CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  

Search Article Archives

Find:   

Author:    Article: 
Search Date (From):    Search Date (To):   
Sort Results by:  Relevance
 Date
Show me  Results

   Show Article Summaries

New! Search comments:      
(NOTE: Relevance, Author, and Article are not applicable for comment searches)

Ben Carsley
551 comments | 8 total rating | 0.01 average rating
Facebook Twitter email a friend
Share comments by 'Ben Carsley' posted at
Baseball Prospectus http://bbp.cx/i/67815
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Welp, I've been getting that reference wrong for a decade-plus. Thanks!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Strong. TMI, but strong.

Sep 11, 2017 11:54 AM on September 11, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I just want to say that commenters playfully arguing over whether the Reds will win 7 more games because of a throwaway line in a column is the reason I love BP. Not being sarcastic for once <3

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He's <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=18258">Larry Sheets</a></span>' son -- our bad!

Aug 28, 2017 11:20 AM on August 28, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Oof! Fixed, thank you.

Aug 28, 2017 11:19 AM on August 28, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

True, we know how Marte's entire career will play out now.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Obviously I meant January 2017 ... which was still wrong! Thanks for your note - it's been fixed :)

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is a little self-evident, but so is my first point, so fair enough! Sorry about your Cubs :( blame Theo

Jul 28, 2017 7:48 AM on Ignore the Trades
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

News from the Citadel = what have they been up to Oathkeeper = best outcome Kingslayer = if they fall short Hope that helps. Thank you for reading anyway!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

69

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Just a little too early. He'd be in the next 25-35 names, I think.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You have to check a 4th time

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

And I'd like to see Robb Stark fall into Margaery Tyrell's arms. Alas,

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Nunez hit .288/325/.432 with 16 homers and 40 steals last year. That's Barreto's ceiling to me, and it's a damn good one.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Just a GoT joke. Adams would've made the next 50 as a lowish ceiling MLB arm who's almost ready now. Acevedo I'm not quite as high on, but he'd probably be top-150

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

MerAXXXEEEEEEEEEEESSSS

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think DeShields is a perfectly reasonable comp for Mateo's floor, sure.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That being said, I grant you that Mateo has among the highest bust potential of anyone on this list, and if you just want to stay away, I can see why. Pretty nice upside, though.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

<span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=50297">Jarrod Dyson</a></span> is the no. 39 OF in 5x5 leagues right now per ESPN's Player Rater because he has an OK average and 20 steals. <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=51988">Cameron Maybin</a></span> is at 26 because he has 25 steals, and he's batting .245. Speed matters!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

No to Perez. Pache wans't particularly close to making this list but would make a top-101, I believe.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think there's a strong argument to be made for him in Tier 2, but not in Tier 1. He still hasn't proven that he can hold up to the rigors of catching for a full season (has caught 94 games max), he's small for a catcher and the history of very good catching prospects is pretty dicey. He's also a guy who might not be a huge impact fantasy asset right when he reaches the majors, given that he'll have to learn his pitching staff, adjust to MLB pitching, (potentially) get used to catching even more regularly, etc. It adds an element of risk to his profile that's missing from the top five names and, in my opinion, most of the tier 2 names as well. You're not crazy if you love him though. The dude can hit.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Bret generally has a better grasp on international talent than I do, but from what I understand he'd be in Tier 1

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Fixed, but if they go 0-8 from July 21-29 I'm changing it back.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Or a Sal Perez owner nodded his head in agreement.

Jun 22, 2017 11:15 AM on The Saddest Milestone
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Bradley was the third-most important piece in the deal. I think we can all agree that we'd rather have Bradley than <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=Alex+Wilson">Alex Wilson</a></span> in Dynasty, so it was just another little angle I worked in at the end to try and tilt the scales another 1% in my favor. It's a strategy I use often in trades. I think we disagree on Contreras' potential. I'm with you that most catchers aren't worth investing in big-time, but I'm also confident that Contreras is a top-7 Dynasty backup, and all he cost me was a third-round pick two years ago. He plays more, has more versatility than and more upside than your average (non-elite) catcher.

Jun 22, 2017 6:55 AM on The Saddest Milestone
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd go with Bichette but it's very close for me. I'm definitely the high guy on Mountcastle, though.

Jun 14, 2017 11:28 AM on 11-player update
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Fixed, thank you

Jun 12, 2017 9:19 AM on June 12, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Alas, the order is computer-generated.

Jun 12, 2017 8:59 AM on June 12, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I get to write *and* edit these given that they have to go up late at night or early in the morning, so all the blame goes to me!

Jun 12, 2017 8:59 AM on June 12, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=28649 <3

Jun 08, 2017 7:05 PM on The 2017 Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I considered Asa Lacy but had already made a porn joke last year and this was before Kurt Eichenwald, so

Jun 08, 2017 11:47 AM on The 2017 Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I missed you, fawcettbb

Jun 08, 2017 9:29 AM on The 2017 Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

BP has many of the highest quality editors in the industry who will all back me here when I say it's definitely "should of."

Jun 08, 2017 6:08 AM on The 2017 Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Updated. Wish this was the first time I'd gotten my Colons confused ...

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm always due for one of those per article. Ty!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This column runs every three days is partially predicated on the ability to turn current events into jokes. If the relatively benign political one-liners bother you that much, it's not going to be a column you enjoy, unfortunately. Not trying to be standoffish here - just being honest.

May 15, 2017 1:47 PM on May 15, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Can't believe I'd make that mistake during Jeter Week.

May 15, 2017 8:19 AM on May 15, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thank you - fixed

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

See, you only seem mildly uncomfortable!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Devin Travos, got it

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

30 steals? Like, maybe three-to-five? It's not like he's just been eking over the 30 mark, and there's no evidence to suggest his PED suspension will have an impact on his performance.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Strongly prefer Marte but it's not crazy

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

My god. Nice job!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You have taken the bait, my friend. You have taken the bait.

Apr 18, 2017 5:27 PM on April 17, 2017
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Unfortunately you have indeed gone full BFIB.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If only Matheny had said "<span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=Joe+Kelly">Joe Kelly</a></span>'s Stuff is like a Ferrari," we'd really be cooking :(

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I agree with on par with Reynaldo. I just limited it to guys who are prospect eligible for the sake of a coherent piece.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I should've mentioned him, good point, but I'm not taking the over on ~15 starts from him this year.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Was always the low guy on Severino. I agree the upside is there but I don't like his odds of reaching it. In the long term I maintain he's a reliever.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I looooove Anderson. He's no. 18 among SS right now, and I'd prefer him to a few names being popped before him, but I don't think he's being super underdrafted.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yeah, we've gotten a lot of feedback that ETAs would be useful and I think that's something we'll look to incorporate next year. Thank you!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I love Gallo, thought I admit I am starting to get a little concerned. He probably would've beat out Berrios for the list if not for his hamstring injury.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

A majority of the key players in that brain trust are gone.

Mar 21, 2017 7:39 AM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I honestly don't know a lot about him. The speed could be interesting but I want to see how the bat plays at a level more appropriate for his age before I get excited.

Mar 15, 2017 9:19 AM on The Next 112
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I used to love him but the injuries, distance from majors and non-elite ETA put him behind some of the other guys on this list who only have two out of those three problems. But like I said, if you really like him I get it.

Mar 15, 2017 9:17 AM on The Next 112
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I agree that Nunez is kinda bad but even if Hwang grabs the 3B job I don't think he'll really do anything with it. And thanks! Interacting with you guys is half the fun :)

Mar 15, 2017 9:17 AM on The Next 112
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think he's a cut below the Toles/Tillson grouping but he's not a bad sleeper for some value soonish

Mar 15, 2017 9:16 AM on The Next 112
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Utility

Mar 15, 2017 8:15 AM on The Next 112
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Don't believe in Hwang as anything more than UTIL. If you want to put Arozarena with the sleepers guys that's fine. I don't have a ton of intel on Perez or Yander, tbh. They'd be outside the scope of top-200 guys.

Mar 15, 2017 8:15 AM on The Next 112
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm not owned, I'm not owned

Mar 15, 2017 4:42 AM on The Next 112
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Wasn't considered. Old, little upside, etc. He won't even be on the next ~100 names I release next week.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He fits in well with the Others group.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think that's fair to say. This is probably the highest I've seen anyone be on him, fwiw.

Mar 07, 2017 8:52 AM on Rounds 3-4
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Very long lead time with a solid but unremarkable cieling

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Sure, you can throw him in with Others II.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Ask us again when MiLB rosters are finalized and we'll let you know!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Let's talk about my huge electoral win over Craig.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Think it might be important to differentiate between fantasy and IRL lists here. He does probably have the upside of an IRL all-star because of his defense. That doesn't matter in fantasy, though, and while 30-plus steals are super valuable, he doesn't bring a ton else to tha table (maybe runs). Frankly, I think his placement here says we like him plenty.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Good question. Thompson would've gotten a full write-up and would've ranked right around Hoffman. Blair would've been in the "mildly interesting back-end starter" section.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Any line of reasoning behind "certainly?" Because I don't really agree.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Hopefully a reverse jinx, assuming that means it won't happen? I'm ... I'm confused now.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Does not have a shot in hell of making the majors in 2017.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

A fair note, but as we mentioned in the intro, I've gone deeper on all 101 of these prospects (and 200+ more) in the individual top-10 lists. I'd suggest reading those if you want more detailed dynasty info on a player. This list is really just a recap, though maybe we could link directly to each 101 caption if we do this next year. Thanks for reading!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Nope, none came close. Hernandez and Long will be on the next 75 piece that comes out in a week or two.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Certainly fair. He'd be in the 20-30 range for me, but I'm high on him.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Curious what you mean by the floors are off? If you mean they're not low enough, well, we thought this would be more entertaining than writing "not a major leaguer" like 70 times. But if you're coming at it from another angle, I'm interested!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Bret was higher on Happ, Collins, Dom Smith and Taveras. I was higher on Barreto, Zimmer, Sisco and <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=107192">Yusniel Diaz</a></span>. Wouldn't say any of them were particularly contentious, though. Maybe Happ but I know I'm gonna lose that battle :)

