sense. I can understand that there is no urgency to trade him RIGHT NOW... but if youve decided to rebuild you dont want to wait too long because youre just delaying the rebuilding process. Gonzalez is a piece for a contender. You want the guys you trade him for to be ready around the same time the guys you got for Peavy are...

May 22, 2009 8:38 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Youre missing the point. If you can get three good players who arent as good as Gonzalez in 2012 but are still going to be under team control for 5-6 years... well, you came out ahead, because you dont have to break the bank to re-sign Gonzalez or let him walk and break up your young core. The Red Sox would rightfully hang up on you if you asked for that return.

May 22, 2009 8:32 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Youre not if he stays healthy. Fangraphs has his last full season (2007) as worth >$25M. That's great value. The only reason his three year numbers (not sure why you chose that) are deflated is because he missed time in 08, pitching only 173 innings.

May 21, 2009 12:42 PM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yeah... still no idea how to make a lineup out though. Also has a penchant for playing terrible defensive players over better choices.

May 21, 2009 12:38 PM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Right. If you cant afford to spend that kind of money on your #1 starter... what exactly are you saving it for? That's a discount rate for what Peavy gives you.

May 21, 2009 10:28 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

You would be wrong.

May 21, 2009 10:05 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Really? I cant see anyone making a Teixeira like offer for anyone. The value of prospects has shifted. That was a boatload that Texas got from Atlanta in the first place... it was considered a ton of value even then. Unless you meant Tex to LA for Kotchman...?

May 21, 2009 9:26 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

That's exceptionally affordable for the kind of player Peavy is. $52 million guaranteed over three years is affordable for the majority of teams, and is a bargain for many mid market teams that otherwise could never get a player of this talent in free agency without committing 8 years and >100 mill.

May 21, 2009 9:23 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I was saying that is why they SHOULD trade Gonzalez. tombores99 was saying they wouldnt trade Gonzalez because he is affordable, controlled and good. The same arguments go for Peavy, so if they saw fit to trade Peavy it stands to reason they wont let those things stop them from trading Gonzalez.

May 21, 2009 9:21 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

You could cite the same reasons for not trading Peavy! Where would they get a controlled, affordable Ace?

May 21, 2009 8:55 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Is it? The guy is kind of a lunatic and knocks his players to the press all the time. I wouldnt want to play for him and Im sure there are plenty of others. Also, he's really bad at some aspects of managing. Like setting a batting order. Its like him and Ron Gardenhire have a bet to see who can bat the most .290 OBP players 1-2 in the lineup.

May 21, 2009 8:43 AM on There They Go Again
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -4

Where is this "grumbling among Boston fans?" Please. You mean "among YANKEE fans."

May 07, 2009 1:29 PM on Your Mileage May Vary
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 16

Ive long thought this year's NL West winner would win somewhere around 43 games.

May 07, 2009 10:43 AM on Your Mileage May Vary
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

PEDSPN

May 07, 2009 10:42 AM on Your Mileage May Vary
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

EVERY YEAR Martinez has never actually done well - he's just held his own against older competition. Id like to see him actually hit well once, regardless of ARL. Until then he's just a good prospect to me, not a top 50 guy.

May 05, 2009 11:19 AM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I never said that... I said the University of Miami (the one in Florida) was named after the nearby city. Go read it again. You really, really need to work on your reading comprehension.

May 05, 2009 11:16 AM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yeah... about that... Doing some research before opening your mouth would help you not look stupid. My original point was made jokingly, anyway. Besides, I said "MAJOR American city." Major was the important part...

May 04, 2009 10:15 PM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -3

Except the University in Florida was named for the nearby City (actually in Coral Gables), not the tribe, strictly speaking...

May 04, 2009 10:13 PM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -5

What I dont understand is why people who name their University after a major American city a 1,000 miles away get angry when confusion arises. They should just rename the Ohio school "Fake Miami." Of course, I should mention my parents are both Alums of the Florida school...

May 04, 2009 11:16 AM on Monday Ten Pack
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

If he could hit 15 HRs that would have ranked him what? 15th among MLB 3B last year.

Apr 30, 2009 10:30 PM on AL Central Notebook
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

The Mets move EVERYONE too aggressively. Same thing happened with Gomez. People were excited about his hitting ARL... neither of these guys has ever actually hit.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Its a good preview of what he would look like in the New Yankee Stadium at Arlington.

Apr 29, 2009 9:48 PM on
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Hmm... was kind of jokingly hoping that you might use this opportunity (my comment) to tell us a little something about Rondon...

Apr 29, 2009 9:47 PM on
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

Im pretty sure anyone can put up Manny Ramirez-esque defense in LF.

Apr 29, 2009 1:31 PM on
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

You chose to feature Mike Carp over Rondon???

Apr 29, 2009 9:21 AM on
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I mean... we knew you already follow this stuff on a daily basis. Why not share your reactions with us? Really a great idea. Also, I can't wait to see what you have on Hector Rondon tomorrow.

