CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  

Search Article Archives

Find:   

Author:    Article: 
Search Date (From):    Search Date (To):   
Sort Results by:  Relevance
 Date
Show me  Results

   Show Article Summaries

New! Search comments:      
(NOTE: Relevance, Author, and Article are not applicable for comment searches)

WaldoInSC
258 comments | 86 total rating | 0.33 average rating
Facebook Twitter email a friend
Share comments by 'WaldoInSC' posted at
Baseball Prospectus http://bbp.cx/i/26415
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -3

This is some beautiful writing, Meg. Point taken and noted. And to traipse a moment where you dared not go, the suspension is almost exactly the equivalent of three-game NFL games, which would precipitate howls of anger. Evidently the real crime is getting caught on video.

Mar 02, 2016 5:05 PM on The Chapman Precedent
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I'm having trouble understanding what the "Ian Desmond Problem" <i>is</i>? I mean, other than for the Desmond family. Why is it a problem for MLB if some free agent's value is depressed by the loss of a draft pick? Wasn't dampening the demand for free agents the whole point of the QO system?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

With all due respect to Tulo, the best player in Rockies history by a wide margin is <span class="playerdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/player_search.php?search_name=Larry+Walker">Larry Walker</a></span>.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Ahem...back to our regularly-scheduled discussion: I'm shocked that so few people voted. Is that the norm? I've always been under the impression that BP subscribers are highly-motivated to exercise their franchise since they are shut out of the real awards process and believe they are more knowledgeable than the average sportswriter. (And might be.) I have never failed to vote in the IBA and always assumed that was pretty standard.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Sounds like this era's market inefficiency.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Wonderful Terrific Monds III congratulates you. http://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.cgi?id=monds-001won

Dec 28, 2015 5:14 PM on The Name Game
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

And though it might not seem so sometimes when we talk about professional sports, it is possible to be happy with *only* $15.8 million.

Nov 13, 2015 7:01 PM on Colby Qualifies
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

What? Get rid of pitchers batting in both leagues? Right there with you!

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Try Googling "best ways to waste 15 minutes."

Oct 05, 2015 6:45 PM on Fin
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

It's not the PED "stuff" with Lyin' Ryan. It's the smug spin-doctoring once he got caught red-handed that rankles. To this day, he has never faced the public and acknowledged the depth of his mendacity and cynical self-righteousness.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -6

Uh-huh, yeah. Um, so? Neat-o graphs but what, in the end, have you discovered -- that some players are like others? If your research is more profound than that, you might want to explain how.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

Paredes is not a benefactor; he's a beneficiary. Benefactors are people who provide the benefits, not those who receive them.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Re: Molina. Sure they loved his glove. His bat offered a .160 <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=TAv" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('TAv'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">TAv</span></a> and more strikeouts than total bases.

Mar 25, 2015 8:26 PM on Getting Personal
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Making decisions based on <span class="statdef"><a href="http://www.baseballprospectus.com/glossary/index.php?search=PECOTA" onmouseover="doTooltip(event, jpfl_getStat('PECOTA'))" onmouseout="hideTip()">PECOTA</span></a> projections is a prescription for silliness. Projection systems have proved to be only slightly less flawed than our intuition. The Reds don't believe their playoff chances are merely 13%, so they are making a move they believe will make them better. Other than teams in total rebuild, I don't know what else their fans could ask of them.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I agree with Travis. We're conflating winning the post-season tournament with fielding a top team. The post-season tournament is, in many ways, a lottery. During the last three years, when they won two titles, the Giants could be characterized as excellent-bad-good.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -2

And at the risk of putting too fine a point on it, "regressing back" is redundant. And repetitive!

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Right, because what's noteworthy about PECOTA's White Sox projections isn't that they underestimate actual performance, it's that they aren't much better than flipping a coin. PECOTA has been wildly wrong four of the past 11 years, significantly wrong twice more and pretty dead on three times. Anyone one of us could have guessed roughly that badly.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

The Pitchf/x information doesn't contradict the possibility of a breakout; it simply explains why Peralta hasn't dominated with 96mph heat in the past. The whole point of breakouts is that they do something different than they were doing before -- learn a new pitch, reduce their walk rate, figure something out, etc. If Peralta improves his differentiation good things might happen. Of course, we should be skeptical, not because of Pitchf/x but for the very reason you elucidate to end your piece: breakouts are not the way to bet.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Changes nothing. He was a fantasy writer -- period.

Jan 05, 2015 5:27 PM on A Look Ahead
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Thank you for a lot of great content. A quibble with your use of English: If Nick Shlain was a former fantasy writer at Rotowire then he must be a fantasy writer now. If you mean to say that he is no longer a fantasy writer there then either he was a fantasy writer at Rotowire or he is a former fantasy writer at Rotowire. And before you all pound the minus button, allow me to argue that we should expect professional communicators to be precise with their language. I suspect Bret would agree.

Jan 02, 2015 5:32 PM on A Look Ahead
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Maybe he was looking at your daughter.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

You don't have to hope. A contracts is not something teams can choose to honor. Renteria's children will not want for food.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Okay Robert, we can disagree on base running and FIP, but if you put mustard on hamburgers, that's where I draw the line.

Sep 03, 2014 7:12 PM on Time vs. Pace
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

I don't believe the problem is the length of the game so much as its pace, to which FlyingDutchman was alluding. There's so much unnecessary stoppage of play that could be removed without serious consequence to the competition. Take the endless in-frame pitching changes, for example. My wife loses interest in MLB games right about the time the excitement should be heating up. That's because rather than build the drama steadily in the late innings, the game allows managers to interrupt it for minutes at a time. This is not how a wise entertainment business acts.

Aug 28, 2014 7:24 PM on A Three-Hour Tour
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Or he's arrived, but can't parallel park.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Loosen the tie, homey. Facts are not the coin of the realm when tongue is so firmly planted in cheek.

Jul 28, 2014 5:19 PM on Monday, July 28
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

To take your solid point a step further, Piazza's not one of the the best hitting catchers; he's the best hitting catcher of all time. The argument against him is not sponge-worthy.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

...and the World Series ends October 15 before the snow falls.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I'm constantly amused by the persistent narrative of Jeter "diving into the stands to make the catch," which appears to be immune to the actual facts. Watch the video: Jeter caught the ball several yards from the stands and -- by his own admission -- threw his body into the crowd in hopes of landing in someone's lap, rather than flipping over the wall and onto the concrete floor in front of the first row. Who needs truth when we we want so badly to believe a fantasy? It was a nice catch, of course, but it was hardly the stuff of hero worship. Except, evidently, it was.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Sometimes you're the windshield; sometimes you're the bug.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

With all due respect, I think this is the exact opposite of the truth. There is rarely a "right" or "wrong" answer because there are so many variables unknown to us, including whether the pitcher is losing his command, whether the meat of the order is due up or whether the batter is a dead fastball hitter. This is why you pay a manager and not a computer to skipper the team.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Basically, the club is selling insurance to the player. In the long run, the club is likely to profit, but if anything goes wrong, the player at least earns a few million bucks. This is particularly mutually beneficial because the marginal utility of the player's first few millions is much greater than of the millions that might follow. That makes the player more risk averse than the team. It takes a lot of gumption for a player to reject a reasonable deal. It makes sense that these contracts are proliferating.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I appreciate your point, but that's only true because a self-selected sample of hitters has bunted. Keep in mind that guys who stink at bunting have not attempted it.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 21

You'd feel better if you thought smarter, not harder.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

"Add in that he struck out more batters than he walked, and Tanaka looks like an elite pitcher..." Um...