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

don't we all

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Pretty massive for me. Gillaspie is a better bet to make the majors but not as anything substantial in fantasy. It probably won't work for Bradley, but if it does you'll want to own him.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Also, no one's asked yet, but I'm planning on publishing a list of the next ~50-75 names at some point in the next few weeks. It won't be a strict ranking like this, but it should help those of you in deeper leagues where most of these 101 guys are gone!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Three main reasons 1) Tapia gets a boost for Coors in this list but is evaluated independently of Coors in the IRL 101 2) Tapia gets dinged a bit for his defense (he's probably a LF) on the IRL 101 3) Bret and I did not contribute to the IRL 101 rankings

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Glad you enjoyed it! I'd say most of the change is due to Bret having to deal with me and some of it is based on feedback we got throughout this process.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You're too good to me

Feb 15, 2017 6:57 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The top-101 won't be out for another 7-10 days, but Email me [ed - please use Contact Us page http://www.baseballprospectus.com/contact.php] with questions :)

Feb 15, 2017 6:57 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Bret and I collaborated on it this year and are aiming for next week, which means it will probably be out the week after next :)

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd argue it's a bit more nuanced than that. I just really hate backend starters in fantasy, and unfortunately a lot of SP prospects are backend starters. Plenty of MLB value, but utterly replaceable in most leagues.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

"There have been players who've debuted at 20" doesn't really move the needle for me. Maitan is not that caliber of talent.

Feb 08, 2017 8:31 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Andujar is listed as an Other. I hope he works out because he's fun to watch the but approach is worrisome

Feb 01, 2017 11:02 AM on Third Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Welker is another good one for the Others portion of the 2018 and beyond list. Not a top-200 guy yet but could be with a solid stint in Asheville

Feb 01, 2017 11:02 AM on Third Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Hey, at least something related to the Padres rotation generated a strikeout

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If this piece stops you from watching the Padres in 2017 we've actually saved you time, tbf.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thank you!

Jan 25, 2017 2:58 PM on Second Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I originally had Diaz here but was told some of his defensive reviews at short last year were more positive than once imagined. I do still think he'll be a 2B long-term though.

Jan 25, 2017 11:06 AM on Second Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Robertson will appear as an Other in 2017 shortstops. His fantasy value has cratered. Not a top-150 guy.

Jan 25, 2017 11:05 AM on Second Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Appreciated!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is uncomfortably close to the truth

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Herrera is no longer prospect eligible. I think he's a potential second-division starter and a decent buy-low candidate in fantasy.

Jan 25, 2017 6:27 AM on Second Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Your feedback is well taken. With the format we've used for the past few years, every top-10 prospect needs a fantasy writeup, but not every top-10 prospect is fantasy-relevant. That forces me to get ... let's be kind and say creative ... especially in a down-year overall for fantasy prospects. There are only so many ways I can say "don't bother with this guy." But your point stands, and thank you for continuing to read the meat of the lists anyway.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Not prospect eligible because of service time

Jan 18, 2017 1:49 PM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The sad reality is that fantasy 1B isn't what it used to be, at least in terms of depth. <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=204">Albert Pujols</a></span> was the 11th-best fantasy 1B last year, per ESPN's player rater. <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=31606">Mike Napoli</a></span> was 15. Some of these low-ceiling guys are going to need to be used in moderate-to-deep leagues. To answer your question, I'll go with <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=104042">Rafael Devers</a></span>. He's not a lock to have to move, but he's probably not a super long-term 3B. His bat will play at 1B and could potentially still be special-ish there.

Jan 18, 2017 6:56 AM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Due to a position eligibility quick the Royals WS entries are actually listed under the Dynasty OF rankings

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

My eyes are green

Jan 03, 2017 5:14 AM on The Road to Draft Day
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

*Andre the Giant voice* I don't think objective means what you think it means.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You have successfully stayed away from Boston media if you think no one is mentioning the depleted farm system. And for that I commend you. We are terrible.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That's addressed in the post, but even if you factor in the ~30 mil owed to Moncada (don't count the penalty $ that's already paid) Sale is a relative bargain.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Someone got it!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Hardware :D

Nov 01, 2016 8:42 AM on Hardware
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Easier pickings than two hobbits marching through an army of Orcs? I think not, ChicagoOriole. I think not.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's entirely possible there will be an Ironically Named Relievers follow-up post

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You answered your own question!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This could be an Annual lineout

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Honorable mention, imo

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The thing is he's unlikely to end up in the 40-60 range, right? He's gonna be good and healthy and borderline top-25 or bad and injured and barely top 100. I'm not comfortable taking that type of a gamble with my SP2, though I suppose that's more my personal roster construction preference.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

"The problems? Pomeranz has already thrown 102 innings, which puts him close to his career high of 147 in 2012. The lanky lefty has the frame to log innings but has had plenty of trouble staying on the mound. That’s part of the reason why the A’s used him primarily out of the bullpen a season ago"

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

"Elephant in the room" was aggressive but 22 is a bit old for a "top" prospect in High-A. Perhaps a better way to put it is 22 isn't an impressive age in High-A. Especially not for a (now) struggling college bat.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You are correct. We'll get that fixed. Thanks.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Actually I love agriculture

Jun 09, 2016 1:08 PM on The 2016 Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

pretty impressive group here http://www.famousbirthdays.com/names/davis.html

Jun 09, 2016 8:11 AM on The 2016 Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Do you want CarGo back

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Strong

Jun 09, 2016 6:22 AM on The 2016 Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks. And yeah, I have the Sox finishing third.

Apr 07, 2016 7:01 AM on Rebuilding in TDGX
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Will do!

Apr 07, 2016 7:01 AM on Rebuilding in TDGX
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

[subtweet about reaction to snarky retort]

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Well, part of the reason we think they'll have so many ROY candidates is the rest of the team isn't very good, opening up opportunities for young players.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

And here’s how those picks performed: 2005 - Boston - 95 wins, tied w/Yankees, 2nd place (WC) 2006 - Boston - 86 wins, 3rd place 2007 - New York - 94 wins, 2nd place (WC) 2008 - Boston - 95 wins, 2nd place (WC) 2009 - Boston - 95 wins, 2nd place (WC) 2010 - Boston - 89 wins, 3rd place 2011 - Boston - 90 wins, 3rd place 2012 - New York - 95 wins, 1st place 2013 - Tampa Bay - 92 wins, 2nd place (WC) 2014 - Red Sox - 71 wins, 5th place 2015 - Red Sox - 78 wins, 5th place We’ve absolutely blown it the past two years, and we have not shied away from that. But I don’t think you’re going to get us to feel terribly guilty about the five instances in which we incorrectly picked a division winner that made the Wild Card anyway. I get that this is your favorite thing to do and I remember when you posted this last year. Like Sam said, it looks like we’ve learned. But maybe chill on trying to make us look like idiots for liking a Red Sox team that averaged 92 wins from 2005-2011.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I read this and immediately thought "oh, like me and <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=67248">Xander Bogaerts</a></span>."

Mar 31, 2016 9:30 AM on Freedom Brown
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Ben can't read email.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Fixed, thank you

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Pretty tough to project out at this point but it seems reasonable to me, yeah.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I believe the formatting here will answer your question

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The issue with Urias is workload/innings limit, not ability. I'll say 60% he gets the call but only 20% he makes a meaningful fantasy impact.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He'd be on my top-150 but I don't think the hit tool will play in the long run -- his MiLB stats are aided by poor fielding. That being said, if you prefer him to <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=70776">Roman Quinn</a></span>, I get it.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If honorable mention extended another 10-15 players he'd be there, but he's more of a fantasy no. 5/6 or streamer to me

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

near Brandon Drury

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Not particularly. Someone to keep an eye on but he wasn't close to consideration here.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This guy gets it.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Let's go with Williams and Paulino, with Sims as a bounce-back candidate and McKenzie as a darkhorse.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I do not mean this in a flippant way, but nope! I don't really pay attention to foreign players until they are about to sign/Bret tells me to.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Checking on this now.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If you've truly never heard of a player who makes a big jump, odds are it's due more to a new pitch or a step up in stuff than command. If you're seeing a massive jump from an existing low-101 prospect or a guy who just missed, it's often a player who had ... great stuff ... who's learned how to harness it. Tough to give catch-all answers for something like this and there are certainly exceptions, but I think that's a general rule.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's a very, very loose ranking. I basically use these lists as drafts for my top 101. If there's a huge gap between players you can assume I like one more than the other but on a 3-4 slot basis it's not binding.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He was featured in names for 2016 http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=28538

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

... because I don't think Giolito is going to have much of an impact this year.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Giolito has the highest upside of any pitcher in the minors but he won't see as much time as Matz in 2016

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't think Reyes is going to contribute meaningfully for fantasy this year. In terms of overall SP prospects, he's in the top 5.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Definitely Matz. Has a job and is very good. I'd probably go Snell, Lopez and Berrios next with Bradley as a darkhorse.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This list isn't quite meant to be a straight ranking, but I'd have him right in the Thompson/Gray/Lopez area. Potential for lots of Ks and a high <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=WHIP" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('WHIP'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">WHIP</span></a>, still might be a reliever.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He'll be featured Monday in the 2017 and Beyond group

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

In my book Betts is the more complete player right now and Bogaerts has the higher upside.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Cole and Polanco are a nice a 1-2 punch and while the Sox have more young MLB talent right now, the Pirates have more talent in the upper minors. I'd take Boston's duo over Pittsburgh's for sure but in terms of overall young talent I think they're in the same league.

Feb 22, 2016 3:17 PM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Life as a Red Sox fan is great when you totally ignore the corner positions!

