CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  

Search Article Archives

Find:   

Author:    Article: 
Search Date (From):    Search Date (To):   
Sort Results by:  Relevance
 Date
Show me  Results

   Show Article Summaries

New! Search comments:      
(NOTE: Relevance, Author, and Article are not applicable for comment searches)

therealn0d
461 comments | 40 total rating | 0.09 average rating
Facebook Twitter email a friend
Share comments by 'therealn0d' posted at
Baseball Prospectus http://bbp.cx/i/51857
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

That's okay. It's still pretty cool.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I guess it wasn't intentional. All Friends episode names begin with "The One..."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I dig the Friends reference.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

They're not extinct, of course, just rare. Perhaps only one can exist at any one time.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

^this is among the best advice your are ever likely to receive.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I think you read a different article.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

What a fantastic article. One time reading it isn't enough.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

To be fair, "Deadly Accurate" only applies to cases where it is somewhat accurate, or I mean predicted what everyone knew and that actually happened. I mean, they only ever put seven or so examples on the back cover.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

Regarding no. 3, how did <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=Mark+Reynolds">Mark Reynolds</a></span> get around that?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

That brings up how this wasn't controlled for age, because ARod is kinda super old to learn a new position.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Just (this moment) finished reading your article in the annual (after having just read this). You just keep getting better and better Russell. Thank you for being here.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Classically trained trumpet player here.That is a great example. I was in both concert band and jazz band, first chair in both. I could handle jazz just fine, could play the leads just fine, but when it came time to get out the Fake Book and turn to page whatever...there are the changes, have at it...I was completely lost. I had spent plenty of time playing it but very little time actually learning it. I could play a cadenza just fine, because that's the language I knew.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Just to be clear, I'm not trying to be a jerk or simply contrarian. I think what we are really talking about here is that what the eye doesn't "catch" the mind fills in the blanks.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

The catcher is closer to the pitch than the umpire (obviously not by much.) Obviously, if pitch framing is a thing, and we acknowledge it is, the catcher would be doing far more than simply getting his glove in front of the ball. Let's play the substitution game here...the catcher has to be able to tell whether--in mid-flight--it ended up in an imaginary box... I'll grant you that catchers have the advantage of knowing the specifics of the pitch coming, but I'm not buying the argument that umpires can't process the information fast enough to know the differences. Maybe the vantage point is disadvantageous.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Aren't catchers doing this very thing (resolving an image in three dimensions)? Consciously? Isn't that what framing is?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

<span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=TAv" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('TAv'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">TAv</span></a> is not like WAR in any sense of what you said because TAv is the hitting basis of <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=WARP" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('WARP'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">WARP</span></a>, which is the model that is like WAR and even that values things just about as equally as every other model, albeit in a slightly different manner. Just going by pure hitting, TAv is basically equivalent to wOBA on a different scale. They both form the basis for a production to runs conversion, and they're not as different as they might seem.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

History may not forgive, but it can forget.

Dec 14, 2015 10:16 PM on Sano's Strikeouts
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

If he was the nicest dude in the game you would have to change your numbers more than a little. He didn't lack employment solely based on personality.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

My concern is there is no mention of <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=Batting+Average" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('Batting Average'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">Batting Average</span></a> and it's relation to <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=OBP" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('OBP'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">OBP</span></a>. When analyzing pre and post-Moneyball trends you would need to isolate BA from OBP to tell which one teams were really paying for.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

No one has been dead set on trading Miller. He's returned <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=57396">Jason Heyward</a></span> to a Cardinals team that had young arms to spare, and a ridiculous package being lampooned for its lopsidedness to the rebuilding Braves. He's fetched quite a bit of value and pitched just fine for a kid three years away from free agency. No one is passing on Miller, they're just turning him in for other things, almost as if he's an asset. I think this happens with young players from time to time.

Dec 10, 2015 11:53 AM on The Shelby Shocker
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

This probably doesn't really need to be said, but I'll say it anyway: the games in April and May count exactly as much in the standings as the games played on the last week of the season.

Nov 24, 2015 6:53 AM on Overlooking Trout
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I think think what fawcetb meant to write is that "sometimes you should also talk to your model." I'm not sure that would have any effect, but I'm not against it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Any guesses what Votto says as he's watching Iglesias shift back to normal position? It appears to me he's saying "that's right," or "that's fine."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

The only winning move is not to play.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

I love these GM in a Box write ups. Great stuff.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Actually, the low bird has been holding down that end of the bat just waiting to jump off and watch the other end crash to the ground. The low bird has all the leverage.

Aug 22, 2015 9:48 AM on August 21, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I had mistakenly requested Ryan to do one of these on Goldy last year not realizing he doesn't take requests. Here is the .gif I made that I really, really like. The motion of this swing is beautiful. http://gfycat.com/GraciousShockedDutchsmoushond

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Thanks for doing this Ryan. I've been waiting for you to get around to Goldschmidt for a while.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Have you developed a stand up routine yet, Matthew?

Aug 17, 2015 11:53 AM on August 17, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I really enjoyed this, love the format.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Awesome Office Space reference!

Aug 12, 2015 12:37 PM on August 12, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I definitely noticed that every one of those throws (save the ones into second) were up the line.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Are there any rules that prevent me from starting a franchise from players I buy on Amazon? I have Amazon Unlimited, so I think I could put together a winner in less than a week. Plus, free audio books!

Jul 22, 2015 3:56 PM on July 22, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Not family friendly, but Hair of the Dog by Nazareth, or for times when the strike zone has been treated unfairly Eyesight to the Blind by Sonny Boy Williamson (II).

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I could've sworn we did this here before, but I may be misremembering. My top choice for closer song: Blind by Korn. Best start to any debut album ever. "Are you ready!" Second would have to be For Whom the Bell Tolls by Metallica. Because Cliff Burton, and also people would think it was Hell's Bells until...Cliff Burton. I'd have to give an honorable mention to Run to the Hills by Iron Maiden.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

The Texas Rangers comment...isn't it about time somebody said that?

Jul 06, 2015 3:59 PM on July 6, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Alex Gordon was drafted as a third baseman.

Jul 06, 2015 3:57 PM on July 6, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Alex Gordon was drafted as a third baseman.

Jul 06, 2015 3:57 PM on July 6, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

All I can say to that is that it's pretty obvious whoever is pulling the strings doesn't know what they're doing. A joke that got posted yesterday: "I heard today the Dodgers tried to hack into the DBacks computers but found nothing there."

Jun 24, 2015 9:18 PM on Hot Takes on Touki
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I can supply the why not from the perspective of the AZ fanbase (such that it is these days). Because this isn't the first time, not even after the first time that this organization has done something like this. It is the way they do business. I'm not trying to represent how the entire fan base feels (such that it is these days), just what gets expressed on a daily basis among the more "dedicated."

Jun 24, 2015 1:54 PM on Hot Takes on Touki
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Post hoc ergo propter hoc

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Okay, no more compliments for Sussman anymore.

Jun 19, 2015 5:15 PM on June 17, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Obviously it was enough to matter, hence this piece. Every team may have faced all the same other teams, but did every pitcher face all the same hitters? That's what this is getting at. Whether or not that's enough to matter is something that can be debated, but not simply dimissed out of hand.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

All of my reply didn't make it somehow, but it really doesn't matter too much. Unless every division in baseball was uniformly strong, how could the division he pitched in be irrelevant? Saying the division he pitched in, the batters he faced, has nothing to do with the strength of his oppostion makes absolutely no sense. There must be some misunderstanding.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

All of his games and opponents are relevant. If you want to make a claim about the quality of oppostion (just league average) that is one thing, but to claim that is irrevelvant is just weird.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

A lot of people didn't seem very happy with Bauer's "eccentricities."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

This was timely, as I was just thinking about that quote...if it was true, why have so many teams been hiring analysts from the outside? Teams have been raiding the Hell out of the BP staff just over the last two years alone, and we are to believe they are that far ahead? Are they just poaching talent because they don't know what to do with the data they have? I understand they have data we don't, but I'm not buying a gap that large. There very well might be, and maybe the gap has been widening (due to the talent poaching), but it wasn't all that long ago that front offices didn't have much of an idea about this stuff and didn't pay much attention even to the people they brought in to explore it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

If by chance you had read my comment on the previous Hit List and took that as incentive to surpass Mr. Kory's efforts, then congratulations are in order. You almost did it! (Seriously, though, well done)

Jun 17, 2015 10:20 PM on June 17, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Kory, you absolutely killed it today. It was one louder.

Jun 15, 2015 1:52 PM on June 15, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"Which isn't to say it's surprising that they're good, or that their performance is fluky and unsustainable, or anything. It's just that this historic level of success doesn't match up with their talent or their performance." Doesn't that make it sort of fluky and unsustainable?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I think you guys out to combine some of these into a Super Two series, or at least tag them as Super Two. I'm sure many of us here understand it fairly well, but it could definitely stand alone as a primer for those that don't. Or how about a roster manipulation tag? There's this and Rule 5, waiver wire, the various 40 man roster rules. This is real world stuff. I'm a little chagrined that no one has commented on either of the articles today that tackle this subject.

Jun 12, 2015 3:38 PM on Super Boo
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Might as well do that for every team. They're all much hated by someone.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It does, just not in the official MLB standings. It's like Mitch Hedberg's joke about hotels not having 13th floors: "people on the fourteenth floor, you know what floor you're really on."

Jun 08, 2015 1:06 PM on June 8, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Good looking out, Josh. Sounds like the kid could have ended up in a world of crap without your help Sounds pretty stressful.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Two Wrongs don't make a Wright. (I had to do it)

Jun 05, 2015 5:36 PM on June 5, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

That picture of the seal statue reminded me of this, as it almost always would: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pb5U8C8rALk

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I thought I would save that for an article that had something to do with <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/card/card.php?id=7">Craig Biggio</a></span>.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

That's awfully fine-grained. It could probably be done, but I'm not sure either that it's worth it or would even be accurate enough to be usable.

