CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Premium Article On the Beat: Taking Ce... (08/10)
<< Previous Column
The Lineup Card: 12 Fa... (08/03)
Next Column >>
The Lineup Card: 11 Me... (08/18)
Next Article >>
Painting the Black: Wh... (08/10)

August 10, 2011

The Lineup Card

12 Favorite Basebrawls and Individual Performances in Basebrawls

by Baseball Prospectus

1) Armando Benitez vs. Tino Martinez and the Yankees
At 28-9, the 1998 Yankees had already shown that they were in the business of kicking ass and taking names when the Orioles came to town having lost five straight games to push them under .500. The O's were on track to snap their streak with a 5-3 lead in the eighth inning when the Yankees drew two walks while making two outs against tiring O's starter Sidney Ponson and reliever Alan Mills. A Paul O'Neill single off Norm Charlton cut the lead to 5-4 when Benitez, the Orioles' imposing but immature closer, was summoned for a four-out save. Instead, he served up a three-run homer to Bernie Williams to give the Yankees a 7-5 lead, then blatantly plunked Tino Martinez between the shoulder blades with a 90-something MPH fastball on his next pitch. "That was a real cheap shot," said Yankees broadcaster Jim Kaat.

Martinez jawed at Benitez on the way down to first base, and the 6-foot-4 reliever dropped his glove. Both benches and bullpens emptied, and things escalated when Yankees' lefty reliever Graeme Lloyd—a 6-foot-8 Australian native my friends and I called "The Big Dingo"—came charging out of the bullpen and grabbed Benitez's chin before throwing a few wild punches with fellow Yankee reliever Jeff Nelson joining the fray. Benitez connected on a blow to the back of Lloyd's neck as he retreated from the mound into foul territory. As he neared the dugout, he squared off with Scott Brosius, who threw no punches but captured his attention while Darryl Strawberry rolled up behind and connected on a sucker punch to Benitez's head before pushing him into the Oriole dugout. Strawberry was restrained by multiple Orioles at the edge of the dugout, but amazingly enough, the two would square off again minutes later after Mills punched Strawberry while an irate Martinez kept making his way towards Benitez. The second time, Stawberry's blow was more glancing, and his momentum carried him into the dugout where Eddie Murray and Cal Ripken tried to calm him down. Ultimately, it took around 15 minutes before order was restored and play resumed.

"This is like one of those hockey brawls where the umpires have to figure out who stays and who goes," said Yankees broadcaster (and former Oriole) Ken Singleton. "To a man, the Orioles refused to muster even feigned support for Benitez," wrote Sports Illustrated's Tom Verducci. "The action of 'I'll hurt you if I can't beat you' totally misrepresents the Baltimore Orioles' tradition of good play and sportsmanship," said manager Ray Miller in apologizing to the Yankees. Benitez drew an eight-game suspension while Strawberry and Lloyd (three games) and Mills and Nelson (two games) received suspensions as well. The Yankees went on to win 114 regular season games and the World Series while the Orioles were swept by the Yankees en route to a nine-game losing streak. They haven't had a winning season since. —Jay Jaffe


2) Jonny Gomes vs. Shelly Duncan, Jonny Gomes vs. Coco Crisp
Not often is a player involved in two basebrawls in the same season, but then again, not too many players have Jonny Gomes’s personality. Perhaps the only thing you need to know about Gomes’s psyche is that he once willingly sipped champagne from Dioner Navarro’s protective cup. Any person willing to go that far is not someone with whom you want to tango, yet Shelley Duncan and Coco Crisp found themselves in Gomes’ crosshairs during the 2008 season.

The first incident came in spring training. After another Ray had smashed into Francisco Cervelli and broke his wrist, Duncan decided to retaliate with a high, aggressive slide into the Rays second baseman. Gomes, never one willing to wait for an invitation, flew in from his right field perch and attempted to tackle Duncan before the pair was separated.

Crisp wasn’t as lucky as he charged the mound after being plunked by a pitch, only to find Gomes straddling and pummeling his upper body for a few seconds. Those incidents became inspiration for what Rays’ fans labeled “brawlfense”. —R.J. Anderson
 

3) Rick Porcello vs. Kevin Youkilis (Watch)
In August 2009, Detroit Tigers’ 20-year-old right-hander Rick Porcello took the mound against the Boston Red Sox with one thing on his mind: to pick up his 11th win of the season as the Tigers made their Playoff push. What he would leave with was his first career ejection, a no-decision, and a takedown of Kevin Youkilis. The young Tigers phenom may not have won the game, but with his takedown of Youkilis that day, Rick Porcello cemented himself in Tigers lore and earned the unwavering trust and respect of his veteran teammates. Porcello had hit Youkilis with a breaking ball in the back, clearly unintentional considering that intentional bean-balls are generally fastballs in the ribs, not soft stuff in the back.