Feb 22, 2016 9:05 AM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

<span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=70362">Tyler Naquin</a></span> 2.0 to me

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Alright, I'm not entirely sure what's happened here, but no, <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=100634">Lewis Brinson</a></span> is not moving to catcher.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If he can stay on the field, ya. Dahl will be featured tomorrow, too.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He's not going to be up next year. He'll be featured tomorrow.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Did we read the same Nimmo blurb? I think I made it pretty clear I'm not excited either. De Aza is fine but not special enough to block anyone worthwhile. But fine, he's a poor bet for even 100 <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=PA" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('PA'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">PA</span></a>.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Also, before anyone sees this and is confused, he'll be featured in Names for 2017 and Beyond tomorrow.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I have absolutely zero confidence that O'Brien can catch

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd still go Correa, yes. I'd prefer Correa/Votto to Goldy/Heyward, though I know you can't guarantee such a combo in any case.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

recap: Craig and I are good and right and Bret is bad and wrong here

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I agree that 40 <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=SB" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('SB'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">SB</span></a> is probably his ceiling, but that number is based more off of his 70-grade speed and overall baseball instincts than anything he's done in the minors. Although fwiw, he stole 31 bases across three levels last year.

Feb 10, 2016 7:08 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The rule I made is that I'm listing players by where they appeared most last year. Otherwise he'd battle Wall for second-most interesting guy in 2017 or beyond.

Jan 28, 2016 3:25 PM on Second-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We hate him, personally.

Jan 27, 2016 7:45 PM on Ep. 62: Enya's Kitchen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I can 100% assure you that this was done on porpoise.

Jan 27, 2016 7:40 AM on Second-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Seriously, <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=58842">Caleb Joseph</a></span> is bad.

Jan 22, 2016 11:17 AM on Ep. 62: Enya's Kitchen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E5d0KXJMRWQ

Jan 21, 2016 11:40 AM on Top 50 First Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

There were only two pretty benign <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=Chris+Davis">Chris Davis</a></span> comments when I posted this and neither of them were terribly constructive. This was not in response to any of the more legitimate questions about methodology you'll find below. Also nothing is beneath my humor.

Jan 21, 2016 11:18 AM on Top 50 First Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Where is <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=59265">Khris Davis</a></span> am I doing this right

Jan 21, 2016 7:51 AM on Top 50 First Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Jesus, you keep, like, 600 MiLBers? In that case no, but in leagues that "only" roster 200-250 MiLBers, yes.

Jan 20, 2016 10:03 AM on First-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Not prospect-eligible

Jan 20, 2016 9:00 AM on First-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Fair to say he can be lumped in with Ravelo/Walker but I don't see much impact potential.

Jan 20, 2016 8:37 AM on First-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

<span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=1499">David Ortiz</a></span> is 22 spots too low.

Jan 20, 2016 6:32 AM on First Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Good point on Bellinger's age. No disrespect meant for Hoskins. He's pretty close to the Smith/Travis/Bauers tier in that I don't see massive upside but he's got enough going for him that he should be a major leaguer.

Jan 20, 2016 4:44 AM on First-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It put him on the map but I don't think it's indicative of his future output.

Jan 14, 2016 7:59 AM on Catcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's simply a listing of guys who were once fantasy-relevant who I wouldn't consider ~top-250 names at this point. In Coulter's specific case I don't believe the bat will be much to speak of in the outfield, yes.

Jan 13, 2016 12:03 PM on Catcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The reason the player opts out is because he thinks he can get more, not because his current contract is "a bargain." <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=David+Price">David Price</a></span> may read the market in 2018 and think he can do better than 4/$127m, and he'll be right if his agents can convince one team that he's worth more. That doesn't mean the Red Sox will have "lost out" by not wanting to pay a pitcher 4/$127m for his age-33-37 years. I see where you're coming from and I think there are plenty of opt-outs that can hurt teams, but this is a pretty team-friendly one, albeit one that doesn't move the needle a ton on the risk associated with this deal.

Dec 02, 2015 8:53 AM on Oh, Hello David
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I believe so

Dec 02, 2015 5:12 AM on Oh, Hello David
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Kershaw was not a free agent, which is a pretty huge factor, and when you adjust for inflation Kershaw got more than Price. Price *didn't* quite get Kershaw money, which is appropriate.

Dec 02, 2015 5:12 AM on Oh, Hello David
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The article's premise is that *not* all trades have a winner and loser, and I then argue that this makes sense for both sides, so I'm not sue what your disagreement is here. I was indeed not alive in 1948.

Nov 14, 2015 3:33 PM on Straight Kimbrelin'
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Has anything ever made you smile?

Nov 10, 2015 8:57 AM on Part 1
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'll go so far as to say I don't really think he belongs in the discussion yet, no. A few good months doesn't outweigh the years of production Altuve, Dozier and Kipnis have provided, and I still prefer Rendon's upside to Odor's by quite a bit. Craig's point about linear development is huge, too. Just because Odor is X good in 2015 doesn't mean he'll be X+3 good in three years. And, as Craig also said, most people prefer to play for now. I hate you for making me agree with Craig this much. I guess you could argue that Odor should be ahead of Gordon and I'd listen, but mostly you just seem to be really, really high on Odor. That's fine and maybe you'll be right, but acting like we're insane for preferring players who are clearly better right now is a bit much.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd also add that playing for five years in the future isn't a good strategy even in dynasty leagues.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

And for a real answer, firmly entrenched near the top of the second tier. Can definitely argue for him over Cano in dynasty.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

A gentleman doesn't kiss and tell.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I refuse to believe Craig didn't write the assumption joke.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Also is Carswell a burn?

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Do you have twitter?

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It was a tongue-in-cheek reference to my refusal to let him go. He's nowhere close to eligible for this.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The day is young. We'll get there.

Aug 19, 2015 7:29 AM on The Shake-Up in Boston
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The main reason I don't want to write such a piece at this point is I'd miss you leaving a slightly different version of the same comment on every Red Sox-related article we post.

Aug 19, 2015 7:11 AM on The Shake-Up in Boston
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yep. We'll get that fixed. Thanks.

Aug 19, 2015 7:08 AM on The Shake-Up in Boston
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Do you use Twitter

Jul 28, 2015 11:12 AM on Justin Upton
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Do you use Twitter

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

a) Going off minor league stats alone is a fool's errand b) He's always been like 12 years younger than the competition c) The drop-off in positional value from SS to 2B is real but not dramatic.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Redraft or shallow keeper? No. Dynasty? Yes.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If he's healthy, he'll be playing somewhere everyday by 2017. Too much talent to be blocked by Odor or Andrus, or he could easily be used as a trade chip. Those issues always work themselves out.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Idk I found the Red Queen Hypothesis piece on TFM to be a little esoteric.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

do you have twitter

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes

Jul 08, 2015 11:30 AM on Pitchers and Picks
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This isn’t funny enough to be satire, and it sure as hell isn’t smart enough to be serious. C-.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Is this for like, not this year or something? I don't get it.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Not a believer.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Omg. Trey Cabbage might've gone 1:1

Jun 05, 2015 6:47 AM on The Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Missed you buddy. How's life?

Jun 05, 2015 6:21 AM on The Name Game
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You're probably not even a collection of anchovy.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We started this in the pre-season, so we used April 1 as the cut-off date (also keeps continuity with the series from last year). I get why it's a bit awkward toward the back-end of this series now, but such is life.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

"Robertson" is I'm tired for "Stephenson"

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Lorenzen would've been in my next two or three guys. Robertson's ranking is a reflection of upside, which I weigh a lot more heavily for fantasy than I do IRL.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Vogelbach would rank highly on a list that only ranks people according to things he's good at.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Guess who just lost Friend of Podcast privileges

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Upside, upside, upside.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

And by "tow" I mean "homophones before 9AM are hard"

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks for clarifying. This is really the only BP Boston/main BP crossover I can think of to date, so hopefully in the long run you'll find that we tow the line pretty well.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Do you feel as though it was a fanboy debate because Betts and Bogaerts were both portrayed too positively, or just because they're both Red Sox?

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't think this is a revolutionary concept. As Craig said, looking at MiLB stat lines is a good way to signal to yourself that maybe you should take another or a deeper look at a player. No one disputes that. Saying Travis was the fourth-best 2B prospect in the Tigers system two years ago doesn't mean anyone ignored the stats. It just means at the time, we thought three 2B prospects were better. Maybe they even *were* better back then, and Travis has just taken steps forward. Prospects change. If they didn't, this would be no fun. Altuve is a fine cherry-picked example, but I'm willing to bet I can find one or two minor leaguers with great stat lines who scouts didn't like who didn't pan out.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Agreed. If I thought he'd do that, he'd be higher.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

They're also arbitrary endpoints

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd argue this comment is evidence that people are still easily seduced by small sample size.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Bradley, Castillo and Cecchini are all starting the year in Triple-A, where there is most assuredly room. Equally simple!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Ugh, thanks! We'll get that fixed.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Note: don't do this.

Mar 25, 2015 9:10 AM on ERA and WHIP
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I hear you, but at 319 overall and 29th among 2B, I'd argue a late-round flier is exactly how he's being valued presently. The direct comparisons to Zobrist also only go so far: they're not the same player, even if Maddon wants to use them in the same way, so Zobrist's career path doesn't do much for me. The approach and playing time arguments are strong ones, and that's why I just have him as "moderately" undervalued. I don't think he's close to a starting option, I'd just gamble on his power/speed upside over a bunch of guys being taken right ahead of him.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Sifting through <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=23954">Tommy John</a></span> applications must be miserable.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Zomg jinx

Mar 23, 2015 11:57 AM on Wins and Strikeouts
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

"Second of all, we're going to allow everyone to choose the player they want, regardless of how many other people are choosing them. That means, if four writers think that <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=59265">Khris Davis</a></span> will lead the league in homers, then by god there will be four Khris Davis blurbs detailing why."