Jun 04, 2015 2:19 PM on The Credit Card Game
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

They've been good.

Jun 04, 2015 4:00 AM on June 3, 2015
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You guys forgot to mention the body armor Bonds was permitted to wear that allowed him to eclipse the inner third of the plate.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

C'mon, man, that's not awful at all...it's far worse than that.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm a bit remiss to bring up this possibility, but could it be that he doesn't have the grip he needs for his secondaries because maybe he isn't "using" grip enhancements? I'm not trying to stir anything up here, but...maybe he's pitching naked.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

Maybe the pitcher and catcher should just use headsets.

May 28, 2015 7:36 AM on Stealing Signs
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

In 1916 Ferdinand Cole Lane wrote that batting average was "worse than worthless." To support this view he collected data to determine what percentage of a run each hit type was responsible for. His results are pretty similar to the weights you'll see in something like wOBA.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Bill James is undebiably a very important figure in sabermetrics, but this statement completely ignores the contributions of others like <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=FC" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('FC'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">FC</span></a> Lane, George Lindsey, and Earnshaw Cook. Lane looked at 1000 hits of different types and assigned what percentage of a run each was responsible way back in 1916 (in an effort to displace batting average.) George Lindsey devised the blueprint for win expectancy and linear weights in the early 1960s, even before Cook wrote his book Percetage Baseball. Bill James benefits from being a very engaging writer and is a true heavyweight in the field, but by no means was he the first to start "cribbing the numbers."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Great stuff, Ryan. I love these articles. Since I'm not so sure huztlers is going to give you an answer, I like Goldschmidt's swing a lot. I can't see anything wrong with it, but I'm learning the finer points through these articles. Can't wait for the next one.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Almost forgot...love the Mitch Hedberg quote. One of my favorite comedians. "Fruit on bottom, hope on top."

May 21, 2015 3:24 PM on An Offer
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

If all around encompasses the totality of their offense and defense, and you are sure that Harper will be the better offensive player, how can you be so sure? Trout has already lost some of his basestealing value and given what we know about what we don't know about defense...

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

If you see the pic, mouseover it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Not a link, just an embedded animation. Are you on a tablet or phone, by chance?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Yeah, this reminds me of one of those YouTube "you think you know" series.

May 21, 2015 10:41 AM on An Offer
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Oh, I agree. It should be great fun watching the two of them for the next ten years. I'm excited just to see how crazy-insane Harper's going to get during the run of this season.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I had an idea about how to find a lesser known player: look through the comps/similar players here and at B-R. Just pick some player from today or the recent past or whatever and see who pops up in the lists. Then maybe pick one of those and look through his comps.

May 21, 2015 8:55 AM on An Offer
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Happy birthday, Josh. That's a great idea there. Really highlights the romanticism baseball engenders better than other sports.

May 21, 2015 8:34 AM on An Offer
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

What are the chances Harper ends up being better than Trout for the next six or so years?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I've been saying the same thing for years now. Maybe we'll see it happen someday.

May 19, 2015 10:14 AM on Rickey Henderson's OBP
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Good times.

May 18, 2015 12:18 PM on Marlins Do Odd Thing
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 5

That's what I like about the Phillies; I keep getting older, they...keep getting older, too.

May 15, 2015 8:56 AM on Friday, May 15
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Players (both sides) are allowed to ask for an appeal to either the first base or third base umpire. Why doesn't that happen in this case?

May 14, 2015 10:23 AM on Thwarted!
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Guys, it's number two...I mean the second comment.

May 09, 2015 9:06 AM on Friday, May 8
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

This is all anecdotal and speculative. How do you know what most players would say?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Given how much turnover there has been, top to bottom, I would find it hard to characterize BP as having an organizational stance on PEDs. It's a pretty widespread stance throughout the sabermetric community that it just isn't knowable how much PEDs affect performance. It's not a denial outright, it's just that...what do you want? How much of a debit should be applied to known PED users? If you really want to read hot-take hyperbole about the issue, there are many, many sources for that kind of stuff. Here we just basically go for baseball analysis that makes as much sense as it can. It would be every bit the turnoff for me if every other article had to mention PEDs. What do you want us to do about it? Maybe someone should start their own website...BPeds

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Off-roadin' with Russell. Count me in.

May 07, 2015 11:44 AM on Chemical Equations
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Wow, I don't think I can add anything to the above comments about how amazing this story is, but I will say that this story needs sharing. Everyone should read this.

May 07, 2015 10:41 AM on The Will to #Want
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Man, you got me good on that one, Sam.

May 07, 2015 10:24 AM on Thrice Harper!
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I remember that Zimmerman piece, and it had some problems with survival bias. I no longer have the code or the file, but I ran the numbers selecting for players that lasted at least 10 big league seasons and found nothing substantially different about player aging. It seems likely that there is a pretty good sized crowd of 23-25 year olds that get their shot and flame out before there is any aging curve for them to have.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I had to double check, but I was right...those Donruss cards that year were the ugliest baseball cards I had ever seen. Fortunately Upper Deck debuted the next year.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

All day? Oh boy, have I got a stockpile of GIFs I'd like to send you. This is where this comment was meant to go...and while I'm here, let me say I always enjoy the absolute Hell out of your articles. I probably spend far too much time staring at the GIFs over and over again. Addicting.

Apr 17, 2015 1:55 PM on How Bryant Can Crush
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

All day? Oh boy, have I got a stockpile of GIFs I'd like to send you.

Apr 17, 2015 1:51 PM on How Bryant Can Crush
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

During the season, outside of things like contract negotiations and roster moves (things you can't talk about), do clients often drop you a line to tell you how they're doing, how their season is coming, if they think they're about to go on a roll?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 5

I'll keep my fingers crossed for your checkup, Joshua.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Two things: 1) You state that Maddon "does this to show...that he is smarter than other managers" with no evidence. How do you know that Maddon does it for this reason and not because he genuinely believes he may be able to get some advantage from it? 2) The shaming of the #9 hitter. Assuming he would otherwise be batting 8th, how much shaming is there really to be done? It's not like he's getting bumped from the third spot in the order. I'm sure a tactful manager would explain to his batter that he's hitting him 8th because he feels it gives the team a better chance to win. That's a positive thing, not a personal slight. Again, we're talking about a guy that would be normally hitting 8th anyway, so how much better or worse is that bitter going to get?

Apr 15, 2015 12:18 AM on Hit the Pitcher Eighth?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

What if you're a fan of one of the other 27 teams? It's going to be a long slap in the face for those fans. BP Cleveland ain't happening...that's not where the money is.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I got a good laugh out of that one, Matt.

Apr 07, 2015 4:40 PM on Don't Trade Tulo
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

How'd you enjoy Arizona, Mauricio?

Apr 02, 2015 9:09 AM on Last Looks From Arizona
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

"the best laid schemes of mice and Ben often go awry." I like that.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Might the difference be throwing a breaking ball and throwing a breaking ball for strikes?

Mar 31, 2015 10:59 AM on All Spin Is Not Alike
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

See what I mean?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 9

Ken, either you don't write enough, or I don't read what you write enough. I dig your style my man.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

All the same, Bryant is at the age where he either is or he isn't. I don't think it's likely that any more seasoning will make a difference in his future role, and in fact might be counter-productive. He has to hit at the highest level, or he isn't.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I checked, too, and noticed that it doesn't have regular baseball stuff, so I realized, hey, Rob is going to be the regular baseball writer. They couldn't have made a better choice.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

A better way of stating the basic Occam's razor is that between explanations that are equally satisfying, the one that requires the fewest assumptions is preferable.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

If I could vote for this one twice, I would.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I'll definitely be checking it out.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

"I know from having made an attempt[1] to collect bat cracks that manual data collection is a painstaking, error-prone, and difficult process." This is very true. It's especially disheartening when you spend a couple of hours on processing a few dozen audio files and lose your place :( Congrats, Robert. We will miss having a regularly scheduled <a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/column/moonshot/">Moonshot</a> to read. Best wishes.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I didn't read the basketball study yet, so I wonder if one might be able to draw the conclusion that teams performing measurably better touch each other more often, rather than the other way around.

Mar 25, 2015 9:43 AM on On the High Five
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Venn diagrams of regrets?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

Sam, thank you, and very well said. Indeed, Matt has a sickness and we should deal with the problem through treatment and not punishment.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

This will never make sense to posterity.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I see what you are doing, though. Maybe need some regex help?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Hmm, weird. <span class="bookdef"><a href="http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0393324818/baseballpro07-20/ref=nosim/" target="blank">Moneyball</a></span>.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Can't wait to see the Every Teams' <span class="bookdef"><a href="http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0393324818/baseballpro07-20/ref=nosim/" target="blank">Moneyball</a></span> Marlins edition.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

"OH! and bring your prospectus handbook to the game. I think I might have convinced my entire row to buy it for next year. The thing sells itself." I did this once. I found it very hard getting it back. So maybe buy two copies and take one with you.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It's possible to sanitize HTML.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Here might be a good place to look for destinations (complete with reviews from site members): http://www.beeradvocate.com/place/list/?city=Mesa&c_id=US&s_id=AZ

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I don't know about there not being a go-to beer here...Sierra Nevada's Pale Ale and Torpedo are pretty much everywhere; you can pick up a sixer in a 7-11 or Circle K for $8.99 if you're in a hurry. Total Wine and BevMo both have locations at Tempe Marketplace, which is just two miles down the road from Mesa Riverview and not at all far from Talking Stick. Four Peaks Brewery is not far either, on McClintock and University...you can call ahead to find out what's on tap. If you like to get your shopping done early, Sprout's Farmer's Market opens at 7am, has a decent selection (and lets you build your own six pack), and is also nearby, on McClintock and Southern. If you wouldn't mind giving some of the local small craft stores some love, there is Sun Devil Liquors that has a nice selection and a cellar pub located on Country Club Dr and University. DJ's liquor is a small place that also sells tobacco and accessories and also has a full humidor if you like cigars. It is located on Dobson and Southern, just three miles south of Mesa Riverview. Ask for Jeff...he knows just about everything about both cigars and beer.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