Jan 22, 2014 7:45 PM on Yankees Sign Tanaka
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

...in Canada, president's a relatively useless job, like a LOOGY.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Indeed, pre-season predictions in all sports are so much gumbo, as the Falcons, Steelers, Texans, Giants, Panthers, Bengals and Cardinals have made clear in the NFL. (I predict the Heat will be good this year...)

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -4

Kolten Wong isn't a benefactor of any trade unless he's suddenly taken a GM job and donated David Freese to the Angels. He is the *beneficiary* of the trade. Professional writers should know the difference.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

But once the winning run scores, isn't the game over? Didn't the runner score with none out, meaning the pitcher gets no credit for the out? After all, if the pitcher had simply walked off the mound, the game would have ended with a 4-3 score, even if the other runners had continued running and crossed the plate.

Nov 15, 2013 7:03 PM on Suicide is Painless
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

...but you repeat yourself.

Nov 14, 2013 8:15 PM on AL Player of the Year
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

This endeavor demonstrates such maturity. Congratulations to everyone involved in advance for your collaborative approach.

Aug 23, 2013 11:49 AM on The Series Ahead
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Don't know if you've noticed, fellow SC dude, but Choo pretty much has.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

It's not an insult to say I don't throw hard enough. I think I topped out at 70 in 1994. Thanks for the knowledge. I honestly didn't know that.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

You say the natural tailing action on thrown baseballs that, for left-handed catchers, would make the assist veer away from the oncoming baserunner. Is that right? Since we all throw across our bodies to some degree, I'd have thought a lefty's ball would tail to the right, and into the oncoming runner. I'm a northpaw and my throws run out of steam to the left. Are you saying we all throw natural screwballs? If that's so why can't most pitchers throw real screwballs?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

This may be a figure of speech known as synecdoche (pronounced sort of like Schenectady), in which a part is used to describe a whole. The quintessential example is "head of cattle." If you see "your Bryce Harpers" as a general description of young, talented players, this fits the bill. Or the speakers of the phrase could just be knuckleheads...

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Sell Tim Lincecum? Who's buying?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

The irony of this whole discussion is that it very much matters who bats in front of a hitter. It seems like such an obvious point that who's on base when you bat is more important than who's on deck.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Jeff Francoeur? Do the Yankees need outfield help in Columbus?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

It's not possible to use a dwarf like Eddie Gaedel because Eddie Gaedel was a midget, not a dwarf. Midgets are proportionally small. Dwarfs are small people with disproportionally normal sized heads and hands. Randy Newman is not popular with either group.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

The FOT defending Lohse's deal has been drinking too much of the Brewers' product. Lohse is a 2 1/2 only in the sense that he was a 1 last year and will be a 4 this year.

Mar 28, 2013 7:14 PM on Great Expectations
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Thank you for using "comprise" correctly. It's a noble fight we are doomed to lose.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

The problem with all these intriguing experiments -- the Red Sox' closer by committee a few years back, the Rockies last year, LaRussa in '93 -- is that no groundwork was laid. A franchise that wants to experiment with an unconventional approach needs to start in the low minors and develop it through the system. They wouldn't have to worry about entrenched beliefs if the people affected had grown up in professional baseball with their approach.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Your research actually demonstrates that Barry Zito is a magician. He manages to win 3% of games in which his team does not score for him.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

6. What is the plural of RBI? 7. Can a $20 million player in Cincinnati be a Red? 8. If four balls is a walk and three strikes is an out, isn't a pitcher ahead in the count at 0-0, 1-1 and 2-2? 9. What exactly is a Met? 10. Are they of L.A. or Anaheim?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Actually, that glorious orb transits not, at least not as far as we can tell. That our little marble rolls around it is the cause of earlier starts on the Atlantic.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Nothing like eight innings of Spring Training to redeem a pitcher who's been run out of the league. Or 37 PA against pitchers who'll be staffing the West Tennessee Diamond Jacks come Opening Day to guarantee greatness from a second-year player. Or "basic fundamentals" to make a writer look silly. This article needs to get a grip.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -4

To describe Ramirez as a "greater player" is to genuflect at the shrine of WARP without recognizing that it has never come to grips with reliever value. Even if Mariano Rivera contributed less to his teams than Manny Ramirez, the fault is in his usage, not in his dominance. He is the greatest relief pitcher of all time; Ramirez is hardly the greatest outfielder of all time, the greatest rightfielder of all time, or even the greatest knucklehead rightfielder of all time.

Mar 12, 2013 2:28 PM on The Letting Go
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -9

If the Dodgers jell this season is Don Mattingly a jenius? Should we jenuflect to him? I want to be a gournalist!

Feb 07, 2013 7:34 PM on Spring Headliners
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I'm surprised at the silence over Mike Piazza's poor showing. I'd like to ask the 40% of the voters who passed him by: if the greatest hitting catcher of all-time isn't a Hall of Famer, who is?

Jan 10, 2013 7:04 PM on A Change in the Process
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

It is worth reminding everyone that the new parks are no smaller, they just have fewer seats. That's about creating scarcity, not home runs.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Mr. Roher, you have the rare gift of insight and command of language at 22, and a bright future indeed. A crackerjack perspective; thanks for sharing.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

You're only young once but you can be immature your whole life!

Nov 29, 2012 7:13 PM on Upton Goes to A-Town
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

I'm confused by the notion that the Indians should trade Asdrubal Cabrera. How does the math work on plugging a hole elsewhere by creating a hole at short? Cabrera is 26 and signed through 2014, so it's not like he's a departing veteran of no future value to the club. It seems to me what the Indians really have to do is develop more Asdrubal Cabreras.

Nov 21, 2012 5:10 PM on AL Shopping Lists
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Isn't hitting your head with a mallet how you ended up in your parents' basement in the first place? Also, you forgot to mention the veteran presence on this team. They would know how to win.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Evidently chicks dig "hells." Or at least one does. You're actually married, right?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

When you consider the Giants' top earners it's pretty astounding they're near the pinnacle. Zito's been a bust, Lincecum evaporated this year, Huff rides the pine and Wilson spent the season on the DL. Only Cain has earned his coin. Other than him, they've spent $55 mil for negative WARP.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

The decision to allow the Cardinals to outscore them by eight runs after the third inning is the reason Washington lost. If you can't hold a 6-0 lead for six innings it's really irrelevant what your manager does.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

But who does PECOTA think wins the electoral votes?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

The full sub-title goes like this: It's a trap. It's a suicide rap. We gotta get out while we're young.

