Under The Knife

The Neverending Story

by Will Carroll

Usually at this time of year, I'm prepping the Playoff Health Reports and coasting through my last couple columns. For those of you new to BP—and there's a lot of you—UTK essentially goes into hibernation for the winter, largely because the volume of injuries to report on goes to nil. I'll be watching the playoffs and posting on BP Unfiltered, so you're not rid of me yet. But instead of coasting, I'm facing three more columns this weekend, watching how injuries will affect the playoff races, with all four slots in the NL as unsettled as can be. I'll head down to Cincy to watch the Cubs and the Reds. We'll see things we don't normally see. Instead of extensive shutdown lists, we'll see kitchen-sink bullpens and aces coming in on short rest looking to lock down or save playoff hopes. We'll see aces like Jake Peavy and Brandon Webb more focused on winning one game than winning a Cy Young. At this stage of the season, I'm less concerned by things like an ace on short rest or Scott Kazmir going over his hard limit to get the K title (though he didn't). You take some risk for the reward and hope you balanced it correctly. Context, especially at this time of year, is everything.

The Brewers don't think that Ben Sheets gives them the best chance of winning if he starts. The tight hamstring is simply too tight to last through several innings and to give the team any sort of confidence that he could go even three or four innings. Instead, he'll be shifted to the pen. Yes, there's a bit of a disconnect here—if he can't get loose on a normal starter's schedule, how is he going to do it popping up in the bullpen? I don't think he'll be treated as a normal reliever, so if anything, he'll be used as a 'kitchen sink' reliever in one of the weekend games. If he reinjures himself, he has four months before spring training and even if it's a bad strain, it's not like he doesn't have other chronic problems to deal with anyway. If the Brewers and Padres are still both in contention on Sunday, things could get really interesting.

The Angels limp into the playoffs with more injuries than any other contending team thought there is a silver lining in their outfield situation. Vladimir Guerrero is suddenly throwing without pain, tossing 100 feet in the outfield and showing no signs of problem. The quick cure smells like a cortisone injection, something that's been mentioned before but never confirmed by the team. No one is willing to give even the slightest hint publicly about when Guerrero will return to the outfield, but there's some talk that they think there could be an experiment this weekend to determine the viability of him playing there in the playoffs. The bad news is that Gary Matthews Jr. is still hobbled by a swollen and painful knee, putting his status for the playoffs in doubt. The Angels have a couple of different rosters worked up for the first round, depending on who's available and who they'll face, so they won't be caught off guard by this.

Milton Bradley had his knee surgery, repairing the ACL torn in the strangest manner I've ever seen as well as some associated meniscal problems. Bradley likely won't be ready for spring training, and even then will have another chronic problem to deal with on top of his leg, back, and oblique problems, as well as any attempt to rehabilitate the reputation he carries. Bradley had Tim Kremchek do the surgery since Kremchek repaired his knee back in 2005 when Bradley was dealing with a patellar tendon problem. Bradley was able to return quickly from that, and there's no reason to think that he won't be able to do the same here, once he finds a team that needs his bat.

The rest of this article is restricted to Baseball Prospectus Subscribers.

Not a subscriber?

Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get access to the best baseball content on the web.

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.

0 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Lies, Damned Lies: Blo... (09/27)

<< Previous Column

Under The Knife: Falli... (09/27)

Next Column >>

Under The Knife: Satur... (09/29)

Next Article >>

Prospectus Matchups: T... (09/28)

RECENTLY AT BASEBALL PROSPECTUS Checking the Numbers: The 2009 Platoon Split... Prospectus Today: The Opening Bell Voting for Real Fantasy Focus: First Base Rankings Review Early Career Splits Prospectus Q&A: Lou Marson and David Huff Future Shock: Indians Top 11	MORE FROM SEPTEMBER 28, 2007 Prospectus Today: September's Gift Prospectus Matchups: The Matchups That Matte...
MORE BY WILL CARROLL 2007-10-03 - Under The Knife: Playoff Health Report, NL 2007-10-02 - Under The Knife: Playoff Health Report, AL 2007-09-29 - Under The Knife: Saturday Special 2007-09-28 - Under The Knife: The Neverending Story 2007-09-27 - Under The Knife: Falling Angels 2007-09-26 - Under The Knife: Tune-ups and Shut-downs 2007-09-24 - Under The Knife: Angels on the Mound and Pad... More...	MORE UNDER THE KNIFE 2007-10-03 - Under The Knife: Playoff Health Report, NL 2007-10-02 - Under The Knife: Playoff Health Report, AL 2007-09-29 - Under The Knife: Saturday Special 2007-09-28 - Under The Knife: The Neverending Story 2007-09-27 - Under The Knife: Falling Angels 2007-09-26 - Under The Knife: Tune-ups and Shut-downs 2007-09-24 - Under The Knife: Angels on the Mound and Pad... More...