There was once a saying: the best way to develop a major league pitcher is to start with five minor league pitchers. Works for staffs, too.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It's likely that being on the lists three or more years means you are young, highly regarded, and haven't done anything real enough yet. Probably lots of international 16 year olds in that area. You are right about the guys who come off the list due to promotion. That's why it's the sweet spot. Interestingly, this won't cover the out-of-nowhere guys like Pujols who are drafted in the later rounds and rocket through the system without making much of an appearance on lists. That's fairly rare, though...right?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Hamilton has been through the program (yes, that one). Hamilton self-reported his latest relapse. He's taken steps before, and by this action would almost certainly be prepared to take further steps (although that is just speculation on my part). The thing is, this is what happens with addicts. It's beyond hard work. There is this notion that "if they would just try hard enough!" That's not how it works...it's a lifetime of struggle. Not to say he shouldn't face any consequences, but I think the problem needs to be understood.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

You would think death is the most powerful deterrent, yet that doesn't make any difference to many addicts.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

It's mysterious? Maybe there should be a name for like "the Coors Effect" or something.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

This isn't a bad idea. I think it could be effectively implemented throughout baseball with an agreement between the MLBPA and MLB so it can cover the minor leagues. There's even a good way to sell it: career help. Just another piece of the development cycle.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Every time I read one of your articles, Josh, it reminds me that there are so many good guys out there with a dream to play baseball and that we should be rooting for all of them.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I'm not sure there is "teetering on the edge of addiction." There probably isn't a window within which it can be said "if you don't stop right now, you will become an addict." For some people the very first use could mean addiction. It's different from person to person. As far as having an effect on future addicts by how one person's case is handled...addiction is very powerful, and addicts only listen to their addiction. Many times it comes down to life or death before an addict will listen to reason. This is a massive topic with many angles. Hamilton, like any case taken singularly, has his own specific set of circumstances.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I had the same thought...that Hamilton might not survive very long if he were to leave baseball and the distraction it provides. I don't know if Hamilton is truly aware of it or not, but he is an addict for life and will always be in recovery. It sounds depressing, and it certainly can be, but people can learn to live with that.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Wrong song.

Mar 09, 2015 6:24 PM on BP's New Owners
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

It might just be that what this is really showing is the elusive clubhouse chemistry. So it would be the manager, the coaches, the players, the general manager, maybe even the owner.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

That shines through in every article and comment you provide here. Thank you.

Feb 17, 2015 3:49 PM on The Joy of the Trade
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

A number of things spring to mind thinking about this, which is too many to go through now, but: Might there be cause for concern about pitcher injuries from rushing pitches? What is the hitter's role in this? Does everybody have to be ready at the same time? I honestly think a pitch clock should be implemented (if at all) in the minors only and, over time, I would be willing to bet that by the time the kids get to the bigs they are already conditioned to play faster.

Feb 17, 2015 2:59 PM on The Clock is Ticking...
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

"Nobody has done this outside the world of video games" Steve Nebraska did it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I would hope that everyone realizes that it's just math. You can criticize the results, and therefore the math, but it's not personal. It's just math.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 9

How unlikely is it that the supermodel is also the village idiot? I don't think the two are exclusive.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Three inches is kinda a lot, I think. I'm not sure what three inches inside the zone would mean.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

How about like: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6_dTvCPD-LDRlZaaVVuQnFPbU0/view?usp=sharing

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm not so sure about that. I wouldn't think umpires are paying all that much attention to this kind of research or are being told to be aware of it. I'd like to think they will continue to "call 'em like I see 'em." If they ever did..."see 'em", that is. The secret to catcher framing may well be Umpire Whispering. We know umpires are blind, right?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Oh, does this bring back 12 year old me memories. On the All Star team they had me play SS full time, claiming they didn't have anyone else that could do it well enough, so I wasn't allowed to pitch...until they needed me for an emergency in an elimination game. Catcher had never caught me before, I hadn't pitched in two weeks, and said catcher had an annoying habit of opening his glove at the last moment to receive the pitch (which kept bouncing off the front of his glove). I was throwing gas straight down the middle and couldn't get a single called strike. Stupid catcher, you owe me ice cream.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -3

Whoever you are POS, I am going to figure out who you are and I don't care why you follow me around and down vote all my comments. I don't really care about the comment ratings but you obviously want my attention, and you've got it. Congratulations. You may not like how this turns out.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Actually it is every bit as easy using the the R GUI that comes with the base installation. It's the exact same command. I do highly recommend R Studio.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Any ideas of introducing a comparable players approach into this?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Well played.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Kendall, who did the face swap on that image?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I concur.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

What haiku, you ask? Was at end of the column Baseball Prospectus.

Jan 05, 2015 12:25 PM on Catchers
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Honestly, I'm touched by this. As much as you enjoy the readership, I must say we enjoy you that much more. Here's wishing you a smooth recovery and looking forward to your next column.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 10

Yeah, well, that's just, like, you're opinion, man.

Jan 01, 2015 1:14 PM on The 2015 Results
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I don't think there is any need to keep going over this, which is why I think we don't keep going over it.

Dec 31, 2014 2:12 PM on The 2015 Results
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Well, I have always had a surly relationship with the media, but it's good you can overlook that.

Dec 31, 2014 2:03 PM on The 2015 Results
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Sussman voted for everyone. I'd feel very good about my chances of getting into the Hall if everyone voted like Matt.

Dec 31, 2014 7:49 AM on The 2015 Results
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Cool #Gory, bro.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Actually, smart teams with four great hitters ought to be in the market for platoon partners and insurance pieces to supplement the talent on it's way up from the farm. Or that's maybe another way to go.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

"Whoa, let's not start a holy war, here."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

"Jesus, I like him very much, but he no help with curveball."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Yeah, I interpreted it as "might be his Rookie of the Year self."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

" relaxed in an offseason hibernation that dates back several color schemes" I LOL'd.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

And there is your problem. There may be large variation among the exclusive group of people that are allowed to work in prominent positions for baseball front offices, but that is just accounting for the variation within that limited group. I understand the difficulty in measuring things that don't exist, but it should be easy to admit the possibility that the very best are the elite of a mediocre group. I'm not saying that is definitely the case, but it has to be considered. I mean, you've selected out an entire subset on the same principle that makes inclusion in the "fraternity" nearly impossible to attain, namely the nebulous property of being "qualified."

Dec 17, 2014 12:45 PM on It's Happening!
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Oh, Bill James...okay, you win. I forgot that Bill James has never been full of sh*t before.

Dec 17, 2014 12:03 PM on It's Happening!
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You're missing something here...clubs already have many bright young interns that they pay virtually nothing for, and they may have brilliant ideas that go completely ignored. They don't necessarily need to expand front offices but perhaps simply listen to the ideas from the people that are working for virtually free. Then pay those guys some money. What's happening right now is really just overpaying for name-recognition hires. The market inefficiency right now would be to hire the smartest baseball-savvy nerd that no one has ever heard of for next to nothing. So I guess the evolution is that it becomes like player development in that you let the expensive guys go when you have young talent waiting in the wings to take their place.

Dec 16, 2014 3:09 PM on It's Happening!
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

" Even Bo and Deion were no more than decent MLB talents." Dude, there is nothing about that sentence that fits in comfortably with reality. And you began the post "With regard to baseball players." If that's what you're citing as evidence, you don't really have any, either.

Dec 16, 2014 11:24 AM on It's Happening!
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I've always wanted an authentic batting helmet, and it would be even better if it actually fit (which isn't likely). Bats, balls, gloves, and jerseys are all awesome, but there is just something about a nice shiny batting helmet with your team logo on it. Sadly, no one in my family reads this site.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"I'm not sure why we should expect the distribution of outcomes like OPS to be Gaussian." We don't, because they're not. "Skill might have a normal distribution," Not at the professional level. You make the right observation with outcome probabilities. Namely, what is the probability of something happening that shouldn't have. I like your dice example since it reminds me of Strat-O-Matic. It IS a very complex subject.

Dec 04, 2014 12:38 PM on The Power of Projections
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Awesome. Appreciate it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

There's an idea...all time wrong name teams. Imagine if instead of Mookie Wilson they had Hack Wilson. Or if instead of Mike Stanton they had Mike Stanton, or Mike Stanton as in Giancarlo Stanton.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I'd be happy for you to send me the data, if you're offering.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I think that is just really an intuitive thing to say. Of course a guy that pumps out the same kind of season year after year is easy(ish) to predict. The problem is: is it possible to identify that player beforehand? I hope we can find something to go on in that regard.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Did you find any commonality among the missed breakouts? Are they of similar ages, experience, batted ball profile, that kind of thing, or does it appear to be randomly distributed?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I think what is being overlooked here regarding Donaldson is that players that break in during their mid-twenties and breakout at 26-27 don't have a good track record for being very useful beyond the very brief peak (I'm currently thinking of Chris Duncan). It's more of a gamble to hang on to a guy like that than to get whatever you can for him. Robert did a survival study not long ago demonstrating the likelihood of career lengths based on debut age. I find this to be a very reasonable course of action.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Oops, my bad. Good news for Puig, though.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -3

That is what it was called, and it was brilliant. It wasn't even a movie, it was a documentary. Sam can go spit.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I don't recall reading anywhere anyone speaking or writing about Tomas being a slam dunk. In fact, the talk around the D'backs internet watercooler is that he simply makes Trumbo redundant, in that he is just a younger version of the same...upside. I haven't read anyone going ball's out for the guy. As for not many guys getting better after 24...have you looked at aging patterns? Granted, there isn't much evidence to examine regarding Cuban imports, but youngish baseball players are youngish baseball players from wherever they are. Tomas doesn't really fit in the Cespedes, Puig, Abreu as he's younger than all of them as he enters the league. And he also has time to get some coaching at that younger age. As for the Red Sox and Yankees, Boston already went on their spending spree, and the Yankees are doing something else right now, so that is basically a not relevant. I don't think a move like this would make any sense for either of them at this point. Other GMs were vying for his services, however.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Are you meaning to say that Tomas is never going to progress beyond .230? You seem to be hinting that Tomas would be better off learning to hit Major League pitching by playing a few more years in Cuba, which I don't think is grounded in logic. We're not looking at a Wily Mo Pena type situation, here.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You are quite right. It is actually a movie about the vices and virtues of wealth and greed and what true friends are. And it's a hard movie to hate, because, John Candy.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

He signals his retirement before the game is even finished, so that line of thought is never expounded upon. For all we know he may have allowed the trade or vetoed the trade, but it never gets to that point.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Actually, I think this could be a neat toy statistic...salary translations. True earnings in present dollars. I'm sure there's an acronym in there somewhere.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

In the Ted Williams section you write: "So Williams, who debuted the same year as Aaron..." which might confuse some people.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

It's delightful the way the humanity shines through in your articles, Joshua. Very enjoyable.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I believe you didn't actually mean to be disrespectful. I also believe you won't forget again.