Mar 23, 2015 11:56 AM on Wins and Strikeouts
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd be careful about making sweeping generalizations based on these 10 players. I'd imagine that if we keep going through this exercise, many of the graduated prospects will be overvalued.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Crap. Heaney should've ranked somewhere in the Mazara/Franco or Tapia/Norris tier. Thank you for that catch. Castillo would've ranked right behind ahead of <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=Josh+Bell">Josh Bell</a></span>. Tomas would've ranked of <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=Jose+Peraza">Jose Peraza</a></span>. Iglesias would not have ranked.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He's 21 and has already held his own against AAA pitching. You're right in that he doesn't project as a stalwart fantasy SS the second he reaches the majors, but as he grows he projects as a 60 hitter with 60 speed and a little bit of power. The last bit of what you wrote is just a leading question. Yes, *if* he can't hit he's not worthy of owning. But the only evidence you've provided that he won't is that he's yet to light the world on fire at levels for which he's incredibly young. The comp to Brendan Ryan is a bit silly.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'll look into this for you!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Anderson's ceiling is higher than Alfaro's if the former sticks at SS and the latter sticks at C. You can argue that Alfaro's floor is higher, though that's up for debate as even if Anderson moves to the OF he has the speed to be interesting. Sometimes it just comes down to personal evaluations. You mentioned some ways in which Anderson and Alfaro are similar, but there are more ways in which they differ. Different positions in play, different carrying tools, different upsides. Lots of variables in play.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

A lot of what Stephen said is accurate. To me, Swihart is a lock to stay at catcher and has a really, really high floor for a guy who plays a premium position. Schwarber has the higher ceiling, yes, but he's substantially farther away from the majors and is far from a lock to stick behind the plate. I'll take someone with an 80% chance of being a consistent top-10 backstop over someone with a, say, 40% chance of being a top-5 backstop. And yes, the equation shifts a bit more in Schwarber's favor in really shallow leagues.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Positional value is a huge factor. From most valuable to least valuable, it's generally C, SS, 2B, 3B, OF, 1B, UT There are only four catchers on this list -- five if you include Schwarber -- and two are in the 90s, so I don't think I've made an especially strong case for drafting catching prospects.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Mid-teens to low 20s.

Mar 06, 2015 6:35 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Average Draft Position. The stuff about adjusting for park and era was a joke.

Mar 06, 2015 6:35 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That's fair, but I do think there's *some* value, even if there's less value than you get in, say, the second base edition of this exercise. Also I just like needling Bret, we don't really hate these that much. (yes we do)

Mar 04, 2015 8:11 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Well, we still skew all three-year rankings pretty heavily toward 2015, because fantasy baseball is unpredictable regardless of the position in question. So I'd argue that having guys like Giles and Davis in the mid-teens is already a pretty strong compliment, and having guys like Hawkins on here at all is a nod to 2015 value. There are plenty of great set-up guys who never become closers, so you have to be careful when weighing their value in the long-run.

Mar 04, 2015 8:10 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Don't downvote him! It's a follow-up Billy Madison quote!

Mar 04, 2015 8:07 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Well, some of us don't need fantasy to exactly mirror real baseball. For me, it's like reading GoT vs. watching the HBO show. They're connected, but both can be consumed and entertaining in their own right.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I can see this.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Craig has RP prospects tomorrow, I have top-40 dynasty RP rankings on Wednesday, which is really just Kimbrell and then 39 names I'll place in a hat and select randomly.

Mar 02, 2015 9:01 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Where would white llama rank?

Feb 26, 2015 12:51 PM on Part 2: 1-50 (plus one)
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Read it backwards

Feb 26, 2015 12:47 PM on Part 2: 1-50 (plus one)
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Jose Jose

Feb 26, 2015 7:27 AM on Part 2: 1-50 (plus one)
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Your comment history is a long series of posts in which you tell us you don't find us funny or clever. If you're really this consistently upset by us trying to entertain people, it'd probably behoove you to find a drier source (check out Mike's work) rather than thinking you're going to change us.

Feb 26, 2015 7:16 AM on Part 2: 1-50 (plus one)
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'll also add that he's probably a reliever.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It also means I'm not good at writing.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Agreed. The only way they ship Fevers out of town is if they somehow acquire more cowbell.

Feb 23, 2015 2:12 PM on Yoan Moncada Fits
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

But on a serious note, I don't think there's much correlation. Signing Moncada might make a trade more likely in general, but Devers is no more or less likely to be dealt now than any other minor leaguer in the system.

Feb 23, 2015 2:00 PM on Yoan Moncada Fits
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

https://twitter.com/BenCarsley/status/569869642853982208

Feb 23, 2015 1:57 PM on Yoan Moncada Fits
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

No longer prospect-eligible

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Sort of, but he'll also appear tomorrow.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

And so he spoke, and so he spoke

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This might be unreasonable, but I think he could be a starter in the majors even before August.

Feb 19, 2015 9:33 AM on Starting Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

A coconut crab

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We know. Old habits. Getting it fixed, thanks.

Feb 13, 2015 6:50 AM on Outfielders
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You are right! We'll get that fixed.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

There probably are worse terms, tbh. From the Reds Top 10: "The Tools: 6 potential hit; 5+ potential power; 5 run; 5 potential glove"

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That's probably a bit optimistic on the power most years and low on the speed. OF2 is the 100th percentile, more likely upside is OF3, more likely still is that you consider him a namedrop by 2019.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Hmmm

Feb 04, 2015 2:19 PM on Shortstop
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Fixed, thank you

Feb 04, 2015 2:17 PM on Shortstop
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

In the Owings/Lindor/Russell group

Feb 04, 2015 5:17 AM on Shortstop
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Not being difficult, but I'd take the highest-ranked player from the 15-30 group who remained :). You're right about notable omissions. The last group is pretty sad.

Feb 04, 2015 5:16 AM on Shortstop
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Super not what I said. "Ramirez would probably rank third on this list, but this is his last year of SS eligibility and he’s moving to the outfield instead of a fantasy-friendly position like 2B or 3B. Still, if Tulo misses time, he could easy finish as the best shortstop in the game in 2015." If Ramirez was going to have SS eligibility for all three years, he'd be second or third on the list.

Feb 04, 2015 5:15 AM on Shortstop
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Just a running gag. Happy to answer any and all questions.

Feb 04, 2015 5:14 AM on Shortstop
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Has the natural ingredients to be good but falls apart when you pick him up.

Feb 03, 2015 10:15 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is a better question for Craig Goldstein

Feb 03, 2015 8:38 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Baez would rank behind Jesus Aguilar but ahead of Moncada

Feb 03, 2015 7:59 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If you're talking about pure ceiling, sure, they're somewhat similar, but floor and probability matter too. Lindor is pretty much ready now and is very safe. Marte could turn into a 2B-first utility guy and Barreto could wash out in Double-A for all we know. That being said, I think a lot of fantasy players discount Lindor's bat: he's got sneaky pop and a good approach. He's gonna hit.

Feb 03, 2015 5:55 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Correa has the best usable power. I'd imagine Gatewood is in the conversation for raw, but that's a better question for the BP Fantasy Staff.

Feb 03, 2015 5:53 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes, that's an apt comparison. I don't project Russell or Correa to hit for big power immediately upon reaching the majors, though Correa has a better shot to do so than most.

Feb 03, 2015 5:52 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He fits in with the "Others" group among 2016 and Beyond, sure. Not a top-150 fantasy guy for me yet, though.

Feb 03, 2015 5:51 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Your point about projecting contextual factors far in advance is a valid one, but both of these guys are probably going to see the majors at some point in 2015; it's not like I'm projecting what Seattle's lineup will look like in 2018. I guess I could write a whole column filled with "what's the point of it all, we don't know where any of these guys will be in the future," but I think that would get boring. Franco has no help in Philly at all aside from Utley. If Franco hits .270 with 20 homers and Peterson hits .255 with 18 homers, there's plenty of room for Peterson to out-RBI Franco.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Agreed. Overall, this piece failed to move me emotionally.

Jan 27, 2015 9:32 AM on Third Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Cuthbert for 2015 because he could get playing time if (when) Moustakas sucks again. Chavis and Lara for the 2016+ guys for me.

Jan 27, 2015 9:24 AM on Third-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I've seen that rumor too but have no inside info as to whether it's true.

Jan 27, 2015 9:22 AM on Third-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks for the kind words!

Jan 27, 2015 9:21 AM on Third-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd like to second you here. The Giolito pick was a stroke of genius by a very smart and good participant.

Jan 27, 2015 9:20 AM on Rounds 1-2
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is a strong comment.

Jan 27, 2015 6:18 AM on Third-Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Come at me with something better and I'll be happy to engage in a debate.

Jan 22, 2015 7:32 AM on Second Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I totally get that this isn't a great answer, but "somewhere in between" is correct. If Profar gets moved off of 2B it's going to be to play SS, so he doesn't get knocked for potential eligibility loss. If Rendon moves full-time it will be to 3B, so he's docked slightly. If I thought, say, Gordon was going to move from 2B to OF, he'd be docked even more. Sliding scale.

Jan 21, 2015 1:31 PM on Second Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm not going to go to war over rankings within the same tier. I think we just saw Dozier's peak, but ranking him at 7 ain't an insult.

Jan 21, 2015 9:10 AM on Second Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Really good Brioche because he has the potential to be delicious but there are obvious flaws (strikeouts/doesn't hold up well w/hearty sandwiches).

Jan 21, 2015 8:15 AM on Second Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

In that scenario I'd gamble on Profar's upside since you already have a safe alternative.

Jan 21, 2015 6:38 AM on Second Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Can't even be mad at this.

Jan 21, 2015 6:37 AM on Second Base
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Not sure how someone can be an annual flop with one year of MLB service time under his belt.

Jan 19, 2015 12:58 PM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

...yes?

Jan 19, 2015 9:21 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We have dynasty and three-year first-base rankings in the coming days that should answer these questions. I understand your comment about "prospect-eligible" disclaimer, but making such distinctions is really the best way to fairly segment a huge population of players into digestible chunks. If you still want to talk Singleton after the dynasty and three-year columns hit, feel free to email me and I'll answer any questions you have!