Once the ball made contact with Youkilis’s back, Porcello turned towards first in dismay having put a man on in a game he was winning 3-0 at the time. Fortunately (for the love of the brawl, at least), Youkilis did not appreciate or understand Porcello’s dismay. What transpired next was straight out of Looney Tunes as Youkilis charged like a bull seeing red and Porcello took him down with the ease of a Bugs Bunny matador dance. As the rookie right-hander put his arms out as if to ask in surprise, “What?” the helmet flew and the two engaged. When the diamond dust settled, the Tigers’ 20-year-old phenom from New Jersey had thrown the Red Sox slugger to the ground and was raining haymakers on him.

At the end of the day, the Red Sox came back to win the game, but without a doubt, that brawl cemented Rick Porcello in baseball lore.—Adam Tower


4) Engel Beltre vs. The Visalia Rawhide (Watch)
The video is fantastic. In the bottom of the tenth inning, Texas Rangers’ prospect Engel Beltre launched a home run over the right field wall in Bakersfield. Whatever he did at the plate must not have gone over well with Visalia pitcher Billy Spottiswood, however, because soon Spottiswood was jawing at Beltre and walking towards him as he continued his home run trot. There was a brief encounter as Beltre passed the shortstop position, but he continued on his trot. Finally, after passing third base, Beltre had had enough and started challenging Spottiswood. The Visalia catcher, who was much closer, pushed Beltre and the benches cleared. Beltre didn't acquit himself well in the brawl; in fact, he seemed to disappear off camera while two other players went at it, but I give him credit here for instigating the brawl (with a whole lot of help from Spottiswood) while in the middle of his home run trot! It's not very often, after all, that one can be the main player in a walkoff brawl. And if you don't think I timed Beltre's trot for the Tater Trot Tracker, you're crazy. —Larry Granillo
 

5) Kevin Goldstein vs. Bill
I'm pretty sure his name was Bill, but I'm not 100 percent sure. I have no clue what his last name was as it was more than 30 years ago, but I do remember his face. Then again, maybe even that is a flawed recall, blurred by pop culture as I must admit a strange resemblance to both Chucky and Damien. I'm certain I remember the sneer, and I'm certain I remember stepping up to the plate with Bill on the mound, knowing exactly what was about to happen. This was the third, maybe fourth grade—I'm not sure which—but the one marker I have in my memory is that my parents were still together (at least technically), so it was before fifth. I have no idea what the impetuous was, but Bill hated me, and the feelings were mutual. I was on the Giants, and while I don't remember what Bill's team was called, I do remember they wore green uniforms.

I don't remember the score, and I don't remember the win-loss record, but I do remember that when I stepped into the box, I knew Bill was going to throw at me, and he did just that, missing wildly with his first offering and nailing me in the back with his second shot. I knew it was coming. Every kid at the game knew it was coming. But it was Little League, where command and control are rarely virtues, so the adults didn't see it coming, nor did they see any malice, and I was in no position to rush the mound and get my revenge in a game where the umpires are three times the size of the players, but I sure wanted to. Bill moved away shortly thereafter, and the thud of that fastball hitting me ended up being the peak of our feud, but I remember how I felt at that moment, and while I don't support fighting in baseball, I certainly understand it. —Kevin Goldstein


6)
The Greenville Drive vs. The Charleston River Dogs (Watch)
It's probably not appreciated how young and inexperienced kids are when they're drafted and sent to pro ball. Coaches have to teach them everything, not just how to make the turn at first or throw a cutter. It's like boot camp in more ways than one, and it's not uncommon for minor leaguers to describe their teams the same way military veterans describe their platoons. In Matt McCarthy's minor-league memoir Odd Man Out, McCarthy recounts manager Tom Kotchman's introduction to the team. "Last thing," McCarthy quotes Kotchman as saying, "It's against league rules to leave the bench in the event of a fight. That said, I expect all of you to be in the thick of things if a brawl ever breaks out. You've got to protect one another." Kotchman began to leave, then stopped at the door and raised his arm. "And for you city guys, this is how you make a fist." When video of the Slade Heathcott brawl went viral this spring, my favorite moment was when I identified the first man into the scrum: not the pitcher, or the first baseman, or the guy on deck, or any of the players in the dugout. It was manager Billy McMillon. —Sam Miller
 

7) The Padres vs. Pascual Perez
It was a beautiful Sunday afternoon on August, 12 1984 in the booming metropolis of Ohioville, Pennsylvania, and three childhood friends and I planned to play a round of golf in the third-to-last weekend before I would embark on my senior year of college, with real life soon to follow. While three of us waited at my friend's house for the final member of our foursome to arrive, we watched on television as the Padres and Braves began playing their game in Atlanta. This was back in the day when what is now TBS was known as SuperStation WTBS, and it carried the vast majority of the Braves' games to a national cable audience.