Nov 18, 2014 8:10 AM on Heyward Movement
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 6

From White Men Can't Jump: "Sometimes when you win, you really lose, and sometimes when you lose, you really win, and sometimes when you win or lose, you actually tie, and sometimes when you tie, you actually win or lose. Winning or losing is all one organic mechanism, from which one extracts what one needs."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

You must be a very hard person to shop for. The kid has a career line of .305/.395/.545 line through age 22 (three full seasons), 98 HRs, 102 SBs, two second place MVP finishes, one 10 win season and two nine win seasons. It's not fawning, it's recognition.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

That's a bingo!

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Just about anytime Mike Trout's name comes up I can't help but think of this player comment from one of the BP annuals (paraphrased here): "Very few players burst on the majors as fully-formed Hall of Famers...it was clear almost right away what kind of player he was, which is why so many people expressed disbelief: They were seeing a player who, if he never grew, if he never peaked, if he just stayed right where he was, was going to be an annual MVP candidate." The reader can probably guess which player the comment is about.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

What a wonderful, strange comment.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I began the process months ago. He makes no little plans.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

One of the things I had wondered about managers is if there is a measurable effect of them getting ejected. I've seen some managers that seemed so passive, almost never coming out of the dugout to argue, that I wondered if that might make a difference in his players in some way. What I'm getting at is if a managers willingness to get run from a game defending his players to the umps might engender some level of trust that bonds the players with their manager.

Nov 04, 2014 11:58 AM on Why Joe Maddon Matters
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Best wishes to the families.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

But you can't trade anything for a guaranteed World Series victory, so it's a false choice. Even so, the Royals even being in this position is good enough, regardless of the results going forward. Hopefully. For them.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Alright, we have some jerk going around and voting down replies for no discernible reason. We have a troll that's invisitrolling. Maybe there should be no more voting on replies. I don't personally care, but this troll/person somehow does.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Maybe they will be if this isn't a one-year thing. What happens if the Royals win 80 games next year? I don't see the Royals running off a dynastic streak...this feels quite random. No hater.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I see above comments from a violinist and a pianist. As a brass player, I can say there is a huge difference. Cottonmouth and nervous breathing will wreck a performance for a wind player (just ask one if you don't believe this one). So there are differing coping mechanisms, and differing levels of competence at coping with those mechanisms, or even knowing what they are if they may be ambiguous. But, when you have reached a certain level, everyone knows what to do...some better than others.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Nicely spotted! That makes sense being that Anchor Steam is brewed in San Francisco.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Robert, I'm jealous of the red circle around the data point. I hadn't thought of that, and it honestly took me a good few seconds to figure it. Always a step ahead are you.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

It could be that the lower strike zone has trained hitters in such a way that, over the course of the season, they are left unprepared for the high fastball. So maybe it is that with the hitters eyes trained down, pitchers have found that elevating a hard fastball can raise the hitters' eyes in a way that they will swing at balls that they can't catch up with simply because they are finally seeing a ball up, however high up is. "Up" being relative, which is the vulnerability.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You know, if you tightened that up it would make a nifty haiku.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Honestly, I'm surprised you guys put this much effort into this while the postseason is in full swing. And I don't think Rob would need to rewrite any queries. I would be able to tell right away if I saw the dataset. If there's any kind of date or pitch ID associated that would be all that's needed, really (I think). You might see if Rob Arthur wants to lend a hand...but yeah, on the side burner. Let's enjoy what's left of the season.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Why would someone downvote this? All I pointed out was that the hard part is composing a dataset, and after that manipulating it is relatively easy.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Well, you did begin with "this is a very complex topic." And it is. Even with perfect data it would be hard to know "did he really mean to throw that...there...now?" Which leads me to wondering if it would ever be possible to determine when the pitcher and catcher got crossed up.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Wait, there is no bad beat jackpot?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

At the point you have the dataset (assuming the year is one of the variables) the rest is (relatively) easy. The really hard part is the sanity check.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

We avoid this by making it its own single word "flyout." Baseball is it's own language.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I use poker analogies a lot, but only because they make sense. This reminds me of exactly how you must feel about that great hand that got beat, or that hand you folded that would've dragged a huge pot had you just called that ridiculously large raise. But you can't let those hands affect future hands...you have to let it go. If it was a mistake you made, you learn from it, but if it was just bad luck, you forget it or you'll just play your way into more bad luck. You have to have a short memory and a long memory. I can imagine that there are quite a few people that get into the agent business chasing that one big hand and go bust, not realizing that it's a grind.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Either I misunderstood this post, or you just wrote: "Anyway, as I said there is no particular reason to change an approach with runners in scoring position." And then reeled off a list of particular reasons why a pitcher might do just that.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

This season, Mariners/Astros, more than 16 pitches below the strike zone called strikes, Mark Carlson...got it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Actually, come to think of it, about four years ago I got a hold of a man-sized wiffle ball bat and started hitting wiffle fungoes in the backyard. Had to start buying wiffle balls in bulk because I kept smashing them to bits. It was quite fun and harmless to all but the wiffle balls. And they actually do give you some feedback on the contact you're making.

Oct 10, 2014 5:08 PM on Cage Work
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Do it, you'll thank yourself.

Oct 10, 2014 4:49 PM on Cage Work
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You can't take a conversation between a Cubs fan and a Cards fan in that regard seriously. We're born to take the piss out of each other.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

All things are particularly unreliable in the postseason, even regression.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"It’s an established fact that human hips are awesome." Yes a thousand times. Power comes from using the hips properly.

Oct 10, 2014 12:21 PM on Cage Work
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Wow, Ryan, this was great.

Oct 10, 2014 9:27 AM on Cage Work
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

I was fortunate enough to watch nearly all of Johnson's starts while he pitched in Arizona. It was a joy to watch him snap off that devastating slider, and quite fun on the occasions that a right handed hitter swung through the slider and got hit on the back foot with it. Good memories.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Where did you find that YouTube video?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

They certainly see it play out in real time, but you have to understand what that means. In real time, it doesn't look anything like what you see when you look backwards. It's like slowly watching your poker chips dwindle in front of you. You're only a little bit down from the previous time you were a little bit down. Is it a trend? Are you on tilt? Is it just random variation? They seem to have rebounded from it rather well after the big drop. But one thing you can always be certain of; when an opponent sees a weakness, they will attack it until it stops being one. It's like when you know an opponent is playing any two cards, you shove chips in his face while you've got the best of it until he finally stops or runs out of money.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

There's an R package that you could use more effectively. http://www.r-bloggers.com/search/twitter

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Sorry, I meant LOL Twitter. I'll have to update the meme.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Don't you wish you'd have your turn one day? ;-)

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

That's considerably less than those that know what pavement is.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -3

LOL internet.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Let me try this another way. Wouldn't it have been a more famous gaffe had Baker started Russ Ortiz in game six of the 2012 World Series when Russ Ortiz was out of baseball and Baker wasn't managing the Giants?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 5

It's annoying, but I would dare say that for the "normal" Cardinals fan, we don't care. Like you say, winning. I never felt comfortable with the labels (before "best fans in baseball" it was "most knowledgeable fans in baseball"), and this is exactly why. Oh well, let them have their fun.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Russ Ortiz must be wondering where his 2012 game checks are...his postseason money, as well.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

As do the Angels.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

The Angels are reading this and thinking what a jerk you are. The Angles care very much, Robert.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

"Grew up more than any player in baseball last year. Beckett's maturation started after A.J. Burnett had to undergo Tommy John surgery. Beckett, who'd been hiding elbow stiffness for three weeks, wisely told the Marlins he may need to sit a while. While on the DL, Dontrelle Willis mania took hold. Once considered the phenom, Beckett watched Willis get all the accolades, and he wasn't happy about it. After the All-Star break, he caught fire, putting up a 2.55 era and striking out 93 in 88.1 second-half innings. Called on to relieve Mark Redmond in game 7 of the NLCS, Beckett's four innings of one-hit ball pushed the Fish into the World Series. When Jack McKeon tapped him to pitch game 6 of the World Series at Yankee Stadium on three days rest, the debate raged over whether he'd succeed, or if his young arm could even take the burden. Beckett threw gas by Yankee hitters all night, throwing a five-hit shutout to win the World Series and a shoulder ride around the mound by delirious teammates. With Torborg's butcherly inclinations gone and Beckett's blister problems apparently behind him, and with a wiser head on his shoulders, the Marlins just have to hope the added load on October has no long-term effect on Beckett's golden right arm. If it doesn't, the sky's the limit."

