CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe
Strength of Schedule Report
<< Previous Article
Premium Article Notes from the Field: ... (08/22)
<< Previous Column
Rubbing Mud: Lineups A... (08/17)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: The Menta... (08/23)
Next Article >>
Liner Notes: Kenny, Bo... (08/22)

August 22, 2017

Rubbing Mud

They Might Be Rebuilding

by Matthew Trueblood


On Thursday afternoon, I hosted a chat on this site, and one of the questions asked was about the immediate future of the Giants. Obviously, this season has been a catastrophe, but they still have a number of guys to whom they’re committed not only financially and emotionally, but on a baseball level. The core of the next good Giants team was supposed to be this core, when the season began, and it’s not clear that the team has significantly altered that general mindset, even as they hurtle toward 100 losses.

When I was asked about them, I found I had relatively little to say. They’re as uninspiring, in that way, as they are bad right now. I mentioned, I think, that it will be very interesting to see if Johnny Cueto can even pitch well enough down the stretch to make what seemed to be an almost automatic opt-out clause in his contract come to fruition. I also said that, if I were to start taking on the task of rebuilding this franchise, I might begin with a front office shakeup. A few days later, I find myself certain that the Giants need to rebuild—urgently, and drastically.

I was winding down the final games of Thursday’s sleepy schedule, and happened to have the Padres (hosting the Nationals) and the Giants (hosting the Phillies) up on my MLB.tv display, side by side. That’s when it really hit me: the Padres are already the better club. It’s not that they’re playing better right now, or that they’re healthier, or that their younger talent is holding up better as we move out of the dog days and into the real home stretch. It’s that they’re honestly better. They have excellent defenders at as many spots as the Giants have them. Their outfield is better, even with Hunter Renfroe being demoted back to the minors. Wil Myers may have eclipsed Brandon Belt, if only because of the latter’s injury problems.

The Giants have a bevy of big-name starters, but the Padres have some interesting guys in their own right, and their bullpen (which is becoming a key barometer of a team’s ability to build a roster suited to the modern game) is far superior to San Francisco’s. They’re also hungrier, and (thanks to their own sprinkling of veteran leadership) they’re learning to handle the ups and downs of a season. The Giants already know how to do all of that, of course, but they learned to do it only in the context of chasing down the next championship. Now the next championship, for every member of that team, will probably come in another uniform, if it comes at all.

It’s hard to maintain concentration and mental discipline under those circumstances. All of that is true, and none of it even reaches the bedrock. Here’s what does: the Padres have one of the elite farm systems in baseball. The Giants, uh, don’t. Both teams are looking up at the Dodgers, not just now, but in any reasonable forecast of the 2020 NL West standings. Both are probably looking up at the Rockies, who are much better than them this year and have enough young talent to make even San Diego’s eventual charge a real fight. The Diamondbacks will eventually have a bridge year or two, but they’re under very smart management now, and their short-term outlook might be even brighter than Colorado’s.

In summary, neither team has an easy road back to contention, and if the Giants hope to sneak right back into the picture in 2018, they’re going to find those hopes violently dashed. It’s an unfortunate state of affairs, but also a predictable one, of course. This is how all dynasties end (well, all non-Yankees dynasties), and the Giants’ dynasty was always a low-flying plane, primed to really crash and burn when it finally went down. They never made consecutive postseasons. Their last World Series-winning team won just 88 games, but then a bee stung Madison Bumgarner’s blue ox or something. The last two seasons saw them fight furiously just to attain win totals in the mid-80s. It cost them something, and now their next half-decade seems likely to look a lot like the last half-decade of the team who visited AT&T Park on Thursday night.

The rest of this article is restricted to Baseball Prospectus Subscribers.

Not a subscriber?

Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get access to the best baseball content on the web.


Cancel anytime.


That's a 33% savings over the monthly price!


That's a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.

Related Content:  San Francisco Giants

2 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Notes from the Field: ... (08/22)
<< Previous Column
Rubbing Mud: Lineups A... (08/17)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: The Menta... (08/23)
Next Article >>
Liner Notes: Kenny, Bo... (08/22)

RECENTLY AT BASEBALL PROSPECTUS
Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: A Few of My Favorite Dyna...
BP En Espanol: Confesiones de un falso manag...
What You Need to Know: Best of the Best
Short Relief: Our Large Retired Sons
BP Toronto
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Half-Truths and Collision Cours...
Baseball Prospectus News: Subscription Price...

MORE FROM AUGUST 22, 2017
Premium Article Notes from the Field: August 22, 2017
Short Relief: The Wonderful Vulgarity of Mia...
What You Need to Know: 88-35
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of August 21
Expert FAAB Review: Week 21
Fantasy Article Closer Report: Week 21
BP South Side

MORE BY MATTHEW TRUEBLOOD
2017-08-30 - Rubbing Mud: Which Stripes Do You Switch?
2017-08-25 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Are You Ready for the Fallout?
2017-08-23 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: The Mental Side of Shifting
2017-08-22 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: They Might Be Rebuilding
2017-08-21 - Transaction Analysis: Grand Exit
2017-08-17 - Rubbing Mud: Lineups Are Just a Social Const...
2017-08-16 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: How the Pendulum Swings
More...

MORE RUBBING MUD
2017-08-30 - Rubbing Mud: Which Stripes Do You Switch?
2017-08-25 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Are You Ready for the Fallout?
2017-08-23 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: The Mental Side of Shifting
2017-08-22 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: They Might Be Rebuilding
2017-08-17 - Rubbing Mud: Lineups Are Just a Social Const...
2017-08-16 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: How the Pendulum Swings
2017-07-14 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: This is Really All We Know: The...
More...