Oct 09, 2012 7:05 PM on It's a Trap!
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I don't know why anyone would bother applying PECOTA to analyze the Orioles this post-season. They have completely baffled the system all year. You might as well use a Ouija board.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

And PECOTA correctly predicted the Braves and Range . . . d'Oh!

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

"If you find yourself in a hole, stop digging."— Will Rogers

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -3

It would also be nice if the authors knew how to use the word comprised, which is not a synonym for composed. But since fewer (not less) Americans everyday know that particular one, I'm not holding my breath.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

What a silly place for the proof. Someone who thinks they're eating pudding is going to choke on it. On the other hand, the proof of the pudding is in the eating.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

I suspect the Dodgers are counting on a rebound from Crawford and a few more Gonzalez-quality years. On the other hand, if Beckett is a #3 starter at this point L.A. brass will do back flips.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Another factoid: Movies are fiction. Ask Mark Zuckerberg.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Adam, Eddie Gaedel was a midget, not a dwarf. Midgets are small people built proportionally, while dwarfs have normal-sized hands and heads but tiny bodies. Also, the Atlanta radio crew bellyaches unusually often about the umpires. I leave the analysis to others; I don't know how that serves as an analog for Braves fans or the Atlanta metro.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

What's the term for a "Nincompoop" who's safe, as the video documents? Gutsy baserunner?

Aug 14, 2012 5:24 PM on Tuesday, August 14
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Your friend's dad didn't make a bad decision; he made a good decision that didn't work out well. The notion that people would go to a store by the thousands to buy mediocre coffee is laughable still, even after it's come to fruition. Only in hindsight, whose advantages he lacked, can we fault him. Likewise, the Angels. Had they known that Vernon Wells, in whom they had made a gargantuan investment, would fail to bounce back, and that Mike Trout was in no further need of seasoning, they would have started Trout Day One. But if we're all so smart, why didn't we buy Apple stock at seven dollars a share?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

The odds are against any of this year’s deals being decisive during the regular season. Au contraire, Pierre. The odds are quite high that one of this year's deals will be decisive; we just don't know which one. A Cody Ross-style fluke could turn an unremarkable acquisition into a playoff catapult.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

By definition, the Marlins' fan base can't be disinterested. That would make them neutral, and therefore, not fans. They may instead be uninterested if they're not showing up to the ballpark.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

Opining like homo erectus. He was no ex-jock spewing pablum and crock, but instead some well-researched invectus.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Get what you paid for: Horsehide erudition, yea! BP and its fans.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Right, I'm sure Robby Cano is all over the Royals' farm system. It wouldn't surprise me if preceding this week, he couldn't pick Billy Butler or Mike Moustakas out of a lineup of pygmies.

Jul 10, 2012 7:45 PM on Tuesday, July 10
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

L-R-L-L R-L-R-R Hey, it's a paradiddle!

Jul 06, 2012 5:12 PM on The Blind BABIP Test
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

That makes him a "heck of a" writer, just not the best on BP.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Because there was no DH when Medwick played.

May 18, 2012 5:27 PM on Friday, May 18
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

You might also want to change your name to, like, Bob.

May 14, 2012 6:26 PM on The One They Missed
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Isn't closing all about small samples?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

The feckless Bowie Kuhn is in the Hall of Fame and his personal tormentor Marvin Miller is not. As long as that's true, the Hall will remain irrelevant.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

...as opposed to a win-win for just one party.

Apr 12, 2012 6:44 PM on Thursday, April 12
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

In truth, the blame for Wieters' bustiness rests squarely with BP, which predicted he'd win four MVPs by his third year and make Baltimorons forget homegrown Babe Whatsisname. Had Wieters simply entered the majors like an ordinary, uncaped crusader, we'd be comparing him favorably to Jonathan Lucroy.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Actually, that would be pretty funny, since the Royals play in Missouri.

Apr 10, 2012 7:48 PM on Tuesday, April 10
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Can't wait 'til my mom has a working knowledge of Matthew Kory's story.

Mar 29, 2012 5:25 PM on 10 Headlines for 2012
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

My sister's face broke out last week. PECOTA didn't see it coming.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Fair to expect the Brewers would have improved dramatically at 3B by replacing Casey McGehee with Casey McGehee and the Marlins would likewise at SS by replacing Hanley Ramirez with Hanley Ramirez.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

I'm guessing those kids have birthdays in mid-December,having been conceived in mid-March.

Feb 17, 2012 5:57 PM on Trading Places
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Interestingly, Neon Hos Smelling A Leafage anagrams to Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim. But Diane knew that.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

I think Shaun was being glib, but it's hard to see that in print.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Only 33 percent of major-league teams will qualify for the playoffs once the postseason field officially expands. By comparison, 38 percent of NFL teams make the playoffs, and that figure goes up to 53 percent for both the NBA and NHL. This is such a bogus and disingenuous argument. The NBA and NHL regular seasons are laughingstocks for this very reason. Baseball is unique because a five- or seven-game series (not to mention a single game) is such a toss-up that the longer the post-season the more of a lottery it becomes. It's deeply unsatisfying to play six months of baseball only to have the seventh-best team go on a 15-game run to win the championship.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -2

Is that less exciting than an intra-league match-up that nobody cares about?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

You must be on to something because, seriously, what's the upside on rejecting $20 million/year for five years? $30 million for five? How is that different? But the downside is it all falls apart and he gets bupkus. Unless Lincecum hates San Francisco, or doesn't trust management, turning down that deal is insanity from a financial standpoint. So it must be something else with him, and if it's what you suggest, good for him.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

That is one ghastly infield if Cabrera's tub of goo staffs the hot corner. With Fielder at first and Peralta at second it's all wood and no leather. Plus, moving Cabrera to third has to be worth 1.5 DL stints. The bigger they are, the harder they fall. Add in Justin Verlander's almost inevitable return to earth and a dearth of starting pitching behind him and this feels like an awfully unbalanced lot.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Ingenious. How much to sponsor Joseph DelGrippo's page? His OPS+ can't be less than Brandon Woods'.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

I know everyone hates a grammarian, but since you're a professional writer, it's worth mentioning that "comprised" does not mean "composed" and should never be used with "of." And "i.e." means "that is," not "for example." For that, you want "e.g." You can all pile on the dings now.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I believe there may be a fella named Pujols involved in that first base mix, nez pas?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

If I'd known that exhibiting even an iota of athletic ability would have aided me in achieving my goal of being a millionaire, I would have done it.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Right, so instead of "fixing" the perfect DH compromise, how about this: Use executive privilege to put Marvin Miller in the Hall of Fame and apologize to him for taking so long.

Jan 16, 2012 2:12 PM on Bud Selig's To-Do List
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 5

You need to dig deeper to find any "sediment."