Oct 08, 2014 11:12 AM on So Long, Josh Beckett
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

2004 seems to be missing for everybody. Guess you'll have to buy the book.

Oct 08, 2014 10:24 AM on So Long, Josh Beckett
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It wouldn't occur at the same time. The A's don't face all the teams at the same time. Advance scouts would be seeing what previous advance scouts were seeing, until something changed. Therefore it wouldn't be simultaneous...scouts noticing that the A's are flailing would notice it in succession.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"getting into specific types can be troublesome without better data." Yes. The pitch types come with confidence %. It's an algorithm that ultimately determines the pitch type, amirite?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I was also thinking pitches seen per plate appearance.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Or advance scouts catching onto something.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I asked my Mexican coworker about this (and Mexican as in immigrant, so actually Mexican.) She says "Mehico no ha' no sandwishes." This is a true story.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Does that mean he might accept an NRI?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

According to Eddie Izzard's "Holy Biblee" (we may change the pronunciation on that), the Meek inherent nothing. Perhaps on old picture of an aunt.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Eddy's in the space-time continuum.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I hope you're starting to see the problem here. You've gotten yourself so wrapped up in sandwich expansion that you don't even know what to think. You are teetering on accepting anything as a sandwich. You must gather yourself, man. The evildoers will stop at nothing.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You went overboard with the butter sandwich. Next thing you know we have an air sandwich.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

The line is a dot to you.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Is this your way of saying you'd vote for Yasiel Puig?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

If you keep making these implications people are going to think I'm the one with the dirty mind.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"I am with Dave (literally as I am also in Pittsburgh)" You mean figuratively?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I ran "Chicago Italian Beef" through my sandwich database and got no results. Interestingly, I did get a result for Justin Verlander; his favorite sandwich is "NA."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I'm proclaiming ramen noodle soup as the world's best spaghetti, and also a sandwich. Do I need to take pictures and make menus and billboards or can I just get away with saying it?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I refuse to concede. These are just mind tricks.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

How many logical fallicies did you plan on using in the construction of that post?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Honestly, this is my favorite comment in this thread. I think I'm about 50/50 with Rocco on this topic, but if I could just get him to understand the morality of the issue... :-)

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

So what I mean to say is that the incompetence is that a hot dog isn't a sandwich. If it somehow becomes a sandwich, your dry cleaning bill goes up.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

That's the most appealing point of a sandwich...you needn't worry about about connective breading. You have mustard stains on your lap, don't you Craig?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

That's the most reasonable position I've seen you take yet. Plus, pizzas are trying to be "pies," apparently. Why do some many things want to be sandwiches? Just be yourself, hotdog/pizza/quesadilla (really?).

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I vote yes to all of these things.

Sep 26, 2014 2:45 PM on Friday, September 26
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"Weiners in buns only, no condiments."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm going to upvote you because some unfeeling sob downvoted you, but keep this in mind: Once you start down the Dark Side, forever will it dominate your destiny.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

A hot dog bun is not two other things, it is one thing...a bun. You are so behind the times.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I'm for 'em! Let's form a club!

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I just see him lifting his foot to start his stride, but the video may start after a toe tap.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Is this like a Big Hall/Small Hall kind of thing? If so, I'm with you.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

If you fold it so that the single piece breaks in to two pieces of bread, you got yourself a sandwich.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

I flew to close to the Sun on wings of pastrami.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Brown mustard, Kate. You can sneak it in to the park.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

If you cut the dogs in half lengthwise and place them between two pieces of bread, I say sandwich.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

To paraphrase a certain Supreme Court Justice, I know a sandwich when I see one.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

In this case I'm inclined to agree with Nightmare above. You can "sandwich" things in an imitation of a sandwich, but it's just an imitation, not a sandwich proper. We gotta draw the line somewhere.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I was afraid it would come to this. We have to be careful here. You can't just put "sandwich" in the name of something and gain entry into the world of legitimate sandwiches. We have to be rational here.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

If the hot dog bun was intended to enclose the weiner, it wouldn't split every time you tried to enclose it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 8

So you're saying it's a subcategory?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 8

When I was a kid we had a quicksand box. I was an only child...eventually.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

French fries? Okay, wait...bad quality french fries? Keep in mind that I'm a big-time-mega-super-huge potato guy, and I say go ahead.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Hoagies are served on rolls. Not sliced bread. No go.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Yeah. What's with the rabid Anti Ketch-ites? Next they'll be saying we should have our own schools!

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm a fify-fifty guy in optimal situations, but as ketchup quality decreases, mustard ratio increases. I think we're on the same page here. I can go ketchup-less but not all ketchup no mustard. Mustard is obligatory. In the golf course scenario (what golf courses are you playing?) I'd be inclined to ditch the bun and chow the dog solo. At the ballpark, condiments in packets only. I'm not dressing my chow from that disgusting open condiment bar.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I have to disagree. I sandwich goes on two or more slices of bread, not a bun, or even a bun cut in half. It has to be traditional bread, no buns. So, yes, I'm arguing against the hamburgers admission to the sandwich fraternity. Wanna hamburger sandwich? Make a patty melt.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Ahem, a club sandwich is classic sandwich. It is only cut into triangles for presentation and ease of consumption. I've been ordering club sandwiches for years and I'm not even a member. I don't know how I've been getting away with it. <-I hope someone gets that reference.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I'm on your side bro. I am not ashamed to admit my usage of ketchup in preparing my hot dogs (onions, too. Anybody got a problem with that?) To Hell with the Anti Ketch-ites. But, just out of curiosity, what if I use catsup?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Doesn't much matter if she's not even being considered, does it? I don't think she'd pass it up just because it's not her dream destination. It's a moot point, anyway.

Sep 25, 2014 2:59 PM on Buxton or Beane?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

There were quite a few of us here in Snakeland hoping that the org would go in that direction, but...you know, the Ol' Boys' Network. So apparently we get Dave Stewart. Cronies fly forever.

Sep 25, 2014 1:20 PM on Buxton or Beane?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

You're confusing "brain power" with A bright idea. Sure, some smart guys' bright idea will get copied, but if there truly is brain power behind it, there will be many more to come. The best will always stay ahead of the copycats.

Sep 25, 2014 9:24 AM on Buxton or Beane?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I was about to say.

Sep 25, 2014 8:50 AM on Buxton or Beane?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Hi, Jeff, thanks. I was going to qualify the question with "and don't say 'we don't know enough about him'." But I understand. At the same time, he has been in the game for a very long time, so we do know things about him. For reference, I'm a born StL Cardinals fan that lives in AZ and hangs out on a Dbacks forum. I share the skepticism towards La Russa (boy do I), however, I can't see him being a total disaster...maybe. I guess worst case is the Snakes end up with Paul Goldschmidt and a gaggle of super-utility players. The bar has been set pretty low in AZ.

Sep 25, 2014 7:56 AM on Buxton or Beane?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I agree. I think it dovetails nicely with the article a few days ago on what is the second hardest thing to do in baseball.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

Does the victim have to keep Amaro?

Sep 25, 2014 6:24 AM on Buxton or Beane?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Since you posed the question initially to two Diamondbacks fans, I wonder where you (or they) would rank Tony La Russa.

Sep 25, 2014 5:05 AM on Buxton or Beane?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

That's a fair point.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

For my two bits, I would agree that pitching is the second hardest. The whole pitcher v hitter thing is often the most chess-iest of chess-iness. And sometimes we can't really even tell who won.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

This reminds me of a rather good anecdote from my days working at one of the (many) AZ courses. We'd go out to pick the pins (we don't leave them out overnight...the greenies are going to recut the cups the next morning anyway, so they reset the pins) in the afternoon, and the late afternoon golfers would complain that we were taking the flags away. Response: "just aim for the center of the green, you'll score better that way." So there's some free advice. BTW, I share your hubris, just not as a rule.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I've wanted to address this one for awhile: "Pitching is quite difficult. It's also one of the most unnatural things we can do with our bodies" It's not, really. It's quite natural. So natural, in fact, that it precedes baseball. The unnatural part is doing it so frequently. Throwing something overhand as hard as you can? Sure. Doing it for a living? Weird.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Just to interject here from a golfer's perspective, you never (well...yeah, never) try to hole out from the fairway or the tee. Sometimes, oftentimes, you don't even aim directly at the hole. You almost always want to aim for a spot on the green that will leave you with a make-able putt. In many situations it can be downright disastrous to aim at the flag. So my point is, hitters try to go the other way and whatnot, golfers don't try hit it in the hole.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm sorry, but aren't projections based on "what they've done already?" Seriously. I may need to re-evaluate my entire stance on scientific inquiry.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

No, Schere, these men are nihilists, there's nothing to be afraid of.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

This is a very complicated case. You know, a lotta ins, lotta outs, lotta what-have-you's.

Sep 18, 2014 10:15 AM on The Plightin' Showalters
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

That random variation really tied the room together.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

It could be random variation over a small sample.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You yada yada'ed over the best part.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I suppose I must now go screw myself as well.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It's kind of old-timey and not used very often.

Sep 10, 2014 12:45 PM on Bless Da 40
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'd argue that baseball is different in the sense that if someone were employed in a situation where no amount of talent or effort resulted in the desired outcome, that someone could seek employment elsewhere to gain fulfillment. In baseball, players are effectively stuck in an organization for six years or so. If it becomes apparent that no amount of effort will bear fruit, some players may just decide the effort is no longer warranted. In our normal lives, it's relatively straightforward to decide that our current job is unsatisfactory and leave for greener pastures. Young ballplayers are swimming upstream the whole way. Performance likely suffers when there is a perception that you are stuck, here, in this godawful place.

Sep 09, 2014 4:18 PM on Poisoned by Losing?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I was under the assumption that this was dug up in the wake of the Ray Rice situation.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You're Penski material.

