CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)
Next Column >>
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)
Next Article >>
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)

November 1, 2010

World Series Prospectus

Game Four Analysis

by Christina Kahrl

In yesterday's space, I speculated about Game Four being more of a pitcher's duel than people anticipated. The Rangers certainly gave it a solid shot at making it so. If you had suggested beforehand that they would allow just two runs through the first six innings, we'd probably figure things had gone about as well as they possibly might in a Tommy Hunter start. Even down 2-0 doesn't sound so bad in the abstract.

But a funny thing or three happened on the way to the final third of the game, things that made certain that this seemingly winnable contest remained as unattainable as world peace or truly indestructible doggie chew toys.

First, the Giants' batters deserve a ton of credit for doing their part to wear Hunter down early, just as they had in the Series' first game against the considerably more frightening Cliff Lee. Complicating matters more than a bit was the presence of home plate ump Mike Winters, whose strike zone seemed to be all over the place. As I tweeted Sunday night at the outset of the game, Winters ranked 14th among big-league umps when it came to the incidence of unintentional walks while behind the dish, but as frustrating as several players seemed to find his zone, perhaps the biggest difference was that Hunter is a nice little strike-thrower without a great off-speed pitch who needs a little bit of wiggle room to operate within. He didn't have that, and the Giants kept after him, having to settle for Aubrey Huff's two-run, hard-pulled, no-doubt shot in the third.

Getting "just" the two runs, however, diminishes what the Giants hitters accomplished by getting Hunter past 80 pitches in just four frames. Pushing Hunter hard had the additional benefit of forcing the Rangers back into using a bullpen that's probably going to end up making Texas fans wishing Nolan Ryan's jabbering about starter endurance was more a matter of actual policy than empty sports-page braggadocio. Alexi Ogando's early exit with an injury exacerbated the issue, but even then, you could anticipate the eventual employment of both Darrens. While you can take Darren Oliver's two-out run allowed in the seventh on Andres Torres' double as a bad break, Edgar Renteria's scoring on the double was perhaps as much the product of his already running on the play as Torres' purportedly unlikely double against a lefty. But even there, give credit where credit's due: despite this year's poor performance against southpaws, Torres was used to good effect as a lefty masher from Bruce Bochy's bench in 2009, slugging them at a .718 clip, and he also crushed them for a .602 SLG at Iowa in 2008. Here as elsewhere, it's important to not get hung up on single-season platoon splits as career-defining.

The Giants' fourth run, on Buster Posey's eighth-inning homer off Darren Number Two, was equal parts pure Posey power and the side-arming O'Day's seeming over-exposure against an opponent far from in awe of him. While I'd be in the front rank among those who tout the Rangers' ROOGY for his situational uses, as a trick pony getting run out to face the same lineup and many of the same batters in a fourth consecutive game, you have to wonder about how much mystery might be left as far as picking up his offerings. If you get to see him four times in five nights instead of once or twice in a month, you can anticipate how familiarity might breed relish, and not merely contempt. You can pity Ron Washington this problem, instead of banging on him: with Frank Francisco not available to him and with only so many bullets to fire in the first place, if he's had to fire this one in particular too many times, you wind up with an illustration of the Rangers' problem with depth this late in the season.

Of course, this sort of trench fight is a matter of deliberately looking away from the incontrovertibly obvious. The Giants' hard-won quartet of runs stood up so handily because Madison Bumgarner's ballgame was one of those outings for which mere superlatives fail. Eight shutout innings, with a lone baserunner getting as far as second base--thanks to an error, no less--had some conjuring references to a young Jim Palmer, others to Steve Avery. I like the latter comparison for what it suggests about the Giants' long-term potential for hanging around; like the '90s Braves, a platform resting on baseball's best one-through-five rotation and Posey makes for a great springboard. If this year's Giants lineup resembles the Braves' cobbled-together crew of '91, that's just a suggestion of where Brian Sabean will have to focus his energies going forward.

In the meantime, Sunday night's performance shouldn't leave red-state Rangers merely seeing red; green with envy would be far more appropriate. The nascent third ace of the Giants' rotation left his calling card at history's doorstep, and the rest is just belaboring the point. Games like Sunday night's one-sided outcome serve as a reminder that, in many ways, the Rangers only just got here. As loaded with tout-worthy talent as the organization might be, they're just not all there yet. This shows up in all sorts of symptoms: they're stuck carting leftovers like Jorge Cantu and Jeff Francoeur to the postseason--and worse yet, having to start Frenchy in consecutive post-season games. They have to get worked up over Bengie Molina's heroic performance beyond understandably low expectations. They're making do with Mitch Moreland's OTJ learning curve as a newlyminted first baseman. They're starting someone like Hunter in a World Series game, and in light of the alternatives, at least until Derek Holland really establishes himself, it seems an unfortunate necessity, survivable as long as the front three roll, but now the full price of Lee's Game One meltdown really comes home.

