CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe
<< Previous Article
Premium Article Future Shock: Future T... (03/17)
<< Previous Column
One-Hoppers: Willie Da... (03/17)
Next Column >>
Premium Article One-Hoppers: What Make... (03/19)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Squawking Baseball: Sp... (03/18)

March 18, 2010


Brendan Ryan Afield

by Christina Kahrl

the archives are now free.

All Baseball Prospectus Premium and Fantasy articles more than a year old are now free as a thank you to the entire Internet for making our work possible.

Not a subscriber? Get exclusive content like this delivered hot to your inbox every weekday. Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get instant access to the best baseball content on the web.

Subscribe for $4.95 per month
Recurring subscription - cancel anytime.

a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Purchase a $39.95 gift subscription
a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.

I'm fond of saying that fielding metrics are probably best used in a wisdom-of-crowds kind of way, where you should look at all or as many of them as possible for any one player, and take the various and sometimes differing interpretations of his performance as a collective broad hint as far as a player's ability. Taking any one of them as gospel is a matter of choice, of course, but since all of the systems have their own quirks, virtues, and weaknesses, I favor casting a wide net.

The reason I bring this up is the interesting case of Brendan Ryan's fielding prowess. As I wrote a bit in this year's Cardinals essay in the Baseball Prospectus 2010, Skip Schumaker's conversion to second base wasn't exactly pretty; it worked, but it came with a cost in the field. But across the bag, Schumaker (and Cardinals pitchers) seemed to get the benefit of a huge defensive contribution from a new regular shortstop--not Khalil Greene, as they might have anticipated after trading for him, but organizational soldier Brendan Ryan. Using just FRAA, I couldn't help but be impressed by what Clay's Fielding Runs had to say in its evaluation of Ryan, crediting him with 31 runs of value. That's an enormous number, so with Eric Seidman's help, I took it up a notch, using FRAA2, the flavor of Fielding Runs that adjusts for league difficulty. Using Clay's metrics gives us the advantage of seeing everybody ever, putting Ryan's season into historical context by relying on the records at our disposal:

Guy Team Year FRAA2
Troy Tulowitzki Rockies 2007 41
Roger Peckinpaugh Senators 1924 37
Rafael Furcal Braves 2005 36
Brendan Ryan Cardinals 2009 35
Terry Turner Indians 1906 34
Bert Campaneris Athletics 1973 34
Adam Everett Astros 2006 34
Mike Bordick Orioles 1999 33
Tommy Thevenow Cardinals 1926 33
Omar Vizquel Giants 2007 32










I stopped with Vizquel for a top 10, but in point of fact he's tied with Frank Crosetti's 1939 season with the Yankees and Art Fletcher's 1917 season with the Giants with a FRAA2 of 32. OK, that's pretty impressive as a group. It's not a rate metric,  of course, but it does give us a broad-strokes comment on some great-fielding shortstops playing regularly. A couple of regulars from pennant winners, but a few from losing ballclubs as well. A few names we recognize and are usually associated with defensive excellence--Everett, Vizquel, Tulo, but also Peckinpaugh--but already, at this early juncture, there a few surprises. Tommy Thevenow? Wow, a positive thing to say about the man perhaps best known for having to play short for the 1930 Phillies, a team infamous for its ability to allow runs, not prevent them.

To see what other tools in the box have to say about Ryan, for a similar metric that, like Clay's metrics, relies on play-by-play data, I referred to Sean Smith's Total Zone, which you'll find for individual players on the incomparable Baseball-Reference (for more info, you can surf here). What does Total Zone's Runs Above Average say about the single-season all-time greats? Well, it's not quite so eager to propel Ryan to such heights, producing this top 10:

Dude Team Year Rtz
Adam Everett Astros 2006 37
Ozzie Smith Cardinals 1989 32
Mark Belanger Orioles 1975 32
Rey Ordonez Mets 1999 29
Art Fletcher Giants 1917 28
Terry Turner Indians 1906 28
Mark Belanger Orioles 1968 27
Monte Ward Giants 1887 26
Tommy Thevenow Cardinals 1926 26
Mark Belanger Orioles 1978 26
Dick Bartell Giants 1936 26

That gives a few of the same names in terms of further back in history (Thevenow, Fletcher, and Turner), gives Mark Belanger and Ozzie Smith some props that certainly feel good on a certain visceral level for those of us willing to admit we're fortysomethings, and provides a number that provides some support to the Mets' decision to play Rey Ordonez regularly. It also ends up agreeing that Adam Everett's 2006 season deserves tremendous regard. And Ryan? He's tied for 122nd all-time with 16 runs above average, tied with Tulo's 2009 campaign, Royce Clayton's 1995, or Bucky Dent's 1978, among others. That's good, handy, lovely... but also not quite epic.