Jan 16, 2012 2:07 PM on Bud Selig's To-Do List
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Modern surgical techniques, glasses and contacts do not shrink testicles, reduce impulse control or shorten life spans. The reason steroids and related PEDs are outlawed is that they are harmful to people who use them. We look askance at players who ignore the danger because they create an uneven playing field that forces other players to decide between success in their career and long-term health. I understand why many are dubious about the crimes against the game committed by Clemens, Bonds, McGwire; we're all at least conflicted by the issue. The view you've just expressed though seems willfully ignorant and pollyana.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Dude, you have got to lighten up.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Look Gareth, you're never going to understand baseball writers if you insist on rational thought. That stuff's for cricket and . . . and . . . tea with crumpets.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 10

Maybe not. It might could be.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

"His 409 total bases were the most since Rice's 406 in 1978." Inasmuch as 409 > 406, Walker's 409 total bases were the most since Stan Musial's 426 in 1948.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Not new; just don't keep tabs. Ramadan's actually all over the Roman calendar from year to year. Not implying offense; just having a smile. Merry Christmas to all.

Dec 22, 2011 4:31 PM on Who Yu Gonna Call?
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I believe I suffered testicular torsion while laughing. Fortunately, my wife is a nurse.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

I think you just wished Merry Christmas to a guy named Goldstein. Happy Ramadan too.

Dec 21, 2011 9:18 AM on Who Yu Gonna Call?
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Think how ecstatic you'd be if you were a Pirates fan. At least your wife is homely.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Stay muscular, my friend.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Two consecutive batters . . . in a row? Would that be four straight?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

...which is why they signed him to an incentive-laden, one-year contract with a base cost of a below-average veteran. If he face plants, they have limited liability. His bonuses don't kick in until 450 plate appearances. This deal shines because Sizemore has so much skin in the game. There's a boatload of monetary incentive for him to succeed, a result that is mutually beneficial.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Does Ryne Sandberg have to manage before anyone can correctly spell his name?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

I did an Internet search of "Joe Mauer" and "racist." It turned up nothing connecting the two. You might want to check your sources before reporting such incendiary conjecture.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

I'm no stranger to fossicking through the leftovers for dinner. Sometimes the fossicking is better than others.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

The greatest World Series involved teams you don't care about -- 1991's titanic Braves-Twins tilt. Two worst-to-first teams played five one-run and three extra-inning games. A walk-off ended Game Six and Game 7 went extras. Best ever.

Oct 29, 2011 3:36 PM on A Card Fought Win
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Really? He needs to return his name. What's the world coming to when Ruben Amaro and Jose Bautista are Jewish and David Eckstein and Max Scherzer aren't?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Scherzer versus Feldman -- when was the last time two hurlers from the Twelve Tribes faced off in a playoff? Anyone know? Scherzer pitching to Kinsler -- first since when?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Not to really be that guy, but Swisher and Martin would have affected those games, not effected them.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

That's some mighty 20/20 hindsight there. The Sox entered the season with Lester, Beckett and Buccholz, plus the hope that Lackey would return to form, plus Wakefield and Daisuke, not to mention a strong bullpen led by Bard and Papelbon. There were complaints during Spring Training that the Sox had too many starters and needed to jettison one. I think they added another data point, to their regret, to the notion that there's no such thing as too much pitching.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -4

Steven, I'm surprised that such a dexterous writer as you doesn't know how to use the word "comprised." Never with "of." It is not a synonym for "composed."

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Maybe he should hold the opposition's...

Sep 08, 2011 6:12 PM on The Houston Astros
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

I believe that was a free agent pickup, not a straight trade.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Colin, thank you for an insightful, balanced and educational article. One quibble about this comment: ... and Cubs fans who saw a Tribune company with many millions and no World Series wins were certainly disinterested. Cubs fans are the very opposite of "disinterested," which means "neutral." I think you mean to say they are "uninterested."

Aug 20, 2011 7:32 PM on Multifold Changes
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 5

And yet, mon frere Jivas, you would in 18 words reveal yourself the intellectual superior of most mainstream sports media representatives.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Good catch. This is known in SAFM (Society of American Face Making) circles as "Explosive Self-Reproach."

Aug 02, 2011 2:27 PM on The Error Face
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

So Rizzuto should be in the HOF despite a transparently sub-HOF career because a)he was well-known (Kevin), b)he was an awful announcer (ScottyB) and c)he's a piece of Yankee lore (srguts). Ha, I love irony!

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Earlier this week, Davey Johnson inserted rookie Ryan Mattheus in the bottom of the ninth inning of an 8-8 affair, icing closer Drew Storen for later to convert a possible save. It never came, of course, because Atlanta scratched out the winning run. Game on the line, best pitcher on the bench. What sense does that make? Who knew Davey Johnson's a conventional thinker?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

All ex-post facto explanations. Hard to believe any of them.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

But isn't it possible that Riggleman truly felt the principle was worth more than the extra cash? In a radio interview I heard, he expressed no animosity for team brass, sought no sympathy and seemed content to kick back and watch baseball as a fan. Maybe Jim Riggleman just doesn't need managing that badly.

Jun 24, 2011 5:42 PM on The Hubris of Riggleman
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

How does eleventy billion dollars compare to Albert's MORP?

Jun 18, 2011 6:20 PM on The Carpenter Conundrum
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

That an unrelated variable correlates with lower pitcher ERA doesn't invalidate the correlation between Mathis and lower ERAs. Southpaws have shorter life expectancies than righties. That doesn't invalidate the the causal relationship between tobacco use and life expectancy. I think the causal relationship between Mathis and consistently lower ERAs would have to be classified as unproven but intriguing and possibly significant.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Besides, we're not talking about "players," we're talking about one particular player, who may or may not perform as the average. Don't forget that PECOTA is just a projection; it's predictive only in the aggregate.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

...or perhaps Hudson's newfound baserunning philosophy is his way of informing Twins brass that they might consider inserting their leadoff spot in their colonic orifice.

May 08, 2011 12:55 PM on Year of the Stolen Base?
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Thanks, professor; an intriguing piece. There's a missing element to this calculation, though. Boras seems to represent a self-selected sample of players who want to maximize income and nothing else. My sense is that guys who weigh other factors -- like geography, club loyalty and pennant prospects -- don't join the Boras stable. Consequently, there's a certain apples and oranges comparison, don't you think?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Evidently Joey has column inches to fill, just like the off-line columnists.

Apr 09, 2011 6:39 PM on The Fast Starters
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

This was really fun, though I imagine you could do the same thing with any other number. 2008 - Rays and Phils end their futility, Yanks fail to make playoffs; 1998 - Sosa, McGwire and Flintstones vitamins; '88 - Kirk Gibson's one-legged Series buster, Canseco first to 40/40; '78 - Yanks erase 14-game deficit to Sox, Bucky Dent destroys lives. '68 - historic year of the pitcher, Gibby 1.12, McLain 31 wins, Tigers in dramatic Game 7; etc.