Braves pitcher Pascual Perez hit the Padres' Alan Wiggins with the first pitch of the game. Knowing of the zany and mercurial Perez from his days as a rookie with the Pirates, the three of us were sure that good theatre was likely ahead. Sure enough, when Perez came to bat in the bottom of the second, Padres pitcher Ed Whitson threw a pitch behind his head. Perez started waving his bat and both benches emptied. That, however, would be just the beginning of one of the most bizarre games in major league history. Every time Perez came to the plate, the Padres kept throwing at him. Three more fights broke out in the fifth, eighth and ninth innings, and even the spectators got involved as five fans were arrested in addition to the ejections of 14 players and coaches. After the game, Braves manager Joe Torre accused Padres manager and future Hall of Famer Dick Williams of "Hitler-like action" for continuing to have his pitchers throw at Perez. We never did make it to the golf course that day, but none of us complained. Instead, we watched a baseball game unlike any other. —John Perrotto
 

8) Nolan Ryan vs. Robin Ventura
The family phone rang in the evening hours of August 4th, 1993. The hour was late enough to suggest only two possible outcomes: 1) A family member was in trouble, or 2) One of my idiot friends called the main house line by mistake after 10 PM CT. Neither eventuality looked promising for me, so with an ear towards the phone conversation, I listened with great anticipation. The voice on the other end of the phone was a close family friend, but the news being delivered wasn’t full of sorrow or sadness; rather, the family friend called to make sure we had our eyes on the evening news, which was replaying and detailing local hero, Nolan Ryan, engaging in a baseball brawl for all the world to see. This was a big moment.

In the top of the third inning on that steamy August night, 25-year-old Robin Ventura decided to take physical exception to a purposeful pitch to his back, courtesy of a then 46-year-old Nolan Ryan. The famous gunslinger was in the twilight of his 27th season in the majors, only a few starts away from packing up the iron and walking away from the mound. The big Texan was already a legend, but what transpired on this fateful night would stand alongside the rest of the pieces of his lore, painting him as the physical embodiment of Texas pride in accepting the challenge of a younger pistoleer and shooting him down in front of the eyes of his brethren.

After being alerted to the incident and having clicked on the local news, my family sat wide-eyed at the television, watching replay after replay of our hero taking his famous right-hand to the top of Robin Ventura’s skull numerous times before landing an upper-cut (or two) to the face. Ventura’s decision to charge the mound was justifiable as he felt he was thrown at intentionally, which, of course, he was. However, you don’t stand on the street with the legend if you don’t have the skill to put the legend down. After being hit, Ventura started towards first but quickly changed his course and exploded towards the mound, where he met an aging (yet willing) adversary with his glove already removed and his pistol drawn. Before Ventura could execute his anger, the John Wayne of Texas baseball stepped toward Ventura in front of the mound, grabbed him like a rogue steer, and beat reality into his head before the scrum could form and force them to the ground.

When the dust settled, the rifleman emerged from the pile to the cheers of thousands of fans—and not just the people in the seats. Ventura was tossed from the game while Ryan remained on the mound, pouring salt on the wounds of the White Sox while pumping even more Texas pride into the veins of those with eyes on the event. My family celebrated that night like the first people celebrated the sunrise, with a nationalistic euphoria that is often quite unattractive to outsiders. Nolan Ryan beating Robin Ventura was one of the highlights of my youth, which doesn’t say much about my youth. On that night, Nolan Ryan’s fist belonged to all Texans, and despite being silly to celebrate the public humiliation of another human, the state rejoiced when our legend was still able to live up to his name. Come and take it. —Jason Parks


9)
George Brett v. Graig Nettles
From 1976 to 1980, the Yankees and Royals squared off for the American League pennant in four of five seasons. The rivalry produced some of the best—and hardest-fought—October drama of the era. Two plays from those playoffs sum up the dislike each team had for the other.

One was Hal McRae’s takeout slide—more accurately described as a body block—that sent Willie Randolph flying, broke up a potential double play, and allowed a run to score. (McRae famously “fell” on top of Randolph and waved the runner ahead of him to the plate. Randolph responded in kind by picking up the ball and firing it toward McRae in the Royals’ dugout.)

The other play came in the first inning of the fifth and deciding game of the 1977 ALCS in Kansas City. With McRae at first base, George Brett drove a ball into the gap and set sail for third base, where Graig Nettles of the Yankees waited for a relay throw. Brett slid hard and came up swinging when, he later explained, Nettles kicked him in the face. Nettles, for his part, thought Brett had pushed or elbowed him. Suddenly, both players were throwing haymakers. Yankees pitcher Ron Guidry—who had been backing up third—joined the fracas, and the three wrestled to the ground as the benches emptied. Brett later revealed that Yankees catcher Thurman Munson had protected him at the bottom of the dog-pile. Remarkably, neither Brett nor Nettles was ejected. A ninth-inning rally eventually sent the Yankees to the World Series, and the best rivalry of the era intensified. —Jeff Euston
 

10) Izzy Alcantara vs. Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Red Barons (Watch)
Izzy Alcantara was a fringe third base prospect in the Expos system in the mid-1990s. After bouncing around various organizations, he ended up with the Red Sox in 1999 and hit 29 homers between Double-A and Triple-A. Alcantara duplicated the feat a year later and in 2001 pounded a career-high 36 home runs. By now, though, he was a 28-year-old corner outfielder with limited defensive skills.

