The Atlanta Blues: Post All-Star-Game Starts

In my years of following baseball, I’ve formed the impression that starters
who pitch in the All-Star Game tend to be a little off in their first start
after the midsummer classic. This year, while watching SportsCenter
highlights of Al Leiter getting shellacked, I decided to look a
little more deeply to see if my impression is borne out by the numbers.

I took all the starters who appeared in the 2000 All-Star Game and looked
at each pitcher’s subsequent start. As you’ll see, the numbers aren’t pretty:

                                                          Rank Among
Pitcher         Date  Park H/R      IP   R  Dec.   SNVA   Own Starts

Darryl Kile     7/15   CHW  R      4.2   6   L    -0.32   3rd worst
Al Leiter       7/16   TOR  R      5.2   6   L    -0.27   worst
Aaron Sele      7/15   SDP  R      5.0   4   L    -0.23   3rd worst
David Wells     7/15   TOR  H      7.0   6   L    -0.20   3rd worst
Kevin Brown     7/14   LAD  H      7.0   4   L    -0.10   worst (tied)
Tim Hudson      7/16   COL  R      3.0   3   N    -0.03   10th worst
Randy Johnson   7/15   ARI  H      7.1   5   N     0.01   4th worst
James Baldwin   7/16   CHW  H      8.0   4   W     0.03   8th worst
Tom Glavine     7/15   BAL  R      7.0   2   W     0.18   6th best

TOTALS                            54.2  40  2-5   -0.93
                                 (6.59 R/9)

(Hudson’s game against the Rockies was called by rain after three innings,
so his numbers above aren’t part of his official stats.)

Remember, these are the All-Stars, supposedly the cream of the crop, and
they collectively allowed more than six-and-a-half runs per game in their
first starts back. Six of the nine pitchers–Leiter, Darryl Kile,
Aaron Sele, David Wells, Kevin Brown and Randy
Johnson–had a start that ranked among their worst four games of the year.

I’m no expert on mechanics, but I can imagine a number of possible reasons
why a starter would struggle after pitching in the All-Star game. Lack of
rest is one possibility. While you may have noticed that three of the
starters above took the usual four days rest after the July 11 exhibition,
none of those three got four days’ rest before the All-Star game. In fact,
of the nine, only Kevin Brown got the standard four days before the
All-Star Game. And the number of rest days aside, simply the act of warming
up and then throwing an inning or two under game conditions represents a
deviation from these guys’ usual routines.

Numbers from nine starts are not enough to prove anything. On the other
hand, when you’re talking about potentially costing your team a game in a
tight pennant race, all for the sake of appearing in an exhibition game,
you have to wonder how much proof is needed. If a few more numbers like the
ones above come to light, you may start seeing more and more of the
league’s top starters suddenly come up with "injuries" right
around the All-Star break.

Michael Wolverton can be reached at mwolverton@baseballprospectus.com.