To quote a commercial I saw far too often this weekend: "Too much good
stuff." That was baseball the past few days, one of those weekends
that had all the variety and all the storylines that keep fans coming back
year after year.
The biggest story was in Minnesota, of all places, where Cal Ripken
broke out of a slump with a three-hit game Saturday night, the last of the
hits his 3,000th. Ripken gets more attention for The Streak than for his
on-field accomplishments, which is a shame, because he will retire as the
second-best shortstop in the game’s history.
The Streak probably isn’t even Ripken’s signature mark on the game. His
greatest legacy will be that he played shortstop, and played it very well,
as a tall, lanky man. Ripken proving that a player of his size could be an
everyday shortstop, and a good one, paved the way for the super shortstops
we see today, players who might have been moved off their positions in
earlier decades.
By extension, Ripken is a contributor to the offensive explosion we see
today. No longer are certain positions deemed "defensive", with
teams content to put a light-hitting glove man somewhere and suffer his
bat. Teams want to get offense from everywhere, and the best teams put
nine-man lineups on the field with no easy outs anywhere. Ripken’s success
as a shortstop was a big part in the way the game changed.
One of the shortstops inheriting Ripken’s legacy had himself a good old
time this weekend. Alex Rodriguez capped a big series in Toronto
with three home runs on Sunday, part of a 19-run barrage that was itself
part of a three-day, 47-run orgy at the expense of the Blue Jays. With all
due respect to Derek Jeter and Nomar Garciaparra, Rodriguez
is the best of the Trinity, and has a reasonable chance to be one of the
ten best players in the game’s history.
That sweep calls into serious question the health of the Blue Jays’ young
pitchers. Two of them, Roy Halladay and Chris Carpenter were
bludgeoned for 12 runs in 7 1/3 innings Saturday and Sunday. Along with
Kelvim Escobar, they all sport ERAs above 7.00 early in the season,
this on top of unimpressive 1999 campaigns and, in Carpenter’s case, injury
problems. The Blue Jays have a good offense, but if Carpenter, Halladay and
Escobar don’t develop, they have no chance to make any noise in the AL East
for the next few years.
Amidst all these runs, there was some impressive pitching as well, and not
just in the obvious places. Yes, Pedro Martinez and Randy
Johnson pitched, they were wildly effective and their teams won. But
Sunday, Esteban Loaiza threw 7 1/3 shutout innings, adding ten
strikeouts for a Game Score of 82–against Cleveland–and came away
with nothing. Chuck Finley went the distance, with a Game Score of
84, and watched his Indians avoid being swept on back-to-back home runs in
the bottom of the ninth. Sidney Ponson of the Orioles shut out the
Twins, and he did it on just 117 pitches, good news for someone who was
ridden hard in 1999. The Angels’ Scott Schoeneweis had his second
straight impressive start, following up his shutout of the Blue Jays by
limiting the White Sox to one run on three hits in eight innings.
And yet, with all that great pitching, the game of the weekend was one I’m
sure many readers were treated to unexpectedly. With rain wiping out ESPN’s
scheduled game of Diamondbacks at Giants, the network plugged in the
Cardinals/Rockies game, a makeup of a game snowed out on Saturday. 27 runs,
32 hits–11 for extra bases–18 walks, 11 pitchers, seven "crooked
numbers" on the scoreboard and a running catch by Larry Walker
that kept it from being even worse. The Rockies game back from a four-run
deficit in the sixth inning and held on despite a four-run ninth by the
Cardinals, who left the bases and, in all likelihood, thousands of Denver
residents loaded.
Many people who write about baseball, both in the mainstream press and
elsewhere, insist that baseball in Colorado is a problem to be solved, that
the altitude requires that something drastic be done, from altering the
baseball to building a pressurized dome. I think we should embrace the
differences. Baseball is baseball, and if it’s different in Denver than it
is in Detroit, or if it’s different in 2000 than it was in 1988, those are
good things. Last night’s game was exciting and fun and crazy and wild,
just as the game in Cleveland between the Rangers and Indians was tense and
taut and thrilling. I have no doubt that anyone new to baseball seeing
either game would be a fan by game’s end.
From two hours and 41 minutes of a spectacular pitchers’ duel during the
day to four hours and 19 minutes of a knock-down, drag-out slugfest at
night. From what could be the last great achievement of one of the greats
of the 20th century to a signature day in the early career of his 21st
century counterpart. It was a great weekend for baseball.
Joe Sheehan can be reached at jsheehan@baseballprospectus.com.
Thank you for reading
This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.
Subscribe now