Mar 23, 2011 8:02 PM on Baseball on the Ones
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

With all due respect to Stephen, who's a wonderful writer and a fine baseball mind, I found this piece to be the exact opposite of brilliant. I found it to be long-winded drivel that does an awful job of making a simple point, a point that no one reading this site needs made. Stephen, I love your work, but this was so far beneath your usual standards that I wonder whether Murray Chass, Bruce Jenkins or Dan Shaughnessy hijacked your computer and signed your name to this dreck.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -6

19 Double-A at bats? Please. Wake us up in 50 innings.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

All these finely crafted appelations stand in the shadow of minor leaguer Wonderful Terrific Monds III, son of NFLer Wonderful Jr.

Mar 08, 2011 7:24 PM on What's In A Name?
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

I believe you've just elucidated Tommy's point. Don't know whether to honor you or ding you for that.

Mar 07, 2011 7:18 PM on Jay Another Day
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

I'm sure Indian fans throughout Ohio are ecstatic over Cleveland's payroll efficiency. Isn't that what every fan roots for? Red Sox supporters are, undoubtedly, forlorn over the millions wasted while winning two titles in the last six years.

Feb 27, 2011 6:22 PM on A Measure of Success
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

What's this about Metfans not wanting to watch the games? Who can blame them?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

If you're a Padre fan, they all scare you.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -4

I think he meant "honkies." You'd be worried with a team of all honkies.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

BP + Fangraphs + Tangotiger + all other analytically-bent baseball sites = boon for readers. FIP FIP Fooray!

Jan 27, 2011 3:25 PM on Testing SIERA
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

PT Barnum saw it coming...

Jan 22, 2011 7:19 PM on Junior Circuit Jumble
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

In fact, at the risk of nitpicking a splendid piece, the win expectancy table is a disaster. It says that with two runs in, runners on the corners and no out, the visiting team is a mortal lock to win -- in the first inning! In fact, it claims there are seven first inning scenarios that make victory certain. It says that the visiting team has a 44% chance of winning to start the game, but open with a triple and the win expectancy rockets to 64%. It says that if the visiting team juices the bases with one out and three runs in, it is doomed to defeat. With just a two run lead, it would win 56% of the time and with just a one run lead, it's a 2-1 favorite. This is all patent nonsense, in stark contrast to the rock-solid logic of the accompanying article.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Am I just projecting my own bias or does Prince Albert come across as a guy who might sacrifice a marginal million for less tangible but still important considerations? I have in mind lifestyle issues like comfort with the organization, manager and fans; livability of the city; prospects for the franchise (sorry, Mets); etc. Isn't happiness the ultimate goal? I have trouble imagining there's anything even remotely relevant (to a normal human being, anyway) unavailable to a man with $200 million but within the means of one with $225 million.

Dec 20, 2010 3:25 PM on Pujols' Price Tag
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Miller did far more than increase salaries; he unmade the 100-year bed in which players wallowed in indentured servitude to overlord owners. Before Miller, baseball's labor economics involved a set of monopolist owners and independent contractors with no rights to their place or conditions of employment. Marvin Miller brought the free market to baseball. Every baseball player alive should name his first child Miller.

Dec 14, 2010 5:07 PM on Marvin Miller
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

Failing to elect Marvin Miller into the Hall while honoring Bowie Kuhn is like electing the Washington Generals into the basketball Hall of Fame but not the Harlem Globetrotters. Love him or hate him, Miller had more impact on the game than anyone. Kuhn, on the other hand, was so utterly feckless that he couldn't have gotten elected into the Bowie Kuhn Hall of Fame.

Dec 13, 2010 7:13 PM on Marvin Miller
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 9

A baseball Hall of Fame that includes Bowie Kuhn and not Marvin Miller is like a basketball Hall of Fame that includes the Washington Generals but not the Harlem Globetrotters. Bowie Kuhn was so feckless he shouldn't even be in the Bowie Kuhn Hall of Fame.

Dec 07, 2010 6:15 PM on Refusing to Surrender
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Really intriguing set of articles, Jay. With respect, I'd just note that Steinbrenner *flouted*, not *flaunted* the rules. Flaunting is more the work of, say, Lady Gaga.

Nov 22, 2010 6:57 PM on Billy and George
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

A baseball Hall of Fame without Marvin Miller is like a Civil War Hall of Fame without Robert E. Lee. Miller's exclusion says much more about the sagacity of the voters than about the accomplishments of the man after whom every player should name his first child.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

"Pavano got swings on 35.9 percent of his offerings which were out of the strike zone ... which is something that nobody can reasonably expect to happen again in 2011." I understand the effort to incorporate into our analysis the substantial amount of luck involved in baseball, but that doesn't mean that anything we can't explain must be serendipity. It is possible that Pavano does something to entice hitters to swing at pitches out of the zone. Wasn't that a particular genius of Greg Maddux? Without contradicting your underlying point, it may very well be reasonable to expect Pavano to get swings on 35.9% of his offerings outside the strike zone in 2011.

Nov 20, 2010 7:28 PM on Carl Pavano
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Christina, eschewing the obtuse references and undulating parenthetical statements for ESPN makes your writing so much crisper and reader-friendly, IMHO. I'd love to see more of that snappy writing and less showing off in the future.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Fun piece, and as long as we're admitting semantic pet peeves, Eric, people are "who," not "that."

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

Here's another thing Ken Burns should know better about: Derek Jeter did not dive into the stands to make the now-famous catch to which he refers. Jeter caught the ball on the run and took two steps before -- by his own admission on 60 Minutes -- flinging himself into the stands in the hope of landing in the lap of a seated patron. I challenge anyone to watch the video and reach another conclusion. It's amazing that that myth has become fact just by being repeated endlessly. It's Thomas Crapper inventing the toilet all over again.

Sep 27, 2010 7:35 PM on Ken Burns
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

I think a big helping of humility is essential in reference to any system of projecting human affairs. It's simply not possible to achieve slightly more accuracy than educated guessing. As long as we all -- BP staff particularly -- treat PECOTA as a suggestion rather than as destiny, we'll all be a lot saner. This goes double for Jay's playoff odds.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

In addition, we all tend towards the illusory notion that a team is a single entity over 162 games. Not only do the players come and go, as do lineups, so do their skill sets. Some improve, some tire, some recover from injuries some get figured out. Strategies and approaches change. Weather heats up, then cools off. Like a river, no team is ever exactly the same as it was the day before. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Void where prohibited by law. Member, FDIC.

Sep 24, 2010 11:38 AM on The Half Giants
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Perhaps Reinsdorf had something in his eye when he traded for Ramirez, and didn't notice the dreads. If he didn't want a player with long hair, he should have traded for Tim Hudson.

Sep 13, 2010 6:47 PM on Breaking It Open
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Why is the percentage of fly balls that leave the park considered random? Isn't a fly that goes 400 feet hit harder than one hit 300 feet? I don't see how that's a factor outside the pitcher's control.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

How was Fig "reasonably expected to score 100 runs" if there's no one hitting behind him? Runs is a team event.

