CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe
Strength of Schedule Report
<< Previous Article
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (07/26)
<< Previous Column
BP Unfiltered: Is Rizz... (07/26)
Next Column >>
BP Unfiltered: The Bes... (07/28)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Collateral Damage: Kee... (07/27)

July 27, 2011

BP Unfiltered

Meals Money

by Mike Fast

Last night the Braves and Pirates played 19 innings. The game ended on a ground ball by Scott Proctor to Pedro Alvarez at third base. Julio Lugo broke from third base in attempt to score, and the throw from Alvarez to catcher Michael McKenry easily beat Lugo to home plate. McKenry attempted a swipe tag of Lugo's leg as he slid toward the plate. Home plate umpire Jerry Meals called Lugo safe with the winning run for the Braves, at which point Lugo quickly made a second effort to touch the plate. The Pirates and a great portion of baseball fans still awake at that hour were incensed with Meals' call, and the Braves celebrated.

Meals offered the following explanation after the game:

I saw the tag, but he looked like he ole'd him, and I called him safe for that. I looked at the replays and it appeared he might have got him on the shin area. I'm guessing he might have got him, but when I was out there when it happened, I didn't see a tag. I just saw the glove sweep up. I didn't see the glove hit his leg.

If you would like to know my opinions on the matter, you can check my Twitter feed. Here, however, I'd like to pose some questions and examine some of the evidence in more detail. Rather than simply blasting Meals for incompetence, I believe it is helpful to be more precise about the different questions at hand. I do not necessarily have answers for these questions, and the answers I do have, I'll keep to myself for the moment. Rob Neyer addressed some of these questions in his post on the topic this morning. You can probably find 500 other opinions on the matter without too much effort.

1. If the throw easily beat Lugo, should the umpire automatically call him out, even if he believed McKenry's tag didn't touch him? What if the umpire was unsure about the tag; should the timing of the throw figure into his judgment in that case?

2. Is the video evidence clear enough to overturn the umpire's call? If we had video replay on safe/out calls, what should the standard of evidence be? Overturn of a boundary home run call using replay requires "clear and convincing evidence." The National Football League uses a standard of "incontrovertible video evidence" for its replay system.

3. What does Lugo's reaction (or the reaction of other players, such as the pitcher Daniel McCutchen) indicate? Should a hypothetical replay umpire be allowed or instructed to consider evidence such as Lugo's reaction, or should he be restricted to video analysis of the tag itself?

4. Do you think McKenry's tag touched Lugo?

5. How should an umpire evaluator grade Meals on this play? Was the umpire positioned properly so that he had a good view of the play? What standard of video evidence should be required for evaluation, as opposed to replay? Should these grades or evaluations be made public? Should these grades or evaluations affect an umpire's continued employment, and if so, how?

6. Leaving aside the question of whether this particular call was correct, is there a better system of training that would improve or help to standardize umpire calls in cases like this? Would the use of replay help to accomplish that?

Finally, I want to offer a series of still frames from the MLB video of this call. Perhaps if you find animated GIFs or single still shots of plays like this to be deceiving or the videos too hard to follow, you will find these still shots as helpful as I did.

From the center-field angle:

CF frame 1

CF frame 2

CF frame 3

CF frame 4

CF frame 5

CF frame 6

CF frame 7

CF frame 8

CF frame 9

CF frame 10

And from the high third-base view:

3B frame 1

3B frame 2

3B frame 3

3B frame 4

3B frame 5

3B frame 6

3B frame 7

3B frame 8

3B frame 9

3B frame 10

3B frame 11

Mike Fast is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Mike's other articles. You can contact Mike by clicking here

Related Content:  Michael Mckenry

24 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (07/26)
<< Previous Column
BP Unfiltered: Is Rizz... (07/26)
Next Column >>
BP Unfiltered: The Bes... (07/28)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Collateral Damage: Kee... (07/27)

BP En Espanol: Confesiones de un falso manag...
BP En Espanol: Los menores records de jonron...
What You Need to Know: The Necessity of Not ...
Short Relief: The Earthly and the Celestial
Premium Article Rubbing Mud: Can a Team Be Too Reliant on Ho...
Premium Article Monday Morning Ten Pack: Our Favorite Prospe...
Flu-Like Symptoms: The Lesser Home Run Recor...

The Lineup Card: 17 Favorite Midseason Trade...
Premium Article On the Beat: The Angels Keep the Faith
Premium Article Collateral Damage: Keeping Up with the Jones
Fantasy Article Fantasy Beat: Expectations and Disappointmen...
Premium Article Expanded Horizons: The Mystery of Jered Weav...
Fantasy Article Value Picks: Outfield for 7/27/11
Premium Article Clubhouse Confidential: Dome Alone

2011-08-17 - Spinning Yarn: Why are Batters Hit by Pitche...
2011-08-06 - BP Unfiltered: Where No Counsell Is, the Peo...
2011-08-04 - Premium Article Spinning Yarn: Counsell for the Defense
2011-07-27 - BP Unfiltered: Meals Money
2011-07-20 - Spinning Yarn: A Zone of Their Own
2011-06-16 - BP Unfiltered: A New Screwballer
2011-06-15 - Spinning Yarn: Vogelsong Poetry

2011-08-16 - BP Unfiltered: Damon's Hunt For 3K
2011-08-06 - BP Unfiltered: Where No Counsell Is, the Peo...
2011-07-28 - BP Unfiltered: The Best First Hits
2011-07-27 - BP Unfiltered: Meals Money
2011-07-26 - BP Unfiltered: Is Rizzo The New Choi?
2011-07-23 - BP Unfiltered: The Hallworthy Alomar and Bly...
2011-07-22 - BP Unfiltered: Get a Job in Baseball Working...