Sep 09, 2014 1:47 PM on Poisoned by Losing?
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I think if you knew just how hard a player was hitting the ball during a streak you might be able to find something. It very well could be that pitchers realize at a point during a hot streak that "you can't throw it anywhere near him right now." Not because he's getting lots of bloopers, but because he's smoking the ball. Which leads to a question like, which kind of streak is likely to last longer, one based on luck, or one where a hitter is just locked in? My initial thought would be that pitchers perceiving a hitter's streak as lucky wouldn't care to pitch him much differently.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

I concur. It's the smaller part of baseball that really gets inside you, the layer that's not so far removed from you and me. We all belong in that space and time, less separated by media distractions and trade deadlines and contract extensions.

Sep 05, 2014 3:57 PM on The Nearby Faraway
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I enjoyed this tremendously as well. Great piece.

Sep 05, 2014 8:16 AM on The Nearby Faraway
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"Wieners in buns, no condiments, it's Hank's way, anything else is wrong" So mustard on hamburgers is out of the question? It's good, I eat it all the time!

Sep 04, 2014 2:40 PM on Time vs. Pace
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Each AB is an independent event.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Hopefully Kirk Gibson will be available after the season ends.

Sep 02, 2014 12:58 PM on Bo Gone
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Trivial. What "most memorable quotes" would you like?

Aug 29, 2014 12:14 PM on Roast A Parks
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

I just want to leave one thing here, and that is: Baseball has been "in crisis" for going on 20 years. It's always something, and it's always highly publicized. For a game that is supposedly losing its relevance, it sure gets a lot of publicity, almost always negative, and yet... It just seems to me that under Selig's reign baseball has always been in the spotlight for negative reasons at precisely the wrong times. I mean, hey, Mike Trout!

Aug 28, 2014 3:15 PM on A Three-Hour Tour
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

<-Lifelong Cardinals fan, longtime BP reader, Jason Parks fan = three crooked hearts

Aug 28, 2014 1:57 PM on Pain Don't Hurt
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mA6kYFeLAs4

Aug 28, 2014 1:35 PM on Pain Don't Hurt
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I know I'm being pedantic here, but it's "So Long, and Thanks For All the Fish." Don't misquote the dolphins.

Aug 28, 2014 1:31 PM on Pain Don't Hurt
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Let me be the first to say, welcome to AZ, Mister Parks.

Aug 28, 2014 7:56 AM on Pain Don't Hurt
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I think I can answer this, but I'm afraid to try. I would imagine that there is a "signature" that gets preserved in a relative way. Speaking as someone who has been in a recording studio as a trained musician, I would...ask the engineer.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I found it. I got a peak of 1.7 kHz. I think it was a pretty hard hit ball :-)

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm not presuming to speak on Robert's behalf, but I tried removing the crowd noise. The problem I had was that removing that noise also removes some of the signal of the bat crack. But, if you isolate just the signal from the crack, cutting away all the noise surrounding it, you really only hear the crack of the bat. Give it a try.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Okay, I downloaded the .wav files and get the same results, but I still can't graph it like that.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Would it be possible to translate acoustical environments to a "neutral" acoustical environment?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

plot spectrum and got what looks like the right results. I am also using the seewave package (the meanspec function). The results in R don't match. I can't even figure out how to get the f and a ranges like you get. I did a couple of Giancarlo Stanton HRs, but I don't trust that I'm doing it correctly. I'm having a lot of fun, but at the same time I'd like to get it right.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I double-checked before asking, and I did use the analyze-

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

What function did you use to plot the frequencies? I'm not getting the same results on the same audio (well, not quite the same audio...I had to record it from the browser link). For instance, on the line drive audio I get peak amplitude at ~500 hZ.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Yes. among other things. I think that's what we want to find out.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

When I saw that first screencap I immediately recognized Audacity and thought instantly, "why didn't I think of this?" Makes me appreciate this awesome article even more. I can't wait to see what's next. Outstanding stuff, Robert.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 7

"Pain does not exist in this clubhouse, does it?" "No, Gibson!" "Fear does not exist in this clubhouse, does it?" "No, Gibson!" "Defeat does not exist in this clubhouse, does it?" "Well..."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -3
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

The first thing that came to my mind when reading the Boesch comment was a line from Broadcast News: "That's a lot of alliteration from anxious anchors placed in powerful posts."

Aug 14, 2014 1:48 AM on Wednesday, August 13
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Having listened to them over that same stretch, I'm fine with it. It was certainly better than listening to the radio side where you could hear the sound of the ball hitting the backstop while they were in the middle of some stupid story and you were left wondering "what's the count?"

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I was, in my youth, an avid skateboarder until my best friend split his head open and ended up in a coma with his skull stapled together (he lived). One of the crucial skills for survival in skateboarding is learning how to fall. There's a lot of body awareness to it and knowing how to pick the moment you're going to bail and take your lumps. Correspondingly, there is a moment when you might choose to hang in and pull off the trick. There's a fearlessness to hanging in coupled with increased risk, but there are skaters that simply have superior spontaneous risk assessment along with the ability to bail effectively (through repetition.) What I'm getting at is that maybe baseball players aren't being taught to "fall" effectively, and that some players naturally have a skill like this.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

J.D. Drew and his Medical Mystery Tour?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

That's just the tip of the spear, but I don't want to clog up the thread.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

This is absolutely my favorite feature. I can only lament that Robert will likely not be with us much longer (or you can just stay forever please)...let us enjoy it while we can.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

We should get go the bottom of this.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

"...negative numbers are hard" That's why we square them. ;)

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

_oodoo economics

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

You must not have listened to many of the D'backs games he called. He was becoming truly unbearable to listen to. He literally couldn't let one game go by without a rant against sabermetrics and "these guys with their numbers." It really got annoying and was reaching the point of being unprofessional.

Jul 26, 2014 8:56 AM on Ode to Joe
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Also, the graphs show that hitters tend to swing more often in counts favorable to them (when they get ahead). Again not surprising.

Jul 22, 2014 1:36 PM on Accounting for Count
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

The colors are logically organized (I didn't see it until you lodged this complaint). You've got warm tones (red, orange, yellow) for 0 ball counts, greens for 1 ball counts, blues for 2 ball counts, and purples for 3 ball counts. Once you realize how it's organized it is easy to spot the trends, which are hardly surprising (tendency to swing more often as the count gets deeper).

Jul 22, 2014 1:31 PM on Accounting for Count
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

No, no I won't. You can't make a compelling argument by putting the onus on the party you are seeking to convince. You must present your case, not ask that it be "looked up."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Excellent work. Looking forward to the next installment.

Jul 16, 2014 1:34 PM on The Matter of the Heart
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

"A pop song with a good hook and a certain timelessness." Perfect.

Jul 16, 2014 1:07 PM on This Time, We Count
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You know, whenever there is a comment bringing up old favorites, I always think of one person, and somehow I haven't yet mentioned him. I think of all the people I miss most, it is Doug Pappas.

Jul 15, 2014 2:17 PM on Strong
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Very thought provoking article, Russell. A lot of good questions come to mind after reading this. That's what I like about a lot of your articles. Sometimes the answer IS the question.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

BP is the big leagues...all the big players are the Yankees buying off our best players. Except, unlike the Yankees, these guys are being bought up in their prime. :(

Jul 11, 2014 1:45 PM on Forever Changes
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

WARP speed, Ben. Any chance we can have a BP alumni day or week or something like that? Just think of the possibilities.

Jul 11, 2014 8:52 AM on Forever Changes
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

No kidding. My example of these would be when the Padres and Cardinals traded shortstops. Worked out pretty well for the Cards.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I've been saying for a while now (fifteen years?) that Age is the most important statistic in baseball. I can recall having a heated debate with a Phillies fan over Ryan Howard and why he would have a short peak based on his debut age (I swear it's true.)

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Awesome, thanks. I started with R about six months ago and I don't think I'll ever be able (or want) to use anything else.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Out of curiosity, what program are you performing the tests in?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Yep, you can pick one up at Home Depot for cheap...o wait

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You're overlooking the fact that MRI machines get scheduled use. There are very likely people that really very much need an MRI while a baseball player, you know, could wait. "This guy might be dying" vs "This guy might need to rest his arm."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I think it would be fair to question how "high" high leverage really is. After all, when was the last time you actually saw a pitcher hit for himself in a meaningful situation after, say, the fifth inning of a close game? Also, I think something that could be looked at regarding pitchers hitting is how effectively they're pitching that day. Managers will often let them hit if they think the guy's going so well that he won't need the runs he might miss out on by letting his hurler stand in. I know this article doesn't intend to go this far, but pitcher hitting (or lack thereof) is a fascinating topic.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

The Beltre play is featured in today's WYNTK.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

That's not quite what the Braves did. They traded plenty of top prospects, except that everybody but the Braves regarded them as top prospects (an oversimplification, sure). The Braves have just been really really good at evaluating their farm system.

May 27, 2014 12:14 PM on Rebuilding a Right Way
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

It's only a subset of the data he already has, unless he didn't save the results. In R it could just be a dataframe, albeit a large one you don't want lingering in memory, but... #ExternalHarddrive

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

With all due respect, that doesn't tell the story.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Enjoyed this tremendously. As a fan of two teams(Cardinals at birth, and Diamondbacks by proximity), I guess I've been both BIRGing and CORFing at the same time...so I guess I'm in a good place, fan-wise. To provide an anecdotal data point to the psychology of expected failure/expected success, in 2001 I was far more elated than I was in 2006. When the Diamondbacks won it all, I was emotionally involved, but my expectations weren't all that heavy, so I was thrilled. When "we" (the Cardinals) finally won again in 2006, it was my first time since I was eight, and while I was very happy, I felt mostly relief that we had finally done it again after so many years and near misses.