Apr 28, 2009 8:07 PM on Whither Runs?
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Awesome! I anxiously await all your articles. Every morning I check to see if there's a new future shock up. KG's in charge for one week and this place is already turning into Baseball America! /kidding

Apr 28, 2009 8:02 PM on Whither Runs?
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I think youre understating the improvement in the Texas defense.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

On Ryan's velocity... gameday is making it out to be only a drop of less than one mph.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

You put Brandon Allen in top 100... but give him no chance to be the #1 in a relatively weak ChiSox system...?

Apr 07, 2009 10:19 AM on Future Top Dogs, AL
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Take another look. Dan Giese, Phil Hughes and Alfredo Aceves arent even on the same planet with Smoltz/Buchholz/Bowden/Masterson. A HOF pitcher who still projects great, last year's best pitching prospect in the game and two other high end, MLB ready starting pitcher prospects. Masterson was #53 on last year's top 100 prospects and Bowden was #31 this year. Hughes hasnt had the same stuff for the last year and a half/two years. A lot of Yankee fans want to throw him in with Buchholz as "elite pitching prospects" but I dare you to find someone in baseball who would trade Buchholz for Hughes. The depth the Yankees have is mostly in DH/corner types and middle relievers... its just not comparable to what the Sox have. I wouldnt say the Yanks or Rays have "poor depth" by any means, but its nothing like the depth Boston has.

Apr 05, 2009 4:03 PM on The Top Ten
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

We know for a fact that Joba can't pitch a full year this year. That's different than saying "Kazmir could get hurt."

Apr 04, 2009 10:22 AM on Projected AL Standings
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

"The cream of the league is so tightly grouped that it's easy to envision any scenario that involves play-in games after the regular season, and all three teams can already be second-guessed before we've played a single game: Going without an A-Rod replacement during his injury-induced absence? Sending down David Price? Missing Manny?" Missing Manny...?

Apr 03, 2009 10:54 AM on Projected AL Standings
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Great article, Mark. Very innovative way of approaching the issue.

Apr 03, 2009 9:52 AM on Stealing Stolen Bases
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Agree completely. Reports on his Slider this spring werent great. It should not be a surprise to anyone if he has some struggles in his rookie season. Look at Clay Buchholz. It is becoming more and more common for guys to come into the majors as MLB ready regulars or stars. This isnt always the case. There is a lot to adjust to on and off the field for these young men.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

A good CF prospect came up last year and put up a line of .280/.336/.413 and an UZR of 14.9. People were not thrilled for some reason. I dont understand it.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Baseball would have been perfect for the system World Soccer uses. Big teams would have to buy talent from lower division clubs. Its scary how much sense it would make. The downside would be that some of the best talents might get stuck down for a couple years (Not a major concern - it doesnt happen that much in soccer). The upside is the minor league would absolutely be worth watching and cheering for. Thanks a lot, Branch Rickey.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 4

Those guys over at Baseball Prospectus did - oh, wait...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Pablo Sandoval isnt exactly proven... and if he ends up at 1B he's basically a replacement level player. Or perhaps I missed the sarcasm...?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I think its a programming error/typo. If you look at the runs scored/runs allowed projections, you do NOT get a pyth of 100 Wins for the Yanks... unless Im doing it wrong.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Right. I hate the Knicks... but every time I that Willis Reed footage...

Mar 24, 2009 12:23 PM on Curt Schilling Bows Out
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -12

Its pretty despicable to throw around accusations like this.

Mar 24, 2009 12:22 PM on Curt Schilling Bows Out
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

was covered in a previous unfiltered titled "Mini-UTK..."

Mar 20, 2009 7:52 PM on Cutting it Close
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

If youre going to make an app, make one for a real phone like the BlackBerry Storm!

Mar 20, 2009 7:51 PM on Cutting it Close
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Still, none of the three are worth Clay Buchholz.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

"Maybe Jesus Montero really can catch after all" Nooooo!!!! Youre just going to get them started again! Prepare for 37 questions on this in your next chat...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

That was my understanding as well. He wants to play SS, but theyre going to make him pitch 100 innings first, then play the reas of the year at SS. My understanding was scouts loved him as a pitcher... and he's likely a good defensive SS, but his bat ceiling is a question mark.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

I wouldnt worry about the Rangers! Those kids are doing just fine...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

No need to apologize. Those of us without any baseball sources are happy to hear the latest rumblings from people in the know. I think everyone is aware that baseball rumors have a high failure rate... still love to hear them!