Jan 13, 2015 2:00 PM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's not an unreasonable opinion, but we've sort of taken a "wait until they actually move" stance on the fantasy squad. Otherwise, you end up ranking people like Bogaerts and Seager at 3B when they're gonna be SS for a while, etc. It's easier/more instructive to rank these guys at their current positions and include a written caveat that they might move, I think.

Jan 13, 2015 9:10 AM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Still considered an outfielder for our purposes. Otherwise he'd be the best 1B prospect in the game by a wide margin.

Jan 13, 2015 8:44 AM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That too.

Jan 13, 2015 8:09 AM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Definitely not. Rough rookie year, but he's not devoid of fantasy value.

Jan 13, 2015 7:59 AM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

My understanding is that Amador was loaned to the Mexican League for the majority of the 2014 season but is still Astros property. Also, I wanted to make fat jokes because I'm projecting.

Jan 13, 2015 6:54 AM on First Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I blame John Sickles

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I only meant in a fantasy context.

Jan 07, 2015 11:24 AM on Catchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Best-case for our purposes would probably see Cervelli earning the most time, but that's not a sure thing and even if he got 450 PA he'd only be in the Salty/Iannetta range. Add in the competition he has in Stewart and Sanchez and I'm very comfortable leaving him off the list.

Jan 07, 2015 10:10 AM on Catchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes, worthy of mentioning. Thanks for bringing this up!

Jan 07, 2015 9:18 AM on Catchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yeah, this piece isn't really geared toward only leagues. Fortunately, we'll have supplemental content in the coming days.

Jan 07, 2015 9:17 AM on Catchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We generally use 20 games as the cutoff for these rankings. If your league uses 10 games, I could see him ranking right around Martin, since he could grab a few appearances behind the plate per year. His days of catching 20+ times a year are behind him, though.

Jan 07, 2015 9:16 AM on Catchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

me?

Jan 06, 2015 8:37 AM on 2014 Draft Class
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is our pre-2014 column.

Jan 05, 2015 10:36 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Nick Schlain died 14 years ago.

Jan 02, 2015 5:43 PM on A Look Ahead
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Nope, I think he'll bat 8th, and while Christian Vazquez isn't very potent behind him, Betts, Pedroia and Ortiz loom.

Dec 11, 2014 6:00 PM on All the Fantasy Angles
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes, some of the greatest left-handed hitters in the history of the game have indeed hit well at Fenway. Statistically, it's still a better park for right-handers, though positive offensively for everyone overall.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes, Wacha should be in that list with Wainwright/Lackey/Lynn, with Garcia as the No. 5 who probably won't pitch, leaving a spot open for Martinez/Gonzalez. Apologies.

Nov 18, 2014 2:22 PM on Heyward Movement
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks for getting the people excited, Craig

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's quite close between these two, but I still prefer Bogaerts. That being said, 144 is probably around his ceiling for impact next year.

Nov 03, 2014 6:13 AM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Craig better get a calendar or his days are numbered. Wait ...

Oct 27, 2014 8:48 AM on Texas Rangers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Ketchup is generally shitty but hot dogs are one of the few acceptable vehicles for its consumption.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is wrong and bad and you are a just a crony for Big Sandwich.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is bad and wrong

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

There's always more sandwich-related content to be had here. You just have to ask. I believe Swihart would be the Croque Madame here because he does a little bit of everything (hit for avg, hit for power, decent defender), just as the Madame has something for salt-lovers, egg-lovers and grilled cheese-lovers. If you get a truly perfect Croque Madame, it's a 60+ sandwich, but it's more likely that it's slightly too salty or the egg makes the bread runny and you end up with a role-50 snack.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks for reading! And yes, at $3, Susac is a worthy gamble.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think Susac will be a nice player, but he's certainly nowhere near the Posey/Lucroy tier for me, and I don't think I'd have him as a top-20 guy for 2015, given the playing time concerns and all. That being said, I was surprised by how much Nick Faleris liked him in my discussions with the MiLB team for this piece, and it's opened my eyes to his understated MiLB production.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's been my pleasure, thanks for reading! If those three stats are the most important, I think I might go Blanco or Mercer, as weird as it is to type that sentence.

Sep 16, 2014 12:01 PM on Week 25
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I like where your head is at.

Sep 16, 2014 11:59 AM on Week 25
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I am also too lazy to look that up, and almost no thought goes into those selections. I will, however, calculate my "streamer of the week" W-L/ERA/K%/BB% before next season.

Sep 16, 2014 6:20 AM on Week 25
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Sadly, I've been invited to join Sandwich Prospectus, not English Prospectus.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

A silly rule for silly, stubborn men and women.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I can't believe you went back an edited that out, wow.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Craig can't even differentiate between a hot dog and a sandwich. You can't expect him to nail au jus/with au jus.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You have excellent taste.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I mistakenly included his four homers from winter ball because of the layout I used to look at the stats, you are correct. Interesting note about Pensacola. Thanks for contributing to the discussion.

Sep 04, 2014 11:48 AM on The Others
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This isn't pedantic, as it completely changes what I was trying to say. And yes, you're right. We'll get it fixed - thanks!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Probably over all of them, yes. Willingham and Martinez are the only two who give me short-term pause.

Aug 26, 2014 7:41 AM on Week 21
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm a Red Sox fan, I understand.

Aug 26, 2014 7:41 AM on Week 21
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Without seeing your roster, I think the upgrade you'd see in Markakis over a few games is too marginal to risk Tanaka's upside over, yes.

Aug 20, 2014 8:24 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I would hold on to Tanaka. P.s. your league rules are awful.

Aug 20, 2014 7:41 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I do indeed believe you are crazy if you prefer Moya, Demeritte or Mejia to Piscotty, yes.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This suggests to me that you think Seager is a vastly superior prospect to Walker. I don't think that's a view many people share.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Would've been in the next ~10 for me. Injury played a role, ya. Distance from majors, too. I preferred Stewart even before the injury though.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I make lists every off-season and used a combination of that list, Bret's list, Bret's mid-season update and some of my own notes to cobble this together. The longest I've ever gone is Top 200.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I've never been quite as high on Taillon as some others -- don't see a fantasy ace, or maybe even a fantasy No. 2. Add in his health, and he drops behind pitchers with similar or even slightly lesser upsides.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yep. Bell is closest and has the most power, so he's slightly ahead of the other two. You can flip Williams and Tapia and get no strong disagreement from me, but I've seen Williams in person and fell in love, so here we are. I'd expect more pop from Williams and a higher average from Tapia, ultimately.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I prefer Liriano

Aug 12, 2014 8:37 AM on Week 19
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

As someone who definitely answers way more BS questions than Craig, let me express my thanks for your thanks!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Such a sneaky humblebrag in here.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Soler is already on Bret's Top 50

Jul 16, 2014 10:28 AM on Top 50 Jumpers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Who do you prefer for a dynasty league: Carlos Correa or Addison Russel?

Jul 14, 2014 7:38 AM on Midseason Update
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This would eliminate 20% of the content on The Internet.

Jul 10, 2014 2:12 PM on Christian Vazquez
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Better career: Alcantara or Miguel Olivo?

Jul 09, 2014 6:55 PM on Arismendy Alcantara
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Episode 20 will be up tomorrow! We miss you too!

Jun 13, 2014 9:44 AM on Ep. 19: Elbow Boo Boo
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

At the point where I just scream "MAINESKINNNNN" like "KAHHHN" whenever you comment on Red Sox prospects.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Due for regression

Jun 10, 2014 7:12 AM on Week 10
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I hate Kevin Gregg so much.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I prefer Butler by a wide margin.

Jun 04, 2014 6:17 AM on Week Nine
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Every pitcher you named could see the majors at some point this year with the possible exceptions of AJ Cole and Folty. But, Montgomery, Santana, Erasmo, Hale, Happ and Deduno don't figure to be of much value. There's a good chance that Fiers, Cosart and Hellickson won't knock your socks off either. For the rest of the arms you've listed, I like Stroman the most for 2014 and Gray the most long-term.

May 28, 2014 1:59 PM on Week Eight
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Uh, he's at 69

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He won't be an MI if he stays in Boston, and I'm a bigger believer in Cecchini's bat than most. And again, they are three spots apart, so it's clear the gulf isn't that big in our minds.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It might be Craig and I being too patient. We originally had Hosmer even higher than this, but at a certain point we need to recognize the reality of his lack of production. I still think he's going to put it together and explode, but Craig and I are out on a limb on this one.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes. The rate of success with TJ is such that we don't have to knock Fernandez too badly, but we can't just assume complete recovery, either. Before the TJ, Fernandez was No. 3 on this list.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

There's definitely an argument to be made for Moore ranking higher, but it doesn't involve Verlander.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That's a flip of the coin, especially since we don't know how long it will take Drew to get ready. I'd say keep Miller, but don't have a big issue with grabbing Drew instead.

May 21, 2014 10:22 AM on Week Seven
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

No, Syndegaard and Gausman are the better prospects.

May 21, 2014 8:54 AM on Week Seven
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't think 14 slots this far down the list suggests they are terribly dissimilar. But I still prefer Moore by a significant margin.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

WAR isn't a fantasy category. WHIP is. And I think TJ is still a fairly big deal, especially for someone with shitty command to begin with.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Are you still personally insulted? :)

May 17, 2014 9:12 AM on Week Five
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Damn. I even looked up the spelling of Bareilles.

May 15, 2014 10:07 AM on Week Six
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

How would you compare him to Mike Foltynewicz?