Apr 25, 2014 9:48 AM on Book Excerpt: Dry Land
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

Kevin Towers makes Kevin Kennedy look like a good logical next choice. No one will ever say anything as nice about Kevin Kennedy after Towers gets fired.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

You might want to include two additional terms for "covets", and "fetishes". They could go a long way to explaining some of the inefficient market practices.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

My immediate reaction before the second paragraph began was basically the conclusion that was drawn. Because it makes sense, and not just on days when you might say the reliever just had a bad outing, but in general. There's a good reason why pitchers get used in these roles, and it's because they're volatile and prone to untrustworthy outings, otherwise they would be closing out games. In short, they're really not all that good on a consistent basis. Now you know why you hate the way your manager uses his bullpen.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Dissident. Off Vs.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

In all honesty, just to be up front (and I hate to keep using poker analogies), it's really about gloating. You've successfully inflicted pain upon me...congratulations, take your bases. Ever seen a crazy reaction when someone slow rolls a player in poker and gloats? It's comparable. I remember the first time I caught a pitcher in a game and he got homered off of...guy stands there like he just painted the Mona Lisa. I was like "Is that your first one? Then fucking run asshole. We still have a game to play." You think I want to watch him stand there for however long he wants? Besides, the mound and the catcher's areas are highly territorial. It's a whole thing.

Apr 21, 2014 4:16 PM on Weekend Wrap-Up, 4/21
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

A wise man once said, "Sticks and stones may break your bones but words cause permanent damage."

Apr 21, 2014 11:37 AM on Weekend Wrap-Up, 4/21
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

On a related note, Mike Trout's two pair beats Chuck Norris' royal flush.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

A team of cloned Mike Trouts splits the pot Mike Trout ways. A Mike Trout, however, wins every hand every time. Mike Trout beats a straight flush.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

I didn't have time at the moment to complete my comment above and how it relates to the article. Mike Caro had a series of "lectures" on his website a long time ago (I printed them out back then, I can't find them online at this time). They were absolute gold. The advice he would give at the end of every article would be along the lines of "in your next session, every time you are last to act and the action is checked all the way to you, I want you to bet." Caro would give you a profitable strategy and tell you to try it and see what happens. No global learning, just bit by bit. I think that could work here. Encourage small risks/rewards and if the coaches see the profitability, maybe they'll come around, bit by bit.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 5

Poker players understand this very well...well, good professional poker players. Perhaps it can be explained in those terms. You are going to have bad beats even when you are well ahead in the hand (it happens), and sometimes you will make a marginal call because the pot odds justify it even though you are behind in the hand. If you don't play that way, you lose money.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Is that you, Dayton Moore?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Could be a good idea to find out how bad B.J.'s golf swing is. Might be a good diagnostic test.

Apr 10, 2014 2:06 PM on (B.J.) Upton No Good
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

While I certainly don't qualify for membership, I did regularly throw a knuckleball as an out pitch and change of pace offering in my limited amateur days. It's a fun pitch, although who it is fun for is difficult to pinpoint. Getting called strikes with it was not easy. There is an excellent documentary currently on Netflix called Knuckleball that I recommend to all.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I say award bases. I haven't done the thought experiment out to imagine the ways it could be abused, but then, the leading cause of problems is solutions.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I can't remember the year, But I seem to recall a Sports Illustrated doing an analysis of the similarities between the golf swing and the baseball swing, specifically at impact...specifically spine angle, shoulder rotation, upper body torsion, etc. I've seen lots of baseball players with pretty bad golf swings, but they were all appreciably better than Charles Barkley's.

Mar 12, 2014 3:28 PM on The Science of Swinging
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Oops, nevermind. You can do that for 20014, though :)

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

There is; download the PECOTA spreadsheet and order it by HRs.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Of course, and the rational move is to pay them less than market value. They don't have the bargaining power. It's a hard position to win...the FOTs are at least as valuable as let's say, an average player? I look forward to seeing the argument.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

They used to have two.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Speaking of this type thing: I took a friend that had never been to a ballgame, had watched them in bars, but never paid any serious attention. I had him trained by the third inning to pay special attention to 2-0, 2-1 counts. It so happened that game that nearly every count that went 2-0 ended with loud contact within the next two pitches. I didn't need to say anymore about that. When he eventually asked why it is, I told him, "he's gotta throw him a good pitch here, something he can hit." The explanation was actually longer than that, but you know what it is. He got it. I think if you can point out some of the subtleties, baseball can fairly explain itself.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Football doesn't have the kind of guaranteed contracts and arbitration system as baseball. Baseball contracts are much less fluid. What I think is missing from this article is the (more or less) rigid nature of budgeting for player expenditures. You want to spend more on FOT? You have less for player payroll. It boils down to arguing that either there should be a bigger pie or that the pie should be split differently. I don't think the pie is going to get any bigger, not to the extent that FOT are going to get substantial raises. At any rate, the real problem is that being really very smart at building teams gets squashed by the ability of certain teams to skew the market for wins. At that point, being the smartest GM boils down to a matter of need, as you are probably running a small budget team, in which case paying the execs more money is self-defeating.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 5

I got this one: "A good friend of mine used to say, This is a very simple game. You throw the ball, you catch the ball, you hit the ball. Sometimes you win, sometimes you lose, sometimes it rains."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Thanks for the link, Ben!

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Luke, the force is strong with you.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

This seems to be a very persistent skill, one not likely to change in any large way. Which makes me wonder if it is a skill that can be learned and improved through coaching, if it improves with age and similarly declines, or if it is just Born Catcher Magic/Jedi Mind Trick.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

The problem is that it would be redundant. The data gathered already provides those solutions. I don't think they can spend the kind of resources NASA does.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

As well as bandwidth, diskspace, and processor speed.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

This is the best article of the year anywhere, on the internet or otherwise. I don't care what anyone says, baseball just keeps getting better.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

In case it was unclear, the article contains an error wherein it claims Jason Heyward earned 6.7 WARP in 2013. The error has likely been allowed to persist long enough.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

I told you so.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Re: Jason Heyward "He's the same player who posted 6.7 WARP in 2013" 2012.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

You want to know if it equals or exceeds 350? That's reasonable.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 9
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm being denied access, and, needless to say, it isn't making me happy.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

My guess would be how hitters respond to pitch types and sequencing. eg how they adjust to being fed fastballs more often.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Thanks for the fine example of Truthiness. One only has to think about it, One needs no further proof.

Feb 12, 2014 12:35 PM on Interpreting the Polls
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Allow me to sum up my position with a parallel from my favorite television show of all time: Seinfeld. Jerry: I think Tim Whatley has converted to Judaism purely for the jokes. Priest: And this offends you as a Jewish person? Jerry: No, it offends me as a comedian! This isn't about race, it's ahout interpreting data.

Feb 12, 2014 12:25 PM on Interpreting the Polls
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -8

You can't effectively state, "these are the facts" without providing, you know, actual facts. Unless you have something to back your statements up with, they are nonsense, and offensive.

Feb 11, 2014 3:40 PM on Interpreting the Polls
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -14

No, the point is that you are not offering any further analysis in response to questioning, only reasserting that the evidence you presented "seems" and "appears" to prove your point.

Feb 11, 2014 12:00 PM on Interpreting the Polls
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -14

Wow, you might want to rethink the position you're taking here. Saying "I don't care" about an issue being raised and essentially saying "I've done all the work I'm going to do on this" won't reflect very well on you in the world out there when people paying you money start asking questions.

Feb 11, 2014 11:27 AM on Interpreting the Polls
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

In thinking about this, the questions posed by Peter and Robert, to my thinking, are what make this article a successful exercise. The questions are as important as the answers. I seem to recall Russell espousing the sentiment that, at this point in sabermetrics, we should be as creative with our questions as with our answers. This is a great way to further exploration in the field. I think it would be helpful if more of the people with interesting questions had the tools to provide their own answers. Maybe there could be a tutorial series on this site showing how to reproduce some of the studies.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

If I'm reading this right, and I like to think I am, this is just the beginning, the ground floor. Models don't come forth fully formed; there is work to be done before you know where you're going. To lay out the whole thing in one article would make it the length of an academic research paper.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Not just that, but there wasn't any mention of the composition of the survey sample in regards to knowledge of or level of interest in baseball. Bonds is famous in a non-baseball context in a way that, say, Gary Sheffield isn't. In addition, we don't have any information about how attitudes towards baseball rules and PEDs break down along racial lines in a general sense. Also, Bonds utter lack of contrition may play a role in how he is viewed within certain racial groups. In fairness, the author did highly recommend reading the cited material in full, citing the difficulty in summarizing the findings within the brevity of this article.

Feb 11, 2014 7:20 AM on Interpreting the Polls
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

So would it be fair to say that a frontline starter is nominal ace/#2/#3, mid rotation type is a weak #2/good #3/excellent #4?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Follow the story. ARod was taking his drugs at scheduled intervals precisely to be able to pass a test after a game. He had a designed drug taking schedule fitted just for him specifically.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

It's posturing...spin control. ARod needs to get something on the books in his defense, and it doesn't matter how preposterous. Plausible "I'm not the biggest douchebag in all this?"

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

CAPS LOCK WON'T SAVE YOU! I NEVER WROTE "FOLLOWED" ANYWHERE IN MY POST! The process that was _agreed to_ is what unfolded. If you want to make an argument that MLB violated some law, that's a different argument, but still not germane to the issue at hand. The arbitration process, as agreed to by the union and MLB, will most assuredly be upheld. The collection of evidence outside of that process, however repugnant to our sensibilities, will not matter to the court.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

None of that matters one little teeny tiny bit. There are rules that were agreed to, found to be violated by a process that was agreed to. He would basically have to prove malice. Not being number one on some arbitrary list doesn't really count as "aggrieved."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

A Cubs posts right below my Cards post. Newman!

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

"You could have the same database that I use on your computer within about 20 minutes, if you are so inclined." It's not quite that easy, Russel. But it can be done. If you were to write a free e-book detailing all the steps to get someone up and running and doing detailed baseball studies using the free datasets, well, I'd vote you in.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Why not just have a preliminary survey to identify who, say, 90% of the voters consider a no-doubt HoFer, induct those players, and then have an actual ballot for the rest? It seems silly to take a vote for a player like Maddux when it's overwhelmingly obvious that he's getting in.