Mar 18, 2009 10:12 AM on Third Base
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Torn rotator cuff AND torn labrum. From Rotoworld: "Rangers pitching prospect Eric Hurley is expected to miss the 2009 season after undergoing surgery to repair a torn rotator cuff and frayed labrum in his right shoulder. Rotator cuff and labrum damage is the worst possible combination for a pitcher and will likely be tougher to come back from than Tommy John elbow surgery. Hurley made his MLB debut as a 22-year-old and looked like a long-term No. 3 starter in the making, but is now out for 2009 and a major question mark beyond that." http://www.rotoworld.com/content/playerpages/player_main.aspx?sport=MLB&id=437 Going to be out for a long time. Decent chance he's toast...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

That's a pretty convoluted hypothesis. Occam's razor wise, I think we can safely say Pedro was just really, really good. Does anyone claim Babe Ruth wasnt really that much better than his peers, but rather that the pitchers day in and day out just faced so many garbage hitters that they werent prepared to face a guy like the Babe? One can only wonder at how ridiculous Pedro's numbers might have looked had he hit his peak in 2008 instead of in the middle of an offensive explosion.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yes, that person would have been ridiculous. Yes, I think its quite possible no one better will ever come along (talking about peak seasons relative to what the rest of the league was doing). Its silly to list all-time greats as upside for prospects. Saying "his upside is Pedro" is like saying his upside is Ruth or Koufax. At his peak, Pedro can certainly make an argument for best season of all time, relative to era. Its absurd to list that as an upside comp because really, we arent talking about his relatively short peak or 2008 Pedro. if youre listing Pedro as his upside you mean peak Pedro. There quite possibly was no one better than his 98, 99 seasons. Its like asking what are the chances that Neftali Feliz's upside is "the best pitcher ever?" Its distasteful and counter productive.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

That's like asking: Do you think Smoak's upside is that of a Lou Gehrig or a healthy switch hitting Prince Fielder?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

No one's upside is Pedro Martinez. That's ridiculous.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Please! I suggested this before in the Indians Top 11 comments and got no response. I would love to see the write ups for some of these guys!

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Word is Gabbard is being converted to a LOOGY/LH reliever. David Murphy and Kason Gabbard are two very marginal MLB players. Beltre was the entire deal, and while he has tools coming out the kazoo, he hasnt really produced or turned those into skill yet. Moot point because Gagne was so bad for Boston, but this deal wasnt nearly as skewed as youre making it. In fact, if Gagne hadnt sucked so hard the Sox would have gotten a comp pick for him. It was amazing he performed poorly enough to lose Type A status...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

good point... point.

Mar 07, 2009 11:25 AM on Writer's Block
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Thank God! There's nowhere on him Id want to put a quarter in!

Mar 05, 2009 7:24 PM on Writer's Block
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

He\'s got a lot of time for the power to develop? What does that matter if scouts dont think he will develop power? ie his swing doesnt generate backsping/loft or he has the wrong swing plane, etc... Hell, Michael Ynoa is even younger - that doesnt mean he has a chance to develop power at the plate...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I was under impression only subscribers could post... That explains a lot. I was shocked that some of these absurd comments were coming from BP subscribers.

Feb 26, 2009 6:47 PM on Record Watch
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

Really? I think some of the best analysis is being done over there. Cameron and Tango are great and there is new and interesting stuff every day.

Feb 26, 2009 11:39 AM on Record Watch
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 4

By the bye... the Keith Olbermann forward was pretty entertaining and well written.

Feb 26, 2009 11:37 AM on Record Watch
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Or Henry Rodriguez...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Good question. I completely forgot about him and I opened the article meaning to ask this question. Foremost on my mind is whether they see him as a reliever or starter...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I scrolled down to \"The Sleeper\" expecting it to be Hunter... curious where he belongs.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Second this... your assessment of him last year turned my head. Wondering where his ceiling is now. Thanks.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

\"Nonetheless, as last year\'s high-QERA, low-defensive efficiency Yankees, Diamondbacks, and Reds discovered, procuring pitching without addressing underlying defensive woes is like using an HDTV to display SD sources: you simply won\'t end up with the pretty picture you thought you were paying for.\" Love this quote... but what pitching did the 08 Yankees \"procure?\" They went with incumbent vets and threw some rookies into the rotation. Are you guilty of looking forward to the 09 Yankees? They have spent a ton of money on pitchers and other than Teixeira have done nothing to improve a pretty awful defensive team(5th worst in MLB, 3rd worst in AL in 2008). In that case, you make a great and much overlooked point.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Reminds of me when PECOTA was pessimistic on the 2007 Rays...

Feb 23, 2009 12:29 PM on Chasing Bonds
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I can\'t believe we\'re only a few years away from ARod\'s somber, strange, and soulless quest to break Barry Bond\'s lifetime home-run record. Should be a fun!

Feb 23, 2009 11:20 AM on Chasing Bonds
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -13

Right, preventive care... and PEDs.