Sep 12, 2010 5:57 PM on Man Up, Mariners!
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Very interesting article, thank you Eric. An unsolicited language lesson: least amount = fewer.

Sep 03, 2010 7:15 PM on A Streak of Myers
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

Indeed, the very concept that it's healthy to examine accepted truths is what distinguishes the community of new baseball analysts from the calcified old baseball guard. Bravo to Matt and BP, and the entire sabermetric sector, for always questioning its conclusions and often acknowledging its errors. And let's all keep in mind, particularly when someone posts a respectful dissent, that BP orthodoxy is just as likely as any other to be misguided. A little humility goes a long way.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

You don't believe he quit on the Red Sox? Jay, I'd like to introduce you do reality. Reality, my friend Jay. I see a goodly portion of cognitive dissonance here that prevents you from acknowledging anything that doesn't fit neatly into your worldview. I'm with BP's distrust of mainstream media and of its resistance to assigning personal characteristics based on on-field play. But Ramirez's arm-length baseball rap sheet provides ample evidence that he's a knucklehead.

Sep 01, 2010 2:41 PM on Going, Going, Gone
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

While acknowledging these two comments, it is worth remembering that for most of Ramirez's career, not leveling with the media was tantamount to not leveling with fans. Ramirez has never honestly addressed his PED suspension, his tanking on the Red Sox, his dust-up with their traveling secretary, his commencement appearance with L.A. or any of his other shenanigans. That leaves it to us to draw our own conclusions. The only reasonable conclusion that I can draw is that these actions speak for themselves and that Ramirez is a recidivist jerk.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Jay, I'm not interested in getting into Manny's head; I'm just observing his actions. He's quit on two teams. He's literally gone onto the field of play and refused to try. That would get you, me and everyone reading this fired on the spot.

Sep 01, 2010 8:02 AM on Going, Going, Gone
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Look, I love the BP approach as much as the next guy, but let's not forget that Dodger brass have to work with Ramirez on a daily basis. The guy is a juvenile, narcissistic twit, whose brain, heart, integrity and pride could fit in a sesame seed with enough room left over for two gnats to polka. The Dodgers may not win more games without Ramirez, but they'll sleep better at night, and that's worth something -- at least to them.

Aug 30, 2010 7:24 PM on Going, Going, Gone
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

At the risk of defending the Evil Empire, perhaps their rookies pale because it's especially tough to crack a $200 mil lineup.

Aug 20, 2010 6:49 PM on The Golden Generation
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Corey, Casey; Rodriguez, Ramirez; prodigal, schmodigal. If I had wanted to get my facts straight I wouldn't have become a journalist.

Aug 18, 2010 7:23 PM on Fish Future is Bright
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

So, according to this article, the secrets to Padre success are: 1. A mix of youth and veterans 2. A coaching staff that teaches 3. "Veteran presence." 4. "Good chemistry." Good god. Didn't this site used to be Baseball Prospectus?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

We're all friends here in BPland, StatFreak.

Aug 14, 2010 6:17 PM on Those Who Need Support
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I'm confused: are we unable to write the word douche or dirt? Or was Bonds an a-bag who got demoted three rungs?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Sandoval's name, his home country, the pitching match-up...good to see we're not letting facts get in the way of the column.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

People here in the South who know about New York and Boston primarily from baseball are shocked to discover that they are actually five hours apart. No one in Atlanta thinks Charleston, SC -- five hours away -- is a neighbor.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Gentlemen, this is a red herring argument. There are plenty of intra-league non-rivalries too. Who's clamoring for the Brewers-Padres tilt, or the Philly-Phoenix face-off? You don't like Marlins-Twins or Pirates-Mariners, but the equally desultory Marlins-Pirates and Twins-Mariners match-ups are scheduled annually.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

That's a boatload of words dedicated to almost entirely dismissing JA Happ, except when you patronize him as a fourth starter. Really? In 217 early career innings he's 14-5 3.11 with 5.5 WARP while pitching in a launching pad. What I know about scouting pitchers could fit in a thimble without spilling, but it seems to me that Wade has finally achieved blind squirrel syndrome, picking up Happ and his years of pre-arb goodness, two potential studs and a significantly fatter bank account for a great talent who would have been wasted in the dying embers of the franchise. At least now there's hope in Houston for 2013.

Jul 29, 2010 7:29 PM on Texas Fold 'Em
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

To add a liberal arts addendum to this insight, Wells and Silva, and to a lesser degree Radke, demonstrated only one skill -- avoiding walks. What Schilling, Maddux, et. al. accomplished is much more impressive because they combined an ability to fan batters with keen command. That's why, as gmolyneaux notes, 150/11 outshines 58/4.

Jul 14, 2010 5:38 PM on K/BB Ratio Redux
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Ditto on the first point. The Braves need another low-power outfielder like I need more ear hair.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

Why would Seattle balk at trading within their division? If they're pawning off Lee, they've jettisoned this season, so they don't care if Texas improves vis-a-vis Anaheim or Oakland. Lee is a free agent at season's end, so unless he re-signs with the trading partner, that team is diminished next year and in the future while Seattle has three or four of their prospects. It seems to me, the M's should be courting an AL West suitor.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -2

I don't know how anyone can compile a list of best baseball announcers without Boog Sciambi and Gary Cohen. It's like omitting U2, the Beatles and the Who from your best rock 'n' roll band list.

Jul 02, 2010 10:11 AM on MLB Radio Broadcasters
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Moreover, there is an argument opportunity savings that probably eradicates the entire time cost of the review. Lou Pinella can't kick dirt and throw a base in under three minutes.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -2

Everything okay at home, amazin? You're a bit tart lately.

Jun 25, 2010 8:24 PM on Friday Update
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

The 1906 Pirates probably deserve a footnote. Their 93-60 campaign was a pale shadow of Chicago's astounding 116-36 mark. Going back one place in the standings, the Phils were eliminated in early August and came up 45.5 games short. Break up the Cubs!

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

"...the BBWAA electorate may have been something of a wise crowd all along." ...Or, the blind squirrel syndrome is at work and the place is littered with acorns.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Good point. The bigger question is, after they pay Gonzalez, can they pay anyone else? If not, why would he want to sign long-term for a team that won't compete?

May 01, 2010 6:15 PM on Friday Update
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

I've always thought that a thumbnail approach to determining the quality of a team is find an average player on the roster and figure out where he fits. If he's batting fifth, enjoy your high draft pick. If he's on the bench, welcome to the Bronx.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Todd Hundley and the nine dwarfs. Should we still like Ike?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -5

"...the Yankees have essentially been run as a loss leader for the ATM machine that is the YES Network." An "ATM machine" would be an automated teller machine machine. Much in the vein of "OPEC countries," "PIN numbers" and "please RSVP," it is redundant and repetitive.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

There's another great American trait: ingenuity!

