CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Baseball Therapy: Trad... (07/29)
<< Previous Column
BP Unfiltered: The Bat... (07/25)
Next Column >>
BP Unfiltered: The 201... (07/31)
Next Article >>
Premium Article What You Need to Know:... (07/30)

July 30, 2014

BP Unfiltered

The Ultimate Showdown of Ultimate Rarities

by Russell A. Carleton

On Wednesday's episode of Effectively Wild, sponsored by the Baseball Reference Play Index and featuring BP's own Editor-in-Chief Sam Miller and some other guy who now works for Disney and is therefore dead to us, a listener asked one of those questions that means nothing in the grand scheme of things, but... can't... resist... answering.

Which is more likely? That a batter would hit 5 home runs in the same game or that a pitcher would record 5 strikeouts in the course of an inning? In baseball history, there have been 16 players who have hit 4 home runs in a game and 71 innings where a pitcher recorded 4 strikeouts in an inning (Chuck Finley did it three times in his career!)

Just in case: Yes, it is possible to record more than three strikeouts in an inning. If a catcher drops the ball on a third strike, then the ball is live and the batter becomes a runner who can try to make it to first and must either be tagged or thrown out. It happens once in a while that a batter swings at and misses a two strike pitch, but it gets to the backstop and he takes first safely. The official scoring is a strikeout, but with the runner to first and no out recorded.

Warning! Gory Mathematical Details Ahead!

Let me flip over this envelope here and first look at the probabilities of 5 K's in one inning:

Despite the fact that we know that pitchers vary in their ability to strike batters out and that catchers vary in their ability to block balls in the dirt from getting away, we're just going to use league averages. For a five-strikeout inning to happen, two things need to be true. All five "outs" need to be of the strikeout variety. We don't necessarily need this to be a 1-2-3-4-5 inning, so we don't care what happens in any plate appearances that don't result in outs. However, 2 of the first 4 strikeouts need to be of the dropped third strike kind. The fifth one will have to necessarily be a clean K, because if more than three of the first four are clean, then the inning is already over.

(Technically, we also need the first guy who gets on base to move off of first, while not recording an out, and to keep other runners off first as well. The drop rule doesn't apply with a runner on first—unless there are two outs—but we're going to solve that problem by ignoring it.)

In 2013, when a batter made an out, he did so via strikeout 29.3 percent of the time. Thankfully, we live in a high strikeout era! Using a simple binary distribution, the chances of five consecutive outs happening via strikeout are 0.216%.

From 2003-2013, 97.6 percent of all strikeouts had the putout credited to the catcher. Either he caught the third strike cleanly or if the ball fell, he scooped it up and tapped the batter on the shin. That leaves 2.4 percent of strikeouts in which either a throw down to first was needed or where the batter made it safely, and the batter only made safe landfall at first in 1 out of 8 of those situations (0.3 percent of all strikeouts). The chances that at least 2 out of the first 4 of the strikeouts in our scenario would also feature a runner getting to first are 0.00000108%.

Multiply those numbers together and you get a 0.0000000023328% chance that an inning would happen like this. As some manner of scaling, that would be once every 42,866,941,015 half innings or roughly 980,039 seasons. We're almost literally looking at a 1 in a million chance that it will happen this year.

You could make the case that certain pitchers who strike more guys out or would be more likely to have a 5 K inning, but they also only account for a small percentage of all innings thrown. Alternately, there could be a bunching effect (strikeouts, like celebrity deaths, tend to come in groups of three?) but bunching effects —better known as "the hot hand"—have not generally appeared when we've gone looking for them.

On to five home runs in a game!