When you miss your shot at stardom, you can accept your fate gracefully and move on with life, or you can come out with guns-a-blazin' and put on a show they'll never forget. Alcantara chose the latter.

On July 3, 2001, after being buzzed by a fastball from Red Barons’ right-hander Blas Cedeno, Alcantara pulled a move worthy of Ray Austin's finest choreography in The Avengers, karate kicking catcher Jeremy Salazar in the facemask. Alcantara, known more for his power than his ability to make contact, then bolted toward the mound where he swung at and missed Cedeno.

The pitcher threw his glove at Alcantara, who danced around looking for someone to fight before realizing that Alcantara’s teammates had not yet come out to support him. Eventually, both benches emptied (“no punches, fortunately, were landed,” intones the announcer), and Alcantara was tackled by former Cubs’ third baseman Kevin Orie.

Alcantara was suspended six games for his actions, Orie was suspended three games, and Cedeno drew a one-game suspension.

Alcantara retired in 2007, the owner of 287 minor-league home runs, six big-league home runs, and one spectacular meltdown captured on video. History may forget his minor-league power-hitting exploits, but the story of his karate kick will survive generations. —Geoff Young
 

11) Pedro Martinez vs. Don Zimmer
Imagine you’re Pedro Martinez, wandering the infield during a standard-issue baseball non-fight. It’s Game 3 of the 2003 ALCS, and you know you had personally toppled the first domino by throwing at Karim Garcia’s head in the top of the fourth, and when a frustrated Garcia later slid through Todd Walker in an attempt to break up the double play your beanball had set up, words had been exchanged—between Walker and Garcia and between you and the Yankees bench, notably Don Zimmer, Roger Clemens and Jorge Posada. You had pointed at your head while shouting at Posada, a gesture perhaps meant to convey that you’d remember his words when you next faced him but which the Yankees had taken as a threat to give Posada exactly the medicine you had just force-fed Garcia. Benches and pitchers were warned, but with Roger Clemens (the hurler most likely to up the testosterone ante) facing Manny Ramirez (the batter most likely to take offense) to lead off the bottom of the inning, no one had been surprised that a high-and-tight fastball had led to a staredown, angry words, and now empty benches. You’ve gone onto the field to support your teammate (since that’s what the baseball code requires), but right now you’re nowhere near the heart of the action.

Suddenly, out of the milling fog, a man rushes towards you, arms extended. To most people, and to you in a different context, the man looks like this:

Right now, however, he looks much different. He’s charging straight at you, bug-eyed and cursing, wearing the uniform of the team you will soon call your “Daddy.” He’s an older man but clearly spry, with a well-known prejudice against beanball pitchers, having spent months in the hospital after a Triple-A pitch resulted in a two-week coma and a skull that had to be screwed back together before re-learning how to walk and talk. Moments ago you didn’t see him, but now he’s lunging at you, looking for all the world like this:

What do you do? You may think you would have side-stepped him, or held him at arm’s length, or just stood there and taken whatever he was there to dish, but I’m here to tell you that in that context, in real-time, that’s not what you would have done. Martinez was in a no-win situation (albeit one of his own making), and as sad as it was to see, grabbing Zimmer’s melon and pushing him aside and down was about the best response we could have expected and a perfect illustration of the monumental stupidity of baseball fights. —Ken Funck

12) Bill Dickey vs. Carl Reynolds
In the early 1930s, there was a lot of hostility between the New York Yankees and the Washington Senators, the latter of which was actually a good team at the time. At Washington on July 4, 1932, the Yankees took a 3-2 lead to the bottom of the seventh. Senators outfielder Carl Reynolds tried to score the tying run on a close play at the plate, colliding with Yankees catcher Bill Dickey and knocking him down. This put Dickey in a surly frame of mind—he had been knocked unconscious on a play at the plate the previous day and was starting to think the Senators were making him their personal punching bag.

Nothing else might have happened, but in the tangle of bodies, Reynolds hadn’t actually touched home plate. Dickey, hearing him coming back, jumped up and punched the defenseless Reynolds in the jaw, breaking it in two places. Dickey was at first suspended indefinitely before the American League president settled on a one-month suspension without pay and a $1,000 fine, both a significant chunk of Dickey's earnings for the year. Reynolds spent the next month with his jaw wired shut, and at one point nearly choked to death when some insufficiently-liquefied food made it past the wires holding his mouth together. You often see it written that Reynolds was never the same, but he hit well enough upon returning as well as during the next season before fading abruptly in his early thirties. The Yankees won the 1932 pennant and World Series despite Dickey’s long absence, while the Senators would win the AL pennant in 1933, though without Reynolds, who was traded to the St. Louis Browns as part of a package for the infinitely better Goose Goslin. That April, the Yankees and Senators would have an even more celebrated brawl, a full-on riot which involved players, fans, and police before it was all over.—Steven Goldman

48 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links

dodgerken222
Other readers have rated this comment below the viewing threshold. Click here to view anyway.

