From The Mailbag
Search From The Mailbag
All Blogs (including podcasts) Select a blog All Podcasts Analyze This B-Warned Baseball Prospectus Book News Baseball Prospectus Press Release Between The Numbers BP Announcements BP Beta Blog BP Daily Podcast BP Fantasy Podcast BP Job Postings BP on SiriusXM BP Podcast BP Unfiltered Collateral Damage DFA Podcast Fantasy Beat Fantasy Hour Flags Fly Forever Podcast Fringe Average Podcast From the Editor's Desk Future Shock Blog Inside The Park Blog Joe's Blog Limited Range Podcast Minor Issues Minor League Update No Pepper One-Hoppers Raw Projection Tater Trot Tracker The BP First Take The Guidance Counselor The Wayback Blog TINO (There Is No Offseason) TINSTAAPP Transaction Analysis Blog Wezen-Ball What You Missed Winter Meetings You Can Blog It Up Active Columns Select a column 2015 Prospects 2016 Prospects 2017 Prospects 5 O'Clock Power 6-4-3 Advance Scouting Series Ahead in the Count All-Star Futures Game All-Star Game All-Star Game Preview All-Star Home Run Derby An Agent's Take Answer Man Arbitration Showdown Arizona Fall League Recap Banished To The Pen Banjo Hitter Baseball ProGUESTus Baseball Prospectus Basics Baseball Prospectus News Baseball Therapy Behind the Curtain Best of BP 2015 Best of BP 2016 Bizball BP Experts Prospect Mock Draft Breaking Balls Bullpen Report Campus Notes Caught Looking Changing Speeds Cheese in the Kitchen Circle Change Closer Report Cold Takes Collateral Damage Collateral Damage Daily Contractual Matters Covert OPS Daily League Strategy Daily Roundup Daisy Cutter Deep Impact Deep League Report Deep, But Playable Dissecting the Draft Divide and Conquer, AL Central Divide and Conquer, AL East Divide and Conquer, NL Central Divide and Conquer, NL East Divide and Conquer, NL West Doctoring The Numbers Don't Believe the Hype Draft Ten Pack Ducks on the Pond Dynasty Dynamics Dynasty League Positional Rankings Dynasty League Positional Rankings Continued Early ADP Analysis Every Team's Moneyball Everyone's Perfect Everything You Could Have Learned This Week Expanded Horizons Expert FAAB Review Expert League Auction Recap Expert League Draft Recap Eyewitness Accounts Fantasy Auction Values Fantasy Bargains and Busts Fantasy Beat Fantasy Categorical Breakdowns Fantasy Draft Rankings Fantasy Focus Fantasy Fool's Gold Fantasy Freestyle Fantasy Infographic Fantasy Mailbag Fantasy Players to Avoid Fantasy Players to Target Fantasy Rounders Fantasy Starting Pitcher Planner Fantasy Team Preview Fantasy Three-Year Projections Fantasy Tiered Rankings Feature Focus Field Generals Fifth Column Five to Watch Flu-Like Symptoms Free Agent Watch From The Mailbag Future Shock Game Reaction Get to Know Glass Cuts Diamond Going Yard Graphical Fantasy Rankings Grumblings from a Surly Sabermetrician Guarding The Lines Head Games Heartburn Hardball Hot Stove Scouting Report In A Pickle In-Season Fantasy Valuations Inside The Park Interleague Report Internet Baseball Awards Let It Eat Lies, Damned Lies Life at the Margins Liner Notes Long Relief Looking Back on Tomorrow Manufactured Runs Memorial Day Remembrance Mid-season Prescriptions Minor Issues Minor League Update MLBDepthCharts Monday Morning Ten Pack Moonshot My Model Portfolio New Arms Ninety Percent Mental Notes About Baseball Notes from the Field On A Jailbreak On the Beat One Move Outta Left Field Overthinking It Painting the Black Pebble Hunting Perfect Game Presents Pitcher Profile PITCHf/ox PITCHf/x Mailbag PITCHf/x Profile Pitching Backward Player Profile Players Prefer Presentation Playing Time Battles Playoff Odds Update Playoff Prospectus Position Battles Potential Impact Call-Ups Pre-Season Positional Rankings Preseason Value Picks Prospect Debate Prospect House Prospect Profile Prospect Push Prospects Will Break Your Heart Prospectus Feature Prospectus Game of the Week Prospectus Hit and Run Prospectus Perspective Prospectus Playoff Quickie Prospectus Preview Prospectus Profile Prospectus Q&A Prospectus Review Prospectus Roundtable Prospectus Today Punk Hits Purpose Pitches Raising Aces Rany On The Royals Reintroducing PECOTA Release Points Research Mailbag Resident Fantasy Genius