CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
The BP Broadside: What... (05/27)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (05/26)
Next Column >>
Transaction Analysis: ... (05/31)
Next Article >>
Grumblings from a Surl... (05/27)

May 27, 2011

Transaction Analysis

May Swapmeet, Sizemore for Purcey

by Kevin Goldstein

The best thing about May trades is that they seem kind of random. When the Detroit Tigers traded infielder Scott Sizemore to the Oakland Athletics for lefty reliever David Purcey this afternoon, no one saw it coming.

“This guy is being wasted at Triple-A.”

“Scouts still believe in the bat.”

“He deserves another shot.”

Those are all things I wrote about Sizemore during the first month of the season, when he dwelt at Triple-A  and hit .408/.495/.605 in 23 games for Toledo. A career .301 hitter in the minors, including a .313 mark at the upper levels, Sizemore has spent a considerable amount of his professional career proving he can hit, but he's yet to jump the final hurdle of solving big league pitching. After earning the Tigers' opening-day job last spring, Sizemore lasted just 48 games after .224/.296/.336 numbers sent him back to the minors, and he didn't do much to get out of Jim Leyland's dog house this month by beginning his second stint by going 14-for-63 (.222). Still, we have a minor-league track record of well over 2000 plate appearances to go along with scouting reports that consistently say that this is not some kind of 4-A mistake hitter. Clearly he had worn out his welcome in Detroit, but he could end up quite the find for Oakland as a potential .280 hitter with plenty of doubles, a fair share of walks, and 10-12 home runs annually.

The biggest question is how Sizemore fits into Oakland's future plans. While he's seen as a second baseman, the position at which he's spent the majority of his time as a professional, that position is occupied by free agent-to-be Mark Ellis in Oakland, and 2008 first-round pick Jemile Weeks has been healthy and outstanding at Triple-A Sacramento, with his .322/.412/.454 line giving him likely first dibs at the position should Ellis get traded, or Oakland simply get tired of his non-productive ways. The guess here is that Oakland will give Sizemore a shot at the third base job, as they are now in their second year of trying to figure out why Kevin Kouzmanoff was never able to build on the somewhat promising seasons he had with San Diego. Currently hitting .198/.238/.333, he's one of many woeful performers in the Oakland lineup. While Sizemore would represent an upgrade at either position, he does have limited experience at the hot corner and fits better there for the A's, both in the near and long term.

As for Purcey, he certainly fits well with the Tigers' affinity for big guys who throw hard, but that has remained the sum of his skills as the 29-year-old is now far more known commodity than developing prospect. With a 92-95 mph fastball, Purcey can still bring it from the left side, but he's yet to find a dependable second pitch, and his control can come and go, with much more "go" in recent outings. It's hard to see him suddenly figuring things out at this point in his career, and his splits are not nearly dramatic enough to make him a future LOOGY. Further complicating matters is a tendency to elevate his pitches, a habit he'll pay for far more in Detroit than Oakland.

There is really no logic in the deal for the Tigers, as between Daniel Schlereth, Adam Wilk, and Charlie Furbush, they have plenty of capable left-handers in their bullpen, and merely being capable is the best they could hope for from Purcey. This is a case of a team getting too frustrated too soon with a prospect struggling in the big leagues, and Oakland swooped in on Friday afternoon to take advantage of the situation. 

Kevin Goldstein is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Kevin's other articles. You can contact Kevin by clicking here

Related Content:  Oakland

10 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links

Jason Wojciechowski

For the A's, the roster angle is probably even more important than the talent -- they only have two relievers who have options remaining, Devine and Ziegler, but someone was going to have to go to make room for Andrew Bailey this weekend.

Kevin, apologies if you've addressed this before somewhere that I've missed, but what's the word on Adrian Cardenas as a possible third base option? He's dropped off the prospect list radar, but just from his stat line, he's finally stopped scuffling at AAA, hitting for a ridiculous average with some walks, and he's still just 23. On the other hand, there's not much power and he's played much more left field than third base and he's DHing a lot.

May 27, 2011 16:42 PM
rating: 3

According to the local A's talk shows Cardenas cannot cut it at third but has been doing much better in LF.