Thanks to Mr. Goldman for giving some historical perspective to this article. It was beginning to look like one of the MLB Network's "50 Greatest Whatevers in History" and everything is from after 1980. You guys need to hire some older writers. Rehashing Don Zimmer and Pedro is sooooo boring.
Anyway, my vote for best brawl goes to Juan Marichal and his bat vs. John Roseboro and his head in 1965. Late August pennant race, Dodgers-Giants, Sandy Koufax on mound. As I recall, Marichal earned himself a 17-game suspension, which was key in the Dodgers winning the '65 pennant. Today, of course, he would have received a 10-day suspension which, on appeal, would have been reduced to eight. Another example of the great contribution of unions to anything they touch.

Aug 10, 2011 04:00 AM
rating: -7
 
Roger Thornhill

I also miss the ten-day clause and the reserve clause. Those were the days.

Aug 10, 2011 04:52 AM
rating: 10
 
ScottyB

You whippersnappers get off my lawn...

Aug 10, 2011 07:30 AM
rating: 11
 
NP_14

Rabbblerousing young hoodlums.

Aug 10, 2011 08:03 AM
rating: 6
 
Joe D.

Are those new slacks?

Aug 10, 2011 14:21 PM
rating: 2
 
Brian Kopec

Ah yes. That was the golden era of suspensions. Sometimes I'll flip through my worn Baseball Encyclopedia to the appendix that lists all of the player suspensions and gaze in amazement at the old records. Too bad the union had to ruin it all.

Aug 10, 2011 09:33 AM
rating: 2
 
JHaugJr
(332)

How about Mario Soto losing his brain on Memorial Day weekend 1984 at wrigley, isntiagting a huge brawl, going into the stands. Also starring Larry Bowa running around with a bat in hand in the middle of the biggest brawl. I was there on a COLD day at Wrigley.

Aug 10, 2011 05:37 AM
rating: 1
 
adecker31

Wow, I totally had forgotten about this...I remember that one of my friends became a huge Mario Soto fan after this, which was twisted, as we were growing up in Chicago.

Aug 10, 2011 23:04 PM
rating: 0
 
mwlsld

One of the most delightful aspects of that Yankees/O's brawl, from a Yankees fan's perspective, what that Tim Raines immediately followed the Martinez HBP with another home run -- this one off Bobby Munoz.

That game also served as an exciting introduction to live baseball for my then-19-year-old girlfriend & now wife. So, thanks Armando.

Aug 10, 2011 07:43 AM
rating: 5
 
Royalsfan

In Game 5 of the 1977 ALCS, George Brett did NOT "come up swinging" when he slid into 3B with his triple. Nettles kicked Brett in the face, and then Brett stood up & threw a punch at Nettles.

The day before, in Game 4, Nettles did not slide into 2B when the Royals were turning a double play. Instead he ran into Frank White, and put his shoulder into White's face.

One of the biggest brawls occured between the Royals & Rangers on May 7, 1977. It was a 25 minute fight, and 7 players/coaches were ejected. http://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/1977/B05070TEX1977.htm

Aug 10, 2011 07:55 AM
rating: 2
 
GreggB

Excellent and fair description of Zimmer/Pedro.

Aug 10, 2011 08:04 AM
rating: 4
 
ttt

Pete Rose and Buddy Harrelson? No one?

Aug 10, 2011 08:09 AM
rating: 0
 
BP staff member Jay Jaffe
BP staff

Our staff is only so big. We could have easily doubled up - Harrelson/Rose, Farnsworth/Affeldt, Yanks vs. Lee, Fisk vs. Munson, and so on. So many to choose from

Aug 10, 2011 11:32 AM
 
Randy Brown
(189)

I would like to humbly nominate one of my most vivid childhood baseball memories, of a Tigers-Twins brawl from 1982 in which Tiger pitcher Dave Rozema delivered a flying karate kick. He missed. Badly. He tore up his knee, missed the rest of the season, and the next season he had to wear a knee brace roughly the size of Kansas.

The memory of the incident has been so enduring that a Tigers minor league affiliate actually had a "Dave Rozema Karate Kick Bobblehead Day" a couple of years ago to commemorate the incident. Sadly, I cannot find a video of it as it would appear MLBAM has been able to effectively scrub bootleg videos of the brawl from the internet.