Which leaves us with what? Certainly the Rangers can reasonably hope for a better outcome in Game Five, what with the usually incomparable Lee back on the mound. But in the last-chance sweepstakes the Rangers are left with Monday night and in every other night they earn from here on out, you can wonder if they have or could even try to have the same combination of top-tier talent and outright desperation that shows up in Bochy's lineup cards, in-game tactics, and defensive switches. That's not a slight of Washington as much as an acknowledgment that the Rangers' bit parts seem to have little to contribute, and haven't really been identified as useful parts, where Bochy has been using almost everything he has to accrue every little advantage he can. Staying out of the way of greatness while also contributing where you can makes for a tough combination to beat, but that's Texas' lot, now as it has been all Series.

Christina Kahrl is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Christina's other articles. You can contact Christina by clicking here

Related Content:  A's,  Andres Torres

6 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links


The Giants also benefited from a couple of double play calls that probably weren't, but given the inability of the Rangers to get an extra base hit, it's hard to say that those calls changed the outcome of the game. Bumgarner and Posey also deserve credit for nailing Josh Hamilton attempting to steal eliminating one potential runner in scoring position and getting one out closer to the end of the game. That's a tough combination to steal a base on.

Nov 01, 2010 08:24 AM
rating: 0

That was an incredible throw by Posey. Hamilton had a huge jump but it ended up not even being close.

Nov 01, 2010 15:09 PM
rating: 0

As a still-getting-over-it Phillies fan, I was curious to see how the Giants' pitching would fare against the mighty bats of the Rangers. So while I might still be seething about all the Phillies' missed opportunities, I can sympathize with the Rangers' fans about how they're getting shut down. Give the Giants credit - they're getting great pitching (starters and bullpen) and very timely hitting, a winning combination. Looks like it's their year.

Nov 01, 2010 09:24 AM
rating: 0

It's odd what a few years will do for your perception of a manager. I've been a Giants fan since ever since, and in 2008/early 2009 was no fan of Bochy at all. It seemed that he made the wrong decision with his relievers every time out, and made some odd lineups. I still second guess some of his lineup decisions, but he's been miles better with the bullpen this year. So much so that I wonder if his problem in 2008 was having too many Jack Taschner, Vinnie Chulk, and Tyler Walker's rostered. I guess it's easy to look good when Guillermo Mota is the worst option in your pen.

Nov 01, 2010 09:51 AM
rating: 3

I think Greg's is an interesting point, and can be extended to Brian Sabean as well. How can I go on hating the guy if they go out and win the World Series?

Nov 01, 2010 10:48 AM
rating: 1

Indeed, the greatest shift this year, actively executed by Bochy and supported by Sabean and ownership, has been the willingness to bench guys like Rowand, leave Zito off the playoff roster, and admit that Renteria may be your best option, even in the most important games yet. I wonder if Bochy would have been willing to bench Rowand last year, who deserved it too, with the previous ownership group. Or perhaps he is growing as manager. Regardless, it is refreshing.

As Christina put it, he is taking every slight advantage he has and putting it to work. If Pat the Bat isn't going to hit, then he is of no value. Replace him with Schierholtz, who also won't hit, but will at least contribute on defense. And Nate certainly did contribute.

Go Giants!

Nov 01, 2010 13:23 PM
rating: 2
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)
Next Column >>
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)
Next Article >>
Premium Article World Series Prospectu... (11/01)

Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Thursday, May ...
Premium Article What You Need to Know: Bummed!
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: Friday, May 22
West Coast By Us: Day 1: In The Land Where E...
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: The Quarter-Season Odds Report
West Coast By Us: Taco the Town
Going Yard: The Near Perfection of Pederson

Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Four Report
Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Five Pitching ...
Premium Article On the Beat: Dealing with the DH
Premium Article GM for a Day: Los Angeles Dodgers
Premium Article Contractual Matters: NL West Arbitration For...
Premium Article Future Shock: Monday Ten Pack
The Week in Quotes: October 25-31

2010-11-04 - Premium Article Prospectus Perspective: Four and No More
2010-11-04 - Premium Article Kiss'Em Goodbye: Texas Rangers
2010-11-02 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Five Analysis
2010-11-01 - World Series Prospectus: Game Four Analysis
2010-11-01 - Premium Article GM for a Day: Los Angeles Dodgers
2010-10-31 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Three Analysis
2010-10-29 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Two Analysis

2010-11-02 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Five Analysis
2010-11-02 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: What Makes a Good W...
2010-11-01 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Four Report
2010-11-01 - World Series Prospectus: Game Four Analysis
2010-11-01 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Five Pitching ...
2010-10-31 - World Series Prospectus: Game Three Report
2010-10-31 - Premium Article World Series Prospectus: Game Three Analysis