Figuring this one from a straight-up probability angle is easy enough, but we do need to talk about a couple issues. For one, if a player were to hit four home runs in a game, the opposing pitcher(s) probably didn't bring their A-game that day and it may be a blowout. If he gets a fifth at-bat, he's probably facing a sacrificial bullpen lamb who will be demoted tomorrow (so he's probably not good at HR prevention), but that guy may also not want to be remembered as an answer to the trivia question "Who gave up Duane Kuiper's fifth home run in that game?" On the flip side, the batter is most definitely swinging for the fences! If the game is somehow still close, the guy with four home runs will be intentionally walked. Yes, the fans will boo, but we gotta win.

Again, we will solve the problem by ignoring it.

In 2013, 2.5 percent of all plate appearances ended in a home run. Assuming that our player is league-average and that he had to go 5-for-5, he would do so in 0.0000009765625% of games, or roughly one in 102,400,000 games. However, there are 18 hitters in each of 2,430 games every year, so we would expect to see this once every 2,341 years. If we give him 6 chances to hit 5 HR, we would expect to see it once every 398 years.

There probably are bunching effects here too. Maybe he's having a "locked in" day, but even if we pretended that there was a hitter who was always Barry Bonds in 2001 (Bonds homered in 11.6 percent of the plate appearances where he wasn't intentionally walked) and gave him six chances to hit five home runs each game, we would expect him to do it once every 54 years.

It's not likely that a five home run game would happen, but it's much more likely to happen (by a couple orders of magnitude) than a five strikeout inning. The dropped-third-strike non-strikeout turns out to be so rare that expecting two to happen in the same inning is just too much to ask on top of a pitcher striking out five batters in the same inning. Then again, what sort of pitcher would have the stuff to throw two wild pitches in an inning, and yet get five hitters to strike out?

I guess it would be one who was (wait for it...)

Effectively Wild.

Russell A. Carleton is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Russell's other articles. You can contact Russell by clicking here

15 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links


I don't think it's necessarily true that all three outs, or even any of the three outs, need to be strikeouts. Three outs on strikeouts would be the most likely/simple case, but it's certainly possible to have three outs on balls-in-play and five reach-on-strikeouts. I think these alternative combinations of strikeouts/ball-in-play outs are so unlikely that they won't add to the probability you calculated here, but they're fun to think about. I love this stuff!

Jul 30, 2014 13:49 PM
rating: 0
BP staff member Russell A. Carleton
BP staff

I actually started down that proverbial rabbit hole and then thought better of it. Those are possible ways that it could happen, but again, reaching on a dropped third is such a rarity that covering those would add so little to the probability estimate.

Jul 30, 2014 14:11 PM

All of your simplifying assumptions were very defensible, because refining any of those matters was not going to take away a couple of orders of magnitude of difference. You never said you would estimate either event's probability accurately, only that you would try to figure out which was more likely.

Jul 31, 2014 20:18 PM
rating: 1

That said, I have this feeling that the 5-K event will happen next week, just to remind us that the universe does play dice.

Jul 31, 2014 20:21 PM
rating: 1

The synergy between the podcast and the rest of the site, particularly Russell, is fantastic. I mean, you know this already, but just wanted to say so. Love it.

Jul 30, 2014 13:55 PM
rating: 6
BP staff member Russell A. Carleton
BP staff

My goal is to have a week where they mention me in all 5 episodes.

Jul 30, 2014 14:16 PM

Difficult to calculate the likelihood of this. But I'd estimate it to be rather high.

Jul 30, 2014 15:58 PM
rating: 6

Potential-ish 5-strikeout catcher/pitcher combos to watch (based on high K% pitcher/low Blocking Runs Added catcher teammates, 2013-2014):

Wilin Rosario (-7.4 BR Added '13-14) and Boone Logan (30.6%) or Rex Brothers (24.7%)

Evan Gattis (-4.0) and anyone in the ATL bullpen

Jose Molina (-4.9) and anyone in the TBR bullpen

Jul 30, 2014 14:30 PM
rating: 3

Fun stuff. As a check of this line of reasoning, how do the actual versus expected occurrences for 4K innings and 4HR games compare?