However, Deadspin has a great article that describes the incident, as well as what a...what's the right word here....."character" that Dave Rozema was generally. If you are interested:

http://deadspin.com/5021739/dave-rozemas-infamous-karate-kick-immortalized-in-bobble-form-at-last

Aug 10, 2011 08:35 AM
rating: 2
 
bbienk01

My favorite brawl at a game I attended:

Late April 1998, Randy Johnson pitching for the Mariners at Jacobs Field, and Kenny Lofton had the nerve to stay in the lineup despite hitting left-handed. There may have been other bad blood that I don't recall, but I know back then lefties generally sat when Johnson pitched.

Randy Johnson threw at Lofton's head twice, and the very next pitch after being warned, he threw at Lofton's head again. Benches cleared, and I distinctly remember Lou Piniella and Sandy Alomar trading punches. Meanwhile, with the chaos he caused around home plate, Johnson stood on the mound chatting w/ former teammate Omar Vizquel, which looked pretty funny considering Johnson was about two feet taller.

This game also included a David Bell inside-the-park home run with an assist by left-fielder Glenn Allen Hill.

Aug 10, 2011 08:59 AM
rating: 1
 
deholm1

I second Randy Brown's nomination. I heard Paul Carey broadcast that brawl live on WJR. There used to be a decent YouTube clip of the fight that was featured on a Minneapolis TV station's newscast the next day, but MLB for some stupid reason has claimed copyright privileges. (From a 30-year-old TV newscast? Anyone know how they can do that?)

It was quite the fight. Larry Herndon getting some good punches in on Ron Davis, who threw the beanball that precipitated the whole thing. Kirk Gibson tackling Butch Wynegar from behind. Lance Parrish piledriving John Castino (I think) and carrying him about 30 feet from the rest of the fight. And then Rozema's kick, which basically ruined his career.

Interestingly, Rozema was the winning pitcher. The brawl happened in the bottom of the 11th inning of a tie game. Two batters after the brawl, Gibson (who evidently didn't do enough to merit an ejection) hit a game-winning HR.

Aug 10, 2011 09:46 AM
rating: 0
 
Bob Stocking

As a Red Sox fan I'll never forget the image of Bill Lee grimacing and holding his left arm as he rose from the dogpile in Yankee Stadium. The beginning of the descent for the 1978 Sox.

Aug 10, 2011 09:47 AM
rating: 0
 
cubfan131

This needs a "This article is useless without video" icon. MLB needs to get with the times and allow video replays of its games to be posted.

Aug 10, 2011 09:49 AM
rating: 2
 
RedsManRick

I can't believe Kyle Farnsworth (as a Cub) spearing and pummeling Paul Wilson (as a Red) didn't make the cut. Farnsworth came in on Wilson when Wilson was hitting. Paul took exception, took a few steps towards Farnsworth and shouted at him. Farnsworth didn't wait -- he took of running at Wilson and form-tackled Wilson at full-speed before Wilson even had a chance to react. Even as a Reds fan, that was awesome to watch.

Aug 10, 2011 09:57 AM
rating: 2
 
buddons42

If I recall, wasn't Wilson bloodied up pretty good in that one? That also wasn't the last time Farnsworth form-tackled anyone, he came out from the bullpen in a Tigers/Royals brawl in... 2007?.. then proceeded to seek out Jeremy Affeldt and drive him into the ground like a middle linebacker. Rod Allen was announcing the game for Detroit and just about lost his mind with excitement when that happened.

Aug 10, 2011 10:07 AM
rating: 1
 
jetson
(660)

It probably doesn't rise to the level of a brawl - but Ed Ott put some seriously violent poetic justice on Bud Harrelson about 35 years back.

Aug 10, 2011 10:22 AM
rating: 0
 
jetson
(660)

pardon me, Felix Millan, not Harrelson.

Aug 10, 2011 10:23 AM
rating: 0
 
bigbart

Ray Knight dropping Eric Davis and the brawl that ensued?

http://baseballcrank.com/archives2/2003/04/baseball_knight.php

Aug 10, 2011 10:45 AM
rating: 1
 
Richard Bergstrom

Loved Kevin Goldstein's #5.

I spent a few days on Facebook trying to convince Cub fans that beaning Matt Holliday for sliding hard into Starlin Castro wouldn't make the Cubs a .500 team and in fact, would just risk further injury in retaliation. I agree fighting is pointless and wish the teams in the major leagues would do a few more things Little Leaguers do like shake hands after the game.

Aug 10, 2011 11:30 AM
rating: 0
 
Richard Bergstrom

Oh, almost forgot. The last brawl I was at was at new Comiskey the year it opened, Jack McDowell vs Mark Whiten.

Aug 10, 2011 11:30 AM
rating: 0
 
adrock

Richard, you get a +1 for calling to mind my second favorite Blue Jays brawl moment, after George Bell's karate kick on Bruce Kison.

Aug 10, 2011 11:45 AM
rating: 0
 
Richard Bergstrom

McDowell was on an interview the day after thar brawl and was sporting a real shiner.