Jan 08, 2014 9:34 AM on The 2014 Results
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Tom Ferrick has a report on Lankford as well, from '93. 6 hit, 6 power, 7 run, 6 field. "front line CF"..."Allstar type." Also in the report are Greg Jeffries, who he rates average across the board, Jose Oquendo, who he calls "not an everyday player, good glove, defense and sb, no power, contact type" and Tom Pagnozzi who gets good marks for defense. I think most of that was obvious by the time this report was filed.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Because Ray Lankford is my favorite player ever and Mike Rizzo would've been my choice for the Diamondbacks GM position, I found two reports Rizzo filed on Lankford in 1990. Strong points:"Good looking athlete with all the tools. Hits w/ quick bat and some pop. Runs well and is a plus CF" Weak points:"Needs some work in CF to become plus CF. Also needs to be more selective at the plate" Summation:"Young player w/ above ave tools across the board. Will be an impact player. Will arrive in ML soon" His summation from a report filed about a month later: "Great young talent that can hit, power, run, and field. Will be a good one"

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I found this very interesting and entertaining. It also gave me an idea...I think it would be every bit as interesting, albeit much more work, to explore the "misses" where the scouts vastly overrated a player. Of course there would need to be leniency for players that didn't pan out due to unforeseeable circumstances.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It’s pronounced “és queue el.” Yes it is. If I hear one more person call it "sequel", I'll say stop again.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

well, that was my first reply to this thread, so I'm not certain it's fair for you to wonder why I'm searching for reasons against your results. Maybe you aren't directly adressing "me." I find your work reasonable, but I also wonder what may be missing. There may be some confirmation bias? I don't mean to criticize without purpose...I'd love to join in the effort when time permits I have much longer thoughts on this, but i don't think this the space for it.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Have you considered that by the fourth time through the lineup it is maybe no longer the same lineup? Pinch hitters, defensive replacements...those guys are first -timers. Not to mention the nature of the score and the pitch count. Is the starter still in there because his pitch count is low and the game is easily in hand and he's being given the opportunity to get the CG/PG/No-No? Have the hitters just given up more or less because it's a blowout and their best team is no longer playing (garbage time)?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Lighten up, Francis.

Nov 16, 2013 9:13 AM on Suicide is Painless
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

It's the Establishment Clause. The young kid will eventually "earn" his if he's really that good. The established veteran has proven himself over the years. I'd liken it to the perceived hazing young players go through in regards to calls on close ball/strike safe/out plays.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It came to light far before that. Lke, way far before that. Like almost from the advent of RBI.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

there's so much misdirection and misunderstanding in this post that I'm left wondering why it's author left it here of all places. I will not be one of the people down voting this.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Let us not forget hitters that are so inclined, time permitting, to run into the video room and watch their at bats to see how they were pitched and whatever else they have time to observe.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

i'm surprised that the hiring of AJ Hinch by Josh Byrnes goes unmentioned. That went over like...well, it didn't go over at all. There was a recent article here at BP that sort of highlighted this kind of thing; trendsetters are really following a trend set by someone who gets skewered for the idea and forgotten.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

Yes, I know how to use an SQL database and I can write code in R. Am I hired? Congratulations Colin. I can only imagine how exciting this news must be for you.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -3

This is a math site, not a baseball site. :rollseyes:

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Nearly any of these for me would involve me screaming at the television "get him out of there!" I advocate hard for having managers watch the game in the clubhouse on TV...please recognize when your pitcher has lost it. Every manager I've ever watched manage has frustrated the hell out of me with not seeing his pitcher is finished. Three runs later...

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

It's good to be a cards fan.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Don't Cardinals fans ever want to just be mean?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

[shakes fist] SUSSMAAAAAAAAAAAN!!!

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

How did I know the quote from the Boston Globe column was Bob Ryan before clicking the link? Ryan just gets more ridiculous over time.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

I'm not certain you are correct here. Standard error and standard deviation aren't very different, unless you mean some other use of the term standard error. If Colin is using samples to estimate a mean and thus estimate a standard deviation from the sample means, he is using standard error correctly.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

impossible? No, improbable. Please learn the difference

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 8

So you want BP to set up a league wide test case study with a control group? Sure, consider it done. Listen, people, this really is an issue that has to be ignored in a statistical sense in the absence of data. Data we will never get. We will never know who took what when and for how long or in what dosage. It's analytically irresponsible to aply anectodal evidence to objective pursuits without any other data. You want a definitive analysis? Let them use whatever they want and we'll collect the data and run the analysis. Otherwise there is really no point in knee-jerk, high horse moralizing. We analyze the data we have at our disposal...there are plenty of columnists doing the other thing.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

He had two dogs named Shamsky. There was an episode where Raymond went to Cooperstown to cover a HoF event that Robert begged into just to meet Art Shamsky.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

This is exactly the sort of thing that gets mentioned around the batting cages. Players can become hated for these things.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

The incident that answers the riddle happened in the eighth...DeShields was already on base .

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

"I give you a gift and you stand there and show up my pitcher? Run dummy!"

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

You beat me to it. Liriano was to be my next thought. Never seen someone so electric. I always hope for him.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

For a bit of context regarding the names involved, from BP 2005: " Back problems suck. They destroyed the career of Don Mattingly, and Sweeney, as good a hitter as he is, is no Don Mattingly."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

I second the mentions (and was waiting for these names while reading the article) of Don Mattingly, Eric Davis, Ken Griffey, Jr, and Bo Jackson. I would like to add Mike Sweeney. Please let us not forget Sweeney.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Why has the Law of Large Numbers never been interjected into these debates? I know it is in essence sample size, but not entirely.

Apr 26, 2013 4:01 PM on The Hawk Trap
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 15

Hawk and Harold don't want to know the percentages? I want to play poker with those fellows. And I would never dare tell them they are wrong.

Apr 26, 2013 8:21 AM on The Hawk Trap
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

You're thinking of Tom Glavine and his Personal Strike Zone.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 2

Regarding the Diamondbacks...well, many of us Snakes fans thought the org was looking like a dynasty in the making. Then Jeff Moorad decided he had to have Eric Byrnes to the tune of 3 years and 30 million, which crowded the outfield and basically got Quentin and Carlos Gonzalez traded. Things could have gone better.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

It's doubtful. I just think of you as "Wojo." *Voice of Muddy Waters* got my Wojo working!

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

The thing is, a knuckler isn't just one pitch, it's a thousand different pitches thrown the same way. There is no getting used to it. A tailing fastball tails in a predictable way...a knuckleball does nothing in a predictable way.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

"Warren Corbett, argues in a SABR article that Richards was far ahead of his time in terms of modern baseball analysis, using OBP, for example, long before Total Baseball or The Bill James Abstracts." Branch Rickey: http://www.baseballthinkfactory.org/btf/pages/essays/rickey/goodby_to_old_idea.htm

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 5

And so ends the Official Annual Nick Johnson Injury Watch...officially. I think he goes into the Erubiel Dorazo Hall of Fame.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

This was addressed via: Watson generously gives Holmes credit for predicting a “popup to center.”

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 0

I love how Dusty Baker gets dinged in this article...really puts it over the top.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

That pitch that hit him in the stomach hit him in the forearm first. He was hit two times by one pitch.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Turns out I was paraphrasing. The actual quote is: "It's supposed to be hard. If it wasn't hard everyone would do it. The hard is what makes it great."

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 1

It seems like quite a few people have misunderstood the tone and point of this article. "Too often, that doesn’t seem to happen in baseball. But I guess if it did, we wouldn’t have anything left to debate. And what fun would that be?" Nick is actually telling you that the uncertainty is what makes it fun. Certitude would make it easy. To quote a famous baseball movie: "Hard is what makes it great. If it were easy, everyone would do it." Baseball analysis is hard. That's what makes it great.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Really, skill is he ability to keep luck from mattering. Skill should eliminate luck. Luck is a coin toss. Skill would create situations that avoid coin tosses, not create them...because they can't be taken advantage of reliably.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -2

Interesting to note this part of the press release from Braun's camp: " there was absolutely no intentional violation of the program" Soooooo, there was no _intentional_ violation, but a violation nonetheless? That's an admission. Are we going to hear the "never knowingly took them" line next?

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 3

Precisely, he is arguing that too many of them got it right, implying there;s a problem that more of them didn't get it wrong.

Nov 21, 2011 11:16 AM on Voting Outrage
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: 4

You cannot be serious. If you're going to focus on results? What would you have the awards based on if not results? Did you actually think before you wrote that _and_read it before you hit submit?

Nov 21, 2011 11:01 AM on Voting Outrage
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

The problem with Tony isn't that he overmanages...he's a fine Strat-O-Manager. The problem is the pieces he chooses to manage with. If he could season his own meat instead of picking over others beef jerky, he might have more rings.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Nomar's got no shot at the Hall...don't be silly.

Mar 12, 2010 12:55 PM on Nomar and the Trinity
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

Well, the fact of the matter is that a decision can be a win or a loss, but a no decision can never be a win. Percentage of wins fails for the same reasons accounting for pitcher wins fails. It's going to fluctuate wildly with no real logic involved.

 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -3

Forgetting about the 300 win threshold, which of those pitchers do we think will make the HOF? I don't see how they can keep Pedro out, Santana certainly has a chance, Halladay should see consideration, Peavy and Oswalt seem like good candidates going forward. I think this class of pitchers will set the new threshold for wins by a starting pitcher.

Jun 05, 2009 10:13 AM on The Next 300
 
therealn0d
(51857)
Comment rating: -1

On the one hand, is Selig stupid? On the other hand, is he a liar? As Joey from Friends would say: put your hands together.

Jun 04, 2009 9:57 AM on Mid-week Roundup