Feb 23, 2009 11:14 AM on Chasing Bonds
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

One criticism... this list seems to have numerous candidates for \"weakest three star guy to make a top 11.\" Just based on your descriptions it seems like many of these guys are similar to the two star guys youve written up. For instance, you just gave Tyler Sample two stars... and his write up sound a lot better than a few of the three star guys on this list.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

...but much more professional that accusing a professional of bias. Especially when, if you had read the comments already instead of just rushing to post, you would have seen Kevin already said: \"Yeah, you\'ve found an bit of a weakness in the system. Basically, 5-star for me is a top 50 level prospect. Now, until I actually DO a Top 100, that\'s a bit of a guessing game. I thought they\'d rank lower personally, and then when I added it all up there were less 5-star guy than expected, so I\'d up Martinez and Rosario.\" That\'s right - this shouldnt even be an issue because he has changed FMart and Rosario to five star.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Or maybe the plus column for basball just still outweighs the minus column. Just like how I keep watching the NBA despite the fact the refs are insane, crooked and awful. Steroids ARE a bad drug. Do people not understand why there has to be a limit to PEDs?? Can you imagine a sports world with no regulation of PEDs? It would be perennial race to find who has the best doctor. Player health would always be at risk as they try to find that next edge. Instead of worrying about who has the best fastball we would have fantasy magazines talking about what roids a pitcher is using. Steroids would become a necessity for all MLB players. THAT is the evil of steroids and why they must be banned and why those who use them must be condemned. We are always a hair away from a bizarro, 1984 style professional sports world. The level of competition and the money involved form a gigantic force forever pushing things in that direction. Much like with freedom, the price here is constant vigilance.

Feb 22, 2009 5:28 PM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

What does that prove? That story broke the same time as the ARod story! Take a look at the Mitchell report coverage.

Feb 22, 2009 8:42 AM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

It was a broken wrist and that\'s a great point. I would take him over Aviles anyday. I see nothing to like about Aviles.

Feb 21, 2009 12:20 AM on Shortstops
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

What I was saying is that I, personally, have zero doubt that steroids are effective. I dont care why ARod is the story. He\'s a public figure and he did something wrong - it was an illegal act, performance enhancing or not. If he gets more than his share, well, that\'s life. If that\'s the price for the money he makes you can sign me up.

Feb 21, 2009 12:11 AM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -5

Its funny the outrage ARod fans seem to have over the leaks. No one doubts the leaks are wrong, but that doesnt change the fact ARod did in fact use steroids. Its even more funny that these same people want the other 103 names to come out. Privacy for ARod = good. Privacy for everybody else = bad. \"Enough of this witch hunt against ARod! That information never should have been leaked! That\'s the real crime! ... Now lets get those other 103 names out! Why do those guys get off scot-free!?\" Major hypocrisy. Only makes sense if our goal is \"diminish what ARod has done.\"

Feb 20, 2009 8:03 PM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

They were an ILLEGAL substance. They were also prohibited by baseball. Although practically, it was probably not possible to punish players because of collective bargaining issues, that doesnt change the fact it was prohibited by baseball. Let me ask you this: 1) Do steroids help you in with weight training? 2) Does weight training help you on the baseball diamond? If you answer \"Yes\" to both of these questions I dont understand how you can maintain that steroids dont help you play baseball. I cant imagine anyone answering \"No\" to either of these, either. Steroids improve baseball performance by helping you get stronger and heal quicker. Just because its not a pill you can take that makes your flyballs automatically go farther doesnt mean its not helping you. Steroids are also cheating IMHO. The notion they were cheating has always been there, too. Its not like in 2005 people woke up and said \"wait a minute, that\'s cheating!\" Go back to 1990, 1980, 1970, etc... and ask players, FO personnel and MLB execs and even the steroid users: \"Are steroids cheating?\" and they would answer \"Yes.\" They were explicitly forbidden by the Fay Vincent memo. Yes, he admitted he couldnt enforce it - but what does that change??? The ability to punish players has nothing to do with whether they are cheating or not. Vincent wasnt able to punish them for a tertiary reason that has nothing to do with this. I dont understand why people jump on the fact Vincent admitted he couldnt enforce it. The fact he issued it is far more telling about what people though about steroids. Just because its \"not breaking a rule\" doesnt fly with me either. There is no rule on the books against stealing signs, even electronically. Its just a memo from the commish - SAME AS IN THIS CASE. Yet any type of sign stealing would be, to ballplayers, \"cheating. The only difference with steroids is it overlapped collective bargaining issues.

Feb 20, 2009 7:55 PM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I dont question that is happening... my issue is whether actively trying to find out those other 108 names is a good goal to have. What\'s the point here? To make ARod look better by comparison? Do we really think if all those names came out the Steroids story would go away...? I thought the party line at BP was that we want the steroids story to go away - in that light, it seems strange to want those other names to come out... I dont think making ARod look comparatively better by bringing down more players is something we should shoot for. THAT sounds like TMZ to me. I also dont agree that steroids isnt the reason for the ARod backlash. Did people hate Raffy or Big Mac? Why were those such big stories? Im sure a good bit of it is the taking down of a celebrity - but I cant feel bad for these guys because they put themselves in that situation. I agree with you w/respects to the NFL. I have no doubt they have ten times the steroids problem of MLB.

Feb 20, 2009 11:37 AM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Dammit, Joe Sheehan, I didnt expect you to comment in the middle of a Carroll thing! Sorry!

Feb 20, 2009 11:28 AM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

So Will, youre against a \"witch hunt\" (admittedly not your words!) against ARod to find out the details of him using - the whole TMZ thing, unless Ive misunderstood - which is entirely possible... But you would be totally for a \"witch hunt\" to find out the other 108 names who tested positive? To what end?