Aug 10, 2011 12:55 PM
rating: 0
 
bobbygrace

Not only did Nolan Ryan remain in the game after the Robin Ventura beatdown -- he proceeded to no-hit the White Sox for the remainder of the game. Now *that's* rubbing salt in the wound!

Aug 10, 2011 11:35 AM
rating: 2
 
Keith7971

I would simply nominate Kyle Farnsworth, for spearing Jeremy Affeldt after it seemed the conflict had ended, and for being the only pitcher ive ever heard of charging the plate.
http://bit.ly/qdMDOY

Aug 10, 2011 11:46 AM
rating: 1
 
salvomania
(449)

One of the most bizzare brawl-related photos of all time:

http://images.stltoday.com/stltoday/resources/busch10.pdf

Without reading the caption, try to figure out what the hell is going on in this picture, taken as the pitch has just reached the catcher, Ted Simmons.

Even after reading the caption it's hard to tell what's going on unless you know the whole sequence of events.

Aug 10, 2011 12:17 PM
rating: 0
 
apbadogs

What the hell IS going on in that picture??!

Aug 11, 2011 10:20 AM
rating: 0
 
rbrianc

The fact that Ryan is the only HOF in the Top 10, an all-time legend that set records that will likely not be broken, that he was giving away about 20 years, no-hit the Sox the rest of the way, and Ventura was quickly subdued all adds up to the fact that this should be #1 - its certainly my most memorable one over the last 40 years.

Was it over too quick, too one-sided and not dramataic enough? All the more reason it is #1

Aug 10, 2011 15:00 PM
rating: 0
 
ScottyB

I don't think these are ranked as such. Just a numbered list.

Aug 10, 2011 20:32 PM
rating: 3
 
rbrianc

ok, I missed Brett being the other HOF in the Top Ten.

Aug 10, 2011 15:02 PM
rating: 0
 
mblthd

Baseball players can't fight. The so-called "basebrawl" is merely a ninny slap-fest in which none of the participants have the will or the skill to throw a proper punch.

Aug 10, 2011 17:29 PM
rating: 0
 
jetson
(660)

You missed Ed Ott then.

Aug 10, 2011 18:11 PM
rating: 1
 
amazin_mess

What exactly is stupid about baseball fights, Ken? A team can only be pushed around so much before something has to happen, right?

Aug 10, 2011 21:59 PM
rating: 0
 
BP staff member Ken Funck
BP staff

I'm not a stranger to team sports, so I understand that sentiment. But what does it really accomplish? Most MLB fights (which usually aren't fights, but are shouting matches with a few players restraining a few other players, and everyone else milling about) are precipitated by some unsportsmanlike act -- throwing at a player, or an illegally rough slide, or a player showing someone up. When that act happens, umpires have every right to eject the offending player. If umpires did that, there would be no need for the eventual fight. What usually happens, though, is that umpires choose not to do this, instead warning players and benches. Then teams shift into "vigilante justice" mode, and the offended team's pitcher throws at a hitter on the offending team, and HE gets ejected. How does that help the offended team? Or, instead, no one is ejected, a few players mill around, everyone gets to demonstrate the rote position that "we won't be bullied" and "we have our teammates' backs," and the game goes on, with nothing really changed.

In the Pedro/Zimmer case, Pedro clearly threw at Garcia. He should have been ejected right then and there, end of story. Everything that happened after that was pointless, and did nothing to help either team win. Did Clemens deciding he had been deputized and throwing inside to Manny, Manny taking exception to it, and the shouting match that ensued really have any bearing on the eventual outcome of the game or the series, or achieve anything other than to give us the horrific spectacle of Pedro shoving Popeye to the ground? I've heard the argument that those are bonding moments that help team chemistry, or that teams prove their mental and physical toughness in this way and that provides a confidence boost, but it's hard for me to believe that those things outweigh the injury risk and the possible expulsion and suspension of players that such moments cost. That, exactly, is why I think they're stupid: they're avoidable, and even when they're not avoided, they don't help anybody in any way.

Aug 11, 2011 07:41 AM
 
thegeneral13

Unfortunately, the beanball/brawlfest thing starts at an age when boys are trying to prove they are men and becomes permanently ingrained. The dumbest thing is, as you say, they aren't even real fights. It's mostly shoving and occasional cheap shots. And if somebody pulls a Johnny Cueto and fights vale tudo when backed against a wall, he's vilified.

Aug 11, 2011 11:22 AM
rating: 0
 
Richard Bergstrom

That's funny. I played Little League and high school ball and don't remember hearing a coach telling me or anyone else to throw at a player... so either Little League has changed or I'm just not sure how it starts at a young age.

+1 to Ken's comment about the pointlessness of fighting btw.

Aug 11, 2011 15:09 PM
rating: 0
 
thegeneral13

For me it came in high school in the form of peer pressure to bean someone on the other team when one of our guys got hit, even when it clearly wan't intentional. The machismo of it was lost on me at the time - I refused to do it b/c I didn't want the baserunner. I never heard a coach talk about it (through college).