Retro Transaction Analysis Retrospective Player Valuation Reworking WARP Roto Restart Rubbing Mud Rumor Roundup Scouting the Draft Seidnotes Short Relief Skewed Left Sobsequy Soft Toss Some Projection Left Spinning Yarn Spitballing Sporer Report State of the Position Swing Change Tale of the Tape Tale of the Tape, Dynasty Edition TDGX Transactions Team Chemistry Team Health Reports Team Injury Projection The -Only League Landscape The Adjuster The Asian Equation The BP Broadside The BP Trading Post The BP Wayback Machine The Buyer's Guide The Call-Up The Column to Be Named Later The Daily Prospectus The Darkhorses The Fantasy Verdict The Great Debaters The Jong Show The Keeper Reaper The Landscape The Lineup Card The Other 15 Percent The Over/Underachievers The Payoff Pitch The Platoon Advantage The Process The Prospectus Hit List The Quinton The Stash List The Stats Go Marching In The Things We Believe The View From Behind The Backstop The View from the Loge Level The Week in Quotes They Hold No Quarter This is Not Your Father's Baseball Road Trip Tools of Ignorance Top 10 Week Top Tools Transaction Analysis TTO Scoresheet Podcast Two-Strike Approach Under The Knife Updating the Tiers UTK Special Value Picks Weekly Planner Weekly Wrap Welcome to Splitsville West Coast By Us Western Front Wezen-Ball Extra What Scouts Are Saying What You Need to Know Working the Count You Could Look It Up Youth Movement Authors Select an author Peter Abraham Jim Albert Martin Alonso Colin Anderle Mark Anderson R.J. Anderson Cee Angi Bradley Ankrom Jorge Arangure Jr. Robert Arthur Nick Ashbourne Julien Assouline Nick Bacarella Emma Baccellieri Bill Baer Tim Baffoe Jim Baker Mike Banghart Javier Barragan Pete Barrett Mark Barry Michael Bates Michael Baumann Stephani Bee Jesse Behr Hudson Belinsky Demetrius Bell Alex Belth Isaac Bennett Tommy Bennett Jonah Birenbaum Justin Birnbaum Nathan Bishop George Bissell Mo Bjonski Tucker Blair Michael Bradburn Bennett Brauer Riley Breckenridge J.P. Breen Tim Britton Shawn Brody Dan Brooks Maury Brown Craig Brown David Brown Lance Brozdowski Evan Brunell Jon Bruschke William Burke Matthew Callan Nick Canelas Marc Carig Russell A. Carleton Will Carroll Ben Carsley Derek Carty Alex Chamberlain Clint Chisam John Choiniere Dave Church Jason Churchill Michael Clair Ben Cohen Jason Cole Bryan Cole Jason Collette Matt Collins Tim Collins Jack Conness John Coppolella Leigh Coridan Brett Cowett Mary Craig Christopher Crawford Zach Crizer Keith Cromer Mike Curto Jeff Dahn Clay Davenport Evan Davis Ryan Davis Corey Dawkins Zach Day Brandon Decker Scott Delp Rocco DeMaro Neil deMause Thomas Desmidt Nathan Desutter Ben Diamond Austin Diamond Nick Dika Ryan Divish Bradford Doolittle Evan Drellich Henry Druschel Patrick Dubuque Kenny Ducey Brian Duricy Patrick Ebert Matt Ellis Cam Ellis John Erhardt John Eshleman Jeff Euston Dan Evans Sarah Evans Nick J. Faleris BP Fantasy Staff Mike Fast James Fegan Kate Feldman Andrew Felper Sam Fels Hunter Felt Chad Finn Tim Finnegan Chaz Fiorino Frank Firke James Fisher Clark Fosler Adam Foster Dan Fox Ian Frazer Eugene Freedman Jeffrey A. Friedman Ken Funck Iain Fyffe Brent S. Gambill Perfect Game Jake Garcia Cat Garcia Eric Garcia McKinley Jim Gardner Eriq Gardner Andrew Gargano Brendan Gawlowski Maiya Gessling Mike Gianella Steve Givarz Craig Glaser Rebecca Glass Conor Glassey Aaron Gleeman Clark Goble Todd Gold Mitch Goldich Steven Goldman Craig Goldstein Greg Goldstein Kevin Goldstein Jordan Gorosh Stacey Gotsulias Nathan Graham Noah Grand Larry Granillo Garrett Greeby Morris Greenberg Jeremy Greenhouse Bryan Grosnick Brian Gunn Matt Gwin Parker Hageman Will Haines Jonathan Hale Joe Hamrahi Glenn Healey Brandon Heipp Octavio Hernandez Bob Hertzel Josh Herzenberg Tom Hitchner Shawn Hoffman Randy Holt Andrew Hopen Tony Horwitz Scooter Hotz Kit House Joshua Howsam Gary Huckabay Steven Jacobson Derek Jacques Jay Jaffe J.J. Jansons Rany Jazayerli Max Jensen Bryan Joiner Grant Jones Michael Jong Jonathan Judge Christina Kahrl Sky Kalkman Alex Kantecki Gabe Kapler Wilson Karaman Len Kasper King Kaufman Adam Kaufman Jeff Kensrud Jonah Keri Kevin Kerrane Daniel Kim