Feb 20, 2009 11:20 AM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Those were news stories in turn, though not on this level. ARod is the highest paid player in the game and a much more news worthy story. Its not some kind of witch hunt - the American public doesnt care about the Mike Morse\'s of the world. They do care about ARod. The reason its still being talked about today is that he keeps adding info for some insane reason. He needs to just stop talking about it. Other steroids stories have caused a media frenzy like this! Rafael Palmeiro was a big story. McGwire crying was a big story. The Mitchell Report was a big story. Barry Bonds has been a huge story a hundred times over. No one is claiming those other 100+ names dont count. We dont have them, though. Theyre sealed evidence. There is nothing we can do about that. Should we ignore the ARod story because we cant find out the rest of the names right now? Give me those other names and Ill skewer them too, but enough of this portraying ARod as a victim. He DID use steroids and got caught. Im aware that 8% of the players got caught too, and I think theyre deserving of as much condemnation when/if we find out who they are. It doesnt change that we know for a fact that ARod was one of those names right now.

Feb 20, 2009 11:15 AM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Im not following you... You are aware ARod both tested positive and has admitted to using steroids, right? I would agree with you that speculation about other players without any sort of evidence or proof or confession is not worthwhile. Fortunately, in ARod\'s case we have all those things and can be 100% sure he used steroids. Therefore, I dont consider it covering \"this story as if we’re the sports section of TMZ\" when people criticize him for doing what he had openly admitted to doing and apologizing for. I would say random speculation about players would be more TMZ-like than anything. In fact, one could easily take the opposite tack from you and applaud the media for not accusing others of using steroids in the complete absence of evidence.

Feb 20, 2009 10:52 AM on The Men In Black
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

Also, hilariously, Dusty plans on batting him lead off. How does this guy keep getting jobs?

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Im not sure I want to kill Amaro for it, but I agree that Ibanez was an awful idea and contract. Rather than make it a referendum on Amaro and where the Phils are going Im inclined to chalk this up to \"badly misinterpreting where the market was headed.\"

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

The difference is Kennedy was never the finesse/control pitcher he was made out to be. His walk rates throughout the minors were never great - just good. The only thing he has in common with control artists like Slowey, Moyer, etc... isnt control - its marginal stuff. Take a look at his walk rates. He walked WAY more guys than Slowey in the minors. Kennedy has been typecasted as something he\'s not.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

A very mediocre offense. One made worse by Gardenhire mad desire to bat two speedy .310 OBP players 1-2.

Feb 19, 2009 3:18 PM on Pegging the 2009 Season
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Hmmm... Well, working on the assumption that these projected standings are run off a database using the weighted means (when will that be updated, btw??)... what if the projections were done using the 40th percentile and 60th percentile for every player? Or 30 and 70, etc... That would give a great look at team \"upside.\" I realize you wouldnt want to run those every day all season, but a one team pre-season run would sure be fun and informative.

Feb 19, 2009 3:15 PM on Pegging the 2009 Season
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I would think Chris Carter (or even Jeff Bailey - though he isnt on the 40 man) would have the edge over Van Every in terms of playing time at LF behind Bay. Theyre probably all behind Baldelli, Kotsay, Wilkerson too, so I would think 10% of LF for Van Every is high...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I dont know that it makes much difference, but isnt it time to put Penny as the #5 starter and Buchholz somewhere around #7? The IP projections already reflect this...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Anyone who doesnt burst on the scene as a ready made fantasy God like Evan Longoria is immediately labeled a \"bust\" or \"awful\" these days.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Players do improve their discipline and patience as they get old, but think of it more as \"slight improvements\" and \"over the course of their career.\" Not so much \"drastic improvements\" and \"upon reaching the high minors/MLB.\" The ability of young players (like Andrus) to improve their OBP/walk rate is being dramatically overstated as of late.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Pretty sure its Inoa...

Feb 13, 2009 11:22 AM on The Best of the Best
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Kevin, any comments on Inoa\'s ranking? Or should I just wait for the Athletics top 11?

Feb 13, 2009 10:55 AM on The Best of the Best
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Does anyone have Castro above Smoak? I thought this was a given...

Feb 13, 2009 10:12 AM on The Best of the Best
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I dont know... was hoping youd have some magical answer that would put a divide between them... like... \"Hosmer\'s extra power is too much to ignore!\" or something like that. Thanks anyway.

Feb 13, 2009 10:01 AM on The Best of the Best
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I guess at this point Im just bearish on Brignac\'s ability to reach that potential.

Feb 13, 2009 9:59 AM on The Best of the Best
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I know you havent done the Rangers yet... but Im having trouble separating Smoak and Hosmer as prospects. One high school, one college. One a switch, one a lefty. Massive power vs. polished high AVG. What is the difference in ceiling here? I cant eyeball it at all and Im curious to hear who scouts like more... well... Hosmer apparently, but Im curious as to their rationale. Thanks.