May 28, 2011 12:22 PM
rating: 0

As a Tiger fan just how angry should I be about David Chadd's fixation on power arms right about now? Has it gone too far?

May 27, 2011 23:09 PM
rating: 1

I wrote a bit on Purcey after the Jays finally gave up on him earlier this season, designating him for assignment (he's out of options) and then sending him to Oakland in exchange for the return of Danny Farquhar: http://section203.wordpress.com/2011/04/13/purging-purcey-the-passing-of-a-prospect/.
I haven't followed his meta-pitching in Oakland but in Toronto, he was down to one pitch, and as Kevin noted, it went more often than it came.

May 28, 2011 06:28 AM
rating: 0

I 100% agree with toanstrom...and you Kevin. Sizemore was not given a proper shot to figure things out at the Major League level. Leyland put him in his Malboro-stenched doghouse and never let him out. Now we have another one-pitch power arm who will give up bombs. And a second base tandem of 4A players. Awesome.

May 28, 2011 07:20 AM
rating: 2

Sfgate.com reports that pitching coach Ray Romanic had tweaked Purcy's
mechanics and moved his position on the rubber. Have to see if it did any

May 28, 2011 10:59 AM
rating: 0

"Marlboro-stenched doghouse"...[applause]....And it is a large one too --- you've basically got to go back to Dick Williams Fenway-Park, late-1960s, tobacco-juice-floorboard-rotting, Yaz-calling-the-shots doghouse to find one as large (Mike Andrews, George Scott, Tony C, Billy C, Reggie Smith, Russ Gibson, Ken Harrelson)

May 28, 2011 12:28 PM
rating: 2

Thanks, Kevin, for confirming my initial reaction that this was a terrible move by the Tigers.

May 29, 2011 07:20 AM
rating: 0

I agree this deal makes no sense for the Tigers.

Re: Furbush -

Everything I read/see about his delivery screams, "Each pitch could be my last."

May 29, 2011 21:30 PM
rating: 0

When deals "make no sense" generally they know things we don't.

When the public pronouncements don't really add up it's because they aren't at liberty to give us the real reason.

Jun 02, 2011 05:50 AM
rating: 0
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
The BP Broadside: What... (05/27)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (05/26)
Next Column >>
Transaction Analysis: ... (05/31)
Next Article >>
Grumblings from a Surl... (05/27)

Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: July 1, 2015
Fantasy Rounders: The Slump Buster
Premium Article What Scouts Are Saying: July 1, 2015
Premium Article Going Yard: Futures Game: USA Bats
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Tuesday, June ...
Premium Article What You Need to Know: July 1, 2015
Premium Article Notes from the Field: July 1, 2015

MORE FROM MAY 27, 2011
Premium Article Fantasy Beat: The DH Conundrum
Premium Article Collateral Damage: A Scalpel Full of Posey
Baseball ProGUESTus: Curing the Frank McCour...
Premium Article On the Beat: Can the Braves Contend?
Divide and Conquer, AL West: Bay Area Strife
Fantasy Article Fantasy Beat: Value Picks in the Rotation
Fantasy Article Fantasy Beat: Weekly Planner #9

2011-06-01 - BP Podcast: Episode 52: You're Defying Physi...
2011-05-31 - Premium Article Future Shock: Draft Notebook
2011-05-31 - Premium Article Future Shock Blog: Minor League Update: Game...
2011-05-27 - Transaction Analysis: May Swapmeet, Sizemore...
2011-05-27 - Future Shock Blog: Minor League Update: Game...
2011-05-26 - Premium Article Future Shock: Breaking Down Superman
2011-05-26 - Premium Article Future Shock Blog: Minor League Update: Game...

2011-06-07 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: The DL Giveth, and the...
2011-06-02 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Down Goes Doumit
2011-05-31 - Transaction Analysis: Calling for the Cavalr...
2011-05-27 - Transaction Analysis: May Swapmeet, Sizemore...
2011-05-26 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Return of the Prodigal...
2011-05-24 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Quad-A Saves the Day?
2011-05-18 - Transaction Analysis: Heroes Take a Fall

2011-05-30 - Prospectus Hit List: AL: The Cream Rises