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Craig and I are responsible for this list, and while we respect Bret we don't agree with every one of his evaluations. Bret's pre-season evals weren't used at all for this series. Personally, I was never as high on Tapia or Anderson and have always been high on Gallo. I'll let Craig speak for himself.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We thought there would be too many ties if we went with two respective lists averaged, so we went straight down the line. It took a while. We argued about Danny Duffy for 40 minutes.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You have excellent taste and I would like to know you. http://www.cafepress.com/+tino_logo_drinking_glass,1294161610

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yep. Decent MI in the majors gonna get the nod over a power arm in the low minors almost every time.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is a really good question. There's no real one answer, but I can tell you that at several points during our collaboration, Craig and I would ask each other, "really, you would trade player x for player y straight up?" whenever we had trouble with a ranking. As a very generalized pecking order, I tend to look at it this way: Star MLB player Good MLB player Star prospect Average MLB player Good prospect Average prospect w/ upside Fringe MLB player Average prospect w/high floor

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The list was finalized yesterday. Keep in mind this is just the opinion of two men, but I think the general feeling is that six weeks of solid performance doesn't completely change our eval or Porcello or Eovaldi. I still think they're both No. 4 MLB starters in the long run, though I acknowledge Eovaldi has a tick more upside than that.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

There are 100 players left to rank.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Nope!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Craig is higher on Norris than I am, but I can buy the argument for his upside.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd keep Scutaro out of those three.

May 07, 2014 7:22 PM on Week Five
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I can't put it any better than "Plus change-up. Good control. Fringy prospect."

May 07, 2014 7:22 PM on Week Five
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I was trying to personally insult you, you caught me.

May 07, 2014 7:22 PM on Week Five
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Kalish is better but I expect both to see time.

May 07, 2014 6:47 AM on Week Five
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think we see the same thing with WMB in terms of strikeouts, but I think his power is somewhat undersold. It would not shock me to see him reach 30 homers some day, and while it feels like we've been talking about him forever, he's still just 25. I'm not throwing in the towel just yet. I agree with you that a Cecchini at 3B/WMB at 1B future for the Red Sox is unlikely. WMB's bat doesn't profile there, and I think he'd just be traded if Boston decides Cecchini is the future at the hot corner. He's also a good defensive 3B, so someone will bite even if the return isn't huge.

May 06, 2014 1:31 PM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

These are dynasty rankings, and I still think Matt Moore will have a better career than Archer. Let's not pretend control is Archer's ally, either. The WMB and Cecchini rankings are separate entities. I can't project for contextual factors this far out, but I trust the Red Sox to be smarter with their resources than to put WMB at first and Cecchini at third, which hurts the defense and gives two players poor profiles. Yes, a third baseman who hits .260 with 20 homers and 10 steals is indeed valuable.

May 06, 2014 12:55 PM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Agreed. The Red Sox aren't going to trade Bogaerts, so I don't see a matchup with the Marlins.

May 06, 2014 11:30 AM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think Swihart is in a different tier than Cecchini/Betts/Owens. Swihart is more of a back-end fantasy starter than an amazing fantasy talent to me. He's a better MLB prospect.

May 06, 2014 11:30 AM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't throw HoF comps on prospects as a general rule.

May 06, 2014 11:28 AM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't either, no.

May 06, 2014 11:28 AM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

How do you feel about Matt Lindstrom?

May 06, 2014 7:13 AM on Fourth Edition
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm not in love with Schoop and while I think the Betts hype is getting out of hand, he can really hit and I have my doubts that Schoop can. Schoop has more power, but if Betts out-produces him in every other category by a very wide margin, I won't be surprised.

May 06, 2014 7:10 AM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

In an OBP league, give me Cecchini.

May 06, 2014 6:48 AM on AL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

J.A. Happ came up to replace Morrow.

May 05, 2014 1:02 PM on Marcus Stroman
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's not out of the realm of possibility, but I doubt it happens. I prefer Smyly in the long run anyway.

Apr 30, 2014 11:04 AM on Week Four
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

None that are fit to print.

Apr 30, 2014 8:14 AM on Week Four
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Only Harper is "out of order," but in baseball it's just called going on the DL.

Apr 29, 2014 7:34 AM on NL East U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I would only do this if Lind is still on the DL when we get word that Singleton will be called up. Otherwise, it's too risky for similar upside.

Apr 24, 2014 7:11 AM on Week Three
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Only someone silly would do that (I am 2/2 in random HR guesses, no big deal).

Apr 23, 2014 7:25 AM on Week Three
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks, we'll get that fixed. Either way, are you suggesting that I'm too optimistic here or do you think he can still be a productive MLB bat?

Apr 23, 2014 6:39 AM on Week Three
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Welp, fortunately for you there are only two left!

Apr 22, 2014 6:46 AM on AL Central U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Gah, didn't even mean to make this all AL this week. I'll do my best to spread the love around next time. For an NL streamer, how about Alfredo Simon against the Cubs on Friday.

Apr 16, 2014 10:55 AM on Week Two
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Jack seasons 1-4, Trevor seasons 5-now.

Apr 16, 2014 9:28 AM on Week Two
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I look forward to your slab of beef.

Apr 16, 2014 7:10 AM on NL Central U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'd take Piscotty first IRL, but I think Vogelbach will have a solid fantasy career, even if it comes as a UT.

Apr 16, 2014 7:09 AM on NL Central U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I am keeping an eye on him, but I'm not ready to declare him "broken" after two starts. Even if there is an issue and he needs to miss some of 2014, it doesn't change my long-term view of him as a legit No. 2 fantasy starter.

Apr 15, 2014 6:38 AM on NL Central U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Oops. I'll second Brinson and Velasquez and add Kaleb Cowart and Delino DeShields as some possibilities, too.

Apr 08, 2014 10:44 AM on AL West U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Just some comedy jokes. It would not surprise me to see Gallo or Cosart off the list all together for non-age reasons next year. Some concern with Singleton as well.

Apr 08, 2014 10:19 AM on AL West U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Everyone who is 25 now.

Apr 08, 2014 10:17 AM on AL West U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Ugh, thanks. I'd have Skaggs at 15, behind Brad Miller and ahead of Rougned Odor.

Apr 08, 2014 6:20 AM on AL West U25 Lists
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Mike Carp should not be owned in a 16-team league!

Apr 02, 2014 10:39 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm pushing for it, yes.

Apr 02, 2014 10:39 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You should write in to TINO, strong candidate for WFFOTW

Apr 02, 2014 8:08 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks!

Apr 02, 2014 8:07 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You joke, but I'm going to talk to Bret about this.

Apr 02, 2014 8:07 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I will give you 16 internet dollars if Jonathan Diaz gets 50 hits this season.

Apr 02, 2014 8:06 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It was, but I think the reasons I had to shy away from that one are fairly obvious. It deserves a TINO shoutout though.

Apr 02, 2014 8:06 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks, Ian. I'd go Joyce, Jones, Almonte, Carp I think

Apr 02, 2014 7:09 AM on Introduction
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Agreed, keep Peralta

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

My solo column on deep leagues is out tomorrow. SO STAY TUNED.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You can take these as general fantasy rankings, so roto 5x5, but it's pretty easy to distill H2H value from there.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yep. I try to go the extra mile to cover for your laziness and I get the blame. Sounds about right.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Gerndt?

Apr 01, 2014 6:11 AM on Week One
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You're a handsome man/beautiful woman with excellent taste in roster construction.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I asked if I could pick Tyler Thornburg for every category and was told "no." :(

Mar 26, 2014 7:32 AM on WHIP
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This post is from 2013, not from 2014.

Mar 26, 2014 7:20 AM on Part One: 1-50
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You also don't have to worry about players losing eligibility in mixed leagues. Basically I hate only leagues.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I suppose they're fairly close, but I imagine you have a little more flexibility in a mixed league since you're open to a wider pool of sleepers overall even though the ratio is the same. But most NL leagues don't have 40-man rosters like the TDGX league above did, so in that case a standard NL-only league would still be significantly shallower.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Paul Sporer covered that a bit in his State of the Position piece here: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/a/22840

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think Choice is better than a platoon player in the long run but that he's largely used as a platoon option in 2014.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Using platoon players in deep leagues with daily changes is an excellent idea, especially if you're an attentive owner. I've been targeting Choice and Daniel Nava frequently in leagues of this nature.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks for the kind words!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

If you're playing in a two-catcher 20-team league, you're even more of a glutton for punishment than I.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I agree with both your versatility and set-up points. In the TDGX league I wrote about above, I ended up with Alberto Callaspo, Macier Izturis and Jeff Keppinger as bench players and Luke Gregrson, Brett Cecil and Darren O'Day as pitchers.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I do think he'll hold on to the job all year unless he's truly terrible, because there's little in the way of competition right now. You're right that Villar is useless in average and RBI, but I he could score 60-plus runs with 40 steals and 10 HR. He's a unique player and you'll need to compensate elsewhere for his deficiencies, but I don't think $10 is a crazy number for him in a league that deep. He could be a top-5 finisher in SB.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You're never gonna stop editing me, eh Tim?

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Between Conger, Calhoun, Skaggs, Richards and Green the Angels have a ton of semi-interesting guys who are bound to break some hearts.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The worst.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We mock because we're uncomfortable, but I agree. It's something we're keeping in mind and we appreciate the feedback!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Can you maybe make graphs for each player individually?

Mar 07, 2014 8:53 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I like Lee and he was one of the final cuts from my list, but Cody Allen is the future in Cleveland and it's hard to see the other guys having much fantasy value.

Mar 05, 2014 11:55 AM on Relief Pitcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't have inside info here, but given his injury history and whispers of a future in the 'pen even in college I'd be surprised if he makes it as a starter. There's a non-zero chance, though.

Mar 05, 2014 11:55 AM on Relief Pitcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

These are all fine names, especially Black. They fit in with the "other" category for me. May god have mercy on you if you're in a league where these guys are relevant.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Craig House probably the most inhabitable pitcher of all time IMO.

Mar 05, 2014 9:14 AM on Starting Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Paxton seems to have all but locked up a rotation spot for 2014. Martinez is the better bet to start long-term, but faces quite a logjam right now.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This means more to me than you know.