Mar 22, 2010 6:53 PM on There Goes My Hero
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

I'd like to hear about the scenario that gets the Mets 92 wins. Albert Pujols defects to Queens and takes the Braves rotation with him?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Moreoever, since PECOTA is a projection system based on historical context, and you've just demonstrated that there's no historical context for what Wright has done, PECOTA is probably the wrong tool for this job. I'll go with guessing, in keeping with the Mets' general human resources strategy.

Mar 03, 2010 7:39 PM on Power Sapped
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -2

The humility underlying this piece was refreshing. Great job, Matt.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

IIRC, the Giants are banking on the argument that Lincecum is not an exceptional case, and thus his salary should not be subject to free market forces. This is more a philosophical difference than a difference in linear value, which gives the team at least a hook to hang it hat on in arbitration. I don't see that bucket holding any water with a reasonable arbitrator, but maybe SF brass does.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

The problem with this system is that it measures "most cost-effective" GM not necessarily "best" GM. Brian Cashman isn't paid to be cost-effective; he's paid to win the most games. If the Yankees need to double everyone else's payroll to win the East by one game, that's success to them.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Good point. Moreover, there seems to be little prejudice against bad by first basemen and slugging outfielders; why do we hold *no* defense against a DH? Isn't a DH who gives up no runs in the field less of an albatross than a Dr. Strangeglove at another position?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Just want to add my sadness at Joe's departure and echo the sentiment that I hope it's for better opportunities and not because of a squabble. Joe, write when you get work...

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

...and while you're at it, tell us how a .323 OBP (Dawson) and a .339 OBP (Parker) feels like a Hall of Famer. Just for perspective, here are some notables who accumulated OBP higher than .323 this year: Clete Thomas, Chris Getz, Gerardo Parra, Alex Gordon, Felix Pie, Freddy Sanchez and, well, you get the picture.

Dec 29, 2009 7:09 PM on Weekend Update
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Also, calling Cabrera the Yankees' "anchor" is a little jarring. We know what you mean -- that he dragged the rest of the team down -- but we usually use "anchor" to mean the linchpin around which everything else works. He was more like the team's dead weight.

Dec 24, 2009 1:27 PM on Midweek Update
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

Well I'll be darned. Looked it up and the etymology of the word is as a noun meaning "ten thousand." I stand corrected ... for the myriadth time.

Dec 24, 2009 6:12 AM on Junior Circuit Jumble
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Christina, I know that as a wordsmith you'll want to know that "myriad" means "countless." Gonzalez had "myriad hurts," not "a myriad of hurts." And the rest of you can save you minus button the workout. I know you don't care about proper usage, but Christina does.

Dec 23, 2009 5:34 PM on Junior Circuit Jumble
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 8

The Mets share very few of the Yankees' advantages. Though they play in NY, they don't have generational fans in New Jersey, Connecticut and the northern suburbs. They lack the Yankees' history; there are no '27 Mets. They lack the Yankees' cache. In short, the Mets are a big market team. The Yankees are a singular franchise with advantages at every level.

Dec 22, 2009 7:41 PM on The Braves' New World
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Quit beating around the bush, Joe. Tell us how you really feel.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I believe Billy Beane allowed Michael Lewis to give away the recipe to his success, and now he's just a smart GM empty pockets.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -3

See ya.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Where Aybar was physically located was irrelevant. He could have fallen on his face at second base and never gotten up; he was still awarded third the moment Hunter earned the walk. The umps -- and Fox -- blew it. I'm surprised that no one else is picking up on it since it was determinative.

Oct 19, 2009 10:08 AM on Absent Without Leave
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Thanks Joe. My interpretation of that rule is that the runners get one base, which would bring Aybar home and set up second and third. At the moment that the ball went into the stands, Aybar had already earned third, Figgins second and Hunter first. I think the umps blew it and cost the Angels a run -- and the game.

Oct 18, 2009 5:21 PM on Absent Without Leave
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Why did the ball caroming off Molina and into the stands save the Yankees? Can someone explain that rule, if in fact it exists? It seems to me that, like an errant throw that goes into the stands, the wild pitch allows each runner to advance one base. Since the runners achieved first, second and third by dint of the walk, why didn't the run score on the wild pitch?

Oct 18, 2009 12:12 PM on Absent Without Leave
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

Joe, in case you're feeling friendless and alone, despair not. I enjoyed your insights and have no interest in serving as your assignment editor. On the other hand, doesn't *everyone* make the WNBA playoffs?

Oct 04, 2009 6:45 PM on Do or Die
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Who's debating the MVP race? No reputable baseball analyst I've heard has suggested anyone but Mauer.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

No question. The pioneers are the guys with the arrows in their backs.

Sep 17, 2009 8:17 PM on Closing Out Closing
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

An ironic little typo on "good," eh?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -7

...an anemic offense largely comprised of over-the-hill veterans... Goode writers know that "comprised" is not a synonym for "composed." Individuals comprise a group; a group is composed of individuals. I enjoy your articles. Here's your chance to improve as a writer.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

Maybe he's a card in the clubhouse. Someone to be dealt with. Hehe.

Sep 06, 2009 4:37 PM on Weekend Update
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Nelson, Kim and Marmol are in a different class than those around them in the contact-free zone. Benitez, Gagne, et. al. avoided contact by evading bats. Nelson, Kim and Marmol make the list because they evaded the strike zone and and found body parts. It's the difference between being highly effective and, whoa, Nellie!!

Sep 03, 2009 7:27 PM on No Contact Allowed
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

Actually, Jeter didn't dive into the stands. If you view that video carefully, you'll see that Jeter caught the ball on the field and took two steps before vaulting (by his own admission) into the seats in the hope that seated fans would catch him. But that inconvenient truth undermines the more compelling narrative that has become conventional ignorance and hero worship. Seems to me that a surefire Hall of Famer doesn't need his reputation burnished beyond reality.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

You're proposing a free market approach to an industry that doesn't operate in a free market. The anti-trust exemption, the national labor market/local revenue conundrum and the nearly absolute barrier to entry into the industry -- to name just three issues -- make baseball unique and require solutions that transcend simple free market tactics.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Both these responses miss the point: PECOTA tells us pretty close to nothing that we don't already know. A five percent improvement on my best guess about a player is hardly worth the time. I don't need PECOTA's help getting 75% of performance projections wrong. Moreover, BP authors often rely on PECOTA to evaluate signings, trades, etc., as if PECOTA is destiny. It's still a pretty weak predictor. None of this should be construed as a repudiation of the work done at BP. One can be a fan without being blind to the flaws. A little humility when it comes to predicting performance is indicated here.

Aug 06, 2009 7:08 PM on PECOTA's Wild Pitches
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -10

What these articles really demonstrate, it seems to me, is the futility of PECOTA. I appreciate your willingness to expose the system's warts, but when it can't predict 75% of hitters within 10 points either way of EQA and 75% of pitchers within .33 of EqERA, the system is somewhere in the vicinity of pointless. That PECOTA is the best of the projection systems tells us that, even with all the great research being done, computers still can't predict player performance any better than can a reasonably sentient fan. With all due respect, BP authors ought to keep that in mind when the urge arises to treat PECOTA projections as inevitable.