Turn to other metrics, and Ryan fares well. Via John Dewan's Plus/Minus, it looks like Ryan's 2009 was the second-best shortstop season in MLB in terms of plays (+25) and runs (+19), rating behind the slick-fielding Jack Wilson in both regards. Obviously, that's not historic, and Plus/Minus doesn't cover the full spread of history. And UZR? It ranks him fifth in raw valuation (+10.6), again, saying he's an extremely valuable asset in the field.

Intrigued by the results, I couldn't help but wonder about a few of the factors in play: Joel Pineiro's even more pronounced grounderifficness? Some form of compensation for the recently converted Schumaker? The benefit of playing behind two of the game's best pitchers, Chris Carpenter and Adam Wainwright, since their form of dominance might lead to fewer well-hit balls in play? Musing about this stuff on BP's internal distribution list, I ended up pestering Russell Carleton about his thoughts on Ryan, especially since Russell's got his own fielding tool, OPA! Russell spun his system off of what Dan Fox had started at BP with Simple Fielding Runs as well as Sean Smith's work. But Russell brought into play his own insights into fielding interpretation. As he explains it:

My hook was that I broke things down into component parts. For example, on a ground ball, I thought it was foolish only to count completed plays. For example, a grounder to short, Theriot gets to it, fields it, and throws it to first, but Derek Lee drops the ball. Theriot did everything right... he should get credit, and Lee get the blame. So, I broke grounders down to range, hands, arm, and catch (over at first, mostly). The idea is that if a shortstop gets to the ball, then 70-something percent of the time (probably more, I'm just making numbers up), there will be an out recorded. If he fields it cleanly, that jumps to 90 percent, if he makes the throw, it's 99.5 percent...

I convert it all into runs.  Among shortstops with 81 or more Equivalent Games (26 players), Ryan was fourth in runs saved per inning in MLB at shorstop behind Tulo, Scutaro, and Cesar Izturis; Paul Janish was also better, but didn't qualify. Ryan ranked seventh in ground-ball range (per GB hit in his area), 16th in clean fielding, and third in arm. He was fourth on the double-play pivot (per relevant 'could be' DP GB). ... So, his main skills are in the area of grounders, which of course is the bread and butter of any infielder. His weakness is that he will boot a few of them, but his range is good and his arm is good. He's what I call a gross motor skills shortstop. Good legs, good arms, questionable hands. As opposed to the fine motor skills (which you do with your hands, like picking a grounder).

My system is corrected for chances, so the Joel Piniero ground-ball machine theory goes out the window. Carpenter and Wainwright probably made the batters make less good contact, so maybe he was getting easier grounders to field, but his arm was still good, and Carpenter and Wainwright can't help him there. Schumaker rates out pretty poorly at second, although I don't see how that would make Ryan better. To give some perspective, Tulo saved twice as many runs as Ryan did last year (22 vs. 10). Ryan is pretty good, but not historically good.

All of which is pretty cool to have dug up, and I'm grateful to fellow statheads beyond BP, as well as Eric, Clay, Russell, and Jay Jaffe for their input within our own ranks. As an exercise in casting a broad net to learn something general about a single player's value in the field, there was certainly broad agreement: Ryan's a valuable defender. I know that's perhaps obvious, but basically I wanted to see what all of the systems said about a player which one of them singled out and described as remarkably good. In the broad strokes, doing so settles for me, the liberal arts type, the proposition of roughly where we should place Ryan's greatness in the field: among the ranks of the good to really good, given that the broad consensus seems to favor a more conservative interpretation of his value.

Christina Kahrl is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Christina's other articles. You can contact Christina by clicking here

Related Content:  Brendan Ryan

2 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Future Shock: Future T... (03/17)
<< Previous Column
One-Hoppers: Willie Da... (03/17)
Next Column >>
Premium Article One-Hoppers: What Make... (03/19)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Squawking Baseball: Sp... (03/18)

Short Relief: An Orel History
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Common Sense Beanball Control
Cold Takes: The Natural Conclusion of Baseba...
BP Bronx
BP Milwaukee
BP Wrigleyville
Baseball Prospectus Announcement

Fantasy Article Team Health Reports: Los Angeles Dodgers
Premium Article Squawking Baseball: Sports TV's Golden Age
Premium Article Contractual Matters: NL West Projected Payro...

2010-03-19 - Premium Article Transaction Action: National League
2010-03-19 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: Hendry's Window
2010-03-18 - BP Unfiltered: Chicago DePaul Booksigning
2010-03-18 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: Brendan Ryan Afield
2010-03-17 - Premium Article Transaction Action: Put Up Your Dukes?
2010-03-17 - Premium Article Transaction Action: Small Shuffles
2010-03-16 - Premium Article Transaction Action: Lefty-less and Zedliness

2010-03-22 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: How Long Will Mauer Catch?
2010-03-19 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: Hendry's Window
2010-03-19 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: What Makes a Good Leadoff Man?
2010-03-18 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: Brendan Ryan Afield
2010-03-17 - One-Hoppers: Willie Davis (1940-2010)
2010-03-16 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: Any 'O' In Toronto?
2010-03-16 - Premium Article One-Hoppers: Don't start Strasburg's clock y...