CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (12/06)
<< Previous Column
Winter Meetings: Gaku ... (12/07)
Next Column >>
Winter Meetings: Acta ... (12/07)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (12/07)

December 7, 2010

Winter Meetings

Morning Activity

by Christina Kahrl

Chilly ORLANDO__Well, first things first, I'm here, having arrived in a mental fog created by Sunday's late-night hijinks thanks to the on/off/on-again Adrian Gonzalez deal. There's something funny about waking up in Chicago before dawn, with the temperatures around 11, arrive in Orlando, find temps in the 40s, and think it was warmer back home, but like only too many real estate speculators, Florida managed to leave me feeling cheated in fairly short order.

Here's hoping the Winter Meetings won't do likewise, but a slow start building to a getaway day crescendo seems likely... within limits. One thing to do today, while waiting for announcements about actual current developments, is to catch up a bit on the large volume of moves made before the Winter Meetings this year, as a number of GMs moved with particular celerity, barely waiting for the coals of the Hot Stove to catch fire before moving on some of their major action items.

However, the big development this morning was the BBWAA meeting. A number of substantive issues got hashed out, leaving me with a growing appreciation for the care the organization invests in much of what it does. The most significant discussion was about a proposed annual award for relievers. Jayson Stark deserves credit as the driving force behind the idea, with its proposed title honoring Jerome Holtzman. Debate on the subject of adoption was vigorous, and fell along a lot of the lines you might anticipate: should a specific position be singled out for its own award, or is there a real systemic flaw with leaving relievers competing with starters for attention on Cy Young or MVP ballots? Would such an award reward lamentable mediocrities in some seasons? For that matter, does it make sense to name the award after a writer who invented a statistic, one that many of us in the analysis committee love to hate, instead of a player, consistent with examples like Jackie Robinson or Cy Young? I've argued (and voted) in favor of adoption, but part of what makes the arguments about a reliever-only award so interesting is that there are understandable, reasonable arguments against its adoption.

The other, happier development was the announcement that Jay Jaffe and David Laurila are among those voted in as BBWAA members for next year. The process of getting voted in renewed my understanding that membership is a privilege, not a right, but one that requires active responsibility from those voted in.

Meanwhile, one thing reliably amusing about the Winter Meetings is the too-ready ability for a rumor to take life, get ping-ponged around the hotel halls and the Twittesphere, and wind up dying a necessary death because of multi-system failure, whether as a matter of utter implausibility or the lack of connection with any underlying reality. The "Prince Fielder to the Dodgers" jibber-jabber was yesterday's big afternoon trend, and a reflection that when news is moving slow, almost anything can suddenly become a "story." You'd think that the package proposed--James Loney and Jonathan Broxton, or one year of a closer and two years with a mediocre first baseman for an MVP candidate--would generate an immediate "no mothersmucking way," but apparently not.

Christina Kahrl is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Christina's other articles. You can contact Christina by clicking here

10 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links


Congratulations to Jay and David!

Dec 07, 2010 09:07 AM
rating: 9


Dec 07, 2010 09:24 AM
rating: 0

Awesome news for Team BB Prospectus.

Dec 07, 2010 09:31 AM
rating: 1

Why do I get the sense that a reliever award would follow the same voting conventions as the Cy Young, but with saves substituted for wins? That said, if it draws attention to the save stat as one as meaningless as wins (in light of better alternatives), I'm all for it!

And congrats to Jay & David -- great news indeed.

Dec 07, 2010 09:53 AM
rating: 3

So what's next? The Bowie Kuhn Best LF Who Was Traded but Then Wasn't Award?

Dec 07, 2010 10:26 AM
rating: -1

Can't they just wait a few years and call it the Mariano Rivera Award? I think the awards not a bad idea (partly for the reasons RedsManRick outlined) but I don't like the Jerome Holtzman thing.

Dec 07, 2010 10:58 AM
rating: 1

If named after a player, it has to be Hoyt Wilhelm - the first great relief pitcher.
More importantly, congratulations to both Jay and David for their overdue recognition - well deserved!

Dec 07, 2010 11:27 AM
rating: 1
BP staff member Christina Kahrl
BP staff

Sheesh, give Firpo Marberry some respect! ;-)

Dec 07, 2010 12:03 PM

Absolutely! What could be cooler than winning a Firpo Award?

Dec 07, 2010 20:55 PM
rating: 0

Firpo. Being a multi-sport fan, when I think of Firpo, I think immediately of Luis Firpo, the Argentinian boxer made famous by a 1923 fight with world heavyweight champ Jack Dempsey. Many still think Firpo was jobbed. In the first round he hit Dempsey so hard the champ was knocked through the ropes and out of the ring. Though Dempsey was outside the ring for 17 seconds, the referee did not end the fight. Dempsey went on to win by knockout in the second round. The referee was given a short suspension for his conduct. Firpo became a bit of a legend as the Wild Bull of the Pampas.

Dec 08, 2010 07:50 AM
rating: 0
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (12/06)
<< Previous Column
Winter Meetings: Gaku ... (12/07)
Next Column >>
Winter Meetings: Acta ... (12/07)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (12/07)

Premium Article Baseball Therapy: Better Playing Through Che...
The BP Wayback Machine: The Futures Game Vie...
Fantasy Freestyle: How We Got Here
Fantasy Article Deep League Report: Week 13
Premium Article Field Generals: Under Pressure
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Tuesday, June ...
Premium Article Notes from the Field: July 1, 2015

On the Beat: Refusing to Surrender
Winter Meetings: Quade Time, and Jeter's Dea...
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Reynolds Wrap
Winter Meetings: Gaku Tashiro: A Japanese Mi...
Winter Meetings: Acta looks back and forward...
Premium Article Prospectus Q&A: Michael Saunders

2010-12-08 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Recent Deliveries
2010-12-07 - Winter Meetings: Quade Time, and Jeter's Dea...
2010-12-07 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Reynolds Wrap
2010-12-07 - Winter Meetings: Morning Activity
2010-12-06 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Adrian Gonzalez and Sh...
2010-12-06 - Premium Article Prospectus Perspective: Non-Tender Mercies
2010-12-02 - Premium Article Prospectus Perspective: A Dirty Half-Dozen

2010-12-08 - Winter Meetings: Kenny on Konerko: Deferred ...
2010-12-07 - Winter Meetings: Quade Time, and Jeter's Dea...
2010-12-07 - Winter Meetings: Acta looks back and forward...
2010-12-07 - Winter Meetings: Morning Activity
2010-12-07 - Winter Meetings: Gaku Tashiro: A Japanese Mi...
2010-12-06 - Winter Meetings: Topkin on the Rays
2010-12-06 - Winter Meetings: Chatter from Disney (update...

2010-12-08 - One-Hoppers: Joining the Club