Aug 05, 2009 6:29 PM on PECOTA's Wild Pitches
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

This is outstanding research. In time it will have far-reaching consequences refining Pythagorean accounting. Encore!

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 7

Don't forget Minaya's handling of Willie Randolph's firing. If I recall correctly, it was executed in the middle of the night while on a West Coast road trip after Willie had been publicly hung out to dry for weeks.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

"First baseman Russell Branyan has a .325 EqA after be signed as a free agent..." "Griffey keeps him loose but constantly tickling him..." "They sparked fan outrage last month when by trading center fielder Nate McLouth..." Editor take the day off?

Jul 19, 2009 2:02 PM on The Weekend Wrap
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

That would put you in a very small minority, both among Met fans and lovers of baseball generally. He's generally considered one of the top play-by-play guys by fans and media alike. An internet search of his name demonstrates that. You have the right to your opinion, but it's not broadly shared.

Jul 11, 2009 7:02 PM on Revenue Sharing
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 6

After Wieters, MIT is the Georgia Tech of the north.

May 29, 2009 2:38 PM on The First Coming
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -2

As long as you're evaluating writing, it's germane to note violations of grammar, usage and syntax. I know that many of you baseball fans won't care, but writers should. To wit: 1. People are "who;" things are "that." You can't say "the pitcher that has an ERA..." 2. I.e. means "in other words." If you mean "for example," use e.g. This applies to most BP authors as well as Byron and Brittany.

May 24, 2009 7:47 PM on Getting Hip with FIP
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Veeck and Dan, thanks for setting me straight. Still seems like, from a public policy perspective, a terrible waste to abandon a 20-year-old building.

May 24, 2009 6:43 AM on November 6-18
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I'm going to change my name to Mario Mendoza and...oh...nevermind.

May 22, 2009 6:37 PM on Big Red
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Am I the only one who wonders why an expansion franchise needs a new stadium? I understand the Trop is a tissue box, but it was built specifically for the Rays, no? Are adjoining municipalities really stupid enough to bite on a hook that was similarly baited just 11 years ago?

May 22, 2009 6:32 PM on November 6-18
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 1

He'll come nowhere near plugging the whole created by Manny's suspension. He may plug the hole though.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 4

He may or may not be hung. Your fictional Gammons would want him hanged.

May 07, 2009 2:48 PM on Your Mileage May Vary
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Yankee Stadium is an ATM machine? That made me LOL out loud. I'm going AWOL without leave after reading that. I'd like to invite you along, if you would please RSVP. We'll go to an OPEC country and read BP Prospectus from there. :)

Apr 30, 2009 8:23 PM on Yankee Ticket Pricing
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Could be a Phyrric string of victories if the M's contend through the summer by smoke and mirrors only to fade in the fall along with any chance to cash in the free agents for prospects. The underlying truth hasn't changed: this is a woebegone team.

Apr 27, 2009 8:04 PM on Short-Stack Supremacy
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Nice writing, Ben.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

I'll tell you one thing that has been lost with the demise of newspapers -- facility with the language in print. Good editors don't let trite cliches like "thinking outside the box" see the light of day, particularly trite cliches that mean "the kind of thinking that would never produce trite cliches." Newspaper editors also don't allow mention of "mediums" when discussing "media." "Mediums" are people who see dead relatives, or shirts that are neither smalls nor larges. I dearly love BP, but wish you all were more careful with your writing. By accepting the degradation of English, you are contributing to it.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

Can a White Sox pitching staff that sports John Danks, Gavin Floyd, Mark Buehrle and Bobby Jenks really be expected to surrender 828 runs in the flaccid AL Central? I have trouble seeing them among the worst teams in baseball. Am I alone?

Apr 02, 2009 7:23 PM on The Bottom Ten
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

While we're on the subject, how about everyone at BP using the word "comprised" correctly? It is not a replacement for "composed." Members comprise a group; a group is composed of its members. Never use "comprised" with "of."

Mar 27, 2009 1:39 PM on Redemption
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

...which is a good sign if you're a Saux partisan. In fact, their depth is part of the reason they're forecast for supremacy.

Mar 09, 2009 6:16 PM on Irreplaceable
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 0

That the Giants are slotting an untested, 5-11, 246-pound, 22-year-old third in the lineup is all you need to know about their pennant hopes. This team could take batting practice in the lobby of the Waldorf without shattering glass.* *Not an original description

Feb 11, 2009 7:40 PM on Giant Expectations?
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

Asking who is going to close for the Mariners is like asking how an elephant\'s going to ring the bell on his bicycle without any thumbs. It\'s moot: there won\'t be any leads to protect. The key question is, how in God\'s name are they going to score runs?

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 3

It seems that external factors beyond the reach of Joe\'s sabermetric analysis are the cause of their continuing free agency. From what I understand Dunn won\'t sign as a DH and Manny wants a contract that may outlast his motivation. Moreover, signing an inert DH limits a team\'s flexibility and can cause a cascade of roster problems that leave an offensive wet noodle playing in the field.

Jan 30, 2009 12:40 PM on The Designated Whatever
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -3

You say that as if it\'s a bad thing.

Jan 15, 2009 8:01 PM on Bad Timing
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -14

John, I eagerly await your pieces and appreciate your work. As a writer, you should know how to use the word \"comprised.\" Please look it up and use it correctly. Misuse undermines your credibility, which is otherwise considerable.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

You know your team is in trouble when its braintrust is busy rearranging the deck chairs so that Jose Lopez can play first and Jeff Clement can DH. Put Mario Mendoza on speed dial.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

David, the word \"comprised\" is not a synonym for \"composed.\" A group is composed of individuals. Individuals comprise the group. Never use \"comprised\" with \"of.\" Tell your BP mates.

Dec 16, 2008 2:23 PM on June 22-23, 2001
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

This whole discussion assumes that defensive metrics are worth the electrons they consume. I have always been, and remain, highly dubious.

 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: -1

This is a straw man argument in that Jack Morris is -- I would venture an educated guess -- a consensus non-Famer, at least among BP readers and writers. Joe, you could do much more of a service by comparing Mussina to a second-tier HOFer so that we could really determine his bona fides.

Nov 24, 2008 11:42 AM on Moose Tracks
 
WaldoInSC
(26415)
Comment rating: 2

The Volquez-Hamilton trade was a win-win only in the sense that a bald man trading Rogaine for a silver-handled comb is a winner. The Rangers need another bat like I need another wife. Their offense could take them to the playoffs if they could manage to identify and keep a couple of decent starters. In Volquez, they had at least one piece of the Holy Grail, but they auctioned it off for yet more power hitting. Josh Hamilton is a nice story, but a pennant would make baseball fans in Dallas a lot happier.

Sep 26, 2008 7:36 PM on The Gap