CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe
<< Previous Article
Short Relief: Imaginar... (03/17)
<< Previous Column
Rubbing Mud: The World... (03/13)
Next Column >>
Rubbing Mud: Lift Your... (03/21)
Next Article >>
Looking Back on Tomorr... (03/17)

March 17, 2017

Rubbing Mud

Roberto Osuna's Complicated Relationships

by Matthew Trueblood


Earlier this week BP Toronto ran an excellent article by Kyle Matte about Roberto Osuna’s evolving array of breaking stuff. Specifically, Matte wrote about Osuna’s development of a cutter in 2016, and the way (as he observed, providing considerable evidence) it somewhat cannibalized his slider. Whenever a pitcher adds a new pitch to his arsenal there’s reason to hope that it will add a new dimension to his game, but there’s also cause to worry that it might eat into the effectiveness of one or more of his other pitches.

Last week, I wrote about Dan Straily’s effort to flesh out his two-seam fastball this winter and about his expressed concern that doing so would compromise his changeup or slider. As I did with Straily’s sinker, though, I thought I'd dig into Osuna’s tunneling numbers to see whether the cutter offered a benefit that might make the tradeoffs worthwhile. What I found was pretty interesting, so I thought I would briefly share it here.

See, I think Osuna’s cutter actually has the potential to be a devastating weapon. He might just need to deploy it more strategically. First, some basic data. Osuna did see a change in the sequence interaction of his fastball and slider, from 2015 to 2016, and it’s safe to say that the introduction of the cutter drove that change.

Roberto Osuna, Fastball-Slider (and Fastball-Cutter), 2015-16

Sequence

Pitches

Release Diff.

Tunnel Diff.

Flight Time Diff.

Late Break Diff

Plate Diff.

FA-SL ‘15

86

.2130

.7258

.0321

.3258

1.5734

FA-SL ‘16

115

.3211

.7988

.0430

.4262

1.6652

FA-FC ‘16

20

.2296

.4674

.0150

.2007

1.0675

You can see some of what Matte was seeing (from the less granular perspective of PITCHf/x pitch characteristics) in this table. Two things seem to have happened:

  1. Osuna took some percentage of the situations in which he would normally follow up his fastball with his slider, and instead threw the cutter. He used the cutter more often against lefties than against righties. He seems to have selected situations in which he had just thrown a fastball somewhere near the first-base side of home plate, and needed to throw a pitch that played off that one and ended up in a different spot, but didn’t feel he could safely use the bigger-breaking slider to do it.
  2. In switching from one breaking ball to two (or one-and-a-half), Osuna slightly altered the arm slot out of which he threw the slider. That allowed him to spin the slider slightly differently, with a spin axis geared more toward sink and less toward sweep, and left the cutter for the situations in which he needed lateral movement most. It also made the slider easier to differentiate from the fastball, out of the hand.

In a vacuum, however, those cutter numbers are dazzling. Of the 134 pitchers who threw a [four-seamer, cutter] sequence at least 10 times last year, Osuna’s combination had the smallest tunnel differential, by far. The pitch pairing had an above-average post-tunnel break differential too, so no lack of movement minimized the value of the tunnel differential. However (and here’s where things get interesting), Osuna’s plate differential for that pitch sequence was the smallest of the aforementioned 134, by another healthy margin.

What that’s all telling us is that Osuna simply doesn’t have the optimal plan for his cutter yet. He’s throwing the pitch to the same part of the zone as the fastballs that precede it, and while that might be optimal for starters (who occasionally need to trade whiffs for weak contact) it doesn’t suit Osuna’s role or his repertoire. If he can’t figure out how to throw the pitch out of the same arm slot as the fastball without throwing it to the same location, then Matte was right: he should scrap it. If, on the other hand, he can get sufficient feel for the pitch to allow him to throw it to both sides of the plate, he’ll have a legitimate and occasionally dominant fourth pitch.

The rest of this article is restricted to Baseball Prospectus Subscribers.

Not a subscriber?

Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get access to the best baseball content on the web.


Cancel anytime.


That's a 33% savings over the monthly price!


That's a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.

0 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Short Relief: Imaginar... (03/17)
<< Previous Column
Rubbing Mud: The World... (03/13)
Next Column >>
Rubbing Mud: Lift Your... (03/21)
Next Article >>
Looking Back on Tomorr... (03/17)

RECENTLY AT BASEBALL PROSPECTUS
Rumor Roundup: Suspensions, Extensions, and ...
Short Relief: Spring Dismissals, Veteran Exp...
Premium Article Guarding The Lines: The Pompey Zone
Looking Back on Tomorrow: Arizona Diamondbac...
Looking Back on Tomorrow: San Francisco Gian...
Circle Change: Daniel Murphy Raises the Ghos...
Looking Back on Tomorrow: Minnesota Twins

MORE FROM MARCH 17, 2017
Looking Back on Tomorrow: Houston Astros
Looking Back on Tomorrow: Toronto Blue Jays
Short Relief: Imaginary Players and Imaginar...
Rumor Roundup: Kissing Your Sister
Fantasy Article Position Battles: American League East
Fantasy Article Fantasy Auction Values: Third Edition, 2017
Fantasy Article The Quinton: Selecting Relievers and Anticip...

MORE BY MATTHEW TRUEBLOOD
2017-03-24 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Freddie Freeman Takes the Zone ...
2017-03-21 - Rubbing Mud: Lift Yourself Up By Your Launch...
2017-03-20 - Looking Back on Tomorrow: Tampa Bay Rays
2017-03-17 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Roberto Osuna's Complicated Rel...
2017-03-15 - Looking Back on Tomorrow: Los Angeles Angels
2017-03-13 - Rubbing Mud: The World Baseball Classic and ...
2017-03-10 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Dan Straily's Maybe Changing Tw...
More...

MORE RUBBING MUD
2017-03-24 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Freddie Freeman Takes the Zone ...
2017-03-21 - Rubbing Mud: Lift Yourself Up By Your Launch...
2017-03-17 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Roberto Osuna's Complicated Rel...
2017-03-13 - Rubbing Mud: The World Baseball Classic and ...
2017-03-10 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Dan Straily's Maybe Changing Tw...
2017-03-07 - Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Further Frontiers: Handedness
More...