Chris King Tim Kniker Eric Knott Andrew Koo Matthew Kory Jesse Krailler Kourage Kundahl Joshua Kusnick Pat Lackey Chris Lamberti Eric Lang Will Larson David Laurila Keith Law David Lee Ian Lefkowitz David Lesky Zachary Levine Ryan Lind Ben Lindbergh M.J. Lloyd Jeff Long Lee Lowenfish Jen Mac Ramos Graham MacAree Daniel Mack Rich MacLeod Brian MacPherson Rob Mains Erik Malinowski Dan Malkiel Tim Malone Tim Malone Elliot Mann Samuel Mann Max Marchi Annie Maroon Jason Martinez Leo Martinic Kyle Matte Gregory J. Matthews Andy McCullough Rachael McDaniel Kiley McDaniel Adam McInturff Rob McQuown Andrew Mearns Howard Megdal Chris Mellen Dan Mennella Eric Mercer Dave Metz Sam Miller Ian Miller Jake Mintz Guy Molyneux Jeff Moore Jack Moore Chad Moriyama Ryan Morrison Kate Morrison Zach Mortimer Chris Mosch Zack Moser Ben Murphy David Murphy Alan M. Nathan C.J. Nitkowski Marc Normandin Josh Norris Sara Novic Sean O'Rourke Josh Paley Dustin Palmateer Pete Palmer Doug Pappas Jason Paré Ryan Parker Bill Parker Jason Parks John Paschal Mike Passador Brice Paterik Jeffrey Paternostro Andrew Patrick Harry Pavlidis Jeff Pease Dave Pease Andrew Pentis John Perrotto Mike Petriello Evan Petty Nick Piecoro Frankie Piliere David Pinto Lewie Pollis Jeff Polman Carlos Portocarrero Kate Preusser Satchel Price Mark Primiano BP Prospect Staff Baseball Prospectus Matthew Provenzano Matt Pullman Ethan Purser Alex Putterman Jeff Quinton Jessica Quiroli Tammy Rainey David Raposa Daniel Rathman David Rawnsley Dave Raymond Stephen Reichert Anthony Rescan Kristy Robinson Matthew Rocco Chris Rodriguez Jon Roegele Kendall Rogers David Roher Ryan Romano Eric Roseberry C. Trent Rosecrans David Roth Erich Rothmann Andrew Rothstein Meg Rowley Dan Rozenson Seth Rubin Mauricio Rubio Jeff Sackmann Hunter Samuels Drew Samuelson Bret Sayre Nick Schaefer Larry Schechter JH Schroeder Ryan Schultz Ken Schultz Tom Scocca Clint Scoles BP Scoresheet Experts Steffan Segui Jarrett Seidler Eric Seidman Timo Seppa Ron Shah Sahadev Sharma Joe Sheehan Josh Shepardson Jon Shepherd Tom Shieber Nick Shlain Jordan Shusterman Nate Silver Scott Simon Allan Simpson Paul Singman Will Siskel Alex Skillin Al Skorupa Hayley Slye Sean Smith Lloyd Smith Bryan Smith Jenn Smith James Smyth Adam Sobsey Mike Sonne Ethan Spalding Emma Span Alex Speier Paul Sporer Chris St. John BP Staff Tim Steggall Nicolas Stellini Dan Strafford Dan Strafford Michael Street Brandon Stroud Trevor Strunk Dave Studeman Matt Sussman Daron Sutton Matt Swartz Cecilia M. Tan BP Stats Team Chris Teeter David Temple Doug Thorburn Dash Treyhorn Matthew Trueblood Gideon Turk Dan Turkenkopf Ashley Varela Seth Victor Rob Vollman Mike Vorkunov Elie Waitzer Stuart Wallace Jim Walsh Rob Warmowski Brandon Warne Rian Watt Matt Welch Greg Wellemeyer Holly Wendt Michael Wenz Nick Wheatley-Schaller Kevin Whitaker Collin Whitchurch Rob Willer Charlie Wilmoth Ezra Wise Greg Wisniewski CJ Wittmann Brad Wochomurka Jason Wojciechowski Will Woods Noah Woodward Kathy Woolner Keith Woolner Josh Worn Miles Wray Colin Wyers Jared Wyllys Jared Wyllys Austin Yamada Kazuto Yamazaki Colin Young Geoff Young Clarissa Young Jonathan Zeller Nicholas Zettel Shiyuan Zhao Derek Zumsteg Article Types Select an article type Free Articles Fantasy Articles Premium Articles All BP Articles Archives
0 From The Mailbag: Four Man Rotation, Upton, Rust Belt by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Cubans, Standards of Greatness, and Hockey Hair by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: JAWS, Revenue Sharing, and Sandwich Picks by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: No Power, FRAA, AgeGate, and Ballooning ERAs by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Hit List, WXRL, King Felix, Injury Prediction, The Twins by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: MLVr, VORP, BABIP, WXRL, Stadiums, and the Dessert Cart by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: The Flat Earth Society, Win Expectancies, Running Wild, and Baseball Rhymin' by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Crooked Numbers, LABR, JAWS, and Top Prospect Rankings by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Feedback on the Feedback by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Questec, Park Factors and Transactions Galore by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Subluxations, The Pitcher's Mound and J.T. Snow by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Bunts, Arms and Outs by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Unearned Runs, Devil Rays, and the Waiver Wire by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Internet Baseball Awards Edition by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Controversy at Fenway by Jason Grady