Aug 11, 2011 17:42 PM
rating: 0
 
Richard Bergstrom

So, does it really start at a young age then, or is it more of an exception to the rule that coaches tell little leaguers/high schoolers/college players to bean kids?

Aug 12, 2011 14:34 PM
rating: 0
 
saigonsam

I managed an autograph session with Ventura some time after that fight (a really nice guy). He said he was constantly being asked to sign the famous picture of him in a headlock about to receive a Ryan uppercut. He always signed it.

Aug 11, 2011 01:51 AM
rating: 3
 
dodgerken222
Other readers have rated this comment below the viewing threshold. Click here to view anyway.

Hey man...at least I wasn't censored like I was by Strasberg's Fascists.

Aug 11, 2011 04:59 AM
rating: -5
 
NYYanks826

There was an Independent League brawl on Monday night between Yuma and Chico that could go down in history, especially since it involved two ex-Major Leaguers straight out of 1990.

Tony Phillips is the third baseman for Chico. He's the starting third baseman and is 52 years old (don't you love independent ball?), and Jose Canseco is the player/manager for Yuma.

The brawl involved Phillips yelling into the Yuma dugout, and then eventually tackling the opposing manager near the third base line.

Oh, and there was a pitcher named Jonny Bravo involved, too.

http://www.chicoer.com/fromthenewspaper/ci_18644011

Aug 11, 2011 06:26 AM
rating: 0
 
apbadogs

Greg Brady pitched in MLB?

Aug 11, 2011 10:22 AM
rating: 2
 
apbadogs

I love how in the Giants/Phillies "brawl" earlier this week that Shane Victorino conveniently waited for someone to get between him and the Giant before he started flipping out. Baseball players do that ALL the time. HOLD ME BACK! HOLD ME BACK!! I say let the 2 guys go at like hockey does, anyone jump in or come off the bench, instant suspensions...let's see who the tough guys really are.

Aug 11, 2011 10:18 AM
rating: 0
 
David Laurila

Porcello was "raining haymakers" on Youkilis? Looking at the video, I don't see evidence that either of them threw a single punch.

Regarding Gomes-Crisp, Gomes was definitely throwing punches. Granted, they were at someone on the bottom of a pile, unable to defend himself, but unlike the Porcello brawl, they were punches.

Aug 11, 2011 13:27 PM
rating: 0
 
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
Premium Article On the Beat: Taking Ce... (08/10)
<< Previous Column
The Lineup Card: 12 Fa... (08/03)
Next Column >>
The Lineup Card: 11 Me... (08/18)
Next Article >>
Painting the Black: Wh... (08/10)

RECENTLY AT BASEBALL PROSPECTUS
Fantasy Article My Model Portfolio: Framing Decisions Around...
Fantasy Article Dynasty Dynamics: TINO Does Arizona, 2015
Pebble Hunting: The Case For Shaming the Cub...
Every Team's Moneyball: Texas Rangers: Short...
Every Team's Moneyball: Atlanta Braves: Shor...
Prospectus Feature: All Spin Is Not Alike
Premium Article Baseball Therapy: The Most Important Player ...

MORE FROM AUGUST 10, 2011
Premium Article Prospectus Hit and Run: What the Halo?
Premium Article Future Shock: The Advantage of Signing Early
Painting the Black: What to Expect from Stra...
Premium Article On the Beat: Taking Central Stage
Premium Article Expanded Horizons: Anonymastros
Fantasy Article Value Picks: Outfield for 8/10/11
Premium Article Collateral Damage: Backed into Corners

MORE BY BASEBALL PROSPECTUS
2011-09-08 - The Lineup Card: 9 Forgotten Players from De...
2011-08-24 - The Lineup Card: 11 Disastrous Acquisitions
2011-08-18 - The Lineup Card: 11 Memorable Breakdowns, An...
2011-08-10 - The Lineup Card: 12 Favorite Basebrawls and ...
2011-08-03 - The Lineup Card: 12 Favorite Baseball Songs ...
2011-07-27 - The Lineup Card: 17 Favorite Midseason Trade...
2011-07-22 - BP Unfiltered: Get a Job in Baseball Working...
More...

MORE THE LINEUP CARD
2011-09-08 - The Lineup Card: 9 Forgotten Players from De...
2011-08-24 - The Lineup Card: 11 Disastrous Acquisitions
2011-08-18 - The Lineup Card: 11 Memorable Breakdowns, An...
2011-08-10 - The Lineup Card: 12 Favorite Basebrawls and ...
2011-08-03 - The Lineup Card: 12 Favorite Baseball Songs ...
2011-07-27 - The Lineup Card: 17 Favorite Midseason Trade...
2011-07-20 - The Lineup Card: The Top 13 Veterans Committ...
More...