Mar 03, 2014 9:59 AM on Closers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think Clippard is a better pitcher, which is very well why they may keep him in a more flexible role and move Storen back to closer if Soriano falters. That being said, I still like Storen and I don't think Soriano is quite done yet.

Mar 03, 2014 9:59 AM on Relief Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That undersells the potential of his hit tool. He might only be a .250 hitter, but that's far from his ceiling.

Mar 03, 2014 8:52 AM on Part One: 1-50
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It's hard to be comprehensive when you get that far down the list. Doolittle is a fine choice and a worthy target, yes.

Mar 03, 2014 8:43 AM on Closers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Don't you dare get passive aggressive with me after 6k words.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Seconded. These are only seven names and there are 150+ SP, so I wouldn't make too many generalizations based on this piece alone.

Feb 24, 2014 11:47 AM on Starting Pitchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'll bite. What are you referring to?

Feb 23, 2014 6:04 PM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

While the order of players listed above isn't exact, it is specific enough that if more than two or three spots separate players, that should clearly indicate how I feel about them. So I think Dahl is far and away your best bet here, then Tapia with a smaller gulf separating him from Mazara. I would, however, take Frazier over Dahl. But it's close.

Feb 21, 2014 9:47 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks! Yes, Mazara is better for dynasty purposes.

Feb 20, 2014 8:53 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is completely fair.

Feb 19, 2014 12:38 PM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You're being greedy. Don't be greedy.

Feb 19, 2014 8:28 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

ETA largely based on when the player is ready, not when the team makes room for him. You can definitely make the argument that Piscotty should be 2015, though.

Feb 19, 2014 8:28 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

No Ryan Church?

Feb 19, 2014 7:31 AM on Outfielders
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't mean this in a Coldstein way, but the answer is because it's more difficult to hit in the majors than it is in the minors. Springer doesn't project to have a plus hit tool, has been flagged for contact issues since his days at UConn and is not going to post BABIPs of .360-plus once he reaches MLB. I like Springer plenty, don't get me wrong, but looking at a prospect's MiLB stat line and translating the same production to the majors is a dangerous practice.

Feb 19, 2014 7:12 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Chris Young's five-year average from 2007-2011: 25 homers, 22 steals, .240 average, 156 strikeouts per 162 games. I stand by the comparison as a realistic middle ground for Springer, who could easily strike out even more than Young.

Feb 19, 2014 6:38 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I ordered them somewhat deliberately but did not spend a ton of time on the individual rankings. They're a guideline to how I'd order them, but not definitive by any means.

Feb 19, 2014 6:34 AM on Outfield Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Just call me Ben-Her

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

In a keeper, Machado is the one to hold on to and I don't think it's all that close.

Feb 14, 2014 3:48 PM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Correct, these are for 2014 only. I also love Machado long-term.

Feb 14, 2014 6:23 AM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm glad authors don't have the +/- 1 feature because I'm not sure which option I would've gone with here.

Feb 12, 2014 3:18 PM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't think we see him until mid-2015 and he's got very limited upside. The last cut for me was Cecchini.

Feb 12, 2014 12:21 PM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't expect him to be up until late 2015 or, more likely, mid-2016, so he would not rank at all.

Feb 12, 2014 11:53 AM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is a common POV, but I have a really hard time believing the Orioles are going to shift Machado back to SS after two-plus years at third, where he defense is absurd. I think he's a 3B long-term. But if I'm wrong, at least Machado is moving up the positional value chain and not down it.

Feb 12, 2014 6:20 AM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Near Prado and Headley, ahead of Sandoval.

Feb 10, 2014 6:21 AM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You don't have to be an asswhole about it

Feb 10, 2014 6:20 AM on Third Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Is Arkansas a major turnip trade route or something?

Feb 08, 2014 10:11 AM on Shortstops
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Levi Michael is none too pleased right now.

Feb 06, 2014 8:00 PM on Top 50 Shortstops
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I lol'd

Feb 06, 2014 7:59 PM on Top 50 Shortstops
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Roman Quinn is 44 spots too low. Otherwise, nice list.

Feb 06, 2014 8:00 AM on Top 50 Shortstops
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think that's his ultimate ceiling, but that time frame is a bit early. In 2016 he'd still only be 23 for the entire season, so he's likely not to be at his peak power potential yet.

Feb 05, 2014 11:55 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think he's better than the 107th-best fantasy prospect, so in that regard he fell a bit due to the board. But he's probably somewhere in the 70-80 range for me in terms of fantasy top-100, so it's not a huge drop.

Feb 05, 2014 10:50 AM on Rounds 8-10
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thank you, sir. Hopefully the fixes make this easier to understand.

Feb 05, 2014 7:24 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I also have no idea where you're getting that 60 runs stat from. We have his FRAA as -6.9 and Fangrahps' DRS has him at -1 for last year.

Feb 05, 2014 7:23 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'll chime in here, because I strongly considered Tirado/Gohara/Guzman and the like with my final picks. I decided to go with post-hype guys like Bauer and Olt because I'll know what they are by year's end, and possibly sooner. They'll either be contributing in the majors and off of my MiLB roster, or their value will have sunk to the point where I'd be comfortable dropping them. If I had gone with Tirado/Gohara, I'm resigning myself to sacrificing a roster spot for the next 3-4 years.

Feb 05, 2014 7:10 AM on Rounds 8-10
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks, going to get both of those fixed. But yes, I think Lindor and Mondesi are both on the path to becoming Andurs-like fantasy assets who really only contribute in AVG, R and SB.

Feb 05, 2014 7:02 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't think they'll kick him to the curb, but I do think Owings will see the majority of the PT there this season.

Feb 05, 2014 7:01 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is helpful info - thanks!

Feb 05, 2014 7:00 AM on Shortstop Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Other way around.

Feb 03, 2014 3:59 PM on Shortstops
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I didn't suggest he'd lose playing time. If Drew is resigned I expect Bogaerts to get the majority of his PA at 3B, as he'd likely only man SS against LHP for the most part.

Feb 03, 2014 3:58 PM on Shortstops
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I can't speak for everyone, but I think Beckham isn't here because he's obviously someone to avoid. Don't do that to yourself. You work hard and you're an honest man or woman. You deserve better.

Jan 31, 2014 9:17 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think we see Alcantara some time in late July or August. I think it's possible you'll see Starlin traded if he does well in 2014, but we could also see Baez at 3B, Castro at SS, Alcantara at 2B and Bryant in RF.

Jan 29, 2014 6:41 PM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

He needs to give up hitting from the right side, which he proved consistently in the minors he can't really do. That's fine, as it still leaves him as the long-side of a platoon, and I'm actually not sure how much worse he could do facing southpaws as a lefty himself. Franklin isn't a superstar in the making, but he could challenge for 20 homers a year in a semi-favorable ballpark, and he's the type of player who will start at 2B somewhere for 10 seasons. There's still plenty of reason for optimism, though a trade - to the Yankees, perhaps? - would do wonders for his fantasy value.

Jan 29, 2014 12:39 PM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Weeks hit .209/.306/.357 in 399 PA last year. You have a very deep first tier.

Jan 29, 2014 11:44 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is a point well taken, and I'll try to make sure I do a better job of laying out this info when we're talking about no-Top 100 names. Thank you for the feedback!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE SO MEAN ABO ... oh, thanks!

Jan 29, 2014 7:46 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Gennett is pretty rough at 2B, so he definitely can't play at SS, unfortunately. I agree that they're likely to try and make room for Gindl on the roster - perhaps they'll risk Segura staying healthy and will start without Bianchi.

Jan 29, 2014 7:11 AM on Milwaukee Brewers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The last two sentences of this comment are pure gold.

Jan 28, 2014 11:29 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I guess I'll put it this way: I'd give Cecchini a 50% change of being a solid five-category contributor, with solid AVG, R and RBI totals and double-digit homers and steals. I'd give Gallo a 5% chance of being a Fantasy beast with low averages and massive HR, RBI and R totals. I'll take the security, but as you'll see later I like Gallo as well.

Jan 28, 2014 11:05 AM on Rounds 3-4
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I cover Weeks in-depth in the Brewers fantasy preview going up later this week, but the short answer to your question is: probably not. I think it's Gennett's job to lose in a righty-heavy lineup right now, and with deteriorating speed Weeks loses a part of what once made him so attractive. Is he worth a $1 flier or a very late-round pick? Sure. But he's not worth any significant investment.

Jan 28, 2014 10:36 AM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That underrated Cecchini pretty badly. He's likely to be MLB ready by mid-2014 and he's a safe bet to be an above average hitter. I can see the argument for Seager, but you'd be hard-pressed to find many who prefer Davidson, Moran, Peterson, Olt or Gallo to Cecchini.

Jan 28, 2014 9:55 AM on Rounds 3-4
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I agree with this, yes. I won't speak for Eno, but when you pick first or last, some times you have to reach for a guy you really like.

Jan 28, 2014 9:53 AM on Rounds 3-4
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think you're overstating Alcantara's 2014 impact a bit. The Cubs have no reason to play him in the majors much before July, and he'd likely be batting near the bottom of a bad lineup. I like Alcantara a lot and he's an easy Top 50 name for me, but I don't think he'll have much fantasy impact until 2015.

Jan 28, 2014 8:51 AM on Rounds 3-4
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I believe the enthusiasm for Rendon stems more from scouting than it does his 2013 numbers.

Jan 27, 2014 6:38 PM on Second Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Old habits die hard. I'll get that fixed, thanks.

Jan 24, 2014 10:58 AM on First Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

We should be friends

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I find this comment to be taste less.

Jan 22, 2014 10:30 AM on Rounds 1-2
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

MiLB stats don't count, but this is a dynasty draft, meaning you would retain these players past the 2014 season. So while 2014 production is certainly valued, it's not the be-all end-all, or this would be a much shorter draft.

Jan 22, 2014 7:49 AM on Rounds 1-2
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Am I not understanding this comment or are you not seeing the data bins?