0 From The Mailbag: Halladay, Gagne, Ichiro, and GWHBPRBI by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Stats, Roster Shuffling, and Padres Injuries by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Caught Stealing Numbers, Hitting it on the Screws, and Tony Gwynn by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Tout Wars, Pulled Groins, and The Four-Man Rotation Debate Continues by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Rick Peterson, Assorted Injuries, and the Devil Rays by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Bartolo Colon, George W. Bush, and the Newly Important All-Star Game by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Barry Bonds, the AFL, and Bob Klapisch Responds by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Pete Rose, Mike Marshall, and K-Rod by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Baseball Prospectus by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Greatest Living Pitcher and Sadaharu Oh by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: BP2002, Revenue Sharing, and Jack Morris by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: The Man With The Golden Gun by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: The Debate Continues by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Transactions Feedback by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Stadia, Transactions Fun, and Ben Davis by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Free Erubiel Durazo! by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Ramon Martinez, Freon Deion, and Albert Pujols by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Management, Homework, and Frank Thomas by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Special Edition: Top 40 Prospects by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Special Edition: Pitching and Defense by Voros McCracken and Keith Woolner
0 From The Mailbag: Dave Parker and Box O'Rocks by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: The Hall Of Fame by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Baseball Prospectus 2001 and Managerial Retreads by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Umpire Stolen Base Rates and Scott Sheldon by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Shortstop defense and The Imbalance Sheet by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Tony Perez, Ed Lynch, and Jay Canizaro by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Orthodoxy, All-Stars, Mariners and Rockies by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: The Strike Zone Revisited, September in Sydney by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: The Strike Zone, Old Books and Sammy Sosa by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Spanning the Northeast by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Wrigley Field, Scabs, and Curt Schilling by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Pat Burrell, Park Effects, and Rohypnol by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: DiMaggio vs. Williams, Davenport Translations, More Mets Fun by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Gerut vs. Clemente, Hampton vs. Dotel, Gord Ash vs. Chris Kahrl by Baseball Prospectus
0 From The Mailbag: Ben Christensen and Neifi Perez by Baseball Prospectus
BP staffers reach into the mailbag to address the four-man rotation, B.J. Upton's service time, the postseason odds report, Frank Thomas, and more.
This is a BP Premium article. To read it,
sign up for Premium today!