When I do the same math for 4K innings (one guy getting on after K plus 3 other Ks), I get 1 per 45,228 half innings (but did not get paranoid and double and triple check my numbers). Given your statement on half innings and seasons, I get roughly 43,740 half innings in a season these days. So we expect about one 4K inning per season. That seems like it's under reality since 2003. Which might give some insight into the bunching effects. It seems like the actual rate of 4K innings is 2 or 3 times the expected rate in the modern strikeout era.

Fun fact while looking at this: There have been two occasions since 2003 where two different pitchers had 4K innings on the same day. What are the odds of that?

Jul 30, 2014 15:32 PM
rating: 4
BP staff member Russell A. Carleton
BP staff

I actually ran those just to look, but didn't save it. Four strikeouts has an odds of happening about once every year. Four HR is supposed to happen once every 11 or 12 years, using 2013 numbers as my baseline.

Jul 30, 2014 18:01 PM

And I just remembered reading this earlier in the season. Five strikeout innings have happened multiple times in minor league play: http://www.milb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20140702&content_id=82689052&fext=.jsp&vkey=news_milb

Jul 30, 2014 17:19 PM
rating: 5

Lloyd McClendon homered five times in the 1971 Little World Series. He was walked every other time. So, that's pretty cool.

Jul 30, 2014 23:26 PM
rating: 3

Little League*

Jul 30, 2014 23:26 PM
rating: 0


How's this for a rarity: lose your MILLION DOLLAR buyin televised on ESPN with AA vs. AA preflop to a runner/runner flush draw?

Jul 31, 2014 08:35 AM
rating: -1
Greg Ioannou

Is a double play on a walk even less likely that those events? (I would have thought it was impossible until Pittsburgh did it this week.) How about a triple play on a walk?

Jul 31, 2014 09:29 AM
rating: 1
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
Premium Article Baseball Therapy: Trad... (07/29)
<< Previous Column
BP Unfiltered: The Bat... (07/25)
Next Column >>
BP Unfiltered: The 201... (07/31)
Next Article >>
Premium Article What You Need to Know:... (07/30)

Premium Article What You Need to Know: June 2, 2015
Premium Article The Call-Up: Manny Banuelos
Fantasy Rounders: Split the Bit
Premium Article Painting the Black: #HugWatch2015: The Hugge...
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: They're No Angels
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: The Cole Hamels Decision
Premium Article The Call-Up: Miguel Sano

Premium Article Scouting the Draft: The Cape League All-Star...
Eyewitness Accounts: July 30, 2014
BBQ State of Mind
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Tuesday, July ...
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: Wednesday, July 30
Fantasy Article Dynasty Dynamics: Who We're Selling at the D...
Premium Article What You Need to Know: July 30, 2014

2014-08-19 - Premium Article Baseball Therapy: Becoming An Adult f/x
2014-08-12 - Baseball Therapy: I Believe In Clutch Hittin...
2014-08-05 - Premium Article Baseball Therapy: Big Extension, Big Mistake...
2014-07-30 - BP Unfiltered: The Ultimate Showdown of Ulti...
2014-07-29 - Premium Article Baseball Therapy: Trading Ryan Howard For No...
2014-07-15 - Premium Article Baseball Therapy: Why Are We Playing Hunger ...
2014-07-08 - Premium Article Baseball Therapy: What is a Fast Runner Wort...

2014-08-01 - BP Unfiltered: Professional Courtesy, and Ho...
2014-08-01 - BP Unfiltered: From the Road: Up Close, Batt...
2014-07-31 - BP Unfiltered: The 2014 Trade Deadline Trans...
2014-07-30 - BP Unfiltered: The Ultimate Showdown of Ulti...
2014-07-25 - BP Unfiltered: The Battered Bastards of Base...
2014-07-25 - BP Unfiltered: Every Yu/You Headline On MLB....
2014-07-23 - BP Unfiltered: The Baseball Fan's Guide to t...