Jan 21, 2014 7:21 AM on First Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think we do try and mention OBP whenever a player sees a substantial increase or decline in value in OBP leagues compared to standard formats, but the fact is the vast majority of fantasy leagues still use AVG. The suggestion to include OBP more is a good one and one I know I'll personally consider, but it's not going to come at the expense of AVG.

Jan 21, 2014 7:17 AM on First Basemen
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks for the kind words!

Jan 18, 2014 11:52 AM on Catchers
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

The counting stats point is a fair one, but I think that only makes Hedges a safe bet to be a top-15-20 option consistently, rather than someone who routinely starts in 12-team leagues. When you consider that he's an elite MLB prospect, that makes the gap in value pretty substantial.

Jan 15, 2014 11:11 AM on Catcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks! For upside, I'd rank them Bell, Williams, Heathcott. For probability/floor, let's go Heathcott, Williams, Bell. Overall, I'll go Williams, Bell, Heathcott.

Jan 15, 2014 8:13 AM on Catcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I would defer to Mr. Parks on the first point. If he says 2015, 2015 it is, though his offense may take a bit longer to fully develop. I'm less concerned about his actual average than I am whether his hit tool will let his power play. I think the number you pegged is a good one to plan for, as a .290 average would then be gravy and a .240 average won't completely ruin your evaluation of Alfaro.

Jan 15, 2014 7:10 AM on Catcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes. There's also a gap with Lindor, but it's nowhere near as wide as with Hedges and Lindor is still a top-30 fantasy prospect.

Jan 15, 2014 6:42 AM on Catcher Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

You're among friends here.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Nothing comes to mind re: others doing "what are you drinking?" and would be willing to wager that finding other examples will be difficult.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Fringe top-10 is unfair for Rosario. He's definitely top-10, but I think he's closer to 10 than 2, which is a point I conveyed poorly in this write up. It's a fair criticism. My concern is that the BABIP is obviously unsustainable and his ability to reach base really worries me. The power is clearly legit, but I don't think the good averages are. As for Cargo, I think we all know what he is at this point and I do think I articulated the pros and cons of drafting him early in the piece. I personally err on the side of safety that early in drafts, which means I don't think he's a reach at eight but I don't think it would be crazy for him to fall to the 10-15 range either.

Jan 11, 2014 8:17 AM on Colorado Rockies
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Rymer <3

Jan 10, 2014 6:23 AM on San Diego Padres
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I knew I'd get tagged for putting the "not very good" tag on Chatwood and maybe that's not totally fair, but I don't think his limited ceiling (low K%) is worth the risk for fantasy purposes. He's a deep league/NL-only guy for me.

Jan 08, 2014 10:20 AM on Colorado Rockies
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think he'd need to be pitching really well and the Rockies would need to be semi-relevant for that to happen, although I do think a 2014 debut is likely. This should be a much more interesting rotation by mid-2015 with Butler and Gray.

Jan 08, 2014 8:51 AM on Colorado Rockies
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think it's just an exercise in risk vs. floor. He finished as the 32nd-best player on ESPN's player rater for 5x5 leagues last season, but that was in 3/4 of a season, of course. I think he'll generally go between 10-20 in all leagues.

Jan 08, 2014 8:24 AM on Colorado Rockies
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

As yet another right-handed bat, Parker's path to playing time is full of obstacles. That being said, thanks to the positional versatility of Morneau and Rosario and the like there are a few scenarios in which he could see time, and he'd be immediately worthy of attention in just about all leagues. As Bret Sayre pointed out here (http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=22525) Parker is a better fantasy prospect than an MLB one, as 30-homer power doesn't grow on trees.

Jan 08, 2014 6:49 AM on Colorado Rockies
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Good to note re: Rosario, thank you. I've read the same about Lyles, but I just can't imagine Morales or Friedrich pitching well enough in Spring Training to win a spot in the rotation, so I think only Nicasio represents a real challenge there.

Jan 08, 2014 6:25 AM on Colorado Rockies
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

When your name means "Defender of the People," you need no nickname.

Jan 08, 2014 6:24 AM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

When it's that close you always take the position player, IMO. Bogaerts it is.

Jan 07, 2014 6:05 AM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I second this notion but disapprove of this nickname.

Jan 06, 2014 11:56 AM on Boston Red Sox
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This might be my favorite BP title ever. Well done.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I think Wong is still eligible for inclusion on a list like this, sure, but there's no question that his job security took a hit with the Ellis signing. It's likely that Wong loses some playing time against LHP, and he could lose substantially more if he really flops, but the plan still appears to be for him to start. I still don't think Wong loses more than 100 PA, so let's dock his pre-Ellis value by ~15% .

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks for your comments, mbovie. I agree with you that Calhoun is a nice sleeper headed into 2014, but this wasn't meant to be a definitive guide to every fantasy prospect who'll see success next year - it was just a snapshot look at seven of the more popular names. There are at least a dozen other prospects who come to mind that would fit in a column like this, and I'll probably address them in the weeks to come.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

"He was less valuable as a fantasy first baseman than Brandon Moss last season, for example." I filtered by 1B for the comparison. He was worse than Moss regardless of his C eligibility.

Dec 09, 2013 5:44 PM on The AL East Rearms
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I was trying to use McGowan as an example of a pitcher who we all wanted to rebound from injury for several years, but who didn't.

Dec 06, 2013 4:11 PM on Toronto Blue Jays
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Caught in the act of favoriting. For shame.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

That's a complex question, but I'd start with a lack of high-caliber pitching, pouring a lot of money into two players who've suffered through injuries and some uninspiring drafts towards the turn of the decade. Without digging to deep right now, I can't think of many Twins trades that have worked out exceptionally well either, although Denard Span for Alex Meyer has the chance to do so.

Nov 19, 2013 9:06 AM on Minnesota Twins
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

From a fantasy POV, that could be a blessing in disguise. Potentially three Top 20 catchers coming from one team.

Nov 18, 2013 3:59 PM on Minnesota Twins
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

.260-270 AVG, 15-20 HR, ~50 R and RBI. Potential Top 15 backstop.

Nov 18, 2013 9:04 AM on Minnesota Twins
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I would fully expect Milone to be first in line should any of the above starters falter. There's also a chance the A's deal Brett Anderson this offseason and give Milone the No. 5 spot right out of spring training. He'd be the worst fantasy option among Oakland's starters, and should be used as a streamer only.

Nov 14, 2013 7:27 AM on Oakland Athletics
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

What did Cameron Diaz do to you?

Nov 11, 2013 5:07 AM on National League Central
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I believe you will feel differently when Hosmer finally hits .400/.500/.800. But on a serious note, I think I oversold the Royals offense here, and that's a fair criticism. I'd expect Escobar, Moustakas and Gordon to have slightly better 2014 campaigns than they did a season ago, though, and still believe it would be easier to find a replacement DH than it would be a good/affordable starting pitcher in this market.

Nov 08, 2013 3:29 PM on American League Central
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I don't think he'll be worse than Gordon Beckham, and he'll be much cheaper.

Nov 08, 2013 3:23 PM on American League Central
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I do think the Blue Jays need pitching, but I think even a mid-rotation starter will come at more of a cost than Pierzynski, Navarro, Suzuki or possibly even Ruiz. It's tough to lay out a full plan for each team in ~300 words, so the point I was trying to make is that catcher would seem to be the easiest fix for them given this year's market. They also do need a 2B, of course, but I would prioritize a catcher and starting pitching first.

Nov 06, 2013 6:14 AM on American League East
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I believe this is correct and that Encarnacion will still have 3B eligibility for Yahoo!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Apologies for the confusion this has caused, but Ben L. has it right. This was indeed supposed to be laden with sarcasm, and I don't see how calling the Dodgers "the essence of America's moral decline" can be taken as an anti-Cardinals statement. I have no rooting interest in this series or in the "controversy" that surrounds it.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This has been fixed now, thanks.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is a fair criticism, to be sure. I should have said it's the best lineup against righties that Leyland seems willing to use.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

An excellent pitcher and fantasy asset, but I don't think he has quite the same type of strikeout upside, despite what he did in 60 innings this year.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is dependent on your entire budget, of course, but I'd go for Gray and Salazar and drop Archer.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Perhaps my favorite comment on any of my pieces os far. Well done.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

PECOTA still uses the entire histories of all players involved, not just postseason stats.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

It would make some sense, sure, but I would rather have Alexei.

Sep 16, 2013 5:16 PM on Hot Corner Conundrums
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

This is largely my line of reasoning as well, yes. I certainly haven't seen Asche play every game, but I'm not going to abandon a few years of scouting reports for a 38-game sample.

Sep 16, 2013 5:16 PM on Hot Corner Conundrums
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Yes, you are both right. I did consider including Washington, along with the Angels and Dodgers as well.

Sep 16, 2013 4:58 PM on Hot Corner Conundrums
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Whether Hernandez can stick in center is a question better left for someone from our MiLB team, but if that's a move he does make his fantasy value takes yet another hit. He'd still only be relevant for AVG and SB, yet that would come without the 2B eligibility.

Sep 11, 2013 7:14 AM on Second Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Delusional is strong, but let's put it this way: Panik isn't a Top 500 fantasy guy for me. I don't think Zobrist is a reasonable comp.

Sep 11, 2013 7:13 AM on Second Base Prospects
 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Well, I understand your point re: not being useful for your specific league, but there are AL and NL-only keeper leagues with separate MiLB rosters, and these players have (or could have) some relevancy there. Either way, I'll keep your feedback in mind as the series progress, and thanks for your idea re: role players. Those of us afflicted with the need to play in leagues like this have to stick together.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Duly noted, and this is also a good idea. Thanks for the suggestion!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

I'm glad this piece has found its target audience then!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Thanks, Nick. I appreciate it!

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: -

Rest assured that as soon as it makes sense for me to write about Thornburg, I will do so. I think he's a viable long-term starter.

 
Ben Carsley
(67815)
Comment rating: 4

My favorite prospect piece on BP so far. I was talking myself into Wood even last season.