March 22, 2006 12:00 am
BP Staffers reach into the mailbag to discuss Cuban performance, two upcoming Hall of Fame cases, the Pirates' front office, and steroids in other sports.
Rolling Some Cubans
You wrote this article a year or so ago and I found
it incredibly interesting at the time. As I was watching the
in the World Baseball Classic tournament I couldn't help but think back to this research and
wanted to get your impressions.
December 22, 2005 12:00 am
BP staffers address reader mail about JAWS, revenue sharing, and the confusing rules of the sandwich round.
Worst of the Best
I like your articles looking at the Hall of Fame ballot each year, but
I disagree with some of your methods. It isn't the JAWS score but that
you use the average of all HOFers, dropping the worst
ones. Players who meet these standards are obviously in, the
standards that need to be met are those of the borderline guys.
Read the full article...
This is a BP Premium article. To read it,
sign up for Premium today!
September 26, 2005 12:00 am
BP staffers answer questions on outfield power droughts, weighing EqA against fielding, young pitchers and ERA spikes.
, the White Sox left fielder, is about to go homerless with
more than 500 at bats for the season! Does anyone know if a regular
left fielder has ever done this before?
Scott Podsednik The remainder of this post cannot be viewed at this subscription level. Please click here to subscribe. BP staffers reach into the mailbag to talk King Felix, WXRL usage, Hit List construction and more.
The Angels have a better record than the A's, a better record for the
week against better opponents, and a better run differential for the
season, yet you list the A's higher and have them going up. I know I am
biased for the Angels but how do you explain your ranking without
Read the full article... Keith Woolner, Steven Goldman, Jonah Keri and Neil deMause reach into the mailbag to address questions on using stats, pitching performances, stadium financing, and local broadcasters.
I was wondering something
MLVr. I always see players plugged into a
lague average team whenever it is used, but can you plug Player X into
a current team (say, put
in the place
of Lyle Overbay in the Red
Sox order) and still have the results work? It seems like it would
no problem, but I just wanted to make sure there was no reason that
alluded me as to why it may not work.
Kevin Millar Read the full article...
Jay Jaffe, Keith Woolner, James Click and Jonah Keri reach into the mailbag and address win expectancies, the stathead revolution, the running game, gambling, and...scrabble? Plus, a reader known only as "J.S." offers Steven Goldman (if that is his real name) some more conspiracy fuel for the fire.
James Click, Jonah Keri and Jay Jaffe reach into the BP mailbag. Plus, a reader does some research and gives us a grade on our Prospect Rankings.
October 15, 2004 12:00 am
What do the D.C. Expos, surprising seasons and infield singles have in common? Just the readers' interest.
As a longtime D.C.-area resident, I seriously doubt deMause's breakdown of the fan base. deMause claims that D.C. is the 'region's entertainment hub' and 50% of the dollars spent at the D.C. ballpark would otherwise be spent in D.C. Very doubtful. Ask a Virginian who holds Redskins season tickets how often they otherwise spend money in Prince Georges County. This answer is never. Because of the uniqueness of D.C.'s location, the 'bowling alley effect' in this case is negligible--probably less than 5%. Money spent by VA/MD/WV surburbanites at the D.C. ballpark is truly money that would not go to D.C.
Read the full article...
Dipping into the BP Mailbag, Jason Karegeannes has more on being a Questec operator; Clay Davenport delves into RFK's park factors; a D'backs fan suggests another reason for the team's struggles; and Chris Kahrl's inbox is stuffed with TA thoughts.
Will Carroll delves deeper into shoulder injuries. Clay Davenport provides a history lesson on pitcher's mounds. Chris Kahrl takes a closer look at J.T. Snow. All in this edition of From The Mailbag.
Excellent columns on sacrificing. One question though. In the situation where the team is looking for just one run, and there is a runner on 2nd with no outs. If I were the opposing manager, and the other team succesfully sacrificed the runner to third, depending on the next batters, I might give batter two an intentional walk and hope for a double play to get out of the inning. Does this response by the opposing manager change the effectiveness of the strategy?
You make an excellent point. Running the numbers assuming that a GIDP is possible after a sacrifice of the man to third, the breakeven levels now read:
(Instead of the .351/.436/.619 line from the article.) Obviously this reduces the number of players who should be sacrificing from "everyone except Bonds" to simply the vast majority. I will definitely include this correction in future adjustments to the equations. Thanks for pointing out the shortfall.