Feb 13, 2009 9:49 AM on The Best of the Best
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

So I see you havent given up on Brignac or Adenhart yet... Andrus at 73 and Brignac at 62...? I understand Brignac profiles as a more complete hitter and Andrus\'s secondary skills are fairly limited, but that still strikes me as a strange choice.

Feb 13, 2009 9:46 AM on The Best of the Best
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Speaking of which... when will we see a new weighted means spreadsheet? Its vastly different from the PECOTAs up now w/playing time adjustments. Im still surprised Abreu makes that much of a difference with the bat. Looking at the PECOTAs for Sarge, Jr. and Juan Rivera I guess it is a pretty big upgrade.

Feb 12, 2009 9:36 PM on Florida Fraud
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Stupid East Coast Bias!

Feb 12, 2009 3:48 PM on Royals Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Im pretty shocked Abreu was a 4 win difference... isnt PECOTA aware he\'s now a terrible defender?

Feb 12, 2009 10:29 AM on Florida Fraud
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

He probably would be as viable an option as Dunn or Manny in the OF. Thankfully for Royals fans, Dayton Moore isnt that dumb.

Feb 12, 2009 10:02 AM on Royals Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I think Dave Cameron had a great article over at fangraphs about this. Simply taking his away ABs as his \"true talent\" line is a woefully inadequate way to measure Holliday\'s talent. NEARLY EVERY PLAYER hits better at home. Taking his home ABs out of the equation unfaily punishes Holliday. A better way is to correct ALL his batting stats for park and run scoring environment.

Feb 12, 2009 9:39 AM on Florida Fraud
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

I think this may just be a symptom of the larger issue: pitchers are inherently more difficult to predict from year to year than hitters.

Feb 11, 2009 11:33 PM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

To clarify: Most of those articles, that is, and again, my issue wasnt the Ellsbury wasnt hyped up... Im just saying much of that can be attributed to a hot start. The contention was that before the season many people picked him ROY and I dont think there\'s much if any truth to that.

Feb 11, 2009 3:44 PM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

Those arent from before the season. As I said, those were from when he came out of the gates like a rocket.

Feb 11, 2009 3:39 PM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 4

What? 1) He\'s almost certain to get \"serious BABIP love\" consistently because of his speed. 2) .336 is a decent OBP. ~.330 is average. If he\'s a GG quality CFer with tremendous speed who gets 50SB/5CS every year with a .350 OBP that would be a pretty valuable player to have. Sign me and every GM in baseball up for that. That\'s a great leadoff option. 3) Considering PECOTA has him for a .348 OBP this season as a 25 year old in his sophmore season Id say him consistently getting on base at a .350 clip is pretty reasonable and his peak years will probably surpass that.

Feb 11, 2009 3:37 PM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 3

A .336 OBP \"isn\'t acceptable?\" He\'s a center fielder! Right now, this season, he was an above average option at CF. He looked like he was going to be much better until he got hurt diving for a ball at the end of May and his swing got messed up. He didnt recover for a couple months. He\'s a very good player. What KG means, and I mostly agree with, is that he lacks the secondary skills to make his ceiling much higher - but he\'s a very good player.

Feb 11, 2009 3:31 PM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Though there was talk of Ellsbury winning when he started off hitting like .335 with 30 SBs, to be fair... but that\'s not really the same. I dont think saying he was overhyped when he was hitting .335 is a particularly cogent point, you know?

Feb 11, 2009 10:40 AM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

You got a link on this??? Longoria, Joba and Buchholz were the favorites most places IIRC

Feb 11, 2009 10:37 AM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Yes, where is the mention of \"incredible luck?\"

Feb 11, 2009 10:05 AM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

\"Jacoby Ellsbury: That\'s a pure bullseye. He\'s good, but the Boston hype machine put him up there as a star; PECOTA saw through that, as PECOTA doesn\'t read.\" Who is putting Jacoby Ellsbury up as a \"star?\" I hear this claimed a lot... Ive never really seen it happen, and I live in the Boston area. He was a good CFer in his rookie season and started off better before hitting a rookie wall. Is 90% of Ichiro a \"star?\" He wsa ~3.5 wins last year. That\'s pretty good.

Feb 11, 2009 10:02 AM on Impact Rookies
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

What kind of reasoning is that? Baseball is a game, but at the MLB level its a very big business as well. Im all for the fun, but if Im a M\'s fan and they lose Ichiro for the year because he got hurt pitching in the WBC I would be pretty p***ed off and less likely to spend my money on them.

Feb 09, 2009 9:28 PM on August 13-19
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 4

The amount of people who didnt read the comments above are stunning. I found the first fifteen \"Player X on my favorite team doesnt have the appropriate amount of playing time!\" comments funny. The next hundred are just irritating. RTFA, people. Clay is already aware of these problems and it says so above. Please stop.

Feb 09, 2009 9:22 PM on August 12-14, 2001
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

Hey, in all fairness Will was just talking about how ARod using Roids made him question his love for the game... ...or something like that...

Feb 09, 2009 4:57 PM on August 13-19
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -16

Clay, you forgot to put an asterisk next to A-Rod\'s projection in the Team Depth Charts...

Feb 09, 2009 1:32 PM on August 12-14, 2001
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Denial: Not just a river in Africa...

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Sort of... but it has always been in the purview of MLB to punish/suspend a player if they were arrested/charged with using an illegal substance. The same goes for steroids. I would argue the same goes for if there is evidence of someone using steroids. No one would blink if the NFL punished a player for this - they do it all the time, often not waiting to see if there\'s a conviction, and even if the player pleads out.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -3

Who is forgetting this? No one is. It doesnt change anything. He used steroids and lied about it. I dont care if every other ballplayer did - that\'s still a scumbag thing to do. Watch the Couric interview again. Disgusting.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Lets just hope Barry Lamar isnt the one doing the pissing... or the page with be covered with THG... and the government\'s case just got stronger!

Feb 05, 2009 12:01 PM on The Debate Continues
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Are they? Undoubtedly the political/moral reasons are a major element, but if youre implying there is no medical risk associated with anabolic steroids you are way off base. There are compelling medical reasons to ban steroids. Not just talking the abuse of steroids either. This isnt a blue laws issue.

Feb 05, 2009 12:00 PM on The Debate Continues
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 2

That already happened. We called it \"2006.\"

Feb 05, 2009 10:05 AM on Taking a Moment
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

So? Jeter has terminal PRS - Poor range syndrome. If youre saying the Mantle and Yount were obvious candidates to move because of health issues - well, that\'s not really any different from where Jeter is.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

I am slightly surprised by Carmona. I was more surprised to find Asdrubal so LOW, frankly. He\'s held his own in the majors at a very young age and has shown improvement. He\'s a patient hitter already and a plus plus defender. Id put him above Weglarz and Adam Miller. Miller I just dont believe can stay healthy and Weglarz is looking awfully Garko-esque.

Feb 04, 2009 11:45 AM on Indians Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Damn... any chance you want to give us a quick write up on De La Cruz? You know... that would make for a great article. I know youre swamped trying to finish the top 11s right now... but Im always unhappy when I see a guy in the \"Just Missed\" who Im curious about. I would love to see your write ups on the top 11 (or 33 or whatever!)guys around baseball who \"just missed.\" Complete with \"the Good\" \"the Bad\" and perfect world projections, etc... Its a bummer when I dont get to see your complete write up for someone like De La Cruz. Instead we have to read about the Tigers 11th best \"prospect.\" Your write ups are my first stop all season long and I usually punch something when I see the guy Im looking to read about just missed the list. Heck, I wouldnt care if this article came in April even. There\'s nothing going on with prospects then and Im always dying for the Monday Ten Packs to start... it would be great to read about the next level of prospects, even if it was just quick write ups. I realize this is probably the worst time to ask you about this, what with you rushing to finish the AL and probably sick of making phone calls... but think about it!

Feb 04, 2009 11:43 AM on Indians Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -3

Maybe you can explain to me the difference between corking your bat and poisoning the other team\'s starting pitcher on the day of his start.

Feb 04, 2009 11:19 AM on The Debate Continues
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -3

Yes, most Giants fans do agree on this.

Feb 04, 2009 11:18 AM on The Debate Continues
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

Well, lasix, tinted contacts and video arent illegal under U.S. Law. You don\'t go to jail if the police catch you using tinted contacts.

Feb 04, 2009 11:17 AM on The Debate Continues
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

Of course they were steroids. The marker in his blood that indicates what he took was steroids wasnt known. They also werent strictly prohibited by MLB at the time, but that\'s different from what youre saying. What we have now is (further) strong evidence that Barry Bonds took steroids. He took an illegal (Yes illegal by US Law even if not proscribed by baseball) substance for performance enhancing purposes.

Feb 04, 2009 11:13 AM on The Debate Continues
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -1

Not sure where you got that... Its just a rough measure of perceived upside (the term as you would regularly use it) based on how the player\'s top comparables (which is the major part of how PECOTA works - comparing players based on numerous factors in common) performed. I guess you could look at it as a loose measure of how likely a player is to perform above average based on his comps... of course, there are more learned minds than I on this site, so take it fwiw...

Feb 02, 2009 7:42 PM on August 9-11, 2001
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Juan Uribe says \"yes.\" Ozzie was on his case pretty bad despite some good numbers (minus his last full season).

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 5

What? Really? A) Pedroia still gets a very good projection, and his upside score is very high. There arent many 2B with better projections. B) Youkilis is projected for a great line. C) This is like the best line PECOTA has given J.D. Drew in years. D) Ortiz is still projected as one of the better hitters in baseball. E) Jason Bay\'s projection is still an excellent hitter. F) Jed Lowrie - okay, he doesnt get a great projection but it still ranks pretty good among SSs. G) Lowell got a very good projection! In fact, his PECOTA in 08 had his 09 season as .282/.341/.437 with 12 HRs. PECOTA has him for .272/.332/.442 with 14 HRs this year. Considering his injuries that\'s pretty good. H) If the Sox players perform like this they will be one of the top few teams in baseball. I) Have you looked at many players around baseball? PECOTA liked the Sox plenty. Take a look at how its killing the Yankees if you want to see it \"hate\" a team. Im a Boston, fan too - so Im pretty excited that its validating what Ive been saying about the Yankees. I was actually pretty pleased with the Sox projections, to tell you the truth.

Jan 31, 2009 10:55 AM on August 9-11, 2001
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

PECOTA isnt falling for those minor league BAs... about time. Davis looks like he\'s going to have some contact issues. Looks like a .260-.270 hitter to me, at least initially.

Jan 31, 2009 2:14 AM on August 9-11, 2001
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

No one thought he would sign.

 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

The defensive metrics liked him a great deal. I dont think he\'s a strength there but I see him pretty close to average - there are worse shortstops defensively and many worse offensively.

Jan 28, 2009 12:05 PM on Red Sox Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -2

That\'s the stupidest thing I\'ve ever heard! Youre an idiot.

Jan 22, 2009 10:35 PM on Andy Pratt
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: -3

I didnt realize there were so many bitter baseball fans in the Red States... As a resident of the Northeast, let me just reiterate that most of us dont care about your baseball or politics! That said, I dont really like Olbermann. I think most of you on both sides of the aisle have missed the boat anyway. Cheering for political parties like they are baseball teams is about the worst, most irresponsible thing an adult can do, in my opinion. Its all the rage in this country and it needs to stop. Its all a moot point, too - because WHO THE HECK READS FORWARDS ANYWAY? It might be the last part of the book I read, after Ive gone through all the PECOTAs and new Davenport stuff and after its been relegated to my bathroom for >month.

Jan 21, 2009 11:56 PM on Andy Pratt
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

No need to do the Nats(Not much to talk about there anyway)! Get to the A.L. already, please!!

Jan 20, 2009 7:01 PM on Giants Top 11 Prospects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

One objection: Juve HAS to be the Yankees of Serie A.

Jan 16, 2009 11:38 PM on Your Tax Dollars at Work
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Really? I would say Liverpool would be the perfect analogy for the Yankees... traditonally dominant, spends a lot of money and hasnt won anything in a decade or so. I guess they resemble Man U in a lot of ways too, though. At least in how they have such a huge international following and their gear is so popular. The Cubs are clearly Newcastle, btw. Even down to the ownership issues. Arsenal has to be the Angels... never deviating from their plan or trading young kids/paying for front line stars. Yet they still spend a lot of money and are near the top every year. I guess they could resemble the Red Sox too, because they play a great system and stick to it... especially with player values. The Indians and Everton seem like a good match. As do the Twinkies and Middleboro. Sunderland and Seattle work. West Ham or Tottenham works for the Orioles. Good tradition. ----------------------------------------- I often think that baseball would be much better off with a transfer system. Then the Yankees would really have to pay out the a** for their players, and at least the Royals and Brewers of the World would get paid. Second division teams could still garner a lot of interest because people would better understand their limitations and would adjust their expectations. Damn that Branch Rickey... this almost happened. I would have loved to have seen a Saudi Sheikh purchase the Tigers and make a bid for Grady Sizemore.

Jan 16, 2009 11:34 PM on Your Tax Dollars at Work
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Great analogy on Watergate. Dont hear much about pay-for-performance anymore either...

Jan 08, 2009 8:10 PM on Do-Nothings
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Im a big Marvin Miller fan... but if I ran a network going for ratings Im not sure labor law makes the best documentary for drawing in fans to a new network.

Jan 08, 2009 12:03 PM on Do-Nothings
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Ah, sorry... +21 UZR/150. +4.9 runs.

Jan 08, 2009 12:00 PM on Defense and Effects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Lowrie was +21.0 runs by UZR and +8 plays by Dewan.

Jan 08, 2009 11:58 AM on Defense and Effects
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 0

Without having seen the segment its hard to say, but since his point was about the Yankees and their spending - and a mention of collusion would have required a lengthy explanation - it seems like he easily could have made that choice for the sake of brevity.

Jan 08, 2009 10:49 AM on Do-Nothings
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

Play by play based Fielding Metrics! FRAA and FRAR are wacky and they skew the WARPs. I would think BP would be a leader in this stuff, but I see fangraphs.com adding UZR and all sorts of cutting edge metrics. Where is BP\'s answer? Other than that, just keep up the great work - but more chats, too please.

Dec 31, 2008 3:56 PM on July 23-30
 
alskor
(39403)
Comment rating: 1

\"The Tigers feel shortstop Adam Everett is the equivalent on Wilson and they can acquire more cheaply as a free agent without giving up any players in return.\" It took them how long to realize this...? The Tigers dont seem to have a lot of trade chips beyond Larish... you have to think someone would outbid them for Putz, even in this closer-flooded market.

Dec 07, 2008 11:59 PM on Venting